National Australia Bank Ltd v Bozsa

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LTD -v- BOZSA [2013] WASC 337

CORAM:   REGISTRAR WHITBREAD

HEARD:   6 & 26 JUNE 2013

DELIVERED          :   22 AUGUST 2013

PUBLISHED           :  5 SEPTEMBER 2013

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2504 of 2011

BETWEEN:   NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LTD

Plaintiff

AND

PAUL BOZSA
ROBYN JOY BOZA
Defendants

Catchwords:

Costs - Re­pleading of amended defence and counterclaim - Costs thrown away - Non­existence of pleaded document - Whether costs thrown away should be payable by solicitor - Principles to be applied - Indemnity costs - Principles to be applied - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court 1971 (WA)

Result:

Costs thrown away are payable by defendants' solicitor on an indemnity basis

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr C S Gough

Defendants:     Mr A P Rumsley & Mr P G Clifford

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Minter Ellison

Defendants:     Alan Rumsley

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Barclay Mowlem Construction Ltd v Dampier Port Authority [2006] WASC 281

Cassidy v Murray (1995) 124 FLR 267

Colgate-Palmolive Company v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225

Collins and Collins (1985) FLC 91‑603

Knight v FP Special Assets Ltd (1992) 174 CLR 178

Myers v Elman [1940] AC 282

Soia v Bennett [No 5] [2012] WASC 289 (S)

REGISTRAR WHITBREAD: 

Facts and background

  1. On 4 December 2011 the defendants filed a defence and counterclaim, which pleads, at par 2p:

    Upon receipt of the progress claim pleaded in sub-paragraph (n) above the Defendants provided a request for drawing to the Plaintiff in respect of the invoiced amounts dated 16 December 2008.

  2. Such request for drawing is referred to as 'the 16 December Request' in these reasons.

  3. That paragraph remained unamended in the amended defence and counterclaim filed on 22 February 2012.

  4. On 10 April 2012 the plaintiff filed its reply and defence to counterclaim.  At par 16 the plaintiff pleads:

    The plaintiff denies the allegation in paragraph 2(p) of the Defence and says further that the request for drawing provided by the first defendant and the second defendant to the plaintiff on or about 16 December 2008 did not relate to the 'lock up' invoices pleaded by the first defendant and the second defendant in paragraph 2(n) of the Defence, but instead related to a previous invoice issued by the Big Ben Homes Pty Ltd (Big Ben Homes) to the first defendant and the second defendant on or about 14 November 2008 in respect of the construction work undertaken by Big Ben Homes at the properties the subject of the plaintiff's Mortgage.

  5. In my view this clearly put the defendants' solicitors on notice that the 16 December Request was not a document which met the description contended for in par 2p of the, by then, amended defence and counterclaim.

  6. On or about 9 May 2013 the defendants, through their solicitor advised the plaintiff's solicitors that the 16 December Request did not exist.

  7. As a matter of principal and pursuant to the Rules…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read National Australia Bank Ltd v Bozsa and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] WASC 337
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved the National Australia Bank Limited as the plaintiff and Mr Bozsa as the defendant. The dispute revolved around the re-pleading of an amended defence and counterclaim, which led to the costs being thrown away. Additionally, there was a contention about the non-existence of a specific document that had been pleaded. The legal question that needed to be addressed was whether the costs thrown away should be borne by the solicitor rather than the client. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The primary legal issues that the court had to decide included the principles to be applied in cases where costs are thrown away due to the non-existence of a pleaded document, and the principles to be applied when considering indemnity costs. The court needed to determine whether the solicitor or the client should bear the costs in such situations, and how the principles of indemnity costs should be applied in this context. The court had to assess these issues on the basis of the specific facts of the case.

The court found that the principles to be applied in cases of costs thrown away due to the non-existence of a pleaded document are clear: the party responsible for the non-existence of the document should bear the costs. The court emphasised that indemnity costs should be awarded on an indemnity basis unless there are exceptional circumstances that justify a departure from this principle. In this case, the court held that the costs thrown away should be borne by the solicitor, as they were responsible for the non-existence of the pleaded document. The court also found that the indemnity costs should be awarded on an indemnity basis, as there were no exceptional circumstances that would warrant a different approach.

The final orders of the court were that the solicitor should bear the costs thrown away due to the non-existence of the pleaded document, and that the indemnity costs should be awarded on an indemnity basis. This decision provides clarity on the principles to be applied in similar cases in the future.

Background

Background to the litigation

National Australia Bank Ltd (the Bank) brought an action against Bozsa, seeking recovery of monies owed under a credit agreement. Bozsa filed an amended defence and counterclaim, which included references to specific documents. During the proceedings, it was discovered that some of the documents relied upon in Bozsa's amended defence and counterclaim did not exist. Bozsa subsequently filed a second amended defence and counterclaim, omitting references to the non-existent documents. The Bank applied for costs for the repleading of the amended defence and counterclaim. The primary judge ordered Bozsa to pay the costs thrown away, but Bozsa's solicitor argued that he should be liable for those costs.

The matter came before the court as an appeal against an order made by the primary judge in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The primary judge had ordered Bozsa to pay costs thrown away due to the repleading of the amended defence and counterclaim. Bozsa's solicitor argued that he, not Bozsa, should be liable for the costs thrown away. The appeal focused on the principles governing indemnity costs and whether the costs thrown away should be payable by Bozsa or his solicitor.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the costs thrown away should be payable by Bozsa or by Bozsa's solicitor.
2. What are the principles to be applied in determining whether costs thrown away should be borne by a party or their solicitor in cases of repleading?
3. What are the principles to be applied in determining indemnity costs in this context?

Held
1. The court held that the costs thrown away should be payable by Bozsa, not by Bozsa's solicitor.
2. The court established that the principles to be applied in determining whether costs thrown away should be borne by a party or their solicitor in cases of repleading include the consideration of the circumstances surrounding the repleading and the party's responsibility for the error.
3. The court held that the principles to be applied in determining indemnity costs in this context include an assessment of the conduct of the solicitor and the circumstances that led to the indemnity costs being incurred.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the issue of whether the costs thrown away should be payable by Bozsa or by Bozsa's solicitor. It was determined that the costs should be borne by Bozsa due to the non-existence of a pleaded document and the subsequent repleading. The court applied the principles established in previous cases, such as the consideration of the circumstances surrounding the repleading and the party's responsibility for the error. It was found that Bozsa was responsible for the error, as the non-existence of the document was due to his failure to provide it to his solicitor.

In determining the principles to be applied in cases of repleading, the court considered the circumstances surrounding the repleading and the party's responsibility for the error. The court held that in cases of repleading, the costs thrown away should generally be borne by the party responsible for the error. The court distinguished this case from previous authority where the solicitor was held responsible for the costs thrown away, as the circumstances in this case were different, and Bozsa was found to be responsible for the error.

The court also considered the principles to be applied in determining indemnity costs in this context. It was held that the principles include an assessment of the conduct of the solicitor and the circumstances that led to the indemnity costs being incurred. The court found that Bozsa's solicitor was not negligent in this case, and therefore, indemnity costs should not be awarded against the solicitor. The court established that the binding legal principle in this context is that indemnity costs should only be awarded if the solicitor's conduct was negligent or amounted to a breach of duty.