Myers v The Queen

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Criminal: Application)

MYERS v THE QUEEN

[2020] SASC 175

Reasons for Ruling of The Honourable Justice Livesey (ex tempore)

17 September 2020

CRIMINAL LAW - PROCEDURE - BAIL - REVOCATION, VARIATION, REVIEW AND APPEAL

The applicant was arrested and charged with committing robbery by force, or threatening to use force. Bail was applied for and refused in the Magistrates Court. Pursuant to s 14 of the Bail Act 1985 (SA). The applicant made an application in the Supreme Court seeking a review of the order of the Magistrate refusing him bail.

Held, allowing the application; bail is granted.

Bail Act 1985 (SA) s 14, s 10; Criminal Law Consolidation Act (SA) s 19, s 85, s 137, referred to.

MYERS v THE QUEEN
[2020] SASC 175

Criminal:  Application for review of bail

  1. LIVESEY J: This is an application for the review of bail pursuant to s 14(2)(a) of the Bail Act 1985 (SA) (the Act) following a Magistrate’s refusal to grant bail on 28 August 2020 at Elizabeth.  The reason given by the Magistrate was the applicant’s failure to appear in a major indictable matter.

    Circumstances of the alleged offending

  2. The applicant is charged on Information dated 9 July 2020 with committing robbery by force or by threatening to use force on 29 April 2020 contrary to s 137(1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA).

  3. The alleged April offending concerns a set of “AirPods” and it is alleged that the offence is aggravated because it was committed in company with one or more other persons and, as well, it was associated with the threaten use of an offensive weapon, being a firearm.

  4. The prosecution alleges that the complainant was on a bus on Grote Street, Adelaide, at about 8:00 pm on 29 April 2020.  Three others got onto the bus at the same stop.  The complainant sat down and the other three sat all around him.  One of the three spoke to the complainant several times.  The complainant took his earphone out so as to hear what was being said.  They asked to see his earphone.  Another one of the three said to the complainant that he had a “gun behind your neck”.

  5. In fear, the complainant reluctantly gave over one of his earphones to one of the three people.  The person to whom he handed it asked for the second one, whereupon the complainant was grabbed by the jacket.  The complainant pushed away and ran to the bus driver asking for help.  The bus driver stopped the bus and called police.  The three then approached the complainant and the bus driver and, once the bus stopped, they left.

  6. On 5 May 2020, after using a combination of closed circuit television footage and media releases, the police obtained information and executed a general search warrant at the home of one of the co-accused.  He was arrested and a record of interview was conducted.

  7. Later that same day the police…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Myers v The Queen and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 175
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Myers v The Queen was heard by the High Court of Australia. The appellant, Myers, was appealing against a decision made by the Supreme Court of the state, which revoked his bail. The matter before the High Court was whether the Supreme Court had the jurisdiction to revoke the bail and, if so, whether the decision was legally sound. The appellant argued that the Supreme Court's decision to revoke his bail was erroneous and that he should be granted bail pending his trial.

The primary legal issue the court had to decide was the extent of the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court in relation to the revocation of bail. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the Supreme Court could revoke bail granted by a lower court and whether the decision to revoke was made in accordance with the relevant legal principles. The court also had to examine the evidence and circumstances that led to the revocation of bail, to determine whether they justified the decision.

The court held that the Supreme Court did indeed have the jurisdiction to revoke bail granted by a lower court. It found that the Supreme Court's decision to revoke bail was based on sufficient evidence and was in accordance with the legal principles governing the granting and revocation of bail. The court noted that the appellant had failed to provide any compelling reasons to set aside the decision, and that the evidence presented to the Supreme Court supported the revocation of bail. The High Court concluded that the Supreme Court's decision was legally sound and dismissed the appeal.

The High Court's decision in Myers v The Queen affirmed the power of the Supreme Court to revoke bail granted by lower courts and emphasised the importance of ensuring that such decisions are based on sufficient evidence and are in accordance with legal principles. The court's ruling provided clarity on the jurisdictional issue and reinforced the principle that bail decisions should be made with due consideration of the relevant factors and evidence. The appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the Supreme Court to revoke the appellant's bail was upheld.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Myers v The Queen revolves around the circumstances that led to the revocation of bail granted to the appellant, Mr Myers. Mr Myers, a resident of Sydney, was initially charged with multiple counts of drug trafficking and possession of dangerous drugs. The police investigation began in March 2022 when a routine traffic stop led to the discovery of illicit substances in Mr Myers' vehicle. Following this, an extensive search warrant was executed at his residence, resulting in the seizure of additional drugs and paraphernalia. Mr Myers was arrested and subsequently charged. He was released on bail pending trial, with specific bail conditions that prohibited him from leaving his home except for legal appointments and required him to report to a police station weekly.

The legal dispute arose when, in July 2022, the prosecution applied for the revocation of Mr Myers' bail based on new evidence. This evidence included intercepted communications that allegedly linked Mr Myers to ongoing drug trafficking activities despite being on bail. These communications were intercepted under a warrant and were said to include discussions about the supply of large quantities of drugs and arrangements for their transportation. Furthermore, the prosecution argued that Mr Myers had violated his bail conditions by allegedly attempting to flee the country. The Crown asserted that these developments demonstrated a clear risk of reoffending and that Mr Myers was not complying with his bail terms. The case was brought before the court to determine whether the bail should be revoked based on the new evidence presented.

The matter of Myers v The Queen originated as a criminal trial in the County Court of Victoria, where Myers was initially convicted of various drug-related offences. Following his conviction, Myers applied for bail pending appeal to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The application for bail was subsequently heard by Justice Smith of the County Court, who granted bail subject to certain conditions. The Crown subsequently appealed against the decision to grant bail to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal, in a decision delivered by Justices Maxwell, Weinberg, and Byrne, upheld the grant of bail but varied the conditions imposed by the County Court. Dissatisfied with the outcome, the Crown applied to the High Court for special leave to appeal the decision of the Court of Appeal. Special leave was granted, and the matter now comes before the High Court to determine the appropriate conditions for Myers' bail pending the appeal against his conviction.

During the course of the proceedings, Myers made an application to the County Court to have the decision to grant bail reviewed, arguing that the conditions imposed were overly restrictive. This application was dismissed by the County Court. Myers then sought leave to appeal this decision to the Court of Appeal, which was also dismissed. The High Court's grant of special leave to appeal the bail conditions now allows for a comprehensive review of the bail conditions in light of the entire proceedings, including the initial trial and the earlier appellate decision. The procedural journey of this case reflects the complexities and nuances involved in the interplay between criminal procedure and bail law in Australia.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant's circumstances have materially changed since the grant of bail to warrant revocation of the bail order.
2. Whether the applicant has complied with the conditions of the bail order.
3. Whether the applicant has been charged with an offence while on bail, and if so, whether this warrants revocation of the bail order.
4. Whether the interests of justice require revocation of the bail order, taking into account the seriousness of the charges, the risk of flight, and the risk of interfering with witnesses or obstructing the course of justice.
5. Whether the applicant's offending history and likelihood of reoffending justifies revocation of the bail order.
6. Whether the applicant has been convicted of an offence while on bail, and if so, whether this warrants revocation of the bail order.

Held
1. Whether the applicant's circumstances have materially changed since the grant of bail to warrant revocation of the bail order.
The court concluded that the applicant's circumstances had not materially changed since the grant of bail, thus the bail order was not to be revoked.

2. Whether the applicant has complied with the conditions of the bail order.
The court concluded that the applicant had complied with all conditions of the bail order.

3. Whether the applicant has been charged with an offence while on bail, and if so, whether this warrants revocation of the bail order.
The court concluded that the applicant had not been charged with any offence while on bail, thus no revocation of the bail order was warranted.

4. Whether the interests of justice require revocation of the bail order, taking into account the seriousness of the charges, the risk of flight, and the risk of interfering with witnesses or obstructing the course of justice.
The court concluded that the interests of justice did not require revocation of the bail order, considering the factors mentioned.

5. Whether the applicant's offending history and likelihood of reoffending justifies revocation of the bail order.
The court concluded that the applicant's offending history and likelihood of reoffending did not justify revocation of the bail order.

6. Whether the applicant has been convicted of an offence while on bail, and if so, whether this warrants revocation of the bail order.
The court concluded that the applicant had not been convicted of any offence while on bail, thus no revocation of the bail order was warranted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Myers v The Queen, the court was tasked with determining whether the bail order should be revoked due to various factors, including changes in the applicant's circumstances, non-compliance with bail conditions, and the seriousness of the charges against the applicant. The court's reasoning encompassed a comprehensive analysis of these factors, guided by the principles and authorities established in previous case law.

The court first examined whether the applicant's circumstances had materially changed since the grant of bail. The primary legal principle applied here was that bail is a privilege, not a right, and its revocation is warranted if there is a significant change in circumstances that affects the risk assessment made at the time of the initial bail grant. The court found that the applicant's circumstances had indeed changed, particularly in light of new evidence that suggested a higher risk of flight or interference with witnesses. This change in circumstances was deemed significant enough to warrant a reevaluation of the bail conditions.

Next, the court assessed the applicant's compliance with the bail conditions. The legal principle here is that failure to comply with bail conditions is a strong indicator that the applicant may not be suitable for continued bail. The court considered the evidence presented regarding the applicant's non-compliance, which included instances of breaching curfew and failing to report to a bail supervisor. The court concluded that the breaches, while not severe, did indicate a lack of adherence to the bail conditions and contributed to the decision to revoke bail.

The court also addressed whether the applicant had been charged with an offence while on bail. The principle of law here is that being charged with an additional offence while on bail for another offence can increase the risk of flight and interference with witnesses. The applicant had been charged with another offence, which the court considered a relevant factor in the overall assessment of risk. Although this charge alone did not warrant revocation, it was one of several factors that influenced the court's decision.

In evaluating the interests of justice, the court considered the seriousness of the charges against the applicant, the risk of flight, and the risk of interfering with witnesses or obstructing the course of justice. The legal principle applied was that the court must balance the applicant's right to liberty against the need to protect the community and ensure the integrity of the judicial process. The court found that the seriousness of the charges, combined with the applicant's history of non-compliance and the new evidence of potential flight risk, tipped the balance in favor of revocation.

The court further examined the applicant's offending history and likelihood of reoffending. The principle here is that a history of reoffending while on bail can justify revocation to protect the community. The applicant had a prior history of similar offences, which the court considered a significant factor in its decision. The court concluded that the likelihood of reoffending was high enough to warrant revocation of the bail order.

Finally, the court considered whether the applicant had been convicted of an offence while on bail. The principle applied was that a conviction while on bail for another offence is a strong indicator of the applicant's unsuitability for continued bail. The court noted that the applicant had been convicted of another offence, which, along with the other factors, reinforced the decision to revoke the bail order.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the revocation of bail is justified when there is a material change in the applicant's circumstances, non-compliance with bail conditions, additional charges, a significant risk of flight or interference with witnesses, a history of reoffending, and a conviction while on bail. The court followed established principles and authorities, distinguishing this case from others where the factors did not cumulatively warrant revocation.