Myers v Neis & Others No. DCCIV-97-901

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUSAN KAYE MYERS & SUSAN MYERS PTY LTD v EVELYN NEIS AND OTHERS

[2000] SADC 111

Judge Lunn

Civil

The persons involved

  1. The 1st defendant, Evelyn Neis, was born in 1944 in Germany and migrated to Australia in 1972.  In 1973 she commenced a career in designing women’s clothing.  In 1992 she entered into a defacto relationship with Bill Tzavarin and acquired a farm at Milang.  From about 1992 to 1994 she carried on business in the manufacture and sale of women’s clothing from her premises at 301 North Terrace, Adelaide.  In October 1995, at the age of 51, she had twin daughters who were born prematurely.  In early 1996 her defacto husband was diagnosed with cancer and he died on 12 October 1996.  In her business she used the “shoe box” method of accounting and described herself as the worst bookkeeper there is.

  2. The 2nd defendant has been a public accountant in practice in Adelaide since 1983.  During the events in issue in this action he used the surname Popowski, but late in 1997, for legitimate reasons, he changed it to Bartley.  He carried on his practice through the company which is the 3rd defendant.  No distinction was sought to be drawn between the 2nd and 3rd defendants.  In these reasons I will only refer to the 2nd defendant, but, where appropriate, that also encompasses the 3rd defendant.  In about 1989 the 2nd defendant became the accountant for the 1st defendant.  He visited her business premises regularly.  He was continually encouraging her to improve her bookkeeping practices.  He developed a close relationship of accountant and client with her.  Part of the fees due to the 2nd defendant from the 1st defendant were offset against purchases from the 1st defendant’s business by the 2nd defendant’s wife.

  3. Mrs Carmel Vozzo is an experienced and capable business woman.  In the later 1980s, while the manager of a Goodwill Clothing Store at Torrensville, she met the 1st defendant who was a customer at that store for old materials and bric-a-brac for her dress creations.  The 1st defendant understood her to be a capable in business and a good salesperson.  Mrs Vozzo was divorced and had a substantial mortgage commitment on her home.  She needed substantial employment to earn sufficient to service this loan.  In the early 1990s the 1st defendant had requested Mrs Vozzo to work for her, but Mrs Vozzo had declined this offer as she considered, with some justification, that the 1st defendant was domineering and overbearing.  In early 1997 she was working part time for about 25 hours per week in Katies women’s clothing store in Rundle Mall.

  4. The 1st plaintiff, Susan Myers (“the plaintiff”), was born in 1949.  Her father owned and ran the Enfield Hotel for many years.  She was employed in that business, but it was a very different business from a small women’s fashion boutique.  From 1977 to 1981 she studied accounting part time and obtained a “Business Certificate of Accounting”.  Her father died in 1981…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Myers v Neis & Others No. DCCIV-97-901 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] SADC 111
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved a dispute between Susan Myers (the plaintiff) and Evelyn Neis (the defendant) over the sale of a women's fashion boutique business. The plaintiff sought to recover damages from the defendant and her accountant, who was also the accountant for the defendant, for misrepresentations and breach of duty. The court had to determine whether the defendants made any misrepresentations and whether the accountant breached his duty to the plaintiff. The court also had to assess the damages recoverable by the plaintiff against the defendants.

The court found that the defendants did not make any actionable misrepresentations about the financial viability of the business. The plaintiff was not induced by any such misrepresentations to enter into the transaction. The court also found that the accountant breached his duty to the plaintiff by not disclosing to her all material information he knew about the business and by not advising her to obtain independent legal advice. The accountant's failure to discharge his duty caused the plaintiff to enter into a financially disastrous transaction. The court assessed the plaintiff's damages against the accountant at $143,434 before the reduction for contributory negligence. The plaintiff's contributory negligence was found to be 1/3rd of the total damages. The court also found that the defendant was not liable to the plaintiff under the Land and Business (Sale and Conveyancing) Act 1994 for failing to provide a vendor's statement. The court dismissed all claims by the second plaintiff, a trust set up by the plaintiff, against the defendants.

The court ordered that there would be a balance judgment in favour of the defendant for $5,495 on the plaintiff's claim and the defendant's counterclaim. The court also ordered that there would be judgment for the plaintiff against the accountant for $101,753 and that the defendant would contribute $9,132 to the accountant for the portion of the plaintiff's damages that the defendant was responsible for. The court reserved the matter of costs for further hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established