National Australia Bank Limited v Bedford

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

Serial No B41/1992
List “B”

CITATION:  National Australia Bank Limited v Bedford [1992] TASSC 118; B41/1992

PARTIES:  NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LIMITED

v

BEDFORD, R A

BONE, M E

TITLE OF COURT:                  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

JURISDICTION:  ORIGINAL

FILE NOS:  443/1991

DELIVERED:  30 September 1992

HEARING DATES:                   21 September 1992

JUDGMENT OF:  Cox J

CATCHWORDS:

Practice—Application for summary judgment—Some evidence to support counter—claim—Judgment on claim but execution stayed on terms until counter—claim heard.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:  R E Sugden

Defendant:  S C Chopping

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:  Finlay Watchorn

Defendant:  Steven Chopping

Judgment category classification:

Court Computer Code:

Judgment ID Number:              B41/1992

Number of paragraphs:            10

Serial No B41/1992

List "B"

File No 443/1991

NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LIMITED v R A BEDFORD & M E BONE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  COX J

30 September 1992

  1. The plaintiff bank seeks summary judgment against the defendants in respect of the balance of loans made by the plaintiff to the defendants alleged to be still outstanding. The defendants in their defence admitted all of the plaintiff‘s statements of claim save for par18 which pleaded that:

"Since service of the demand, the sum that then became due and payable has increased due to further non–payment of interest, service fees and other charges."

and par32 which pleaded that:

"The Defendants have not paid any money to the Plaintiff since the service of either demand and the amounts by which both accounts were in debit on the 31st of January 1991 have continued to increase by virtue of further debits of interest, service fees and other costs and charges."

  1. Those paragraphs have been proved by the affidavit in support of the application. The defendants however, pleaded a counter–claim and sought to set off any monies due thereunder. The counter–claim was in the following terms:

"33     The said loans were secured by a charge on the interest of the Defendants in a property situated at Bagdad.

34      It was an implied term of the said loans that in the event that the Plaintiff exercised any power of sale it would sell the properties for a realistic market value.

35      In breach of the said implied term the Plaintiff sold the property for a price below the realistic market value.

36      As a consequence of the said breach the Defendants suffered damages (particulars to be supplied) and the Defendants seek to set off and or counter–claim damages."

  1. The remedy of summary judgment is confined to clear cases and as O15, r3 makes clear, if the defendant satisfies the judge with respect to the claim or the part of the claim to which the application relates that there is an issue or question in dispute that ought to be tried, he should be given leave to defend and afforded his day in court. The defendants have filed an affidavit in support of the genuineness of their set off and counter–claim. In it the second named defendant deposes that she verily believes that the sum of $38,000 realised by the plaintiff on the sale…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read National Australia Bank Limited v Bedford and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1992] TASSC 118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of Tasmania, the case of National Australia Bank Limited v Bedford involved a dispute between the plaintiff, the bank, and the defendants, the borrowers. The bank sought summary judgment against the defendants for the outstanding balance on loans they had made to the defendants. The defendants admitted most of the bank's claims but contested the amounts they owed, alleging that additional charges had accrued. They also filed a counterclaim, asserting that the bank had sold a property they had used as security for the loans for less than its market value. The counterclaim was based on an alleged implied term that the bank would sell the property for a realistic market value.

The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether the bank's claim for the outstanding loan balance was clear and indisputable and whether the defendants' counterclaim, alleging a breach of the implied term, presented a genuine issue that warranted a trial. The court had to determine if there was sufficient evidence to warrant denying the bank's application for summary judgment and allowing the counterclaim to proceed. The bank argued that summary judgment should be granted as there was no evidence to dispute their claim, while the defendants maintained that their counterclaim required a full hearing.

The court found that while the bank's claim for the outstanding loan balance appeared to be valid, the defendants had presented some evidence supporting their counterclaim. Specifically, the defendants provided an affidavit stating that the bank sold the property for significantly less than its market value and did not make reasonable efforts to obtain a higher price. The court acknowledged that the bank's obligation to sell the property for a realistic market value, if it existed, would need to be proven with evidence of the bank's lack of good faith or failure to take reasonable steps to achieve a proper sale price. Given the lack of detail in the defendants' pleadings regarding how the implied term arose and the need for further evidence, the court decided to grant summary judgment on the bank's claim but stayed execution on most of the judgment amount pending the outcome of the counterclaim. The court ordered that the defendants deliver an amended counterclaim and pursue it diligently, while allowing them to argue against any additional sums owed if they could prove their counterclaim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established