MZYOA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MZYOA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 1462

Citation: MZYOA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 1462
Appeal from: MZYOA v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2011] FMCA 45
Parties: MZYOA v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP and JILLIAN BARTLETT IN HER CAPACITY AS INDEPENDENT MERITS REVIEWER
File number: VID 138 of 2012
Judge: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 20 December 2012
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Appeal from decision of Federal Magistrates Court –failure to consider an integer of the claim –-
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth)
Cases cited:

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 184
Attorney General (NSW) v Quin (1990) 170 CLR 1
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v MZYRI [2012] FCA 1107
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259

MZYOA v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2011] FMCA 45

NABE v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs (No 2) [2004] FCAFC 263
Plaintiff M61/2010E v Commonwealth; Plaintiff M69 of 2010 v Commonwealth (2010) 243 CLR 319
SZCBT v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2007] FCA 9
SZQJH v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 297

Date of hearing: 16 May 2012
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 44
Counsel for the Appellant: The Appellant appeared in person
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr W Mosely
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Second Respondent: The Second Respondent did not appear

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 138 of 2012

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

MZYOA
Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

JILLIAN BARTLETT IN HER CAPACITY AS INDEPENDENT MERITS REVIEWER
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MURPHY J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 DECEMBER 2012

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal is allowed.

2.The First Respondent to pay the Appellant's costs, including the costs of the proceeding before the Federal Magistrates Court.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 138 of 2012

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

MZYOA
Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

JILLIAN BARTLETT IN HER CAPACITY AS INDEPENDENT MERITS REVIEWER
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MURPHY J

DATE:

20 DECEMBER 2012

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. This proceeding is an appeal from the judgment of the Federal Magistrates Court (MZYOA v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2011] FMCA 45).

  2. The appellant is a citizen of Afghanistan of Hazara ethnicity. He left Afghanistan illegally and arrived in Australia by boat on 11 February 2010 at Christmas Island. He is an “offshore entry person” and an “unlawful non-citizen” for the purposes of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) because he arrived at Christmas Island, which is an “excised offshore place”,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MZYOA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 1462
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of MZYOA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship involves an Afghan Hazara man of Shi’a Muslim faith who was born in 1968 in Maidan Wardak, Afghanistan. He fled his homeland in 1986 due to the threat of compulsory military service, living in Iran for 22 years before returning to Kabul in 2008. His application to the Federal Magistrates Court was based on multiple claims for refugee status, including his fear of persecution due to his Hazara ethnicity, Shi’a faith, and his return to Afghanistan after living in Iran. The central claim, which forms the basis of this appeal, is that he faces persecution because he is identifiable as a Hazara who had been living in Iran for 22 years.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Reviewer properly considered and dealt with each integer of the appellant’s claim that he faces persecution due to being an Hazara who had returned to Afghanistan after living in Iran. The appellant argued that not all of the integers of this claim were properly considered by the Reviewer, specifically focusing on the risk of persecution due to his long absence from Afghanistan and his time spent in Iran. The court examined the submissions and the evidence presented by the appellant to determine if there was a failure to properly consider this integral part of his claim.

The court found that the Reviewer did not adequately consider the full scope of the Returnee from Iran Claim, particularly the risk associated with the appellant's long absence from Afghanistan and his time spent in Iran. The appellant's detailed account of his experiences and fears upon returning to Afghanistan, as well as the incidents of violence he encountered, highlighted the need for a more comprehensive analysis of this specific aspect of his claim. The court concluded that the Reviewer’s decision contained a jurisdictional error due to the inadequate consideration of the Returnee from Iran Claim.

The appeal was allowed, and the court ordered that the First Respondent pay the Appellant's costs, including the costs of the proceeding before the Federal Magistrates Court. This decision underscores the importance of a thorough and comprehensive assessment of all aspects of a refugee claimant’s circumstances to ensure that their application is properly considered.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The First Respondent to pay the Appellant's costs, including the costs of the proceeding before the Federal Magistrates Court.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons I set out below I have decided to allow the appeal.THE IMR HEARING AND DECISIONThe facts The appellant is an Afghan Hazara of Shi’a Muslim faith, with a wife and six children aged between 3 and 16, five of whom are girls. He was born in 1968 in Maidan Wardak, a province in the central east region of Afghanistan. From 1975 until 1985 he worked as a fruit seller in his father’s business. In order to avoid compulsory military service the appellant left his homeland in 1986 and moved to neighbouring Iran. He lived there for 22 years until 2008 when he returned to Kabul. He returned because of the significant difficulties associated with living illegally in Iran. The application to the Reviewer was based on a number of different claims. These claims were first detailed under a series of headings in a lengthy letter from the Refugee and Immigration Legal Centre dated 22 March 2011 (“the March 2011 RILC letter”). The headings were as follows:(a)Risk of serious harm on account of the applicant’s Hazara ethnicity and membership of the Hazara community;(b)The applicant’s fear of being targeted by the Kuchi and Taliban on account of his ethnicity and religion and/or his membership of the particular social group ‘Hazara landowners/farmers’;(c)Risk of serious harm on account of the applicant’s Shi’a religion;(d)Risk of serious harm on account of;(i)the applicant’s membership of the particular social group ‘Hazaras who have returned to Afghanistan after living abroad’; and ‘Afghans who have returned to Afghanistan after living in a Western country’ and/or ‘Afghans who have sought asylum in a Western Country’;(ii)actual or imputed political opinion in favour of the West, coalition forces and the Karzai government and/or in opposition to the Taliban and other anti-government elements on account of his long absence from Afghanistan, his presence in Australia, his Hazara ethnicity and Shi’a religion. The claim which is central to the appeal is contained within heading (d)(i) above – namely that because he was an Hazara who had returned to Afghanistan after living in Iran for 22 years the appellant faced a risk of persecution (“the Returnee from Iran Claim”). The appellant contends that not all of the integers of this claim were properly considered and dealt with by the Reviewer. Because the appellant does not make this contention in relation to the other bases for refugee status (advanced under the other headings) it is unnecessary that I deal with them. The appellant said in an undated statement provided to the Reviewer:[3]I strongly disagree with the information that my case officer relied on which indicates that Hazara and Shi’a Muslims are no longer at risk in Afghanistan. As I explained to my case officer, when I decided to return to Afghanistan from Iran I also thought that Afghanistan would now be safe for Hazaras because the Taliban are no longer in power. Unfortunately, I was very wrong and I saw with my own eyes the dangers and hardships that Hazaras face in Afghanistan. I do not believe that it will be safe for me to return there. Hazaras continued to be at risk of harm from Taliban, Pashtuns and Tajiks and unfortunately, I do not see any hope of the situation changing any time in the near future.…[4]I am originally from Beshood, in Wardak province although my family moved to Kabul when I was very young…. I have not been to Beshood since I was a young child. I do not believe that it would be a safe place for me to live as an Hazara and a Shi’a Muslim. For one thing, I have no family left in that area. My family still does have some land there but I have no idea what has happened to it or who is looking after it now. My cousin had asked someone to look after the family's land but he has been killed and I don't know what arrangements he made. I don't have any farming skills so would not be able to make a living there. I would not be able to live there because every year Kuchis come and kill Hazaras and take their land and property. They are very aggressive against Hazaras. For example, about two or three years ago, Kuchis attacked Beshood and killed many Hazaras. They are against us because they are Pashtuns and we are Hazaras and also because we are Shi’a Muslims. Furthermore, I have been away from Afghanistan for over 20 years and I fear that this may also identify me and put me at further risk. (Emphasis added)In the last paragraph of this submission the appellant sets out his fear that he will be killed if returned to Afghanistan because he is identifiable as a person who had been living in Iran for 22 years, and is therefore liable to be targeted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The question before me turns on whether the Reviewer properly considered each integer of the Returnee from Iran Claim. The appellant was not represented in the hearing before me and, understandably enough, was unable to make submissions as to jurisdictional error. He simply submits that if he is returned to Afghanistan he will be killed. He states:I don't want to go back because I believe 100 per cent that probably they will behead me and they put my head on top of my chest…. I don't know what to say but the only that I request you is to help me to be - to alive and to serve my family and my children. (sic)I have scrutinised the documents in the Appeal Book that set out the appellant’s claims and the submissions by counsel for the appellant in the Federal Magistrate’s Court in order to deal with the contention as to jurisdictional error.CONSIDERATION It seems clear that the appellant’s life in the relatively short period of his return to Afghanistan between 2008 and 2010 was very difficult. For example, the appellant swore that his five young daughters were sexually harassed and molested by four men of Kuchi ethnicity. This violence occurred in public while the girls were in the company of the appellant and his wife. The appellant attempted to defend his daughters but was attacked and beaten badly by half of the assailants, while the others continued to molest them. The assaults were only stopped when they attracted the attention of passers by. The Reviewer accepted that this incident occurred, although she did not relate it to the appellant's Hazara ethnicity or his Shi’a faith. She treated the assaults as “opportunistic” or “indiscriminate” sexual harassment, and the assault on the appellant as a furtherance of that harassment. The appellant also swore that shortly before he left Afghanistan he had worked as a welder with his cousin in a business that made doors. His cousin was beaten and shot dead when, in attempting to obtain payment of a business debt, he went with some Pashtun customers to a neighbouring province. The appellant knew these customers and had been asked to go with his cousin at the time but did not do so. The appellant said that the customers were Taliban, that they had refused to pay in full because his cousin was an Hazara, and in effect that his cousin was killed because he was an Hazara who pursued the payment. The cousin was not robbed of his valuable items, which led the appellant to believe that his cousin was not killed for money. It seems the murder was never solved and the murderers not apprehended. Again, the Reviewer accepted that this murder occurred. However, she rejected the suggestion that the killers were Taliban and treated the murder as a criminal act which was not motivated by any reason covered by the Refugee Convention. The Reviewer’s findings in this regard are not part of the appeal. I set these facts out as they illustrate the harshness of the appellant’s life in Afghanistan and the difference between this and the life we expect in Australia. It is the life to which the appellant will be returned if his application to be treated as a refugee is unsuccessful. That is not to say that his appeal ought not be rejected if he cannot establish jurisdictional error, but rather that he is entitled to a proper consideration of his claims.