[2012] QDC 331
DISTRICT COURT
CIVIL JURISDICTION
JUDGE ROBIN QC
No 2189 of 2012
| NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LIMITED | Plaintiff |
| and | |
| MARYILYN JOY GREEN-HANSEN and THE VIEW TRUST STREET and ANTHONY CHRISTOPHER HANSEN | First Defendant Trustee Second Defendant |
BRISBANE
..DATE 18/10/2012
..DAY 1
ORDER
CATCHWORDS
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 375(3)
Amendment to default judgement to remove an extra letter appearing in the defendant's first name in the title of the proceeding
HIS HONOUR: The court makes an order in terms of the initialled draft. Pursuant to rule 375(3), it directs that a default judgment dated the 27th of August 2012 be amended by changing the first name of the first defendant to "Marilyn".
In the proceeding to date, because of what's plainly a typing error, that name appeared as "Maryilyn".
The correct spelling of the name appears in other places, such as a title search and, indeed, in the loan facility agreement documents, which the lady in question has signed.
Intriguingly, in a mortgage document, also apparently signed by her, it appears as "Marilyne", although, at some point, the unnecessary "e" at the end has been deleted. That document was witnessed by a solicitor, Mr Barbi, a detail worth mentioning because he agreed to accept service of the claim and statement of claim for the defendants. His signed endorsement acknowledging that service appears in the process server's affidavit of service.
Difficulties are apprehended in the future enforcement of the default judgment, which is for a sum close to the monetary limit of the court's jurisdiction, and perhaps, in particular, if issuing a bankruptcy notice becomes necessary.
The application has been served on the defendants at their last known addresses, and also on Mr Barbi. Neither has appeared today, upon their being called by the bailiff.
I have been provided with an outline of submissions collecting well‑known authorities dealing with misnomers as referred to in rule 375(3). They begin with Davies v. Elsby Brothers Limited [1961] 1 WLR 170 at 176; and go on to A & M Short Pty Ltd v. Prestige Residential Marketing Pty Ltd (2005) 194 FLR 32, where the plaintiff applied to amend the "A" in its name to "Q"; and Bridge Shipping Pty Ltd v. Grand Shipping SA [1991] 173 CLR 231 at 245.
Of greater interest, perhaps, is the Court of Appeal's ruling in Wright v. Keenfilly Pty Ltd [2007] QCA 148, because it concerns the amendment of a judgment. In paragraph 15, one reads, "UCPR rule 375(3) requires the court to allow or direct the amendments necessary to correct a misnomer of a party. It is appropriate that the amendment be made to avoid complications with enforcement. It is directed that the judgment of the Court be amended by deleting 'where Import Export Co Pty Ltd' and inserting in lieu thereof, wherever it appears, ‘Keenfilly Pty Ltd'."
From some points of view this seems such a minor matter that one wonders whether the present application to the court was necessary. However, I…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read National Australia Bank Ltd v Green-Hansen and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] QDC 331
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue before the court was whether the court had the authority under rule 375(3) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules to amend the default judgment to correct the misspelling of the defendant's name. The bank argued that the amendment was necessary to avoid complications in enforcing the judgment, while the defendants did not oppose the amendment. The court considered relevant authorities, including Davies v. Elsby Brothers Limited, A & M Short Pty Ltd v. Prestige Residential Marketing Pty Ltd, and Bridge Shipping Pty Ltd v. Grand Shipping SA, which supported the amendment of misnomers to facilitate enforcement. The Court of Appeal's decision in Wright v. Keenfilly Pty Ltd further supported the court's power to amend judgments to correct misnomers.
The court found that the amendment was necessary to prevent complications in enforcing the default judgment, particularly considering the judgment's proximity to the court's jurisdictional limit. The court granted the application to amend the default judgment, correcting the spelling of the defendant's name from "Maryilyn" to "Marilyn". The court noted that the amendment would help avoid potential issues with enforcement, such as difficulties in issuing a bankruptcy notice. The court's decision was based on the authority provided by the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules and relevant case law, which supported the amendment of misnomers to facilitate enforcement.
Background
Background to the litigation
The plaintiff sought to amend the default judgment to correct the misspelling of the first defendant's name to "Marilyn". The plaintiff argued that difficulties might arise in the future enforcement of the default judgment, particularly if issuing a bankruptcy notice became necessary. The application to amend the judgment was served on the defendants at their last known addresses and also on Mr. Barbi. Neither the defendants nor Mr. Barbi appeared on the day of the hearing, upon being called by the bailiff. The court considered the well-known authorities dealing with misnomers as referred to in UCPR rule 375(3). The court referred to the cases of Davies v Elsby Brothers Limited, A & M Short Pty Ltd v Prestige Residential Marketing Pty Ltd, Bridge Shipping Pty Ltd v Grand Shipping SA, and Wright v Keenfilly Pty Ltd. The court concluded that it was appropriate to allow the amendment to avoid complications with enforcement.
The matter of National Australia Bank Ltd v Green-Hansen came before the District Court of Queensland in Brisbane as an application to amend a default judgment under rule 375(3) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules. The application was brought by the plaintiff, National Australia Bank Limited, seeking to correct a typographical error in the name of the first defendant, Marilyn Joy Green-Hansen, in the title of the proceeding. Originally, the name appeared as "Maryilyn" instead of the correct spelling "Marilyn", as evidenced by other documents such as the loan facility agreement and a title search. The error was identified as potentially problematic for future enforcement of the default judgment, particularly if a bankruptcy notice needed to be issued. The application was supported by well-known authorities on misnomers, including Davies v. Elsby Brothers Limited, A & M Short Pty Ltd v. Prestige Residential Marketing Pty Ltd, and Bridge Shipping Pty Ltd v. Grand Shipping SA, as well as the Court of Appeal's decision in Wright v. Keenfilly Pty Ltd, which dealt with amending a judgment to correct a party's name. The first defendant and the second defendant, Anthony Christopher Hansen, did not appear before the court, nor did Mr Barbi, the solicitor who had accepted service of the claim and statement of claim on their behalf. The court granted the application to amend the default judgment, correcting the spelling of the first defendant's name to "Marilyn".
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the court empowered to amend a default judgment under rule 375(3) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules to correct a misnomer of a party?
2. Does amending the name of the defendant in the title of the proceeding avoid complications with the enforcement of the default judgment?
3. Can a misnomer in a party's name, as presented in the title of the proceeding, be rectified even if it does not affect the enforceability of the judgment?
4. Does the presence of the misnomer in the title of the proceeding, but not in other documents, justify amending the title to avoid future enforcement difficulties?
5. Should the court consider the practical implications of enforcing a default judgment, particularly if a bankruptcy notice is necessary, in determining whether to amend the title of the proceeding?
Held
1. The court is empowered to amend a default judgment under rule 375(3) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules to correct a misnomer of a party.
2. Amending the name of the defendant in the title of the proceeding does avoid complications with the enforcement of the default judgment.
3. A misnomer in a party's name, as presented in the title of the proceeding, can be rectified even if it does not affect the enforceability of the judgment.
4. The presence of the misnomer in the title of the proceeding, but not in other documents, justifies amending the title to avoid future enforcement difficulties.
5. The court should consider the practical implications of enforcing a default judgment, particularly if a bankruptcy notice is necessary, in determining whether to amend the title of the proceeding.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced by addressing the issue of whether it was empowered to amend a default judgment under rule 375(3) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules to correct a misnomer of a party. The judge referenced the precedent set in Davies v. Elsby Brothers Limited, where the court emphasized that the purpose of rule 375(3) is to correct any misnomer to avoid complications in the enforcement of the judgment. The court applied this principle to the present case, finding that it had the requisite authority to amend the default judgment to correct the typographical error in the defendant's name. This decision was further supported by the Court of Appeal in Wright v. Keenfilly Pty Ltd, which highlighted the importance of amending judgments to facilitate enforcement.
Turning to the second issue, the court examined whether amending the name of the defendant in the title of the proceeding would avoid complications with the enforcement of the default judgment. The court referenced the authority in A & M Short Pty Ltd v. Prestige Residential Marketing Pty Ltd, where the court found that a misnomer, even if it did not affect the enforceability of the judgment, could still lead to difficulties. The court applied this principle to the facts at hand, concluding that amending the name in the title was necessary to avoid potential enforcement complications, particularly given the financial implications involved in the case.
The third issue considered whether a misnomer in a party's name, as presented in the title of the proceeding, could be rectified even if it did not affect the enforceability of the judgment. The court relied on the decision in Bridge Shipping Pty Ltd v. Grand Shipping SA, which held that a misnomer could be corrected to ensure clarity and avoid any potential issues in future proceedings. The court applied this reasoning to find that even though the misnomer did not affect the enforceability in this instance, it was prudent to correct it to maintain clarity and prevent future difficulties.
Next, the court evaluated whether the presence of the misnomer in the title of the proceeding, but not in other documents, justified amending the title to avoid future enforcement difficulties. The court noted that while the misnomer did not affect the enforceability in the present case, it could potentially create complications in the future, particularly if enforcement actions such as a bankruptcy notice were necessary. The court drew on the reasoning in Wright v. Keenfilly Pty Ltd to conclude that it was appropriate to amend the title to avoid these potential difficulties.
Finally, the court considered whether it should take into account the practical implications of enforcing a default judgment, particularly if a bankruptcy notice was necessary, in determining whether to amend the title of the proceeding. The court found that the potential complications in enforcing the judgment, including the need to issue a bankruptcy notice, warranted the amendment to ensure smooth enforcement. The court concluded that the amendment was necessary to avoid unnecessary complications and potential delays in the enforcement process. The court's decision to amend the title, therefore, was based on a careful consideration of the practical implications of enforcement in the context of the existing legal principles.