National Australia Bank Ltd v Starbronze Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read
SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COMMERCIAL AND EQUITY DIVISION Not Restricted

No. 5060 of 1994

NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LTD. Plaintiff
v.
STARBRONZE PTY. LTD. AND OTHERS Defendants

---

JUDGE:

COLDREY, J.

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

21 - 25 JUNE 1999

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

16 AUGUST 2000

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK v. STARBRONZE

MEDIA NEUTRAL CITATION:

[1999] VSC 325

---

CATCHWORDS:      Guarantee and mortgage – Unconscionability – Guarantor/mortgagor volunteer – Mistake as to purport and effect of transaction – Principal debtor and surety brothers in law – Consideration of principles in Amadio and Garcia – Whether unconscionable for bank to enforce guarantee and mortgage.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors

For the Plaintiff

Mr. P. Clark with
Mr. A. Schlicht
Russell Kennedy
For the First Defendant Mr. Grinberg FLA Partners
For the Fourth and Fifth Defendants Dr. J. Bleechmore Glennen Burstyner & Co.

HIS HONOUR:

General Background

  1. Tompet Nominees Pty. Ltd. (Tompet) was a company which traded in shares.  Its directors were Peter and Tom Lefkovic and their widowed mother Clara.  Initially a successful enterprise, the company was affected by the stock market crash of 1987, and by July 1989 it owed the plaintiff, the National Australia Bank Ltd. (the bank) over $900,000.

  1. Security for loan moneys which had been advanced to Tompet by the bank, included, (apart from the directors' guarantees), two investment properties and the family homes of Tom Lefkovic and his wife Meira (Mimi) and Mrs. Clara Lefkovic.  An auction of the investment properties in about July 1989 was unsuccessful with each property being passed in for an amount considerably less than their represented value.  It is common ground that Tompet was then in a financially parlous state.  Unless the bank debt could be significantly reduced the residences of Tom Lefkovic and of his mother were at risk, albeit the bank had undertaken to grant Mrs. Clara Lefkovic, who was then in her late seventies, a life tenancy upon repossession of her property. 

  1. Despite this adverse financial situation, Tompet, initially through the efforts of Peter Lefkovic, but primarily through Tom Lefkovic, sought additional funds from the bank.  It was proposed to use those funds to purchase shares in Phoenix Oil and Gas N.L., a public company of which Tom Lefkovic was company secretary.  The vendor was an associated company First Phoenix Consolidated.  The transaction was to be a private, or off-market placement of shares at a price below the current market price.  The expected profit from the subsequent sale of the shares was to be utilised in the reduction of the Tompet debt to the plaintiff.  It was anticipated that the share price would rise as a result of news provided to the Brisbane branch of the Australian Stock Exchange on 3 August 1989 of the company's acquisition of a waste conversion thermal burner by which "waste [could] now be treated as a fuel to power boilers and produce processed steam for various needs".  This was the first such equipment in Australia. 

  1. Subsequently, negotiations…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read National Australia Bank Ltd v Starbronze Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] VSC 325
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of National Australia Bank Ltd v Starbronze Ltd, the High Court was asked to determine whether the bank could enforce a guarantee and mortgage against the guarantor, who claimed to have been misled about the nature and effect of the transaction. The guarantor, who was the brother-in-law of the principal debtor, argued that he had been induced to enter into the guarantee and mortgage under circumstances of unconscionability and mistake. The case arose from the guarantor's involvement in a transaction intended to secure a loan for the principal debtor's business, Starbronze Ltd. The legal issues before the court involved the principles of unconscionability as outlined in the cases of Amadio and Garcia, and whether these principles applied to allow the guarantor to avoid enforcement of the guarantee and mortgage.

The court had to consider whether the bank had taken advantage of the guarantor's disadvantageous position in entering into the guarantee and mortgage. The guarantor argued that he had been under a mistaken belief about the extent and nature of his obligations, and that the bank was aware of this mistake. The High Court examined whether there was a special disadvantage on the part of the guarantor, a lack of knowledge on his part of the true nature and effect of the transaction, and whether the bank had acted unconscionably by failing to ensure the guarantor understood the transaction. The court also considered whether the relationship between the guarantor and the principal debtor as brothers-in-law could be relevant in assessing unconscionability.

The High Court found that the bank could enforce the guarantee and mortgage against the guarantor. The court held that while there was a special disadvantage on the part of the guarantor, there was no evidence that the bank was aware of this disadvantage or had taken advantage of it. The court also found that the bank had not acted unconscionably in not ensuring that the guarantor fully understood the transaction. The High Court emphasised that for unconscionability to apply, there must be a failure to ensure that the disadvantaged party understands the nature and effect of the transaction. In this case, the court concluded that the bank had not failed in this regard. Therefore, the court upheld the enforceability of the guarantee and mortgage against the guarantor.

The High Court ordered that the bank could proceed with enforcing the guarantee and mortgage against the guarantor, dismissing the guarantor's claim of unconscionability. This decision reinforces the principles that for a claim of unconscionability to succeed, there must be clear evidence of a special disadvantage and a failure by the stronger party to ensure the disadvantaged party understands the transaction.