National Biofuels Group Pty Ltd v Elbow River Marketing

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

National Biofuels Group Pty Ltd v Elbow River Marketing
[2009] FCA 613 

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE –– security for costs –– defendant outside jurisdiction –– plaintiff’s claim for declarations that it terminated contract for sale of goods and consequential damages –– defendant’s cross-claim based on different contract for sale of same goods –– cross-claim sought large amount of damages for breach of contract –– plaintiff’s claim for declarations responsive to defendant’s possible damages claim that may have been brought in another jurisdiction –– whether defendant/cross-claimant is, in substance, the moving party

Held: defendant/cross-claimant to provide security

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 56

Buckley v Bennell Design and Constructions Pty Ltd (1974) 1 ACLR 301 applied
Neck v Taylor [1893] 1 QB 560 followed
Willey v Synan (1935) 54 CLR 175 applied

NATIONAL BIOFUELS GROUP PTY LTD v ELBOW RIVER MARKETING LTD PARTNERSHIP, BY ITS GENERAL PARTNER, ELBOW RIVER MARKETING CORP

NSD 1808 of 2008

RARES J
8 MAY 2009
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1808 of 2008

BETWEEN:

NATIONAL BIOFUELS GROUP PTY LTD
Plaintiff

AND:

ELBOW RIVER MARKETING LTD PARTNERSHIP, BY ITS GENERAL PARTNER, ELBOW RIVER MARKETING CORP
Defendant

JUDGE:

RARES J

DATE OF ORDER:

27 MAY 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The defendant/cross-claimant provide security for the costs of the plaintiff/cross-Defendant, in the following amounts:

(a)$52,500.00 in respect of costs up to the commencement of the final hearing;

(b)       $52,500.00 in respect of the costs of the final hearing.

2.The cross-claim be stayed until security for the costs referred to in order 1(a) is provided by payment into a bank account of the Court.

3.Security for the costs referred to in order 1(b) be by payment into a bank account of the Court at least one month prior to the commencement of the final hearing, in default of which the cross-claim be stayed until further order.

4.Each of the amounts paid by the defendant in accordance with the terms of this order be placed in an interest-bearing account.

5.The defendant provide to the plaintiff a copy of the receipt issued by the Court in confirmation of each of the payments in order 1(a) and (b).

6.The defendant/cross-claimant pay the costs of the plaintiff/cross-defendant in respect of the plaintiff/cross-defendant’s notice of motion filed 27 March 2009.

7.The costs of the defendant/cross-claimant’s notice of motion filed 3 April 2009 be costs in the proceedings.

8.The time fixed by Order 10 made 27 March 2009 for the plaintiff to file and serve its evidence, including any experts’ reports, be extended to 15 June 2009

9.The time fixed by Order 11 Rares made 27 March 2009 for the defendant to file and serve its evidence, including any experts’ reports be extended to 14 July 2009.

10.The directions hearing fixed for 12 June 2009 be vacated and the proceeding be listed for directions on 17 July 2009 at 9:30am.

11.Either party have liberty to apply.

Note:Settlement…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read National Biofuels Group Pty Ltd v Elbow River Marketing and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 613
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

National Biofuels Group Pty Ltd (National Biofuels) filed a motion against Elbow River Marketing (Elbow River) seeking security for costs in a contractual dispute. The court had to determine whether it could order Elbow River, which was based overseas, to provide security for the anticipated costs of the proceedings. National Biofuels argued that Elbow River’s counterclaim was a distinct claim rather than a mere defence, thereby justifying the imposition of security for costs. Elbow River contended that its counterclaim was defensive and that it should not be required to provide security.

The court considered the applicable legal principles, including sections 56 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and O 28 r 3(1)(a) of the Federal Court Rules, which confer jurisdiction to order security for costs. The court referenced precedents such as Buckley v Bennell Design and Constructions Pty Ltd and Neck v Taylor, concluding that where a foreign defendant brings a distinct claim, the court may order security for costs. The court found that Elbow River’s counterclaim was indeed a distinct claim, not merely a defence, and thus it was just and fair to order security for costs. The court granted the motion, requiring Elbow River to provide security for the estimated costs, stay its cross-claim until security was provided, and pay costs associated with the motion.

The court issued several orders, including that Elbow River provide security for costs in specific amounts, place those amounts in interest-bearing accounts, and extend deadlines for filing evidence. The cross-claim was to be stayed until security was provided, and the directions hearing was rescheduled. Both parties were granted liberty to apply for further orders if necessary.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The defendant/cross-claimant provide security for the costs of the plaintiff/cross-Defendant, in the following amounts:

(a) $52,500.00 in respect of costs up to the commencement of the final hearing;

(b) $52,500.00 in respect of the costs of the final hearing.

2. The cross-claim be stayed until security for the costs referred to in order 1(a) is provided by payment into a bank account of the Court.

3. Security for the costs referred to in order 1(b) be by payment into a bank account of the Court at least one month prior to the commencement of the final hearing, in default of which the cross-claim be stayed until further order.

4. Each of the amounts paid by the defendant in accordance with the terms of this order be placed in an interest-bearing account.

5. The defendant provide to the plaintiff a copy of the receipt issued by the Court in confirmation of each of the payments in order 1(a) and (b).

6. The defendant/cross-claimant pay the costs of the plaintiff/cross-defendant in respect of the plaintiff/cross-defendant’s notice of motion filed 27 March 2009.

7. The costs of the defendant/cross-claimant’s notice of motion filed 3 April 2009 be costs in the proceedings.

8. The time fixed by Order 10 made 27 March 2009 for the plaintiff to file and serve its evidence, including any experts’ reports, be extended to 15 June 2009

9. The time fixed by Order 11 Rares made 27 March 2009 for the defendant to file and serve its evidence, including any experts’ reports be extended to 14 July 2009.

10. The directions hearing fixed for 12 June 2009 be vacated and the proceeding be listed for directions on 17 July 2009 at 9:30am.

11. Either party have liberty to apply.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

RARES J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: RARES J

National Biofuels, seeks and the parties have agreed that if National Biofuels is successful is entitled to, security for what it says its costs of the proceedings would be. The parties have agreed for the purposes of this motion only that those costs would be taxed about 65% of the estimate of about $116,000 as the total estimate of solicitor/client costs made by National Biofuels’ solicitor.CONSIDERATION The jurisdiction of the court to order security is conferred in s 56 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), as well as O 28 of the Federal Court Rules. First, s 56(1) provides that the Court or a judge may order an applicant in a proceeding in the Court, relevantly, to give security for the payment of costs that may be awarded against him or her. Secondly, O 28 r 3(1)(a) provides that when considering an application by a respondent for an order for security for costs under s 56 the Court may take into account, relevantly, that the applicant is ordinarily resident outside Australia. That is the basis upon which this present application has proceeded. There is no suggestion that Elbow River would be required to provide security for costs under provisions such as s 1335 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The gravamen of the position revealed on the pleadings is that Elbow River contends that the parties made a contract that did not require it to comply with, and so, relieved it of, the obligation to meet the terms of the letter of credit relating to the nitrogen blanket either from the time of the formation of the contract or by reason of a waiver. Thus, it will claim it is entitled to substantial damages. The parties debated the proper characterisation of their respective positions. Elbow River argued that because, in substance, its participation in the proceedings is defensive and responsive to a substantive claim made by National Biofuels, the power to order it to provide a substantive amount of security has not been enlivened. The word ‘applicant’ used in s 56 of the Act has for many years in various statutory analogues and under the Federal Court Act been accepted as referring to the party against whom security for costs is sought, whether in legal form a plaintiff or initially moving party in the proceedings or a defendant or respondent who brings a cross-action or cross‑claim: see eg Buckley v Bennell Design and Constructions Pty Ltd (1974) 1 ACLR 301 at 306 per Street CJ. In my opinion, the authorities establish that where a foreign defendant counterclaims or cross‑claims, it will be ordered to provide security for costs if, in substance, what it puts forward is not simply a defence to the claim, but a distinct claim in itself, provided that on an overall assessment by the Court it is just and fair that such an order be made. In Neck v Taylor [1893] 1 QB 560 at 562 Lord Esher MR identified the applicable principles (see also at 563 per Lindley LJ and per Lopes LJ). Those principles were applied by Street CJ in Buckley 1 ACLR at 307; see too Bev Wizz Group Pty Ltd v Transport Solutions Pty Ltd [2008] NSWSC 1399 at [12]-[18] where Brereton J summarised a number of the authorities. Lord Esher MR said (Neck [1893] 1 QB at 562):“Where the counterclaim is put forward in respect of a matter wholly distinct from the claim, and the person putting it forward is a foreigner resident out of the jurisdiction, the case may be treated as if that person were a plaintiff, and only a plaintiff, and an order for security for costs may be made accordingly in the absence of anything to the contrary. Where, however, the counterclaim is not in respect of a wholly distinct matter, but arises in respect of the same matter or transaction upon which the claim is founded, the Court will not, merely because the party counterclaiming is resident out of the jurisdiction, order security for costs; it will in that case consider whether the counterclaim is not in substance put forward as a defence to the claim, whatever form in point of strict law and pleading it may take, and, if so, what under all the circumstances will be just and fair as between the parties and will act accordingly.”