Nancy & Albert Pty Ltd v McDonald's Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Nancy & Albert Pty Ltd v McDonald’s Australia Pty Ltd [2018] QCAT 285

PARTIES:

NANCY & ALBERT PTY LTD CAN 085 188 736
(applicant)

v

MCDONALD’S AUSTRALIA LTD CAN 008 496 928

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

RSL057-17

MATTER TYPE:

Retail shop leases matter

DELIVERED ON:

17 August 2018

HEARING DATE:

4 June 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

PJ Roney QC
Neil Judge

Don McBryde

ORDERS:

The application is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

LANDLORD AND TENANT – RETAIL AND COMMERCIAL TENANCIES LEGISLATION – OTHER MATTERS – ground lease – determination of current market rent on the basis of unimproved land value – whether determination by specialist retail valuer complies with the requirements of the Retail Shop Leases Act, reprint 3E – whether valuer failed to comply with s 29 of the Retail Shop Leases Act in not determining the rent on the basis of the rent that would be reasonably expected to be paid for the retail shop if it were unoccupied and offered for leasing for use for which the shop may be used under the lease or substantially similar use, but instead determined the current market rent on the basis that the lease was a ground lease and did not take into account improvements on the leased land – whether a specialist retail valuer’s report was not a proper determination because it failed to disclosure certain information relied upon within it, indicate how comparable properties were relevant, how the benefit of easements have been taken into account – whether the report failed to have regard to exclusive use provisions – whether valuer failed to specify the matters taken into account – whether adequate

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld), s 27B
Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 (Qld) reprint 3E, s 28, s 29, s 31, s 35, Schedule

Annandale Pharmacies (NQ) Pty Ltd v The Angliss Estate (Annandale) Pty Ltd [2017] QCAT 429
Bank of South Australia v SA Health Commission (1996) 65 SASR 409
Beale v Government Insurance Office of NSW (1997) 48 NSWLR 430
Brisbane Comedy Pty Ltd t/as Albion Comedy Club & Restaurant v Malisano & Ors (2015) QCAT 340
City of Subiaco v Home Base Management Pty Ltd [2015] WASCA 54
Finn v Central and Northern Queensland Regional Parole Board [2016] QSC 233
Fletcher Construction Australia Ltd v Lines Macfarlane & Marshall Pty Ltd [2001] 4 VR 28
Fletcher Construction Australia Ltd v Lines Macfarlane and Marshall Pty Ltd (No 2) [2002] 6 VR 1
Legal and General Life Australia Ltd v A HudsonPty Ltd (1985) 1 NSWLR 314
McGlen-McLeod v Galloway [2012] NSWCA 368
S.H.I.F.T. Whitsunday Pty Ltd v McLean Cooke Pty Ltd [2012] QCAT 38
Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs v Charlesworth Piling & Co [1901] AC 393

Vesco Nominees Pty Ltd v Stefan Hair Fashions Pty Ltd [2001] QSC 169

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

C Wilson QC, instructed by Mullins Lawyers

Respondent:

G Gibson QC and S Forder, instructed by Corrs Chambers Westgarth

REASONS FOR DECISION

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nancy & Albert Pty Ltd v McDonald's Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCAT 285
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Nancy & Albert Pty Ltd v McDonald's Australia Pty Ltd, the Applicant, Nancy & Albert, sought to challenge a determination of market rent made by a Specialist Retail Valuer (SRV) appointed under the Retail Shop Leases Act, reprint 3E. The dispute arose from the lease of a fast food restaurant and drive-thru operated by McDonald's at 250 McCullough Street, Sunnybank. The lease stipulated a market review of the rent for the 16th rental year, which was to be conducted in 2015. After the parties could not agree on the market rent, Mr Bruce Barrington was appointed as the SRV, and he determined the market rent to be $197,545 plus GST. Nancy & Albert challenged the adequacy of the SRV's determination, arguing it failed to comply with the requirements of the Act and did not adequately state reasons for the determination.

The court was required to determine whether the SRV's determination of the market rent complied with the statutory requirements under the Retail Shop Leases Act, reprint 3E. Key issues included whether the SRV was required to determine the rent on the basis of the rent that would be reasonably expected to be paid for the retail shop if it were unoccupied and offered for leasing, and whether the SRV's report was a proper determination as it failed to disclose certain information, indicate how comparable properties were relevant, and account for the benefit of easements. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the SRV failed to specify the matters taken into account in making the determination.

The court found that the SRV's determination, while not perfect, was sufficient in meeting the requirements of the Act. It was held that a requirement to provide detailed reasons for a determination does not demand absolute transparency or every conceivable detail of the analysis. The court reasoned that the SRV's determination did refer to the evidence that was significant and bore upon important aspects of the issues, set out material findings of fact, and explained how and why conclusions were reached. The court held that the criticisms of the determination were hypercritical and not justified, leading to the conclusion that the determination was adequate.

The court dismissed the application, affirming that the SRV's determination of market rent was acceptable under the Retail Shop Leases Act, reprint 3E. The determination of $197,545 plus GST was upheld as sufficient for the purposes of the legislation.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The definition of a retail tenancy dispute in the current schedule to the Act identifies it as ‘any dispute under or about retail shop leases, or about the use or occupation of a leased shop under a retail shop lease, regardless of when the lease was entered into’.Factual background The Respondent (‘McDonald’s’) operates a fast food restaurant and drive-thru from premises owned by and leased to it by the Applicant (‘Nancy & Albert’) situated at 250 McCullough Street, Sunnybank. The land comprises an area of 2,116 square meters and the area is described as Lease F on SP 133291. McDonald’s entered into a 20-year lease of the site by lease commencing in 2000. By the terms of the lease, there was to be a market review in rental year 16, that is, as at 26 June 2015, as well as in some earlier years. After the parties failed to reach agreement on the market rent which was to be applied from that date for the further term, Mr Bruce Barrington was appointed as the SRV, charged with the responsibilities imposed upon such valuers under the Act where the parties cannot reach agreement. He made a written determination dated 27 March 2017 that identified the market rent as being $197,545 plus GST at the relevant date. There was a proviso about outgoings in the determination. That rent was a figure lower than the initial annual rent 17 years earlier. It is common ground that the subject site was a retail shop, and that the subject lease was a retail shop lease within the terms of the Act. It is also common ground that in respect of the determination which was required to be made by the SRV, the applicable provisions were those as they stood in reprint 3E of the Act, reprinted as in force on 1 January 2006. That is of critical significance in this case because in that reprint, unlike the position to be found in later versions of the Act, there was no express requirement, as there was in later reprints, in s 31 of the Act, to ‘state detailed reasons for the determination’. There is nevertheless an issue as to the extent to which, in making the determination, the SRV was required to provide reasons, and whether the reasons provided in this case were sufficient to meet whatever those requirements were. We pause to observe that in some other decisions of this Tribunal, where the requirements to provide reasons have been the subject of comment, there has not always been an appreciation of the fact that the requirements of later reprints to the Act, including the current version of the Act, which require that the SRV’s determination of current market rent must state detailed reasons for the determination were not present in earlier versions of the Act. To the extent that that distinction has not been properly made in those other cases, some care must be taken with earlier statements of principle as to what the requirements of a determination are and have in the past been. Prior to the determination in writing being made, the parties each engaged with the valuer to provide him with instructions as to the methodology that he was to adopt. That engagement started with correspondence from the valuer seeking clarification specifically as to what methodology the parties regarded as appropriate to adopt.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 27B provides;27B Content of statement of reasons for decision If an Act requires a tribunal, authority, body or person making a decision to give written reasons for the decision (whether the expression ‘reasons’, ‘grounds’ or another expression is used), the instrument giving the reasons must also— (a) set out the findings on material questions of fact; and (b) refer to the evidence or other material on which those findings were based. Counsel for the parties did not refer us to an authority on the meaning to be given to the words ‘person making a decision to give written reasons’ where they appear in s 27B. On one view of it, s 31 of the Act sets out the extent of the duty on SRV’s in this context, and there is no scope for the application of s 27B of the Acts Interpretation Act. Even if the approach in Brisbane Comedy is the correct approach to be applied since s 31(d) of the Act came into force, we are not persuaded that there was a requirement for a more detailed statement of reasons for the determination than has been made in this case. A requirement that a valuer specify the matters taken into consideration is not a requirement to state in every conceivable detail precisely how the valuer arrived at the determination in question. It is well accepted that the conduct of a valuation requires the use of inferences and inclinations of opinion, and which ‘being more or less conjectural, are difficult to reduce to exact reasoning or to explain to others’.[8][8]See for example statements to this effect more than a century ago in Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs v Charlesworth Piling & Co [1901] AC 393, 391, and in numerous other decisions which have referenced it. The fact that such valuations have that character must of necessity mean that determinations under this Act in stating the matters taken into consideration, and stating the detailed reasons, are not required to disclose on their face each and every element of the analysis in every last detail possible. Senior Counsel for the Respondent contended that the criticisms made of the determination here were hypercritical and inappropriate. We agree. A requirement to set out the findings on material questions of fact and refer to the evidence or other material on which those findings are based does not describe a qualitative process. A material fact is a fact that can affect the outcome of a decision. Accordingly, the findings on the material facts are those that support the decision. Even in the context of judicial decisions the standard is not to require absolute transparency. At a fundamental level, it may be said that for reasons to be sufficient or adequate in a given case it will in general terms require that they:(a)Refer to the evidence which was significant, or which bore upon important aspects of the issues which were required to be determined;(b)Set out material findings of fact, not just state the issues which raise those points;(c)Deal with how and why the conclusions based on those findings of fact have been reached. That would almost always involve stating upon what basis it is that the decision maker has arrived at the conclusion that there is a preference for some part of the evidence in preference to another competing part, or some other inconsistent aspect of the case.[9][9]See Beale v Government Insurance Office of NSW (1997) 48 NSWLR 430, 431; Fletcher Construction Australia Ltd v Lines Macfarlane and Marshall Pty Ltd (No 2) [2002] 6 VR 1, 31-33.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.