Naidoo v George

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:        

Naidoo v George [2016] QIRC 080

PARTIES:  

Naidoo, Navin Dr
(Applicant)

v

George, Preety Dr
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

PID/2016/1

PROCEEDING:

Application for an Injunction

DELIVERED ON:

2 August 2016

HEARING DATES: 

22 April 2016
7 June 2016

HEARD AT:

Brisbane and Gympie

MEMBER:

Industrial Commissioner Thompson
ORDERS:

1. That the Application for Injunction filed by Dr Naidoo on 13 April 2016 be struck out on the basis that he has no right to apply pursuant the provisions of s 50 of the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010.

2.   Order sought for costs refused.

CATCHWORDS:

PUBLIC INTEREST DISCLOSURE ‑ Application for injunction ‑ Jurisdictional issue ‑ Application to strike out filed by Dr George ‑ Anti‑discrimination Commission Queensland complaint ‑ Application for injunction struck out ‑ Dr Naidoo has no right to apply for injunction ‑ Application for injunction misconceived but not vexatious ‑ Order sought for costs refused.

CASES:

Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010, ss 40, 41, 42, 44, 48, 49 and 50
Industrial Relations Act 1999, ss 3, 5, 265, 266, 267, 273, 274, 277, 331 and 335
Health Practitioner Regulation National Law Act 2009
Anti‑Discrimination Act 1991
Health Quality and Complaints Commission Act 2006
Department of Corrective Services v The Queensland Public Sector Union of Employees (2006) 182 QGIG 152
State of Queensland (Metro South Hospital and Health Service) v Misiura [2015] QIRC 30

Agforce v AWU (2001) 167 QGIG 297

O'Sullivan v Farrer (1989) 168 CLR 210
State of Queensland (Queensland Fire and Emergency Services) v United Firefighters' Union of Australia, Union of Employees, Queensland [2014] QIRC 120
State of Queensland v Shankar [2014] QIRC 159

APPEARANCES:

Dr N. Naidoo, Applicant.
Mr M. Brady of Ashdale Workplace Solutions for the Respondent.

Decision

  1. On 13 April 2016 an application was lodged by Dr Navin Naidoo (Dr Naidoo) for an injunction pursuant to the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010 (PIDA).

  2. The injunction was being sought to prevent further reprisals said to be envisaged by s 48 of the PIDA and which had caused Dr Naidoo a detriment within the meaning of the Industrial Relations Act 1999 (IR Act).

  3. The outcome sought (at paragraph 2 of the application) was:

    "(a)    That Dr Preety George be ordered to desist from taking any further reprisals against Dr Navin Naidoo.

    (b)     That Dr Preety George be ordered to retract the allegation she has made about Dr Navin Naidoo's safety to practice as a doctor.

    (c)     That Dr Preety George be ordered to retract the statement that Dr Navin Naidoo's conduct at the time in question, breached the threshold for mandatory notification in terms of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law Act 2009.

    (d)     That a finding be made as to whether Dr Preety George's conduct constitutes a reprisal as envisaged by the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010 Qld."

  4. On 21 April 2016 correspondence from the Crown Solicitor (representing the interests of Dr Preety George (Dr George)) was forwarded to the Industrial Registrar in which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Naidoo v George and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QIRC 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Naidoo v George, the applicant, Dr Navin Naidoo, sought an injunction to prevent further reprisals against him by Dr Preety George. The matter was heard by the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission (QIRC), which was required to decide if Dr Naidoo had the right to apply for an injunction under the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010. Dr George had filed an application to strike out the injunction application, arguing that Dr Naidoo had no right to apply for such an injunction. The central legal issue was whether Dr Naidoo was entitled to seek an injunction under the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010 to prevent further reprisals by Dr George.

The QIRC found that Dr Naidoo did not have the right to apply for an injunction under the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010. The court determined that the application for an injunction was misconceived but not vexatious. The QIRC held that the application was struck out as Dr Naidoo did not possess the necessary statutory right to apply for such an injunction. The court also refused the application for costs, ruling that each party should bear their own costs. Consequently, the application for an injunction was dismissed, and the order sought for costs was refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. That the Application for Injunction filed by Dr Naidoo on 13 April 2016 be struck out on the basis that he has no right to apply pursuant the provisions of s 50 of the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010.

2. Order sought for costs refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On the matter of costs it was the position of Dr Naidoo that each party bear their own costs in these proceedings.Conclusion The sole purpose of these proceedings is first and foremost to address an application filed by Dr George on 6 May 2016 that sought to have: The application relied upon s 274(2) of the IR Act as the head of power available to the QIRC to make the findings sought and in the alternative the QIRC had the authority to strike out or dismiss the substantive application in its entirety pursuant to s 331(b)(ii) of the IR Act. In applications of this nature it is clear that either ss 274(2) and 331(b)(ii) of the IR Act are relevantly available to the QIRC in the exercise of determining applications to strike out or refrain from hearing an application and were not the subject of challenge by the Respondent to the strike out application. The substantive application was lodged by Dr Naidoo with the Industrial Registrar on 13 April 2016 and sought the following decisions:"1. An injunction to prevent further reprisals as envisaged by section 48 of the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010 Qld, which has caused detriment within the meaning of the Industrial Relations Act 1999.2. The following decision:(a)That Dr Preety George be ordered to desist from taking any further reprisals against Dr Navin Naidoo.(b)That Dr Preety George be ordered to retract the allegation she has made about Dr Navin Naidoo's safety to practice as a doctor.(c)That Dr Preety George be ordered to retract the statement that Dr Navin Naidoo's conduct at the time in question, breached the threshold for mandatory notification in terms of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law Act 2009.(d)That a finding be made as to whether Dr Preety George's conduct constitutes a reprisal as envisaged by the Public Interest Disclosure Act 2010 Qld." In this application Dr Naidoo provided material for the period between May 2009 and November 2011 which related to activities of numerous medical officers (other than himself) and whilst of some interest for the purposes of background did not relate directly to the injunctive relief sought. There were however a number of pertinent inclusions that went directly to matters for which the strike out application sought the relief specified in the application. These included:· 22 June 2012 Dr Naidoo received notification from the Crime and Misconduct Commission (CMC) about the under‑reporting of safety statistics;· 6 July 2012 Dr Naidoo informed by the Director of the Emergency Department at the Gympie Hospital that he had been issued with a section 123 of the Health Quality and Complaints Commission Act 2006 to provide a statement with regards to safety issues at the Gympie Hospital;· on or around 26 October 2012 Dr Naidoo became aware that his submission regarding the under‑reporting of safety statistics at the Gympie Hospital had been accepted as a PID;· in October 2012 Dr Naidoo provided information to the Complaints Resolution Manager at the SCHHS regarding SAC investigations at Gympie Hospital that were later accepted as a PID;· in December 2012 Dr George made a mandatory notification to AHPRA alleging Dr Naidoo was unsafe to practice as a doctor;· Dr Naidoo provided a response to AHPRA who ultimately found there were no grounds to support the notification and Dr George's complaint was rejected;· since the rejection of Dr George's complaint she had refused to retract her statement that Dr Naidoo's conduct constituted notable conduct;· at no time did Dr Naidoo's conduct exceed the threshold that AHPRA or the profession of medicine would consider worthy of mandatory notification;· the mere making of a mandatory notification is extremely damaging to a doctor's career, self‑esteem and psychological wellbeing;· Dr George persists she had a legitimate reason to come to her "erroneous conclusion" and refuses to apologise or retract her statement;· as a consequence of Dr George's mandatory notification Dr Naidoo has been the subject of unfair notifications and allegations made against him in addition attempts to address the victimisation have been ignored;· Dr Naidoo took the matter to the District Court in an effort to resolve the issues; and· Dr George had rejected all attempts to negotiate the issues.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established