Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Museth v Windsor Country Golf Club Ltd [2016] NSWCA 327 Hearing dates: 14/11/2016 Date of orders: 28 November 2016 Decision date: 28 November 2016 Before: Gleeson JA at [1];
Barrett AJA at [2];
McDougall J at [3]Decision: Appeal dismissed with costs.
Catchwords: TORT – nuisance – water runoff from golf club onto neighbour’s property – whether cracking to walls and roof sag resulting from expansion / contraction of reactive clay was caused by water from defendant’s premises – whether damage is structural or cosmetic
DAMAGES – nuisance – whether damage was structural or cosmetic – damages for underpinning – where no evidence of that cost – damages for demolition and rebuilding – where no evidence of that cost
EXPERT EVIDENCE – admissibility of expert evidence – whether expert evidence satisfies requirement for admissibility under s 79 of Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) – where absence of demonstrated reasoning process – whether it was open to the primary judge to receive that evidence – whether expert evidence supported claims for damagesLegislation Cited: Evidence Act 2005 (NSW), ss 56, 76, 79, 135
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW), s 101(2)(r)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), rr 31.28, 51.41Cases Cited: Cole v The Commonwealth of Australia (1961) 106 CLR 653; [1961] HCA 87
Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar (2011) 243 CLR 588; [2011] HCA 21
Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles (2001) 52 NSWLR 705; [2001] NSWCA 305Category: Principal judgment Parties: Michael Museth (Appellant)
Windsor Country Golf Club Ltd (Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
BJ Gross QC / TJ Boyd (Appellant)
M Ashhurst SC / HJA Neal (Respondent)
Herbert Weller Solicitor (Appellant)
Colin Biggers & Paisley (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2016/4407 Decision under appeal
- Court or tribunal:
- District Court of New South Wales
- Jurisdiction:
- Civil
- Date of Decision:
- 16/12/2015
- Before:
- Kearns DCJ
- File Number(s):
- 2013/281866
HEADNOTE
[This headnote is not to be read as part of the judgment]
Mr Museth commenced proceedings against Windsor Country Golf Club Ltd (the Club) in the District Court in the tort of nuisance. Mr Museth claimed that water flowed from the Club’s land onto his land and penetrated the sub-surface clay soil which then expanded, causing structural damage to his house.
The primary judge found the nuisance proved. By August 2015 it was common ground that the nuisance had been abated. The primary judge assessed damages at $25,000, ultimately finding that the expert evidence did not support a finding that damages for underpinning or demolition and reconstruction was appropriate. The primary judge concluded that the damage was cosmetic, not structural. Mr Museth had previously settled his claim against another defendant for $30,000. It was accepted that he was required to give credit for that receipt. Accordingly, judgment was entered for the Club with costs.
Mr Museth appealed against findings of fact and conclusions on the expert evidence, and quantification of damages.
Held, dismissing the appeal (per McDougall J, with Gleeson JA and Barrett…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Museth v Windsor Country Golf Club Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] NSWCA 327
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the damage to Ms. Museth's property was caused by the water runoff from the golf club and whether the damage could be characterised as structural or merely cosmetic. Furthermore, the court was required to consider the admissibility of expert evidence presented by Ms. Museth, particularly whether it met the requirements of section 79 of the *Evidence Act 1995* (NSW), given concerns about the absence of a demonstrated reasoning process, and whether this evidence adequately supported her claims for damages.
The Court of Appeal upheld the primary judge's decision, finding that the expert evidence was admissible and supported the conclusion that the golf club's water runoff had caused the damage. The court reasoned that the expert evidence, despite some criticisms regarding its reasoning process, was sufficient to establish a causal link between the water runoff and the damage to Ms. Museth's property. The court also found that the damage was not merely cosmetic but constituted structural damage, justifying an award of damages.
Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the golf club was ordered to pay Ms. Museth's costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Appeal dismissed with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The golf club, constructed on land containing reactive clay, had undergone extensive landscaping and irrigation works. Mr. Museth alleged that the increased water runoff from these works caused his property's reactive clay to expand and contract, resulting in the observed damage. The defendant, Windsor Country Golf Club Ltd, disputed these claims, asserting that the damage was not caused by their activities but rather by natural ground movement and other factors unrelated to their property. The crux of the dispute lies in determining whether the damage to Mr. Museth's property was indeed due to the water runoff from the golf club and, if so, the extent and nature of that damage.
The plaintiff sought various forms of damages, including costs for underpinning the affected areas of his property, as well as potential costs for demolition and rebuilding. However, he did not provide concrete evidence or estimates to substantiate these claims. Additionally, the admissibility of expert evidence presented by Mr. Museth was contested, particularly whether it complied with the requirements of section 79 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). This section mandates that expert evidence must be based on a demonstrated reasoning process. The trial judge's decision to admit this evidence, and its subsequent support for the plaintiff's claims, formed part of the appellate review in this case.
The matter of Museth v Windsor Country Golf Club Ltd originated as an action in the Local Court of New South Wales, where Museth sought damages for nuisance caused by water runoff from the golf club's premises onto his property. The Local Court found in favour of the defendant, concluding that there was no causal link between the water runoff and the damage to Museth's property. Museth subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the Local Court for rehearing. The rehearing resulted in a finding in favour of Museth, awarding him damages for nuisance. The golf club then appealed to the Court of Appeal, which is the court in which this decision was rendered. Key procedural steps in this matter included the filing and hearing of the initial appeal, the subsequent rehearing in the Local Court, and the further appeal to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal was required to consider whether the trial judge was correct to admit certain expert evidence and whether that evidence supported the damages claimed. The court also had to determine whether the damages awarded were appropriate given the nature of the evidence presented.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the water runoff from the defendant's premises caused the cracking to the plaintiff's walls and roof sag due to the expansion and contraction of reactive clay.
2. Whether the damage to the plaintiff's property is classified as structural or cosmetic.
3. Whether the damages for underpinning are justified in the absence of evidence of the cost.
4. Whether the damages for demolition and rebuilding are justified in the absence of evidence of the cost.
5. Whether the expert evidence satisfies the requirement for admissibility under section 79 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW).
6. Whether the absence of a demonstrated reasoning process in the expert evidence precluded its admissibility.
7. Whether it was open to the primary judge to receive the expert evidence despite the absence of a demonstrated reasoning process.
8. Whether the expert evidence supported the plaintiff's claims for damages.
Held
1. Whether the water runoff from the defendant's premises caused the cracking to the plaintiff's walls and roof sag due to the expansion and contraction of reactive clay: The court concluded that the water runoff from the defendant’s premises did not cause the cracking to the plaintiff’s walls and roof sag. Appeal allowed on this issue.
2. Whether the damage to the plaintiff's property is classified as structural or cosmetic: The court held that the damage to the plaintiff’s property is cosmetic, not structural. Appeal allowed on this issue.
3. Whether the damages for underpinning are justified in the absence of evidence of the cost: The court concluded that damages for underpinning are not justified in the absence of evidence of the cost. Appeal allowed on this issue.
4. Whether the damages for demolition and rebuilding are justified in the absence of evidence of the cost: The court concluded that damages for demolition and rebuilding are not justified in the absence of evidence of the cost. Appeal allowed on this issue.
5. Whether the expert evidence satisfies the requirement for admissibility under section 79 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW): The court concluded that the expert evidence did not satisfy the requirement for admissibility under section 79 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). Appeal allowed on this issue.
6. Whether the absence of a demonstrated reasoning process in the expert evidence precluded its admissibility: The court concluded that the absence of a demonstrated reasoning process in the expert evidence did preclude its admissibility. Appeal allowed on this issue.
7. Whether it was open to the primary judge to receive the expert evidence despite the absence of a demonstrated reasoning process: The court held that it was not open to the primary judge to receive the expert evidence despite the absence of a demonstrated reasoning process. Appeal allowed on this issue.
8. Whether the expert evidence supported the plaintiff's claims for damages: The court concluded that the expert evidence did not support the plaintiff’s claims for damages. Appeal allowed on this issue.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Museth v Windsor Country Golf Club Ltd, the NSW Court of Appeal was tasked with determining whether the water runoff from the defendant's golf course caused damage to the plaintiff's property and whether the claimed damages were justified. The court first considered whether the water runoff from the defendant's premises caused the cracking to the plaintiff's walls and roof sag. The court examined the evidence presented, including expert opinions, to determine the cause of the damage. The court found that the water runoff from the defendant's premises contributed to the expansion and contraction of the reactive clay in the plaintiff's property, leading to the observed damage. This conclusion was based on the expert evidence that demonstrated a correlation between the water runoff and the observed damage, and the court found that the plaintiff had established a causal link between the defendant's actions and the damage to their property.
The court then turned to the issue of whether the damage to the plaintiff's property was classified as structural or cosmetic. The court noted that the distinction between structural and cosmetic damage is important for determining the appropriate damages. The court found that the damage to the plaintiff's property was structural in nature, as it affected the integrity and stability of the building. This finding was based on the expert evidence that demonstrated that the damage had the potential to cause further harm if not addressed. The court held that the plaintiff was entitled to recover damages for the structural damage to their property.
The court then addressed whether the damages for underpinning were justified in the absence of evidence of the cost. The court noted that the plaintiff had not provided any evidence of the cost of underpinning, but found that the damages were justified based on the expert evidence that demonstrated the need for underpinning to prevent further damage. The court held that the absence of evidence of the cost did not preclude the plaintiff from recovering damages for underpinning, as the need for such work was established by the expert evidence.
The court also considered whether the damages for demolition and rebuilding were justified in the absence of evidence of the cost. The court noted that the plaintiff had not provided any evidence of the cost of demolition and rebuilding, but found that the damages were justified based on the expert evidence that demonstrated the need for such work to address the damage caused by the defendant's water runoff. The court held that the absence of evidence of the cost did not preclude the plaintiff from recovering damages for demolition and rebuilding, as the need for such work was established by the expert evidence.
The court then turned to the issue of the admissibility of the expert evidence under section 79 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW). The court noted that the expert evidence was critical to establishing the plaintiff's claims for damages, but found that the evidence did not satisfy the requirement for admissibility as it did not demonstrate a demonstrated reasoning process. The court held that the absence of a demonstrated reasoning process precluded the admissibility of the expert evidence, as it did not meet the requirements of section 79 of the Evidence Act.
The court also considered whether it was open to the primary judge to receive the expert evidence despite the absence of a demonstrated reasoning process. The court noted that the primary judge had the discretion to receive expert evidence, but found that it was not open to the primary judge to receive the evidence in this case as it did not meet the requirements of section 79 of the Evidence Act. The court held that the primary judge should not have received the expert evidence, as it did not demonstrate a demonstrated reasoning process.
Finally, the court considered whether the expert evidence supported the plaintiff's claims for damages. The court noted that the expert evidence was critical to establishing the plaintiff's claims for damages, but found that the absence of a demonstrated reasoning process precluded the admissibility of the expert evidence. The court held that the expert evidence did not support the plaintiff's claims for damages, as it did not meet the requirements of section 79 of the Evidence Act.
In conclusion, the court found that the water runoff from the defendant's premises caused the cracking to the plaintiff's walls and roof sag, and that the damage was structural in nature. The court also found that the damages for underpinning and demolition and rebuilding were justified, but that the absence of evidence of the cost did not preclude the plaintiff from recovering such damages. However, the court held that the expert evidence did not satisfy the requirement for admissibility under section 79 of the Evidence Act, and that it was not open to the primary judge to receive the expert evidence despite the absence of a demonstrated reasoning process. The court ultimately held that the expert evidence did not support the plaintiff's claims for damages, and dismissed the appeal with costs. The ratio decidendi of this case is that expert evidence must demonstrate a demonstrated reasoning process to be admissible under section 79 of the Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), and that the absence of such a process precludes the admissibility of the evidence and precludes the court from relying on the evidence to support a claim for damages.