National Heavy Vehicle Regulator v Giannopoulos Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeal: Criminal)

NATIONAL HEAVY VEHICLE REGULATOR v GIANNOPOULOS PTY LTD

[2023] SASC 101

Judgment of the Honourable Justice McIntyre 

18 July 2023

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - NEW TRIAL - IN GENERAL AND PARTICULAR GROUNDS - PARTICULAR GROUNDS - IMPROPER ADMISSION OR REJECTION OF EVIDENCE

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - NEW TRIAL - IN GENERAL AND PARTICULAR GROUNDS - PARTICULAR GROUNDS - IMPROPER ADMISSION OR REJECTION OF EVIDENCE - WHEN NEW TRIAL GRANTED

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - NEW TRIAL - IN GENERAL AND PARTICULAR GROUNDS - PARTICULAR GROUNDS - VERDICT AGAINST EVIDENCE OR WEIGHT OF EVIDENCE

National Heavy Vehicle Regulator appeals from a decision of the Magistrates Court of South Australia.

National Heavy Vehicle Regulator charged Giannopoulos Transport under s 111 (1)(c) of the Heavy Vehicle National (South Australia) Law 2013 alleging that on 26 September 2019, Giannopoulos Transport without reasonable excuse, permitted Mr Thomas McDonald to drive a prime mover towing a trailer in a single semi-trailer combination without ensuring that the all loading requirements were complied with.  Following a trial, all elements of the charged offence were found proven, but Giannopoulos Transport was found not guilty on the basis that the Magistrate was satisfied that it had a reasonable excuse for failing to ensure that the load complied with the loading requirements applicable to the vehicle and the load.

Held:

1.      The appeal is allowed

2.      Matter remitted to the Magistrates Court for rehearing.

Heavy Vehicle National Law (South Australia) Act 2013 (SA), referred to.

GHS Safety Products Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2019] NSWSC 723; McGorm v Bennett and Bennett (Unreported SASC, 22 May 1981); Plenty v Dillon [1991] 171 CLR 635; Police v Korber [2003] 85 SASR 472; Martin v Department of Transport, Energy and Infrastructure (2010) 269 LSJS; Pol v City of Port Adelaide Enfield [2017] SASC 116; Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott (2016) 90 ALJR 679; Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118; Taikato v The Queen (1996) 186 CLR 454; Bridge Shipping Pty Ltd v Grand Shipping SA (1991) 173 CLR 231; Gelzinis v T & R (Murray Bridge) Pty Ltd (2009) 103 SASR 194; Healy v Commissioner of Taxation (2006) 202 FLR 316; House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499, considered.

NATIONAL HEAVY VEHICLE REGULATOR v GIANNOPOULOS PTY LTD
[2023] SASC 101

McIntyre J:

Introduction

  1. By Information dated 22 April 2021 the appellant, National Heavy Vehicle Regulator, charged the respondent with a single offence under s 111(1)(c) of the Heavy Vehicle National (South Australia) Law 2013 (HVNL).  The charge alleged that, on 26 September 2019 at Para Hills, the respondent, without reasonable excuse, permitted Mr Thomas McDonald to drive a heavy vehicle consisting of a prime mover towing a trailer in a single semi-trailer combination on a road without ensuring that the vehicle, the vehicle’s components, and loads complied with the loading requirements applicable to the vehicle. 

  2. The respondent was found not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read National Heavy Vehicle Regulator v Giannopoulos Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 101
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In National Heavy Vehicle Regulator v Giannopoulos Pty Ltd, the respondent, a heavy vehicle transport company, was charged with an offence under the Heavy Vehicle National Law (HVNL) for permitting a driver to operate a vehicle without ensuring that the vehicle and load complied with the loading requirements. The incident involved the driver, Mr Thomas McDonald, who was transporting scrap metal car bodies when one of the bodies became dislodged and fell, becoming lodged between the prime mover cabin and the trailer tub. The respondent argued that it had a reasonable excuse for the breach, as it had provided appropriate training and equipment to its drivers. The case was heard by the Magistrates Court of South Australia, which found that the respondent had a reasonable excuse for the breach, and acquitted the respondent.

The legal issues before the court included whether the respondent had a reasonable excuse for the breach, and if so, what factors should be considered in determining the reasonableness of the excuse. The court considered the purpose of the HVNL, which is to ensure compliance with loading requirements and to promote safety on the roads. The court noted that the HVNL does not define "reasonable excuse" and that the content of such defences is determined by the courts in each case. The court held that the words "reasonable excuse" must operate so as to encourage proper training, equipping and support without punishing those employers who put these resources in place and yet failings beyond their knowledge or control render them ineffective.

The court found that the respondent had provided appropriate training and equipment to its drivers, and that Mr McDonald's failure to appreciate the dangers inherent in the fact of the fourth body being in no way limited in its movements was beyond the respondent's control. The court held that the respondent had a reasonable excuse for the breach, and acquitted the respondent.

The court's decision highlights the importance of providing appropriate training and equipment to drivers, and the need for employers to take reasonable steps to ensure compliance with loading requirements. The court also emphasised the need for the defence of reasonable excuse to be interpreted in a way that encourages proper training, equipping and support, without punishing employers for failings beyond their knowledge or control.

Background

Background to the litigation

I reject the alternative contention that the Information should have been dismissed. Background The charge arises out of an incident on Main North Road at Para Hills West on 26 September 2019. Mr Thomas McDonald was an employee of the respondent. He picked up car bodies from Paradise Motors in order to transport them to a scrap metal depot at Gillman. As Mr McDonald was driving south on Main North Road, the car in front of him stopped suddenly causing him to brake. A car body flipped out of the top of his trailer and landed between the cabin and the trailer. The Information alleged that the respondent permitted Mr McDonald to drive a heavy vehicle consisting of a prime mover and a single semi-trailer combination on Main North Road without ensuring that the vehicle, the vehicle’s components, and load complied with the loading requirements. Further particulars of the charge were included in the Information as follows:1. The trailer of the heavy vehicle comprised a tub with four sides with an open top;2. The load contained within the trailer tub comprised four scrap metal motor vehicle bodies;3. The load was not restrained or secured;4. In the course of the heavy vehicle being driven, one of the scrap metal motor vehicle bodies became dislodged and moved from the trailer tub over the front top lip of the trailer tub and fell, becoming lodged between the prime mover cabin and the trailer tub;5. This is a severe risk breach within the meaning of s 114 of the HVNL. The elements of the charged offence were as follows:1. That the vehicle is a heavy vehicle 2. That the vehicle was driven on the road at the time of the offence. 3. That the vehicle and load did not comply with the applicable load requirements.4. That the defendant permitted the driver to drive the vehicle.5. That there was no reasonable excuse. The respondent further alleged that this incident was a severe risk contravention by virtue of s 114 of the HVNL. Section 114 provides that a contravention of a loading requirement applying to a heavy vehicle is a severe risk if the subject matter of the contravention involves a loss or shifting of the vehicle’s load that involves an appreciable risk to safety, damage to road infrastructure or of causing an adverse effect on public amenity. The first four elements of the offence, and the issue of severe risk, must be proven by the prosecution beyond reasonable doubt. The Magistrate was satisfied beyond reasonable doubt of each of those elements. In particular he found that the reason the car body flipped out of the trailer was the size of the trailer. The respondent sent a large tipper to Paradise Motors having been informed that there were 5-6 car bodies to be transported. Whilst appropriate for 5-6 car bodies, this tipper was too large to safely transport the four car bodies that were in fact loaded because large tipper permitted movement in the load. No issue is taken with these findings. The charge was therefore proven unless the respondent could establish that there was a reasonable excuse on the balance of probabilities. The Magistrate found that the respondent had a reasonable excuse for permitting Mr McDonald to drive in the circumstances that led to the car body leaving the tipper truck on 26 September 2019. Accordingly, he found the respondent not guilty. General Principles

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Magistrate found that there was a misunderstanding between Mr McDonald and the respondent about what the meaning of the water level was. He found that it was 300mm below based on the SWMS. This is in line with Ms Mouratidis’ evidence, but I note that Mr Giannopoulos, who on the respondent’s case trained Mr McDonald, supported Mr McDonald’s evidence that it was the top of the bin. In any event, the relevance of this is limited. All witnesses agreed that the significance of the water level was that, if the vehicles are below the water level, they do not need to be restrained. There was no suggestion that the vehicles on this occasion were loaded above the water mark wherever it was located. Conclusion Having accepted all of the witnesses as honest and reliable, the Magistrate did not resolve two key conflicts of evidence. First, there is the conflict concerning the number of car bodies to be collected and the allocation of trailers. Mr McDonald’s evidence was that he never knew how many car bodies he would collect and that therefore he would usually take the large tipper. On the other hand, Ms Mouratidis said that the customer would advise the number of car bodies to be collected and that the respondent would allocate the appropriately sized tipper to the driver. The driver did not select his own tipper. Second, there is the conflict about the training provided to Mr McDonald by the respondent. Mr McDonald’s evidence was internally inconsistent and inconsistent with the evidence given by Ms Mouratidis and the recorded interview of Mr Giannopoulos. In essence he said he had received little, if any, training from the respondent whereas Ms Mouratidis’ evidence detailed the respondent’s general practice concerning training which, by implication, suggested that Mr McDonald would have received training notwithstanding his prior experience. Mr Giannopoulos’ interview was generally supportive of the evidence of Mr Mouratidis. Ms Mouratidis’ evidence and Mr Giannopoulos’ interview formed the basis of the respondent’s contention that Mr McDonald ought to have realised there was a problem with this load and ought to have communicated this to the respondent. The Magistrate found that Mr McDonald:·was presented with a situation which was very uncommon. Specifically, that there was a request to transport five to six car bodies but only four were loaded onto his truck ”.[33] ·failed to appreciate the difference between carrying five car bodies loaded tightly together and four car bodies where the fourth sat on top of the bottom three[34]; and·failed to appreciate the dangers inherent in the fact of the fourth body being in no way limited in its movements.[35][33] Reasons for Decision [56].[34] Reasons for Decision [55].[35] Reasons for decision [62]. These findings do not sit comfortably with the findings that the respondent had not specifically identified the need to use a smaller tipper to transport four or less car bodies in either the SWMS or the respondent’s driver training. Accordingly, Mr McDonald could not have been alerted to an issue by reason of the number of vehicles or the size of the trailer even had he been informed of the number of vehicles. Mr McDonald’s evidence was that he did not know that the respondent had been instructed to collect 5-6 car bodies. There was no evidence that Mr McDonald was informed of this. Further the finding that this was an uncommon situation is contradicted by Mr McDonald’s evidence that he never knew how many cars he was to collect and therefore generally took the larger tipper.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appellant, however, contends that the Magistrate’s finding that the respondent had a reasonable excuse was not open on the evidence. First it is said that the finding was, in effect, that a lack of specific awareness on the part of the respondent was sufficient. This, it is said has a tendency to undermine the aims of the HVNL. The appellant further contends that it was not open to the Magistrate to find that, through its training of Mr McDonald, the respondent created circumstances where it had a reasonable expectation that Mr McDonald would identify that there was an issue that required him to contact the respondent. Consideration This is an offence of strict liability. The appellant did not have to prove that the respondent knew that a loading requirement was not complied with. The HVNL seeks to fulfil its objectives by imposing requirements on those who permit others to drive a heavy vehicle on the road to ensure compliance with loading requirements. The HVNL does not define reasonable excuse. The Magistrate quoted Taikato v. The Queen[8] where it was determined that what constitutes a reasonable excuse in a given context depends upon the circumstances of the case and the purpose of the provision to which the defence is an exception.[9] In Taikato the plurality noted that:The operation of the criminal law should be as certain as possible. If the interpretative choice is between making a value judgement and applying a rule; the court exercising criminal jurisdiction should prefer the rule…However, the reality is that when legislatures enact defences such as “reasonable excuse” they effectively give, and intend to give, to the courts the power to determine the content of such defences. Defences in this form are categories of indeterminate reference that have no content until a court makes its decision. [10][8] (1996) 186 CLR 454.[9] At [464].[10] At [466]. In formulating that content, the court should avoid an interpretation that defeats the purpose of the legislation. The Magistrate noted that the HVNL places a heavy burden on companies and drivers to:…ensure that safety, as opposed to profit or efficiency is the paramount consideration. To this end while the driver of a heavy vehicle is ultimately responsible for matters such as proper load restraint, the existence of liability also for the driver’s employer, suggests that the legislation seeks to place an obligation on haulage companies to surround their drivers with the right training, equipment, and support.[11][11] Reasons for Decision at [60]. The Magistrate went on to say that, considering the purpose of the HVNL, the words “reasonable excuse” must operate: …so as to encourage proper training, equipping and support without punishing those employers who put these resources in place and yet failings beyond their knowledge or control render them ineffective.[12][12] Reasons for decision at [61]. Both of these propositions are, in my view, correct. Improperly secured loads transported by heavy vehicles have the potential to cause substantial injury and damage to other road users and infrastructure. By imposing responsibility not only on the driver, but also the driver’s employer, the HVNL seeks to ensure compliance with loading requirements.