Myers v Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Myers v Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd & Anor [2022] QSC 230

PARTIES:

LINDSAY JAMES MYERS

(applicant)

v
PETRIE DENTAL PROPERTY PTY LTD
ACN 059 033 902

(first respondent)
PAUL HARVEY GOLLEDGE
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 4807 of 2022

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Originating Application

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

2 November 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

7 October 2022

JUDGE:

Cooper J

ORDERS:

1.     The originating application filed 27 April 2022 is dismissed.

2.      It is declared that the lease between Paul H Golledge Pty Ltd and Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd executed on 20 April 2011 in respect of the premises at 25 Dayboro Road, Petrie, properly described as Lot 41 on RP 30213 in the County of Stanley, Parish of Redcliffe, Title Reference 14369058 is valid.

3. Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd is to be wound up pursuant to s 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

4.     Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson are appointed joint and several liquidators of Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd.

5.     Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson are appointed as receivers, without security, over all present and after acquired property, rights and undertakings (Trust Property) of the Petrie Dental Property Unit Trust (Trust).

6.     It is declared that Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd has a right of exoneration from the Trust Property in respect of all costs, charges and expenses incurred by Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd as trustee for the Trust (Trustee) in relation to the proper performance of its duties in respect of the Trust, which are provable in Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd’s liquidation.

7.     Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson, as liquidators of Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd, are justified, subject to paragraphs 11, 12, 13 and 14 below, in treating the proceeds of the Trust Property received in the liquidation of Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd pursuant to the right of exoneration referred to in paragraph 6 above as being available for distribution to Trust creditors in accordance with the order of priorities provided for in Division 6 of Part 5.6 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

8.     Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson are conferred with the following powers in respect of the property of the Trust:

(a) the powers recited in s 420 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), as if the references in that section to “property of the corporation” was reference to property of the Trust;

(b) the powers that a liquidator has in respect of property of a company by s 477 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth); and

(c)     the power to do all things necessary and convenient to:

(i)   distribute the net proceeds of the sale of the assets of the Trust (after payment of the costs, expenses and remuneration of Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson in their capacity as receivers and as liquidator of Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd in accordance with order 7 above) to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Myers v Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QSC 230
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Myers v Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd, Dr Myers, a former director of the respondent company, sought leave to bring proceedings on behalf of the company against another director, Dr Golledge, and a related entity, PHG. Dr Myers claimed that unpaid rent was due to the company and sought to recover it. The application raised several legal issues, including whether the proposed proceedings raised a serious question to be tried, whether they were in the best interests of the company, whether they were brought in good faith, and whether leave should be granted for derivative proceedings to be commenced. Additionally, the case considered whether a winding-up order was just and equitable due to the deadlock in the relationship between the two directors.

The court found that Dr Myers' application for leave to bring derivative proceedings did not meet the requirements set out in s 237(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Specifically, the court determined that the proposed proceedings did not raise a serious question to be tried and were not in the best interests of the company. Furthermore, the court concluded that the proceedings were not brought in good faith. As a result, Dr Myers' application for leave was dismissed.

Regarding the winding-up application, the court considered the principles governing just and equitable winding-up orders and found that the relationship between the two directors had deteriorated to the point of deadlock, rendering the continued operation of the company futile. The court concluded that a winding-up order was just and equitable, and the company was wound up pursuant to s 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

The court appointed Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson as joint and several liquidators of Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd and as receivers over all present and after-acquired property, rights, and undertakings of the Petrie Dental Property Unit Trust. The liquidators were granted various powers, including the authority to distribute the net proceeds of the sale of the trust assets to creditors and any surplus to the trust members. The liquidators were also directed to wind up the trust and recover any outstanding costs, expenses, and remuneration from the trust property. The applicant was ordered to pay the respondents' costs of and incidental to the consolidated proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The originating application filed 27 April 2022 is dismissed.

2. It is declared that the lease between Paul H Golledge Pty Ltd and Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd executed on 20 April 2011 in respect of the premises at 25 Dayboro Road, Petrie, properly described as Lot 41 on RP 30213 in the County of Stanley, Parish of Redcliffe, Title Reference 14369058 is valid.

3. Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd is to be wound up pursuant to s 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

4. Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson are appointed joint and several liquidators of Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd.

5. Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson are appointed as receivers, without security, over all present and after acquired property, rights and undertakings (Trust Property) of the Petrie Dental Property Unit Trust (Trust).

6. It is declared that Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd has a right of exoneration from the Trust Property in respect of all costs, charges and expenses incurred by Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd as trustee for the Trust (Trustee) in relation to the proper performance of its duties in respect of the Trust, which are provable in Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd’s liquidation.

7. Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson, as liquidators of Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd, are justified, subject to paragraphs 11, 12, 13 and 14 below, in treating the proceeds of the Trust Property received in the liquidation of Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd pursuant to the right of exoneration referred to in paragraph 6 above as being available for distribution to Trust creditors in accordance with the order of priorities provided for in Division 6 of Part 5.6 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

8. Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson are conferred with the following powers in respect of the property of the Trust:

(a) the powers recited in s 420 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), as if the references in that section to “property of the corporation” was reference to property of the Trust;

(b) the powers that a liquidator has in respect of property of a company by s 477 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth); and

(c) the power to do all things necessary and convenient to:

(i) distribute the net proceeds of the sale of the assets of the Trust (after payment of the costs, expenses and remuneration of Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson in their capacity as receivers and as liquidator of Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd in accordance with order 7 above) to creditors of the Trust in accordance with order 6 above;

(ii) distribute any surplus thereafter to the members of the Trust.

9. The need for Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson to file security under r 268 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) is dispensed with.

10. Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson, in their capacity as receivers of the Trust and liquidators of Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd, are directed to cause Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd to wind up the Trust, pursuant to clause 17 of the Deed of Trust of the Trust dated 6 April 1993.

11. Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson, in their capacity as receivers of the property of the Trust or in their capacity as liquidators of Petrie Dental Property Pty Ltd, may have recourse to the Trust Property for their costs, expenses and remuneration in so far as the property or proceeds therefrom relates to costs, expenses and remuneration at the remuneration calculated in accordance with the rates set out in the Consent of Liquidator filed 11 July 2022 and Consent of Receiver filed 5 October 2022, and otherwise as ordered by the Court.

12. The work referred to in paragraph 11 above is to include work relating to:

(a) the identification of Trust assets and liabilities;

(b) the identification of Trust creditors;

(c) the ascertaining of the state of the accounts between the beneficiaries and the trustee;

(d) the recovering or attempting to recover Trust assets for the purposes of meeting the right of exoneration;

(e) the realisation or the attempted realisation of the Trust assets for the purposes of meeting the right of exoneration;

(f) the securing of Trust assets (or their value) to meet the right of exoneration and their application to the Trust creditors;

(g) the distribution of funds which are the subject of the right of exoneration to those who are entitled to them; and

(h) any matter in the administration of the Trust which is reasonably ancillary to the above to the extent to which it had been undertaken for the purposes of the identified tasks.

13. The amounts which Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson are entitled from the Trust Property under paragraph 11 above are to be determined by the Court.

14. Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson have a lien over the Trust Property of the amounts to be paid to them under paragraphs 11, 12 and 13 above.

15. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs of and incidental to the consolidated proceeding to be assessed on the standard basis unless otherwise agreed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Golledge parties’ application raises the issue whether the deterioration of the relationship between Dr Myers and Dr Golledge makes it just and equitable in all of the circumstances for PDP to be wound up.Background PDP was incorporated on 10 February 1993. Dr Myers and Dr Golledge are directors of PDP. At around the time that PDP was incorporated:(a)Dr Myers and Dr Golledge:(i)through their associated companies, Lindsay J Myers Pty Ltd (LJM) and PHG respectively, operated a dental practice known as the Petrie Dental Centre (Petrie Dental);(ii)through the corporate trustees of their respective superannuation funds, had purchased a property at 25 Dayboro Road, Petrie (Property) near the premises from which Petrie Dental was then operating;(iii)intended to move Petrie Dental to a building which was to be constructed on the Property;(b)the Property was transferred to PDP as trustee of a unit trust, of which Dr Myers’ and Dr Golledge’s respective superannuation funds each held a 50% interest, and then leased to LJM and PHG at a commercial rate with profits to be distributed equally to the superannuation funds. No formal lease was entered into between PDP and either of the corporate tenants at that time. Following the construction of the proposed building and the transfer of the Property to PDP, Dr Myers and Dr Golledge operated Petrie Dental from the Property. LJM and PHG each paid one half of the rent charged by PDP. Dr Myers retired from practice on about 29 March 2011 and sold his interest in Petrie Dental to a third party, KH & LAJ Pty Ltd (KHLAJ). In the context of that sale, on about 20 April 2011, PDP (by both of its directors, Dr Myers and Dr Golledge) executed two written leases:(a)one with KHLAJ, which granted:(i)exclusive use of one of the two surgery rooms in the Property, referred to in the lease as Unit 1, being the room from which Dr Myers had previously practiced; and(ii)shared use of the common areas, referred to in the lease as Unit 3;(b)one with PHG, which granted:(i)exclusive use of the other surgery room in the Property, referred to in the lease as Unit 2, being the room from which Dr Golledge had, and would continue, to practice; and(ii)shared use of the common areas referred to as Unit 3. Each of these leases was for a term of five years commencing on 4 May 2011, with two options to renew for further terms of five years. The rent payable under each lease represented 50% of the commercial rent previously charged by PDP to LJM and PHG. In mid-2013 KHLAJ decided to leave Petrie Dental and, in that context, entered into a Deed of Release and Settlement with Lambowl Pty Ltd (Lambowl), the corporate trustee of Dr Golledge’s superannuation fund, by which Lambowl indemnified KHLAJ and assumed all of its obligations under its lease with PDP. By about 15 November 2013, KHLAJ had vacated the Property. Lambowl paid the rent due under PDP’s lease to KHLAJ until about 3 September 2016, at which time it vacated Unit 1, removed all plant and equipment and ceased paying rent to PDP.

Decision

Reasons for decision

However, because I have already concluded that two of the requirements of s 237(2) of the Act have not been fulfilled, it is not necessary for me to say anything further about the question of good faith.Conclusion As I am not satisfied that all of the requirements of s 237(2) of the Act have been met, Dr Myers’ application to bring proceedings on behalf of PDP against PHG and Dr Golledge must be dismissed.Application to wind up on the just and equitable ground There was no real dispute between the parties as to the principles which apply on an application to wind up a company on the just and equitable ground. Useful summaries of the relevant principles were set out in Re Docklands Chiropractic Clinic Pty Ltd[6] and in Re Crow Inn Pty Ltd (No 2).[7] [6][2020] VSC 364 at [19]-[25].[7][2020] NSWSC 1749 at [276]-[279]. The court must consider the factual matrix of the dispute in order to form a view as to whether a sufficient reason for making the winding up order has been demonstrated.[8] A winding up order must be just and equitable not only for Dr Golledge, but also for Dr Myers.[9][8]Re Docklands Chiropractic Clinic Pty Ltd [2020] VSC 364 at [21]; Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Letten (No 10) [2011] FCA 498 at [14].[9]Re Docklands Chiropractic Clinic Pty Ltd [2020] VSC 364 at [39]; Re G Jeffrey (Mens Store) Pty Ltd (1984) 9 ACLR 193 at 201. A deadlock in the management of a company’s affairs is a common case in which an order that a company be wound up on the just and equitable ground has been made, including in circumstances where a company was formed on the basis of a personal relationship involving mutual confidence and that confidence has broken down so that continuation of the association would be futile. That is an apt description of the present situation with PDP. The company was incorporated in the context of Dr Myers and Dr Golledge operating Petrie Dental in quasi-partnership. Dr Myers and Dr Golledge sought to obtain a benefit for their respective superannuation funds from the requirement that LJM and PHG pay commercial rent for premises from which to operate Petrie Dental. PDP’s purpose was to facilitate that aim. When Dr Myers’ sold his interest in Petrie Dental the previously amicable relationship between him and Dr Golledge rapidly deteriorated. The evidence shows that they have not held a meeting as directors of PDP since 2011. Their communications since that time, which have been conducted largely in writing, demonstrate a breakdown in trust between them. Unsurprisingly, this has had an adverse impact on the management of PDP’s affairs. There have been ongoing difficulties in appointing an accountant for PDP and completing financial statements. None of PDP’s financial statements for the financial years since 2015 have been agreed or signed off by the directors. Dr Myers and Dr Golledge have been in dispute for more than 10 years as to how PDP’s financial affairs should be conducted. They have been unable to agree as to the requirement for PDP to undertake work to maintain the Property.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered whether leave should be granted to Dr Myers to bring proceedings on behalf of PDP against PHG and Dr Golledge. The Court found that two of the requirements of s 237(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) were not fulfilled, and therefore, Dr Myers' application must be dismissed. The Court then considered whether a winding up order was just and equitable. It noted that a deadlock in the management of a company's affairs is a common case for a winding up order on the just and equitable ground. The relationship between Dr Myers and Dr Golledge has deteriorated to the extent that continuation of the association would be futile. The Court found that the circumstances warranted a winding up order. The Court also noted that the winding up order should be made pursuant to section 461(1)(k) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The Court concluded that the relationship between the two directors of PDP has deteriorated to the point of deadlock, and the company remains solvent, making a winding up order just and equitable. The Court also appointed Anne Meagher and David Michael Stimpson as joint and several liquidators of PDP and receivers of the Petrie Dental Property Unit Trust. The Court's ratio decidendi is that a winding up order on the just and equitable ground is appropriate where the relationship between the directors has deteriorated to the point of deadlock, and the company remains solvent.