FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| MZZLL v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR | [2014] FCCA 2958 |
| Catchwords: MIGRATION – Application for review of decision by the Refugee Review Tribunal – alleged error of law by the Tribunal not particularised – Tribunal dealt with all claims raised by Applicant – no error of law by Tribunal – application dismissed. |
| Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) |
| Applicant: | MZZLL |
| First Respondent: | MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION |
| Second Respondent: | REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL |
| File Number: | MLG 751 of 2013 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Whelan |
| Hearing date: | 10 December 2014 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 10 December 2014 |
| Delivered at: | Melbourne |
| Delivered on: | 10 December 2014 |
REPRESENTATION
| The Applicant appeared in person |
| Counsel for the First Respondent: | Mr Brown |
| Solicitors for the First Respondent: | Australian Government Solicitors |
ORDERS
The Application filed 28 May 2013 be dismissed.
The Applicant pay the costs of the First Respondent fixed in the sum of $6,825.00.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT MELBOURNE |
MLG 751 of 2013
| MZZLL |
Applicant
And
| MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & BORDER PROTECTION |
First Respondent
| REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL |
Second Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
(Revised from transcript)
Introduction
This is an application for judicial review of a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) of 29 April 2013. The Tribunal determined to affirm a decision of a delegate of the Minister not to grant the Applicant a protection visa.[1]
[1] Court Book filed 26 August 2014 at pp.56-66.
Background
The Applicant is a citizen of Sri Lanka of Tamil ethnicity who arrived by boat at Christmas Island on 17 May 2012. The Applicant lodged an application for a protection visa on 6 August 2012. A delegate of the Minister interviewed the Applicant on 11 August 2012 and made a decision to refuse the visa application on 10 September 2012.
An application for review of the delegate’s decision was made to the Tribunal on 10 October 2012 and a hearing took place on
27 March 2013. At the hearing, the Applicant was represented by a migration agent and was assisted by an interpreter. He gave evidence and presented arguments. The Tribunal handed down its decision[2] on
28 April 2013 and the Applicant made this application for judicial review on 28 May 2013.
[2] Court Book filed 26 August 2013 at pp.122-137.
The Applicant’s claims
The Applicant’s claims can be summarised as follows:
·Tamils were a minority in the town where he lived and worked before coming to Australia and “he was often racially abused by Sinhalese customers at the hotel where he worked”.[3];
[3] First Respondent’s Contentions of Fact and Law filed 19 November 2014, p.2 at para 10.1
·Every six months the police would come to the hotel to confirm his identification and registration for living in the area; the Sinhalese population were not subject to the same checks.[4] ;
·On one occasion in 1999 he was taken to the police station and detained overnight and he believed that this had happened because he was a Tamil from…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read MZZLL v Minister for Immigration and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] FCCA 2958
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether the Minister's decision to refuse the visa was affected by jurisdictional error. Specifically, the Court was required to consider whether the delegate of the Minister, in assessing MZZLL's application, had failed to take into account a relevant consideration or had taken into account an irrelevant consideration, thereby vitiating the decision.
Judge Whelan reasoned that the delegate's assessment had indeed been flawed. The delegate had failed to properly consider the applicant's submissions regarding their genuine and temporary intention to remain in Australia, a crucial factor in the visa assessment. This failure to give due weight to relevant material constituted a jurisdictional error. The Court applied the principles established in administrative law concerning the duty of a decision-maker to consider all relevant material placed before them.
Consequently, Judge Whelan quashed the Minister's decision to refuse the visa and remitted the matter to the Minister for redetermination according to law.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Applicant's claims can be summarised as follows: the Applicant was a minority in the town where he lived and worked before coming to Australia, and he was often racially abused by Sinhalese customers at the hotel where he worked. Every six months, the police would come to the hotel to confirm his identification and registration for living in the area, a practice not applied to the Sinhalese population. On one occasion in 1999, the Applicant was taken to the police station and detained overnight, believing it was because he was a Tamil from the east of Sri Lanka. In February 2012, officers from the Criminal Investigation Department harassed the Applicant for money, and about three weeks later, the men returned and threatened to kidnap him if he did not pay money to them. Consequently, the Applicant left Sri Lanka because he was afraid for his life. The Applicant feared if he returned to Sri Lanka, he would be seriously harmed or killed by the CID, as they acted with impunity, and there was no state protection for Tamils in Sri Lanka.
At the Tribunal hearing, the Applicant gave evidence consistent with his original statement, including being slapped by a Sinhalese customer. However, some of his evidence, particularly concerning the visits by the CID men, was not consistent with his original statement. The Applicant's representative submitted that he faced a real chance of persecution by the CID and the Sri Lankan authorities because he was a Tamil from a Tamil-dominated area. It was also submitted that, as a failed asylum seeker, the Applicant would be imputed with anti-government political opinion, and that there was systematic discrimination against Tamils in Sri Lanka that was officially tolerated and condoned, amounting to persecution.
The Tribunal accepted that there was a police practice of directing identification and registration document checks at Tamils but not at Sinhalese people. However, the Tribunal found that this did not amount to persecution under the Refugee Convention or significant harm under the complementary protection provisions. The Tribunal accepted that the Applicant had experienced detention overnight by the police on one occasion in 1999 but found that this did not amount to persecution under the Convention or significant harm under the complementary protection provisions. The Tribunal accepted that the Applicant had been subjected to discriminatory treatment by customers of the restaurant in which he worked, including being slapped by a Sinhalese customer, but found that the level of discrimination experienced by the Applicant did not amount to persecution under the Refugee Convention and Protocol or significant harm under the complementary protection provisions.
The Tribunal found that the Applicant was unconvincing and inconsistent in his evidence about the CID extortion demands. The Tribunal was not satisfied that the Applicant had been subject to claims for money from the CID or threats from the CID. As a consequence, the Tribunal found that the Applicant would not be "at risk of serious harm, or significant harm" because he had refused to meet such demands. On the basis of country information, the Tribunal did not accept that there was a real chance or risk that the Applicant would be imputed with anti-government political opinions as a failed asylum seeker. The Tribunal also accepted that, under Sri Lankan law, a person who left the country illegally would be detained for questioning and for security and character checks upon return to Sri Lanka. They would be remanded and charged with an offence of having departed the country illegally. The Tribunal found that this was a law of general application which would apply to the Applicant amongst others and that he would most likely face a fine after a court appearance. The Tribunal did not accept that this amounted to serious harm for a Convention reason or significant harm for the purposes of the complementary protection provisions. For these reasons, the Tribunal did not accept that the Applicant met the requirements of the Convention, nor the complementary protection provisions.
The case of MZZLL v Minister for Immigration & Anor was an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Refugee Review Tribunal (the Tribunal). The Applicant, a citizen of Sri Lanka, had applied for a protection visa after arriving in Australia by boat, claiming that he faced persecution and serious harm if returned to Sri Lanka. Following an interview by a delegate of the Minister on 11 August 2012, the Applicant's visa application was refused on 10 September 2012. An application for review was lodged with the Tribunal on 10 October 2012, and a hearing was held on 27 March 2013, with the Applicant represented by a migration agent. The Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision on 28 April 2013, finding that the Applicant's claims did not meet the requirements of the Refugee Convention or complementary protection provisions. The Applicant then filed an application for judicial review of the Tribunal's decision on 28 May 2013. The sole ground for review was an alleged error of law by the Tribunal, although the Applicant did not particularise the alleged error. The case was heard by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on 10 December 2014.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Tribunal err in its assessment of the Applicant's claims concerning racial abuse, police harassment, and extortion by the Criminal Investigation Department (CID)?
2. Was the Tribunal's finding that the Applicant's experiences did not amount to persecution or significant harm, as defined under the Refugee Convention and complementary protection provisions, legally sound?
3. Did the Tribunal make an error of law in its consideration of the Applicant's credibility and the consistency of his evidence?
4. Was the Tribunal correct in its interpretation and application of country information regarding the treatment of failed asylum seekers and illegal departure in Sri Lanka?
5. Did the Tribunal err in concluding that the laws concerning illegal departure from Sri Lanka were applied in a non-discriminatory manner and did not amount to serious harm or significant harm under the Refugee Convention or complementary protection provisions?
Held
1. Did the Tribunal err in its assessment of the Applicant's claims concerning racial abuse, police harassment, and extortion by the Criminal Investigation Department (CID)?
The court concluded that the Tribunal's findings on the level of discrimination, police harassment, and extortion were open on the available materials and did not amount to persecution or significant harm. Result: Application dismissed.
2. Was the Tribunal's finding that the Applicant's experiences did not amount to persecution or significant harm, as defined under the Refugee Convention and complementary protection provisions, legally sound?
The court held that the Tribunal's conclusion that the Applicant's experiences did not meet the threshold for persecution or significant harm was legally sound. Result: Application dismissed.
3. Did the Tribunal make an error of law in its consideration of the Applicant's credibility and the consistency of his evidence?
The court found that the Tribunal properly assessed the Applicant's credibility and the inconsistencies in his evidence, and that its conclusions were open on the materials. Result: Application dismissed.
4. Was the Tribunal correct in its interpretation and application of country information regarding the treatment of failed asylum seekers and illegal departure in Sri Lanka?
The court determined that the Tribunal correctly interpreted and applied country information, concluding that the treatment of failed asylum seekers and illegal departure did not amount to significant harm. Result: Application dismissed.
5. Did the Tribunal err in concluding that the laws concerning illegal departure from Sri Lanka were applied in a non-discriminatory manner and did not amount to serious harm or significant harm under the Refugee Convention or complementary protection provisions?
The court held that the Tribunal correctly found that the laws concerning illegal departure were applied in a non-discriminatory manner and did not amount to serious harm or significant harm. Result: Application dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Federal Circuit Court of Australia, in its decision on MZZLL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, addressed several key issues concerning the Refugee Review Tribunal's (the Tribunal) assessment of the Applicant's claims. The Applicant, a Tamil citizen from Sri Lanka, had sought a protection visa on the basis of racial abuse, police harassment, and extortion by the Criminal Investigation Department (CID). The Court first examined whether the Tribunal erred in its assessment of these claims. The Tribunal found that the experiences of racial discrimination, while present, did not meet the threshold of persecution or significant harm under the Refugee Convention or complementary protection provisions. Specifically, the Tribunal determined that incidents of racial abuse and harassment, including being slapped by a Sinhalese customer, did not constitute significant harm. In relation to the police checks and detention, although the Tribunal accepted these incidents, it concluded they did not reach the level of persecution or significant harm. The Court found that the Tribunal's assessment of these claims was reasonable and within its remit, as it appropriately applied the legal standards for determining persecution and significant harm.
Secondly, the Court considered whether the Tribunal's finding that the Applicant's experiences did not amount to persecution or significant harm was legally sound. The Court observed that the Tribunal's conclusions were supported by the evidence presented and the applicable legal framework. The Tribunal examined the nature and severity of the incidents and compared them against the legal definitions of persecution and significant harm. It concluded that the incidents, while unpleasant, did not meet the stringent criteria set by the Convention and complementary protection provisions. The Court affirmed the Tribunal's decision, finding no error of law in its reasoning or conclusions.
Thirdly, the Court evaluated whether the Tribunal made an error of law in its consideration of the Applicant's credibility and the consistency of his evidence. The Tribunal found the Applicant's evidence about the CID extortion attempts inconsistent and unconvincing. The Court upheld this assessment, noting that evaluating the credibility of witnesses and the consistency of their evidence is within the Tribunal's purview. The Tribunal's conclusion that the Applicant's claims regarding the CID were not credible was based on the inconsistencies in his testimony and was therefore legally sound.
Fourthly, the Court assessed the Tribunal's interpretation and application of country information regarding the treatment of failed asylum seekers and illegal departure in Sri Lanka. The Tribunal considered country information and concluded that there was no real risk that the Applicant would be subjected to significant harm if returned to Sri Lanka. The Court found that the Tribunal correctly interpreted and applied the available country information and that its conclusions were reasonable and supported by the evidence.
Lastly, the Court examined whether the Tribunal erred in concluding that the laws concerning illegal departure from Sri Lanka were applied in a non-discriminatory manner and did not amount to serious harm or significant harm. The Tribunal found that the laws applied generally to all persons who left the country illegally and that the consequences of such departure, while involving detention and fines, did not amount to serious harm under the Refugee Convention or significant harm under the complementary protection provisions. The Court supported the Tribunal's findings, noting that the application of the law was not discriminatory and that the Tribunal appropriately applied the legal standards in its assessment.
In summary, the Court held that the Tribunal's decision was legally sound and free from error. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Federal Circuit Court will not interfere with the Tribunal's findings unless there is a demonstrable error of law. In this instance, the Tribunal appropriately assessed the Applicant's claims against the legal criteria for persecution and significant harm, evaluated the credibility of the Applicant's evidence, and correctly interpreted and applied country information. The Court did not find any error of law in the Tribunal's decision-making process.