MZZES v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MZZES v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 397

Citation: MZZES v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 397
Appeal from: MZZES v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection & Anor [2014] FCCA 758
Parties: MZZES v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File number: VID 256 of 2014
Judge: NORTH J
Date of judgment: 29 April 2015
Catchwords: MIGRATION – whether threat per se amounted to serious harm or a real risk of significant harm – alleged failure to consider two integers based on membership of two particular social groups – whether claim abandoned – reliance on previous written and oral evidence and submissions – expressly adopt all previous oral and written evidence and submissions – where person is professionally represented and claim not expressly articulated
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 5(1), 36(2A)
Cases cited:

MZYQZ v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 948
SZRPA v Minister for Immigration [2012] FCA 962

Date of hearing: 20 November 2014
Date of last submissions: 28 November 2014
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 45
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr G Hughan
Solicitor for the Appellant: Ambi Associates
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr G A Hill
Solicitor for the Respondents: Sparke Helmore

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 256 of 2014

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

MZZES
Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

NORTH J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 APRIL 2015

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be allowed.

2.The orders made by the Federal Circuit Court Judge on 17 April 2014 be set aside.

3.In lieu of those orders, the following orders be made: 

(a)a writ certiorari issue, directed to the second respondent, removing into the Court its decision, made on 5 November 2012 affirming the decision of a delegate of the first respondent not to grant a protection visa to the appellant, for the purpose of quashing that decision;

(b)the decision of the second respondent, made on 5 November 2012, affirming the decision of a delegate of the first respondent not to grant the appellant a protection visa, be quashed;

(c)a writ of mandamus issue, directed to the second respondent, requiring it to hear and determine the application of the appellant for review of the decision of the delegate of the first respondent refusing to grant him a protection visa.

4.The first respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 256 of 2014

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

MZZES
Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

NORTH J

DATE:

29 APRIL 2015

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MZZES v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 397
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an appeal against the Federal Circuit Court’s dismissal of the applicant’s application for judicial review of a decision to refuse to grant a protection visa. The applicant, an individual from Sri Lanka, had applied for a protection visa on the basis of a fear of persecution by the Sri Lankan government due to a land dispute. However, the Tribunal did not consider a separate claim made by the applicant during an entry interview, where he alleged that a people-smuggler had threatened him and his family. The Federal Circuit Court held that the applicant had abandoned the people-smuggler claim. The applicant argued that the Tribunal erred in failing to consider the people-smuggler claim.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Tribunal had erred in concluding that the people-smuggler claim had been abandoned and, if so, whether the Tribunal’s failure to consider the claim amounted to a jurisdictional error. The court noted that for a claim to be abandoned, it must be expressly abandoned by the applicant or it must be clear from the circumstances that the applicant has abandoned the claim. The court also noted that if a claim has not been abandoned, the Tribunal is under a duty to consider it. The court considered whether the people-smuggler claim had been expressly abandoned by the applicant, and if not, whether the Tribunal had erred in failing to consider it.

The court held that the people-smuggler claim had not been expressly abandoned by the applicant. The court found that the applicant had made the claim during an entry interview and that he had not expressly abandoned the claim at any subsequent stage of the proceedings. The court also found that the Tribunal had not expressly stated that it would consider all previously provided information, including the people-smuggler claim. The court distinguished the present case from a previous case where the Independent Merits Reviewer had expressly stated that it would consider all previously provided information. The court held that the Tribunal’s failure to consider the people-smuggler claim amounted to a jurisdictional error.

The court allowed the appeal, set aside the orders made by the Federal Circuit Court, and made orders quashing the decision of the Tribunal and requiring it to hear and determine the applicant’s application for review of the decision of the delegate of the Minister refusing to grant him a protection visa. The court also ordered that the Minister pay the applicant’s costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The orders made by the Federal Circuit Court Judge on 17 April 2014 be set aside.

3. In lieu of those orders, the following orders be made:

(a) a writ certiorari issue, directed to the second respondent, removing into the Court its decision, made on 5 November 2012 affirming the decision of a delegate of the first respondent not to grant a protection visa to the appellant, for the purpose of quashing that decision;

(b) the decision of the second respondent, made on 5 November 2012, affirming the decision of a delegate of the first respondent not to grant the appellant a protection visa, be quashed;

(c) a writ of mandamus issue, directed to the second respondent, requiring it to hear and determine the application of the appellant for review of the decision of the delegate of the first respondent refusing to grant him a protection visa.

4. The first respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Hill, who appeared as counsel for the Minister, correctly accepted that if the appellant had not abandoned the people-smuggler claim then the Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error by failing to consider it.The Relevant Facts On 18 and 21 March 2012, the appellant was interviewed by an officer of the Department of Immigration and Citizenship (the Department) (the entry interview). The officer completed an Entry Interview Record. That record is a form which has a heading including the words “Australian Government” and “Department of Immigration and Citizenship” placed under the Australian coat of arms. The form has pre-printed questions for an interviewer to ask, and then blank spaces for the interviewee’s responses. In his answers the appellant identified [Person X] as a supervisor of the five or six people who drove the boat which brought him to Australia. [Person X] was in the Scherger Immigration Detention Centre with the appellant. The appellant responded “yes” to the question whether there was anyone in the Centre of concern to him and who had been threatening him. He provided the following details, at Question 10(f): [Person X] spoke to [Person Y] [Boat ID XXXXX X] on either [A date] or [B date] and said that he would harm his family and his parents and that if he tried to go back to Sri Lanka they would know about it at the airport. [Person Y] told his Case Manager about this. [Person X] told me the same information on [C date]. I said to [Person Y] that I would remain quiet about this and told my Case Manager about this on [D date]. [Person X] is a Sinhalese and he is here with his son – name is [Person Z] and I think his boat ID is [Boat ID YYYYYY]. The son did not say anything. They have the power to do anything as the Army and Police in Sri Lanka are all Sinhalese and they can go to any country. [Person X] has also threatened many others and they have put in complaints. When asked at the end of the interview whether there was anything the officer had not asked the appellant which he would like to say, the appellant said, at Question 19:… I would like to have on record that the captain of the boat [Person X] [Boat ID ZZZZZZ] has made threats stating that he and his people will create problems and harm my family, so the danger for me has increased further. [Person X] is part of the people smugglers and it is no problem for him to kill somebody. On 28 May 2012, the appellant made a protection visa application. His claims were set out in a statement accompanying the application. The statement made no reference to the people-smuggler claim. On 5 June 2012, the appellant was interviewed by an officer of the Department as delegate of the Minister (the delegate interview). A migration agent acting on behalf of the appellant was also present. The delegate asked the appellant questions about various elements of the claims. Towards the end of the interview the appellant referred to another claim made in the entry interview and in the statement accompanying his application concerning a dispute with the Sri Lankan government over land and the appellant said to the delegate “you have not asked anything about it”. The delegate responded:I just want to assure you whatever you have stated in both of your statements I will take into consideration when I make my decision. So if we haven’t discussed it today, it doesn’t mean that I will not take it into my consideration. [Delegate Interview Transcript p37]

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Then, at the end of the questioning, the following exchange took place between the Tribunal member and the migration agent:Now, Ms Pablo, was there anything you thought we hadn’t covered?No, all aspects of the claims have been covered. [RRT Hearing Transcript p31] The Federal Circuit Court Judgment The Federal Circuit Court observed that the appellant did not raise the people-smuggler claim in the delegate interview or in the hearing before the Tribunal. The Federal Circuit Court also referred to the reply given by the appellant’s migration agent when asked by the Tribunal whether anything had not been covered in the hearing that “all aspects of the claims have been covered”. Further, there was no mention in the written submissions of the people-smuggler claim. Then, the Federal Circuit Court judge said that when the delegate said “I just want to assure you whatever you have stated in both of your statements I will take into consideration when I make my decision” the delegate did not say that he would take into account what the appellant said in his entry interview. The Federal Circuit Court concluded from these factors that the people-smuggler claim had been abandoned. The Federal Circuit Court judge distinguished the present case from MZYQZ v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 948 (MZYQZ). In that case Dodds-Streeton J held that the merits reviewer had made a jurisdictional error by failing to consider a claim that the appellant feared persecution (forced recruitment by the Taliban) as a young Hazara man without parents. The claim was raised by the appellant orally before the refugee status assessment (RSA) officer and referred to in an oral summary of the appellant’s case made by the appellant’s representative before the officer. The RSA officer did not refer to the claim in his reasons. Then, the appellant’s advisors filed a written submission in support of a merits review application. That submission did not refer to the forced recruitment claim. However, it did state:We refer to and rely on all previous oral and written evidence and submissions previously provided by or on behalf of the applicant and now wish to make the following further submissions in support of his review application. Then, at the commencement of the merits review, the reviewer said:I have all the information previously provided by you and your advisor or referred to in the earlier decision and that will be taken into consideration whether or not we specifically cover it again today. Justice Dodds-Streeton said:58In my opinion, in the circumstances of this case, the conscription claim was not abandoned before the IMR [Independent Merits Reviewer]. The IMR not only failed to challenge the appellant’s express assertion that he relied on previous written and oral evidence and submissions, but reinforced it by his unqualified opening statement that he had “all the information previously provided by you and your adviser or referred to in the earlier decision” and would take it into consideration, whether or not it was specifically covered. …60While it is thus unlikely that the IMR intended, by his opening statement, to undertake to consider claims make orally only in the course of the RSA interview, the statement, according to its literal, ordinary meaning, in my view extended to such claims. Particularly, given the appellant’s express reliance on previous oral and written evidence and submissions, there is no basis to construe the statement as applicable only to written material. Further, there was no evidence that the appellant or his migration agent were aware that the IMR did not have any record of the RSA interview available or before him.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Circuit Court judge distinguished the present case because the factual context was different. He said at [56]:That difference was the reassurance and affirmation given to the appellant in MZYQZ that all previous claims would be fully taken into consideration by the decision-maker and also by the fact that the appellant “expressly adopted all previous oral and written evidence and submissions”. There was an assurance given that all previously provided information would be considered. In this case, the Applicant did not state to the Tribunal that he relied upon all previously provided information; nor did the Tribunal state it would consider all previously provided information, including claims that were not even made before the Delegate. Whereas in MZYQZ the claim was made orally before the Delegate. CONSIDERATION Mr Hill argued on behalf of the Minister that, at least by the time the written submissions were filed in the Tribunal, the appellant had abandoned the people-smuggler claim. This was because there was no mention of the claim in the submissions. There had been no mention of the claim in the delegate interview or any complaint that the delegate had failed to refer to the claim in his reasons. Then, the appellant made no mention of the claim in the hearing before the Tribunal, and his representative replied when asked that all aspects of the claim had been covered in the hearing. Mr Hill contended that a relevant factor in considering whether the claim had been abandoned was that the appellant was professionally represented both at the delegate interview and the hearing before the Tribunal. Where a person is professionally represented and a claim is not expressly articulated it is more difficult to infer that the claim was advanced: SZRPA v Minister for Immigration [2012] FCA 962 at [10]. Mr Hill rightly acknowledged that whilst the representation of the appellant was a factor to be taken into account, the significance of the factor will depend on an assessment of all the circumstances. In the present case, for instance, one of the circumstances was that the appellant did not have the same representative at all stages. Further, it is significant that the people-smuggler claim was made orally at the entry interview. That is to say, it was made by the appellant at an early opportunity in the context of a personal interview with the appellant rather than with the intervention of a professional representative. As in MZYQZ, a central consideration is the statement made by the Tribunal of the material on which it intended to rely. For convenience, that statement is repeated now as follows:Now, I have the file of the department of immigration containing your original application. I’ve also had the opportunity of listening to the recording of the interview you had with the officer of the department who made the decision on your application. What I propose to do today is to ask you some questions and you will have the opportunity to mention anything to me which you haven’t already mentioned to the department.