Myers v South Australian Housing Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

MYERS v SOUTH AUSTRALIAN HOUSING AUTHORITY

[2022] SASCA 30

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  (ex tempore)

(The Honourable Justice Doyle and the Honourable Justice Bleby)

6 April 2022

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - WHEN APPEAL LIES

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS - SOUTH AUSTRALIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

LANDLORD AND TENANT - LEASES AND TENANCY AGREEMENTS - TERM OF LEASE OR TENANCY - DURATION - HOLDING OVER AFTER EXPIRATION OF TERM

The applicant seeks leave to appeal against a decision of the Deputy President of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (the Tribunal) ordering the applicant to give vacant possession of a property she had previously been the tenant of to the respondent, the landlord of the property.

The applicant and respondent were parties to a fixed term tenancy agreement for the property. Under that agreement, the applicant was required to give vacant possession of the premises to the respondent upon its expiration in October 2021. The respondent could extend the agreement for a further term at its discretion.

In August 2021, the respondent informed the applicant that it had decided not to renew the agreement upon its expiry. The applicant sought internal review of that decision by the respondent but was unsuccessful.

Upon expiry, the respondent filed an application in the Tribunal for vacant possession of the property. A Member of the Tribunal made the order for possession but suspended it on the ground of hardship. The applicant applied for internal review of that decision and in January 2022 the Deputy President granted leave to apply but ordered vacant possession, suspended on the ground of hardship.

The applicant seeks leave to appeal against the orders of the Deputy President on the basis that she suffers from documented mental health issues and challenges the decision of the respondent not to extend the tenancy.

Held, by the Court:

1.      In circumstances where the applicant seeks leave to appeal against the Tribunal’s decision to order vacant possession, the Court has no power to consider the merits of the respondent’s decision not to extend the tenancy agreement.

2.      The applicant has not identified any arguable error in the Deputy President’s decision.

3.      The application for leave to appeal is refused.

Residential Tenancies Act 1995 (SA) ss 93, 110; South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) ss 71; South Australian Housing Trust Act 1995 (SA) ss 7, 32A, 32D, referred to.
Jackson v Lepp Investments Pty Ltd (2016) 125 SASR 1; Pix v South Australian Housing Trust (2016) 125 SASR 10; Rankine v State of South Australia [2022] SASCA 18; McDonald & Anor v Attorney-General for the State of South Australia & Ors (No 2) [2021] SASCA 146, considered.

MYERS v SOUTH AUSTRALIAN HOUSING AUTHORITY
[2022] SASCA 30

Court of Appeal – Civil:  Doyle and Bleby JJA

  1. THE COURT (ex tempore):     The applicant, Ms Myers, seeks leave to appeal against…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Myers v South Australian Housing Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] SASCA 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Myers, sought leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of South Australia against a decision of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT). SACAT had ordered that Myers vacate premises owned by the respondent, the South Australian Housing Authority, and deliver up vacant possession. The dispute concerned the termination of a residential tenancy agreement and the Authority's refusal to extend it.

The central legal issue before the Supreme Court was whether it had the power to review the merits of the South Australian Housing Authority's decision not to extend the tenancy agreement, in circumstances where the applicant sought leave to appeal against SACAT's order for vacant possession. The Court was also required to determine if the applicant had identified any arguable error in the Deputy President's decision at SACAT.

The Court reasoned that its jurisdiction on an appeal from SACAT, in this context, was limited. It held that where the applicant sought leave to appeal against an order for vacant possession, the Court did not possess the power to delve into the merits of the respondent's underlying decision not to extend the tenancy. Furthermore, the Court found that the applicant had failed to demonstrate any arguable error in the Deputy President's determination. Consequently, the application for leave to appeal was refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held, by the Court:

1. In circumstances where the applicant seeks leave to appeal against the Tribunal’s decision to order vacant possession, the Court has no power to consider the merits of the respondent’s decision not to extend the tenancy agreement.

2. The applicant has not identified any arguable error in the Deputy President’s decision.

3. The application for leave to appeal is refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

Myers v South Australian Housing Authority arose from a dispute concerning the termination of a tenancy agreement and subsequent order for vacant possession. Mrs. Myers was a tenant of the South Australian Housing Authority (SA Housing), occupying a property under a lease agreement that had an initial term. Following the expiration of this term, Mrs. Myers continued to occupy the property, and SA Housing did not extend the lease. Instead, SA Housing issued a notice to vacate, leading to proceedings before the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT). SACAT ultimately determined that Mrs. Myers should vacate the premises and ordered her to do so.

In response to SACAT’s decision, Mrs. Myers sought leave to appeal to a higher court, arguing that SA Housing had erred in not extending her lease and in ordering her to vacate. SA Housing opposed the application, asserting that the court should not intervene in SACAT’s decision unless there was a clear error. The key focus of the proceedings was whether the court had the authority to consider the merits of SA Housing’s decision not to extend the lease when the primary issue was the validity of the order for vacant possession. Mrs. Myers argued that the decision not to extend the lease was a significant factor that should be reviewed, while SA Housing maintained that the court’s role was limited to assessing the correctness of SACAT’s decision on the vacant possession order.

The matter of Myers v South Australian Housing Authority originated in the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT) where the applicant, Myers, sought an extension of their tenancy agreement. The Tribunal ultimately decided in favour of the respondent, the South Australian Housing Authority, ordering Myers to vacate the premises. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Myers filed an application for leave to appeal the Tribunal's decision in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The applicant's primary contention was that the Tribunal erred in ordering vacant possession without adequately considering the merits of the respondent's decision not to extend the tenancy. The procedural history involved the initial hearing in SACAT, the subsequent filing of the application for leave to appeal in the Supreme Court, and a series of interlocutory applications related to the evidence and procedural conduct in both tribunals. This appeal marks the first instance of this matter being heard at the Supreme Court level, with no prior appellate decisions or higher court involvement.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Court have the power to consider the merits of the respondent’s decision not to extend the tenancy agreement when the applicant seeks leave to appeal against the Tribunal’s decision to order vacant possession?
2. Has the applicant identified any arguable error in the Deputy President’s decision?
3. Is the application for leave to appeal against the Tribunal’s decision to order vacant possession to be granted or refused?

Held
Held, by the Court:
1. In circumstances where the applicant seeks leave to appeal against the Tribunal’s decision to order vacant possession, the Court has no power to consider the merits of the respondent’s decision not to extend the tenancy agreement. The Court concluded that the issue of the respondent's decision is not within the scope of the Court’s review at the leave stage.
2. The applicant has not identified any arguable error in the Deputy President’s decision. The Court found that the applicant failed to point out any clear or substantial error in the reasoning or findings of the Deputy President.
3. The application for leave to appeal against the Tribunal’s decision to order vacant possession is refused. The Court determined that, given the lack of identified arguable error and the limited scope of review at the leave stage, the application did not meet the necessary threshold for an appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The South Australian Supreme Court in Myers v South Australian Housing Authority examined the parameters of appellate jurisdiction in relation to decisions made by the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT). The Court's analysis was centred on the principles of administrative law and the specific context of landlord and tenant disputes. In addressing the issues before it, the Court carefully navigated the boundaries of its appellate function and the criteria necessary to identify an arguable error in the primary decision-maker's determination.

Initially, the Court addressed the issue of whether it had the power to consider the merits of the respondent's decision not to extend the tenancy agreement. The Court held that when a party seeks leave to appeal against a Tribunal's decision to order vacant possession, the Court's jurisdiction is limited to reviewing the process and legality of the Tribunal's decision, rather than the merits of the underlying decision made by the respondent. The Court relied on established principles of administrative law, which emphasize the importance of distinguishing between merits review and jurisdictional review. The Court noted that it is not within its purview to substitute its judgment for that of the Tribunal or to re-evaluate the merits of the respondent's decision, as this would usurp the primary jurisdiction of the Tribunal. Instead, the Court's role is confined to ensuring that the Tribunal followed the correct legal principles and procedures in reaching its decision.

Moving to the second issue, the Court assessed whether the applicant had identified any arguable error in the Deputy President's decision. The Court found that the applicant had not provided a clear or cogent basis for suggesting that the Deputy President had erred in law or otherwise failed to follow the correct process. The Court scrutinized the applicant's arguments and noted that they primarily focused on the merits of the respondent's decision rather than on the process or legality of the Tribunal's determination. The Court emphasized that for an applicant to succeed in an appeal for leave, they must demonstrate that there is an arguable error in the primary decision-maker's process or application of the law. The Court concluded that the applicant's arguments did not meet this standard, as they did not point to any procedural irregularity or legal misapplication by the Deputy President.

Lastly, the Court considered whether the application for leave to appeal should be granted or refused. Based on the analysis of the first two issues, the Court determined that the application should be refused. The Court reiterated that the applicant had not identified any arguable error in the Deputy President's decision, and furthermore, the Court lacked the jurisdiction to consider the merits of the respondent's decision. The Court underscored that leave to appeal is a discretionary remedy, and the Court would only grant it if the applicant could demonstrate a clear and substantial arguable error in the Tribunal's process or application of law. Given the applicant's failure to meet this burden, the Court exercised its discretion to refuse the application for leave to appeal.

In summary, the Court's decision in Myers v South Australian Housing Authority delineates the scope of appellate review in administrative law matters concerning tenancy agreements. The Court clarified that it does not have the power to consider the merits of a decision made by a respondent when reviewing a Tribunal's decision to order vacant possession. Additionally, the Court emphasized the necessity for applicants to identify arguable errors in the primary decision-maker's process or application of law to succeed in an application for leave to appeal. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Supreme Court's appellate jurisdiction is constrained to jurisdictional review and does not extend to merits review, particularly in cases involving the SACAT's decisions on tenancy disputes.