Nazarri v Gaerth & Molnar Engineering No. DCCIV-99-1641

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

NAZARRI v GAERTH & MOLNAR ENGINEERING PTY LTD
[2003] SADC 109

Judge Lunn
Civil

  1. On 20 November 1996 the plaintiff’s left foot was injured when the first defendant lowered a mechanical hoist onto that foot.  In this action the plaintiff has sued the defendants for damages.  The defendants have issued a third party notice against the manufacturer of the hoist claiming contribution.  On the eve of trial the claim was settled as between the plaintiff and the defendants.  Judgment was entered for the plaintiff against the defendants under Rule 40 for $40,000 plus costs agreed at $30,000.  Hence this trial has been confined to the defendants’ claim for contribution against the third party.  At the outset of the trial counsel orally intimated an agreement that the third party conceded the reasonableness of the settlement but as between the defendants and the third party any amount to be recovered by the defendants was to be reduced by any finding which I made about the contributory negligence of the plaintiff.  (Later in the trial there was some argument about the precise terms of this agreement.  It is in the terms recorded in the transcript.  On the findings which I later make there are no issues which turn on the disputed parts of the agreement.)

  2. The first defendant (“the defendant”) conducts an automotive workshop in Eudunda, a country town.  He has been a qualified mechanic for about forty years and has conducted his own business for about the last twenty years.  Prior to the accident the plaintiff was a regular customer in his business.

  3. The third party is a company which has for many years manufactured vehicle hoists.  Mr Frank Molnar, its managing director, had designed and modified various types of hoists.  In September 1989 it manufactured the hoist in question and shortly afterwards it was sold through Repco to the defendants.  It was professionally installed in the defendant’s workshop.

  4. The four post hoist in question is fixed to the level concrete floor of the workshop.  There is no pit under it.  At the operator’s end there are two vertical metal posts.  At its other end, which I will called the front end, there are two further similar vertical posts.  Between each set of vertical posts there is a substantial metal cross beam which slots into grooves on the inner sides of the vertical posts.  An hydraulic mechanism can raise and lower these cross beams up and down the posts.  Between the two cross beams, and at right angles to them, are two metal runners.  The ends of the runners sit on the tops of the cross beams.  On the operator’s end there are two metal ramps about 800 mms long running from the floor up to the commencement of each runner.  When the hoist is in its lowered position a motor vehicle can be driven up these metal ramps and along the runners.  It was usual to position such a motor vehicle on the hoist so that its front wheels were at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nazarri v Gaerth & Molnar Engineering No. DCCIV-99-1641 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SADC 109
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff in this case, Nazarri, has sued the defendants for damages after his left foot was injured when the first defendant, Gaerth, lowered a mechanical hoist onto that foot. The defendants have in turn issued a third-party notice against the manufacturer of the hoist, Molnar Engineering, claiming contribution. The plaintiff and the defendants settled their dispute prior to the trial, resulting in a judgment for the plaintiff against the defendants for $40,000 plus costs of $30,000. The trial proceeded to determine the defendants' claim for contribution against the third party. The court had to decide whether the third party was negligent in the design and manufacture of the hoist, and if so, whether the third party should contribute to the costs awarded to the plaintiff.

The court found that the plaintiff was contributory negligent as he failed to take proper care for his own safety by standing too close to the descending hoist. However, the court held that the defendant was substantially negligent as a reasonable workshop proprietor would have excluded customers and bystanders from the vicinity of the hoist and should have continuously kept the plaintiff under observation while lowering the hoist. The court also found that the third party was negligent in its design and manufacture of the hoist, as a reasonable person in their position would have foreseen the risk of injury to the plaintiff or a class of persons including the plaintiff. The court held that the third party breached its duty of care by not designing and manufacturing the hoist with a clearance of at least 60mm between the bottom of the cross beams and the floor.

The court apportioned liability for the plaintiff's injury on a just and equitable basis between the plaintiff, the defendant, and the third party. The court found that the defendant's negligence contributed more to the occurrence of the accident than that of the plaintiff or the third party. The court apportioned responsibility as to 20% against the plaintiff, 50% against the defendant, and 30% against the third party. The third party is liable to contribute to the defendant 30% of $70,000 (being the total of the plaintiff's judgment and costs), resulting in a judgment for the defendant against the third party for contribution of $21,000.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.