MZYVA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MZYVA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCA 50

Citation: MZYVA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCA 50
Appeal from: MZYVA & MZYVB v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FMCA 787
Parties: MZYVA and MZYVB v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File number: VID 685 of 2012
Judge: DODDS-STREETON J
Date of judgment: 6 February 2013
Catchwords: MIGRATION – where Refugee Review Tribunal (“Tribunal”) found inconsistencies between the appellant’s oral evidence, written statement and supporting documents – whether Tribunal acted in a manifestly unreasonable way when dealing with appellant’s claim – whether Tribunal ignored aspects of the claimed persecution or harm – whether Federal Magistrate considered Tribunal’s reasons and findings – grounds not established – appeal dismissed
Legislation: 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees as amended by the 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees, Art 1A(2)
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 36(2)(a), 36(2)(b), 65(1), 91R, 424A, 424AA, 425
Cases cited: Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Jia Legeng (2001) 205 CLR 507 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v VSAF of 2003 [2005] FCAFC 73 cited
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 cited
NADR v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 167 cited
Nagalingam v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1992) 38 FCR 191 cited
Prasad v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1985) 6 FCR 155 cited
Randhawa v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 52 FCR 437 cited
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; ex parte Durairajasingham (2000) 168 ALR 407 cited
SJSB v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCAFC 225 cited
SZBEL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2006) 228 CLR 152 cited
SZMCD v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) 174 FCR 415 cited
Date of hearing: 14 December 2012
Date of last submissions: 14 December 2012
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 41
Counsel for the Appellants: The first appellant appeared in person assisted by an interpreter
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms E Holt
Solicitor for the Respondents: Clayton Utz

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 685 of 2012

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

MZYVA
First Appellant

MZYVB
Second Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

DODDS-STREETON J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 FEBRUARY 2013

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The appellants pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 685 of 2012

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

MZYVA
First Appellant

MZYVB
Second Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MZYVA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In MZYVA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, the appellants, Indian nationals, challenged the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (Tribunal) to affirm the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship's decision to refuse their applications for Protection (Class XA) visas. The appellants sought to rely on the appellant's claimed political activities and incidents of alleged persecution in India to establish their eligibility for a visa. The Tribunal, however, found inconsistencies between the appellant's oral evidence, written statement, and supporting documents, leading to doubts about his credibility and the veracity of his claims.

The court was required to determine whether the Tribunal acted in a manifestly unreasonable way when dealing with the appellant's claim and whether the Tribunal ignored aspects of the claimed persecution or harm. The court had to assess whether the Federal Magistrate considered the Tribunal's reasons and findings, and if the grounds for appeal were established. The court needed to examine if the Tribunal's decision was so unreasonable that no reasonable tribunal could have arrived at it, and whether the decision demonstrated a failure to consider relevant evidence or an error in the application of the law.

The court found that the Tribunal's decision was not manifestly unreasonable. The court noted that the Tribunal had considered the appellant's evidence and had provided detailed reasons for its findings. The court held that the Tribunal was entitled to find the appellant's evidence lacking in credibility due to the inconsistencies and the similarities with another set of claims. The court also found that the Tribunal had properly considered the evidence of the incidents in September and December 2008, and had given reasons for discounting the appellant's claims. The court held that the Tribunal's decision was open to it and that the appeal did not establish any of the grounds relied upon.

The appeal was dismissed, and the appellants were ordered to pay the Minister's costs of the appeal. The court held that the Tribunal's decision was not so unreasonable as to justify setting it aside, and that the appeal did not establish any error in the application of the law or a failure to consider relevant evidence. The court found that the Tribunal had properly exercised its discretion and that the appellants had not demonstrated any grounds for setting aside the Tribunal's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellants pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Background

Background to the litigation

On appeal, the first appellant appeared in person, assisted by a Gujurati interpreter. The second appellant is the wife of the first appellant and her application for a Protection visa depends upon his claims. Accordingly, in these reasons, unless otherwise indicated, “the appellant” refers to the first appellant. FACTUAL BACKGROUND The appellant, who is 28 years old, arrived in Australia on 18 August 2009, travelling on an Indian passport. On 22 October 2010, he filed an application and supporting documentation with the Department of Immigration and Citizenship (“the Minister”) for a Protection (Class XA) visa. On 20 April 2011, a delegate of the Minister invited the appellant to attend an interview on 4 May 2011. On 26 May 2011, the appellant provided further documentation in support of his visa application. On 28 June 2011, the delegate decided to refuse to grant the appellant a protection visa, as the delegate was not satisfied that the appellants were non-citizens in Australia to whom Australia has protection obligations under the United Nations Refugees Convention of 1951, as amended by the Refugees Protocol of 1967. On 20 July 2011, the appellant applied to the Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s decision. On 24 August 2011, the Tribunal invited the appellant to appear before it in Mildura on 5 October 2011. After a number of adjournments, the Tribunal hearing was held on 17 January 2012. At the Tribunal hearing on 17 January 2012, the appellant, assisted by an interpreter, gave evidence in support of the application. On 23 January 2012, the appellant provided a written response to the Tribunal’s request at the hearing for information pursuant to s 424AA of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”). On 25 January 2012, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision. Before the Tribunal, the appellant principally claimed that he feared for his life if he returned to India, as he would be killed by people from, or associated with, the Bharatiya Janata Party (“BJP”), other Indian political parties or underworld gangs. The appellant claimed that in two separate incidents at his clothing shop, in September and December 2008, he was physically harmed by persons associated with the BJP or others because of his political beliefs. The appellant claimed that on the first occasion, a number of men came into his shop, refused to pay for clothes and grabbed him by the collar. The appellant claimed that in the second incident, several men who entered his shop slapped and verbally abused him for his work with the Congress party. THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal accepted that the appellant was a citizen of India. The Tribunal expressed significant concerns about the appellant’s credibility, due to the inconsistencies between his written and his oral evidence, and because his written claims were 90-95% identical to another set of claims which were before the delegate. The appellant’s explanation of the identicality did not satisfy the Tribunal.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Before the Tribunal, the appellant principally claimed that he feared for his life if he returned to India, as he would be killed by people from, or associated with, the Bharatiya Janata Party (“BJP”), other Indian political parties or underworld gangs. The appellant claimed that in two separate incidents at his clothing shop, in September and December 2008, he was physically harmed by persons associated with the BJP or others because of his political beliefs. The appellant claimed that on the first occasion, a number of men came into his shop, refused to pay for clothes and grabbed him by the collar. The appellant claimed that in the second incident, several men who entered his shop slapped and verbally abused him for his work with the Congress party. THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION The Tribunal accepted that the appellant was a citizen of India. The Tribunal expressed significant concerns about the appellant’s credibility, due to the inconsistencies between his written and his oral evidence, and because his written claims were 90-95% identical to another set of claims which were before the delegate. The appellant’s explanation of the identicality did not satisfy the Tribunal. The Tribunal also expressed concerns about the delay between the appellant’s arrival in Australia and the lodgement of his visa application. Having considered the appellant’s explanation, the Tribunal stated that when combined with its overall concerns about the appellant’s credibility, the delay caused it to doubt that he had a well‑founded fear of persecution. The Tribunal accepted that the appellant was a Congress Party supporter who was involved in canvassing for that party in 2007 and 2008. It found, however, that his oral evidence did not support his written claims that people from the BJP had tried to kill him on many occasions. Due to the significant inconsistencies between the appellant’s oral evidence, his written statement and the supporting documents, the Tribunal did not accept his claims about the alleged incidents in September 2008 and December 2008. The Tribunal found that the appellant’s oral evidence about the details of the incident on 28 September 2008, including the persons allegedly present, was inconsistent with his written statement and supporting documents. Due to the inconsistency combined with its other concerns about the appellant’s credibility, the Tribunal concluded that the relevant incident did not occur as claimed. The Tribunal gave little weight to the evidence of two persons who claimed to have been present at the incident on 1 December 2008, as it was directly contradicted by the evidence of the appellant himself, who stated that they were not present. Due to the inconsistencies between the appellant’s oral evidence, his written statement and the supporting documents, the Tribunal concluded that the alleged incident on 1 December 2008 did not occur. The Tribunal gave little weight to the second appellant’s evidence about the incidents in September 2008 and December 2008, due to its overall concerns about the appellant’s credibility and veracity. The Tribunal accepted the appellant’s father’s evidence about incidents that occurred in Ridrol in 2010, but did not consider that it was relevant to the appellant, who was in Australia at the time.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established