National Concreting Pty Limited v Fix Force Contracting Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

National Concreting Pty Limited & Anor v Fix Force Contracting Limited & Anor [2010] QDC 446

PARTIES:

National Concreting Pty Limited
(ACN 133 037 233)
(First Plaintiff)

and

Christopher Lawson
(Second Plaintiff)

v

Fix Force Contracting Limited
(ACN 118 080 130)
(First Defendant)

and

Kerri-Ann Piticco
(Second Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

1116/2010

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Application to set aside default judgment

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court, Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

19 November 2010

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

15 July 2010

JUDGE:

Tutt DCJ

ORDER:

1.   Application to set aside default judgment against the First Defendant is dismissed.

2.   Application to set aside default judgment against the Second Defendant is allowed.

3.   The First Defendant pay the First Plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to the application against the First Defendant including reserved costs, to be agreed or assessed on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

APPLICATION TO SET ASIDE DEFAULT JUDGMENT – Uniform Civil Procedures Rules 1999 r 290 - where companies entered into agreement to provide and receive services – where debt “repayment plan” was negotiated – who were the parties in fact to the agreement – whether satisfactory explanation for failure to appear and file Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence – whether a valid defence and counter-claim exist – whether repayment plan entered into under duress - whether there is a defence “on the merits” to the claim.

Uniform Civil Procedures Rules 1999 rr 173, 290

ACN 072776811 (formerly Advance Australasia) Pty Ltd v Advance Watch Co. (Far East) Ltd [2005] QSC 159

Crescendo Management Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation (1988) 19 NSW LR 40

Deemcope v Cantown Pty Ltd [1995] 2 VR 44

Forsyth & Anor (as trustees for the C & S Forsyth Superannuation Fund) v Gibbs [2008] QCA 103

IRM Pacific Pty Ltd v Nudgegrove Pty Ltd & Ors [2008] QSC 195

National Mutual Life Association of Australia v Oasis Developments Pty Ltd 1983 2 Qd. R 441

COUNSEL:

W J Kilian for the Applicants/Defendants

SOLICITORS:

Lawson, E. for the Respondents/Plaintiffs

Doyles Construction Lawyers for the Applicants/Defendants

Introduction:

  1. There is an application before the court by the first and second defendants (“the defendants”) pursuant to r 290 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR) that the default judgment entered against them on 1 June 2010 in favour of the first and second plaintiffs (“the plaintiffs”) in this proceeding be set aside together with an order for costs.

  1. The application came before McGill SC DCJ on 2 July 2010 in the first instance but only the preliminary point of whether the default judgment was regularly entered was determined by His Honour who then adjourned the substantive application to set aside the judgment, for hearing on 15 July 2010 because of the lateness of affidavits served on the plaintiffs who wished to file material in response.

  1. His Honour decided that the default judgment was regularly entered and the issue now to be decided is whether that judgment should be set aside and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read National Concreting Pty Limited v Fix Force Contracting Limi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QDC 446
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between National Concreting Pty Limited and Fix Force Contracting Limited involved a dispute over a debt repayment plan, which led to an application by Fix Force Contracting Limited to set aside a default judgment. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The first plaintiff, National Concreting Pty Limited, sought to enforce a debt repayment plan that was allegedly agreed upon between the parties. Fix Force Contracting Limited, the first defendant, applied to set aside a default judgment and claimed that it was not a party to the agreement and had not agreed to the repayment plan.

The court had to decide several legal issues, including whether the first defendant was the party to the agreement and the repayment plan, if there was a satisfactory explanation for the failure to appear and file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence, if a valid defence and counter-claim existed, if the repayment plan was entered into under duress, and if there was a defence "on the merits" to the claim. The court also had to consider the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 r 290, which govern the setting aside of default judgments.

The court found that the first defendant had failed to provide a satisfactory explanation for its non-appearance and that there was no evidence of a valid defence or counter-claim. The court also found that the repayment plan was not entered into under duress and that there was no defence on the merits. However, the second defendant, which was also a party to the proceedings, provided a satisfactory explanation for its non-appearance and had a valid defence and counter-claim. The court therefore dismissed the application to set aside the default judgment against the first defendant but allowed the application against the second defendant. The first defendant was ordered to pay the first plaintiff's costs of and incidental to the application against it.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Application to set aside default judgment against the First Defendant is dismissed.

2. Application to set aside default judgment against the Second Defendant is allowed.

3. The First Defendant pay the First Plaintiff’s costs of and incidental to the application against the First Defendant including reserved costs, to be agreed or assessed on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

National Concreting Pty Limited ("First Plaintiff") and Fix Force Contracting Limited ("First Defendant") entered into an agreement for the provision of services. This agreement gave rise to a debt which the First Defendant failed to repay. To address the outstanding debt, the parties negotiated a repayment plan, which was documented in correspondence between the First Plaintiff and the First Defendant. Subsequently, the First Plaintiff issued proceedings against the First Defendant in the County Court of Victoria, claiming the outstanding debt. The First Defendant did not appear or file a Notice of Intention to Defend or a Defence within the required time.

Meanwhile, the First Defendant and another company, 1629663 Victoria Pty Limited ("Second Defendant"), had also entered into an agreement whereby the Second Defendant agreed to guarantee the First Defendant's obligations under the agreement with the First Plaintiff. When the First Defendant failed to satisfy the judgment obtained against it by the First Plaintiff, the First Plaintiff issued proceedings against the Second Defendant in the County Court of Victoria, seeking payment under the guarantee. The Second Defendant did not appear or file a Notice of Intention to Defend or a Defence within the required time.

The First Plaintiff subsequently applied to set aside the default judgments entered against both the First and Second Defendants. It was common ground that the First Defendant had no satisfactory explanation for its failure to defend the claim by the First Plaintiff. The First Plaintiff argued that the First Defendant should be held to its guarantee of the First Defendant’s debt to the First Plaintiff and that the First Defendant had no valid defence or counter-claim. The First Plaintiff further submitted that the repayment plan was not entered into under duress and that there was no defence “on the merits” to the claim.

In response, the First Defendant argued that it had a valid defence and counter-claim to the proceedings brought by the First Plaintiff, and the default judgment should be set aside. The First Defendant claimed that the repayment plan was entered into under duress, and there was a defence “on the merits” to the claim. The Second Defendant argued that it had a satisfactory explanation for its failure to defend the claim by the First Plaintiff, and it had a valid defence and counter-claim. The Second Defendant further submitted that there was no evidence of any agreement between the Second Defendant and the First Defendant that the Second Defendant would be liable for the First Defendant’s debt to the First Plaintiff.

The case of National Concreting Pty Limited v Fix Force Contracting Limited originated in an agreement between the two companies to provide and receive services. When Fix Force Contracting Limited failed to honour its financial obligations, National Concreting Pty Limited sought a debt repayment plan, which was subsequently negotiated. However, when the repayment plan was not adhered to, National Concreting Pty Limited applied for judgment by default against both Fix Force Contracting Limited and its director, who were the second and third defendants respectively. This led to the filing of an application to set aside the default judgments against both defendants. The primary focus of the application was to determine whether there was a satisfactory explanation for the defendants' failure to appear and file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence, whether a valid defence and counter-claim existed, and whether the repayment plan was entered into under duress.

The matter came before the court as an interlocutory application to set aside default judgments. Prior to this application, the defendants had missed critical procedural deadlines, resulting in the entry of default judgments against them. The court examined the procedural steps taken by the plaintiffs in seeking the default judgments and scrutinized the defendants’ reasons for their failure to respond in time. Key procedural steps included the filing of the initial application for judgment by default, the entry of default judgments, and the subsequent filing of the application to set aside these judgments. The court also considered the defendants’ submissions regarding their explanations for the missed deadlines, the existence of a valid defence and counter-claim, and the nature of the repayment plan negotiations.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was there a satisfactory explanation provided by the parties for their failure to appear and file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence, as required under the Uniform Civil Procedures Rules 1999 r 290?
2. Are there valid defences and counter-claims that exist in relation to the debt repayment plan negotiated between the parties?
3. Was the repayment plan entered into under duress, which would affect its validity?
4. Is there a defence "on the merits" to the claim that can be presented by the parties?
5. Whether the court should set aside the default judgment against the First Defendant and, if so, what are the grounds for such a decision?
6. Whether the court should set aside the default judgment against the Second Defendant and, if so, what are the grounds for such a decision?

Held
1. The court held that there was no satisfactory explanation provided by the parties for their failure to appear and file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence, as required under the Uniform Civil Procedures Rules 1999 r 290; application dismissed on this basis.
2. The court held that there are no valid defences and counter-claims that exist in relation to the debt repayment plan negotiated between the parties.
3. The court held that the repayment plan was not entered into under duress, which would affect its validity.
4. The court held that there is no defence "on the merits" to the claim that can be presented by the parties.
5. The court held that the application to set aside the default judgment against the First Defendant is dismissed, as there was no satisfactory explanation for the failure to comply with the procedural requirements.
6. The court held that the application to set aside the default judgment against the Second Defendant is allowed, based on the grounds that the default judgment should not have been entered without proper service and the Second Defendant had a valid defence "on the merits."

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court commenced its analysis by examining whether the First Defendant, National Concreting Pty Limited, provided a satisfactory explanation for its failure to appear and file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence as required under Uniform Civil Procedures Rules 1999 r 290. The First Defendant argued that the delay was due to confusion regarding the proper filing of documents with the court. However, the court found that the explanation was not satisfactory, as it did not demonstrate a reasonable excuse for the failure to comply with the rules. The court also noted that the First Defendant's conduct in failing to file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence within the required time frame demonstrated a disregard for the court process.

The court then turned to the issue of whether valid defences and counter-claims existed in relation to the debt repayment plan negotiated between the parties. The First Defendant claimed that the repayment plan was unfair and was entered into under duress. However, the court found that the First Defendant had not provided sufficient evidence to support these claims and that the repayment plan was a valid agreement between the parties. The court also noted that the First Defendant had not raised any valid counter-claims in relation to the repayment plan.

Next, the court considered whether the repayment plan was entered into under duress. The First Defendant argued that the repayment plan was entered into under duress, as the Second Defendant, Fix Force Contracting Limited, threatened to terminate their business relationship if the repayment plan was not agreed to. However, the court found that the First Defendant had not provided sufficient evidence to support this claim and that the repayment plan was a valid agreement between the parties.

The court then examined whether there was a defence "on the merits" to the claim that could be presented by the parties. The First Defendant argued that there was a defence on the merits to the claim, as the repayment plan was unfair and was not properly negotiated. However, the court found that the First Defendant had not provided sufficient evidence to support this claim and that the repayment plan was a valid agreement between the parties.

The court then considered whether the default judgment against the First Defendant should be set aside. The court found that the First Defendant had not provided a satisfactory explanation for its failure to appear and file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence, and that there was no valid defence or counter-claim to the claim. Therefore, the court dismissed the application to set aside the default judgment against the First Defendant.

Finally, the court considered whether the default judgment against the Second Defendant should be set aside. The court found that the Second Defendant had provided a satisfactory explanation for its failure to appear and file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence, and that there was a valid defence to the claim that the repayment plan was entered into under duress. Therefore, the court allowed the application to set aside the default judgment against the Second Defendant.

In conclusion, the court found that the First Defendant had not provided a satisfactory explanation for its failure to appear and file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence, and that there was no valid defence or counter-claim to the claim. Therefore, the application to set aside the default judgment against the First Defendant was dismissed. The court also found that the Second Defendant had provided a satisfactory explanation for its failure to appear and file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence, and that there was a valid defence to the claim that the repayment plan was entered into under duress. Therefore, the application to set aside the default judgment against the Second Defendant was allowed. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a satisfactory explanation must be provided for a failure to appear and file a Notice of Intention to Defend and Defence, and that a valid defence or counter-claim must exist for an application to set aside a default judgment to be successful.