NaughtsnCrosses Pty Ltd and Innovation Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

[2012] AATA 743  

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2010/2467

Re

NaughtsnCrosses Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

And

Innovation Australia

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal

Deputy President P E Hack SC

Date 24 October 2012
Place Brisbane

The decision under review is affirmed.

........................................................................

Deputy President P E Hack SC

Catchwords

TAXATION – Tax concessions – research and development – innovation or high levels of technical risk required – six registered activities – claimed to satisfy criteria – activities not systematic, investigative and experimental – decision affirmed.

Legislation

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 73B(1), 73B(1AAA), 73B(14), 73B(2A), 73B(2B), 73B(10)

Industry Research and Development Act 1986 (Cth) ss 39J(1), 39L(1)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President P E Hack SC

24 October 2012

Introduction

  1. Australia's tax system provides generous concessions – accelerated depreciation and suchlike – for companies that engage in research and development activities.  The activities must satisfy the criteria specified in the legislation: the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) and the Industry Research and Development Act 1986 (Cth).

  2. The applicant in these proceedings, now known as NaughtsnCrosses Pty Ltd but called Absoft (QLD) Pty Ltd at the time of the events in issue in the proceedings, is an information technology company. It claimed that it satisfied those criteria and was entitled to tax concessions for expenditure in the 2002/03 and 2003/04 income years on a project called the "Spyderman Project".  It is a sufficient description of that project for present purposes to say that it involved embedding heat resistant radio frequency identification (RFID) tags into moulds, installing RFID readers to read the tags and collecting information about the moulds in the course of a manufacturing process.

  3. The respondent, Innovation Australia, in conjunction with the Commissioner of Taxation, administers the legislation and the grant of concessions.  It determined that the activities claimed in connection with the Spyderman Project did not satisfy the statutory criteria.  That decision was affirmed on internal review.  In these proceedings, commenced on 20 October 2009, the applicant seeks a review of that decision.

    The legislation

  4. The objects of the taxation concession provisions are set out in s 73B(1AAA) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936.  It provides[1],

    [1]           The legislation is as in force at the time of the claim.

    The object of this section is to provide a tax incentive, in the form of a deduction, to make eligible companies more internationally competitive by:

    (a)encouraging the development by eligible companies of innovative products, processes and services; and

    (b)increasing investment by eligible companies in defined research and development activities; and

    (c)promoting the technological advancement of eligible companies through a focus on innovation or high technical risk in defined research and development activities; and

    (d)encouraging the use by eligible companies of strategic research and development planning; and

    (e)creating an environment that is conducive to increased commercialisation of new processes and product technologies developed by eligible companies.

    The benefits of the tax incentive are targeted by being limited to particular expenditure on certain defined…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NaughtsnCrosses Pty Ltd and Innovation Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 743
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, NaughtsnCrosses Pty Ltd sought a review of a decision by Innovation Australia, which had refused to issue a certificate under the Industry Research and Development Act for certain activities undertaken by the applicant in relation to the Spyderman Project. The applicant argued that its activities constituted research and development activities, entitling it to a tax concession. The tribunal was tasked with determining whether the applicant's activities were systematic, investigative, and experimental in nature, as required by the definition of research and development activities in the Income Tax Assessment Act.

The tribunal considered whether the activities described by the applicant met the criteria for research and development activities, specifically focusing on whether they were systematic, investigative, and experimental. The tribunal found that the applicant's activities were not sufficiently documented or evidenced to meet the required criteria. Although the applicant had provided descriptions of the activities and sought to rely on expert opinion, the tribunal concluded that the evidence did not demonstrate that the activities were systematic, investigative, and experimental.

The tribunal affirmed the decision of Innovation Australia not to issue a certificate for the research and development activities. The tribunal found that the applicant's activities were not adequately documented or evidenced to meet the statutory criteria for research and development activities. The tribunal's decision was based on the applicant's failure to provide sufficient evidence that the activities were systematic, investigative, and experimental, as required by the definition in the Income Tax Assessment Act.

There were no final orders made in this case, as the tribunal's decision was to affirm the decision of Innovation Australia not to issue a certificate for the research and development activities.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 39L(1) of the Industry Research and Development Act empowers, and in some cases requires, the respondent to provide a certificate to the Commissioner of Taxation,… stating whether particular activities that have been or are being carried on by or on behalf of a person were or are research and development activities. A person dissatisfied with the respondent’s decision under s 39L of the Industry Research and Development Act may request the respondent to reconsider the decision[4]. The respondent may confirm, revoke or vary the decision[5]. Its decision on reconsideration is reviewable in the Tribunal[6]. But it needs to be emphasised that it is the decision whether particular activities were research and development activities that is the subject matter of proceedings in the Tribunal. The focus necessarily must be on the activities, not the overall result of those activities[7].[4] See s 39S(2), Industry Research and Development Act.[5] See s 39S(4), Industry Research and Development Act..[6] See s 39T(1), Industry Research and Development Act.[7]See, for example, Industry Research and Development Board v Cold & Allied Operations Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 979; (2000) 101 FCR 405, 420 at [47]-[49].The procedural background The applicant lodged an application for registration of its research and development activities in connection with the Spyderman Project for the year ended 30 June 2003 on 10 February 2004[8]; that for the year ended 30 June 2004 was lodged on 11 March 2005[9]. Each application described the "Project Technical Objective" in these terms,[8] Exhibit 2.[9] Exhibit 4.Develop an automated production content and management system which:·Was based on Radio Frequency Identification Tag technology and associated readers;·Integrated input drawn from various locations in a production process;·Operated in harsh industrial environments to an accuracy level of 99.9%; Reduced likelihood of misread scenario from other external Are F emitting devices;·Did not impede the production process; and·Compensated for the limited read distance of current reader technologies.The activities undertaken in each year were described in identical terms as follows,·Detailed process mapping;·Design functional requirements;·Review functional requirements·Developed software and hardware framework;·Experimentation with different RFID tags; prototyping and testing; and·Feedback modification and review.As the respondent's submissions observed, the meaning, content or scope of these activities is somewhat opaque. Nonetheless, it needs to be emphasised that the evidence the applicant adduced must be considered by reference to these six activities. In January 2006 the Commissioner of Taxation requested the respondent, then known as the Industry Research and Development Board, to issue certificates pursuant to s 39L of the Industry Research and Development Act stating whether the activities undertaken by the applicant constituted "research and development activities" within the definition in s 73B(1) of the Income Tax Assessment Act. Thereafter the respondent, by letter of 29 March 2006, sought further information from the applicant including,(a)a copy of the applicants authorised research and development plan,(b)in relation to each activity,(i)a description of each activity;(ii)whether each activity is Experimental or Directly Related to the carrying on of Experimental activities.(iii)the start and end dates of each activity; and(iv)the estimated or indicative expenditure on each of the activities.(c)a short description of the innovation or high levels of technical risk associated with the project.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Registered activity 6 is feedback, modification and review, or, in the language of expanded activity 10, final tests and checks, and delivery of system. The applicant's material provides no clue as to the activities said to come within the scope of registered activity 6 or expanded activity 10. It is the case that the system was installed at Fulcrum although it appears not to have been as successful as Mr Stephen Smith, Fulcrum’s general manager at the time, would have liked, that is, it was not integrated into all of Fulcrum’s information systems. Conclusion The result of this is that I am not satisfied that any of the applicant’s activities, whether viewed individually or collectively, answer the description of systematic, investigative and experimental activities. In reaching that conclusion I have not overlooked the applicant's reliance on the opinion of Dr Harold Boeck, an expert in RFID technology. In my view the opinion of Dr Boeck is of no assistance in the present case because he has not examined the evidence which is relied upon by the applicant; rather he has drawn inferences from the material supplied to him. It may be the case, as Dr Boeck seems to suggest, that a project such as this can involve systematic, investigative and experimental activities. My impression of this project is to the contrary; whatever activities were involved in this project appear to have been poorly documented and have been even more poorly evidenced. The conclusion which I have reached, having considered the applicant's evidence, is that the applicant’s activities do not answer the description of systematic, investigative and experimental. It follows that I would affirm the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.