Myers v Arenco Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MYERS v ARENCO HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ORS [2019] FCCA 3077
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Contravention of provisions of s.340 of FWA – compensation and civil penalty orders to be the subject of further submissions – accessorial liability – adverse credibility findings.

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss.340, 341, 342(1), 358, 360, 361, 550

Cases cited:

Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay (2012) 248 CLR 500
Russel v Institution of Engineers Australia T/A Engineers Australia [2013] FCA 1250

Applicant: ELISE MYERS
First Respondent: ARENCO HOLDINGS PTY LTD T/A OM YOGA STUDIOS / OM WELLNESS
Second Respondent: ISABEL WU
Third Respondent: GAENOR PYM
File Number: BRG 1053 of 2018
Judgment of: Judge Egan
Hearing date: 26 September 2019
Date of Last Submission: 24 October 2019
Delivered at: Brisbane
Delivered on:  29 October 2019

REPRESENTATION

Applicant: In person
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr S. Mackie
Solicitors for the Respondents: Mullins Lawyers

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

  1. The First Respondent has contravened the provisions of s.340(1)(a) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), by terminating the Applicant’s employment because the Applicant exercised her workplace right to make a complaint to the Third Respondent that she had been underpaid and had not been paid her due entitlements payable to her under the Fitness Industry Award 2010.

  2. The Second and Third Respondents were involved in the First Respondent’s contravention as set out in paragraph 1 above and are accessorily liable for such contravention pursuant to the provisions of s.550(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

AND IT IS ORDERED THAT:

  1. The parties:

    (a)Forthwith cause a copy of these reasons and orders to be served upon the First Respondent.

    (b)Confer for the purpose of preparing draft orders, consonant with the reasons for Judgment, for the Court’s consideration within seven (7) days of the making of these orders.

  2. The Court will hear the parties as to the making of orders for compensation and for the imposition of any pecuniary penalty arising out of a contravention or contraventions of the provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) as found by the Court.

  3. Each party shall have liberty to apply on the giving of two (2) days’ notice, each to the other.

  4. The matter is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT BRISBANE

BRG 1053 of 2018

ELISE MYERS

Applicant

And

ARENCO HOLDINGS PTY LTD T/A OM YOGA STUDIOS / OM WELLNESS

First Respondent

ISABEL WU

Second Respondent

gaenor pym

Third Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The applicant had relevantly commenced employment with the first respondent in the role of a fitness (yoga) instructor and administration assistant on 4 April 2018.

  2. On 15 October 2018 the applicant filed an Originating Application by which it was claimed that each of the respondents had contravened the provisions of s. 340 and s. 358 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FWA). It was also asserted that the second and third respondents were…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Myers v Arenco Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCCA 3077
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Ms Myers, brought proceedings against her employer, Arenco Holdings Pty Ltd (trading as OM Yoga Studios), and two of its directors, Mr Pym and Ms Wu. Ms Myers alleged that the respondents contravened section 340 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by taking adverse action against her for exercising a workplace right. The court was required to determine whether the employer's actions constituted a breach of this provision.

The central legal issue was whether the employer's conduct, specifically the circumstances surrounding a meeting where Ms Myers' future teaching schedule and administrative duties were discussed, amounted to adverse action taken because she had raised concerns about her working conditions. Ms Myers contended that her expressed concerns about her roster and the timing of certain classes were workplace rights, and that the subsequent discussions and proposed changes to her role were adverse actions taken in response to her raising these issues. The employer, conversely, argued that any changes were for legitimate operational reasons and not in retaliation for Ms Myers exercising her rights.

Egan J considered the employer's onus to demonstrate that the adverse action was not taken for a proscribed reason. The court referenced the principle that mere declarations of an innocent reason for adverse action may not satisfy this onus if contrary inferences are available. Ms Myers' affidavit detailed a meeting where she raised concerns about her demanding roster and the difficulty of teaching early morning classes due to school drop-off times. She also expressed a preference for teaching a certain number of classes and indicated her availability. The employer's representatives then discussed a potential shift in her role, focusing more on teaching and less on administration, with a potential adjustment to her pay rate to maintain her financial position. Crucially, Ms Myers stated that termination, performance issues, or a formal offer of a new contract were not mentioned during this meeting.

The court found that the employer had not satisfied its onus to prove that the adverse action was not taken for a proscribed reason. The timing of the meeting, following Ms Myers' expressed concerns about her roster and working hours, created an inference that the subsequent discussions and proposed changes were a response to her raising these issues. The court determined that compensation and civil penalty orders would be the subject of further submissions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

An employer’s onus may not be satisfied by a mere statement that the action taken by the employer was not for a proscribed reason. As was said by French CJ and Crennan J at [54] of Barclay:“[54] … a question arose as to whether the director’s evidence was sufficient to satisfy the onus cast upon the employer. In deciding that the director’s evidence was sufficient, the majority in Pearce recognised that mere declarations of an innocent reason or intent in taking adverse action may not satisfy the onus on an employer if contrary inferences are available on the facts.”(Emphasis added) The applicant alleged in her first affidavit that at approximately 1:00pm on 2 July 2018 the third respondent (Pym) approached the applicant (Myers) at the reception area of the OM Yoga Studios, and asked her to meet with Pym and the second respondent (Wu) to discuss what classes Myers would be teaching “moving forward, when the new studio opens”. [2] Myers set out the dialogue of what transpired at the meeting at paragraphs [5] – [19] of her first affidavit as follows: [3][2] Paragraph 3 of Myers Affidavit filed on 14 January 2019 – Page 27 of Ex 1.[3] Myers affidavit – Pages 27 – 29 of Ex 1. “5. In the meeting, The Second Respondent began by asking me a question the effect: "How has your time been so far at Om Yoga Studios (The First Respondent)?"6. I replied: "I really enjoy teaching and also like doing administration."7. The Second Respondent then asked me a question to the following effect: "Do you have any concerns working here at Om (the First Respondent)?"8. I replied: "My Tuesday evening shift where I work late until 8pm and then have to get up early the next day and start at 5:30am is tiring and if l was able to change anything in the roster I would like to change this shift. I am also concerned at being asked to teach a Tuesday morning class at 7:45am. This is at school drop off time and I will need to organise someone to take my three children to school."9. The Second Respondent then said to me words to the following effect: "Ideally Om Yoga (the First Respondent) would like to have you focus on teaching classes when the new studio opens, rather than doing general administration as well. Would mind doing other menial tasks around your teaching schedule?"10. I replied: "I don't mind doing other tasks besides administration around my teaching schedule."11. The Second Respondent then said to me words to the following effect: "If you end up doing less hours overall your rate of pay would increase so that I won't be any worse off financially. You current weekly pay will be maintained."12. The Second Respondent then said to me words to the following effect: "We want you to be happy at Om (the First Respondent). Because you are the first teacher employed you will get preference as to what classes you want to teach and what hours you want to work. What would your ideal teaching schedule look like, and what will your hours of availability be when the new studio opens?"13. I replied: "Teaching 10 tol2 classes a week would be the ideal amount for me. My preference for availability is the same as it has always been since I started working at the studio. I am available to work mostly during school hours but am happy to continue my current roster of one night shift and two early morning shifts. I am also available to teach a weekend class occasionally but not every week."14. The Second Respondent then asked me a question to the following effect: "Would you be able to teach a class on Sundays?"15. I replied: "No. Due to religious and family commitments I cannot teach a regular Sunday class but I can do it occasionally."16. At the end of the meeting, The Second and Third Respondents said to me words to the following effect: "Please put down in writing your ideal scenario for teaching including the types of classes you want to instruct as well as an example roster. We would prefer you to stay behind after your shift today and do this, or come in early before your shift tomorrow on Tuesday to do it."17. I replied: "It is school holidays at the moment. I already have other commitments and I cannot stay later today or come in earlier than my rostered shift tomorrow. But I can send it to you by email in the morning."18. The Second and Third Respondent then said to me words to the following effect: "It is okay for you to send it by email in the morning and not stay later today or come in earlier tomorrow."19. In this meeting there was no mention of termination, any performance issues, changing my part-time status or the official offer of a new employment contract.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established