Details
- Case
- [2010] FCA 1325
- Decision Date
-
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The appeal in MZYFS v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship was brought by a Chinese national who had arrived in Australia on a family visitor visa and subsequently applied for a protection visa on the basis of his Christian beliefs and alleged religious persecution in China. The Federal Magistrates Court dismissed the appellant's application for judicial review of the decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal, which had affirmed the delegate's refusal to grant a protection visa. The central legal issue before the court was whether the appellant had a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of his religious beliefs if he were to return to China. The court needed to determine the credibility of the appellant's claims and whether they were consistent with the evidence presented and the country information available.
The court found that the Tribunal had properly exercised its discretion in rejecting the appellant's claims. The Tribunal concluded that the appellant had fabricated his claims of religious persecution for the purpose of his visa application. The Tribunal did not accept that the appellant was a member of the Local Church or that he had been arrested and detained for his religious activities in China. The court found that the Tribunal had appropriately considered the inconsistencies in the appellant's statements and the lack of detailed knowledge about his alleged church and Christian faith. The Tribunal also disregarded the appellant's attendance at a church in Melbourne as it considered this conduct to be an attempt to strengthen his claim. Furthermore, the Tribunal found the documents provided by the appellant in support of his claims to be unreliable. The court upheld the Tribunal's findings and dismissed the appeal.
The outcome of the case was that the appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the Tribunal affirming the delegate's refusal to grant the appellant a protection visa was upheld. The court found no error in the Tribunal's assessment of the appellant's claims and the evidence provided, and therefore, the appellant's application for judicial review was unsuccessful.
Background
Background to the litigation
For the reasons stated below, I would dismiss the appeal. BACKGROUND The appellant is a citizen of the Peoples Republic of China. He arrived in Australia on 30 August 2007 on a sponsored family visitor visa. On 12 October 2007 he applied for a protection visa. The appellant claimed refugee status on the basis that he would be persecuted in China on account of his Christian beliefs and religious activities. In his visa application, he stated amongst other things that:I came to Australia to visit my sister’s family. I will definitely continue with the involvement with our local family church and I can be arrested and tortured again by Chinese Public Security Bureau officers. …[T]he authority will not protect me instead they will persecute me. The authority is trying to root out our local family church in China. The appellant’s visa application was supported by a statement dated 9 October 2007, in which the appellant described, amongst other things, his church group in China. In this statement the appellant said that he was a member of the “Local Family Church”, or “Local Church”, the members of which were also sometimes known as “Shouters”. The appellant claimed, amongst other things, that he “had started to attend our local family church gatherings since [he] was [a] very young boy” and that he “learned how to pray, how to sing hymns ... at [a] young age”. He described being baptized at twelve years of age. He also claimed that, while attending church meetings, he had been arrested by the Public Security Bureau officers and detained for some weeks in September 2002 and in July 2006 and mistreated whilst in detention. On the first occasion, he claimed that he was released after being required to make a statement in which he agreed to keep away from the Local Church. On the second occasion, he claimed that he was released with a fine. He said that, if he returned to China, he would continue with underground church activities and feared further persecution. On 19 November 2008 a delegate of the first respondent refused to grant the appellant a protection visa, on the basis that the appellant was not a person to whom Australia owed protection obligations under the Refugees Convention. The appellant applied to the Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s decision. The Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision on 17 July 2009. On 19 August 2009 the appellant filed an application for judicial review in the Federal Magistrates Court. This application was heard on 18 December 2009, and it was dismissed on that date: see [2009] FMCA 1302. TRIBUNAL DECISION On 17 July 2009, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision. The Tribunal concluded that the appellant did not have a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason. In summary:1.The Tribunal did not accept that the appellant or his family were members of the Local Church in China or that the appellant had practised as a Shouter in China. It did not accept that the appellant was raised in a Christian household. The Tribunal found that he had fabricated his claims for the purposes of his protection visa application.2.The Tribunal noted that the appellant showed little and superficial knowledge about the Local Church and Christianity; that his knowledge was “patchy and unforthcoming when the questions required anything more than very basic information”; and that he showed “very scant knowledge of the fundamental teachings of the Local Church”. Since the Tribunal did not accept the appellant’s claims of involvement with the Local Church, he did not accept that he was “ever arrested and detained or tortured for reasons of illegal religious activity in China”.3.The Tribunal referred to “significant difference or inconsistencies in the information he provided in his written statement submitted with the protection visa application and that which he provided during an interview with the Department”. The Tribunal did not accept the appellant’s explanation that he had been drinking on the previous night and was still under the influence of alcohol or that his nervousness relevantly affected him. The Tribunal also found the appellant’s responses to the Tribunal’s letter of 2 March 2009 (pursuant to s 424A of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth)) “similarly implausible” and did not accept them “as resolving the significant inconsistencies … identified both during the hearing and in the 2 March 2009 letter”.4.The Tribunal accepted that the appellant may have attended the Local Church in Melbourne and, by so doing, had familiarised himself “with aspects of the Christian faith and the teachings of the Local Church”. In conformity with s 91R(3) of the Migration Act, however, the Tribunal disregarded this conduct, noting that it considered this to be conduct in which the appellant had engaged for the purpose of strengthening his claim to be a refugee.5.The Tribunal did not accept that the documents provided in support of the appellant’s claims of arrest and detention were reliable, taking into account a report from the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, inconsistencies between the address as stated in the documents and the relevant address as disclosed in his evidence, and “different and inconsistent” accounts about when he was arrested and how he obtained the documents.6.The Tribunal also noted that the appellant had obtained a passport and departed China without incident, referring to country information that a person who had been detained for any period or was the subject of other administrative penalties would have a police record; that a person who was considered harmful to state security was likely to be denied a passport; and that illegally obtaining a passport would be highly risky and expensive.7.While the Tribunal accepted that the appellant had paid a fine for having a second child, it did not accept that he was treated differently from others in Fujian Province because of his religious beliefs. The Tribunal found that there was no indication that there would be any further consequences to the appellant in respect of having a second child. The Tribunal was satisfied that the appellant did not face a real chance of further harm in the reasonably foreseeable future for reasons of his second child and, as a result, being a member of a particular social group. In respect of the appellant’s claim that he would suffer further persecution if his wife breached China’s family planning policy by becoming pregnant again, the Tribunal was not satisfied that any such fear was Convention-related.
Decision
Reasons for decision
On 19 November 2008 a delegate of the first respondent refused to grant the appellant a protection visa, on the basis that the appellant was not a person to whom Australia owed protection obligations under the Refugees Convention. The appellant applied to the Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s decision. The Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision on 17 July 2009. On 19 August 2009 the appellant filed an application for judicial review in the Federal Magistrates Court. This application was heard on 18 December 2009, and it was dismissed on that date: see [2009] FMCA 1302. TRIBUNAL DECISION On 17 July 2009, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision. The Tribunal concluded that the appellant did not have a well-founded fear of persecution for a Convention reason. In summary:1.The Tribunal did not accept that the appellant or his family were members of the Local Church in China or that the appellant had practised as a Shouter in China. It did not accept that the appellant was raised in a Christian household. The Tribunal found that he had fabricated his claims for the purposes of his protection visa application.2.The Tribunal noted that the appellant showed little and superficial knowledge about the Local Church and Christianity; that his knowledge was “patchy and unforthcoming when the questions required anything more than very basic information”; and that he showed “very scant knowledge of the fundamental teachings of the Local Church”. Since the Tribunal did not accept the appellant’s claims of involvement with the Local Church, he did not accept that he was “ever arrested and detained or tortured for reasons of illegal religious activity in China”.3.The Tribunal referred to “significant difference or inconsistencies in the information he provided in his written statement submitted with the protection visa application and that which he provided during an interview with the Department”. The Tribunal did not accept the appellant’s explanation that he had been drinking on the previous night and was still under the influence of alcohol or that his nervousness relevantly affected him. The Tribunal also found the appellant’s responses to the Tribunal’s letter of 2 March 2009 (pursuant to s 424A of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth)) “similarly implausible” and did not accept them “as resolving the significant inconsistencies … identified both during the hearing and in the 2 March 2009 letter”.4.The Tribunal accepted that the appellant may have attended the Local Church in Melbourne and, by so doing, had familiarised himself “with aspects of the Christian faith and the teachings of the Local Church”. In conformity with s 91R(3) of the Migration Act, however, the Tribunal disregarded this conduct, noting that it considered this to be conduct in which the appellant had engaged for the purpose of strengthening his claim to be a refugee.5.The Tribunal did not accept that the documents provided in support of the appellant’s claims of arrest and detention were reliable, taking into account a report from the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, inconsistencies between the address as stated in the documents and the relevant address as disclosed in his evidence, and “different and inconsistent” accounts about when he was arrested and how he obtained the documents.6.The Tribunal also noted that the appellant had obtained a passport and departed China without incident, referring to country information that a person who had been detained for any period or was the subject of other administrative penalties would have a police record; that a person who was considered harmful to state security was likely to be denied a passport; and that illegally obtaining a passport would be highly risky and expensive.7.While the Tribunal accepted that the appellant had paid a fine for having a second child, it did not accept that he was treated differently from others in Fujian Province because of his religious beliefs. The Tribunal found that there was no indication that there would be any further consequences to the appellant in respect of having a second child. The Tribunal was satisfied that the appellant did not face a real chance of further harm in the reasonably foreseeable future for reasons of his second child and, as a result, being a member of a particular social group. In respect of the appellant’s claim that he would suffer further persecution if his wife breached China’s family planning policy by becoming pregnant again, the Tribunal was not satisfied that any such fear was Convention-related.