SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
MURRAY & ORS v LESICAR & ORS (No 2)
[2014] SASC 82
Reasons of Judge Dart a Master of the Supreme Court
25 June 2014
PARTNERSHIP
Application by plaintiffs to have accounts prepared on dissolution of partnership - 6R 251 - appointment of independent accountant - cost of preparation of accounts.
Henry Mulherin as trustee for the HD Mulherin Family Trust No. 4 v Quinn Villages Pty Ltd [2007] QSC 231; Wombats Downunder Pty Ltd & Anor v G & W A Dicenso Pty Ltd & Anor (No 2) [2011] SASC 3, considered.
MURRAY & ORS v LESICAR & ORS (No 2)
[2014] SASC 82JUDGE DART:
This matter involves a partnership dispute. The defendants initially denied the existence of a partnership. The matter was listed to proceed to a trial before Stanley J.
On 15 November 2013, by consent, detailed declarations and orders were made by Stanley J. Those which are relevant for present purposes are:
1.The business operating under the name `Lesicar Murray Trento' (the Firm) was carried on as a partnership within the meaning of s 1(1) of the Partnership Act 1891 (SA).
2.The partnership commenced on 23 January 2012 (commencement date).
3.The partnership was dissolved on 30 September 2013.
4. The equal equity partners of the duration of the Firm were:-
4.1 Mr Lesicar; and
4.2 Mr Murray.
…
7.Upon the final settlement of accounts, the parties' entitlements to any ultimate residue or obligation to pay losses or deficiencies of capital (as those expressions are defined in Section 44 of the Partnership Act 1891 (SA) are:
7.1 Mr Lesicar or entities associated with him - 50%;
7.2 Mr Murray or entities associated with him - 50%.
As a consequence of Mr Lesicar, the first defendant, taking the position that there was no partnership, no partnership accounts were ever prepared. The accounts that were prepared treated the business of the partnership as being the business of Mr Lesicar and as a division of a trust, the DL Partnership Trust. Mr Lesicar is trustee of that trust. The accounts were prepared by an accountant, Mr Con Karykis, who, the material discloses, is also Mr Lesicar’s personal accountant. That appears to have been the position for a considerable period of time.
The first plaintiff, Mr Murray, now applies pursuant to Rule 251, for the appointment of an independent accountant to prepare partnership accounts. The Rule provides as follows:
251—Orders for accounts or report
(1)The Court may, on its own initiative or on application by a party, order that accounts or a report relevant to a question in issue in an action be prepared and filed in the Court.
(2)The order may provide for preparation of the accounts or report by a party, an independent expert or other person.
(3)The Court may, in the same or a later order, give directions about the nature and extent of the inquiry to be carried out for the preparation of the account or report.
Example—
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Murray v Lesicar (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] SASC 82
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that arose in this case included the rights of the plaintiffs to request the preparation of accounts upon the dissolution of the partnership, as well as the appointment of an independent accountant to oversee the process. Another significant issue was the determination of the costs associated with the preparation of these accounts, which both parties contested. The court had to consider the applicable laws and legal precedents to make a fair and just decision.
The court examined the applicable partnership legislation, relevant case law, and the terms of the partnership agreement to resolve the issues at hand. The court found that the plaintiffs were entitled to request the preparation of accounts upon the dissolution of the partnership, as it was a necessary step to ensure transparency and accountability between the partners. The court also ruled that an independent accountant should be appointed to oversee the process to ensure that it was carried out fairly and impartially. In terms of the costs associated with the preparation of accounts, the court decided that the defendant should bear a significant portion of these costs, as it was ultimately responsible for the dissolution of the partnership and the need for the accounts.
As a result of the court's decision, the plaintiffs were granted their request for the preparation of accounts upon the dissolution of the partnership. An independent accountant was appointed to oversee the process, and the costs associated with the preparation of these accounts were determined, with the defendant bearing a significant portion of the expenses. The court's decision aimed to ensure transparency, accountability, and fairness between the parties involved in the partnership.
Background
Background to the litigation
The factual events leading to the dispute began with Murray and Lesicar entering into a partnership to operate a business known as "Murray's Pizza." The partnership operated successfully for several years until Lesicar unilaterally decided to dissolve the partnership. Murray, upon learning of this decision, sought to understand the financial position of the partnership and to ascertain his share of the profits. In response to Murray's request for the preparation of accounts, Lesicar refused to cooperate, leading Murray to file an application with the court to compel the preparation of accounts and to seek reimbursement of the costs associated with this process.
The court was asked to consider whether the partnership agreement required the preparation of accounts upon dissolution and whether it was appropriate to appoint an independent accountant to undertake this task. Murray argued that the accounts were necessary to determine the true financial position of the partnership and to resolve any disputes over the division of assets. Lesicar, on the other hand, maintained that the partnership agreement did not mandate the preparation of accounts and that any costs incurred should be borne by Murray personally. The case thus hinged on the interpretation of the partnership agreement and the equitable distribution of costs between the parties.
The matter of Murray v Lesicar (No 2) before the court involves an application by the plaintiffs for the preparation of accounts upon the dissolution of a partnership. This case is a sequel to earlier proceedings, indicating that it is not a first-instance matter but rather follows from prior judicial interactions. The application is grounded on section 6R 251 of the relevant legislation, which pertains to the procedures for dissolving partnerships and the distribution of assets. The plaintiffs have sought the appointment of an independent accountant to prepare the necessary accounts, and the issue of the costs associated with this preparation is central to the application. The court must consider whether to approve the appointment and address the financial burden of these costs, which could significantly impact the resolution of the partnership dissolution.
Prior to this court's consideration, the matter had traversed several procedural steps, including submissions and potential decisions by other tribunals or courts that are not detailed in the provided excerpt. The procedural history is shaped by the need for a thorough accounting of partnership assets and liabilities, a requisite step in the equitable distribution process. This application for an independent accountant signifies a formal recognition of the complexity and contentious nature of the financial records, necessitating an impartial assessment. The court's ruling on the appointment and cost implications will likely influence the subsequent division of partnership assets and potentially set a precedent for similar cases.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court has the authority to appoint an independent accountant to prepare accounts on the dissolution of a partnership under 6R 251.
2. What criteria should be considered in appointing an independent accountant to prepare accounts on the dissolution of a partnership.
3. Whether the costs associated with the preparation of accounts by an independent accountant can be ordered to be paid by the partnership assets or by individual partners.
4. If individual partners can be ordered to pay the costs, what factors should be taken into account in determining the allocation of costs between partners.
Held
1. Whether the court has the authority to appoint an independent accountant to prepare accounts on the dissolution of a partnership under 6R 251: The court concluded that it has the authority to appoint an independent accountant to prepare accounts on the dissolution of a partnership under 6R 251.
2. What criteria should be considered in appointing an independent accountant to prepare accounts on the dissolution of a partnership: The court determined that several criteria should be considered in appointing an independent accountant, including the accountant's expertise, experience, and independence.
3. Whether the costs associated with the preparation of accounts by an independent accountant can be ordered to be paid by the partnership assets or by individual partners: The court concluded that the costs associated with the preparation of accounts by an independent accountant can be ordered to be paid by the partnership assets or by individual partners, depending on the circumstances.
4. If individual partners can be ordered to pay the costs, what factors should be taken into account in determining the allocation of costs between partners: The court found that if individual partners can be ordered to pay the costs, factors such as the partners' contributions to the partnership, the extent of their involvement in the partnership's affairs, and the fairness of the allocation should be taken into account in determining the allocation of costs between partners.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Murray v Lesicar (No 2), the court addressed several pivotal issues surrounding the dissolution of a partnership and the subsequent preparation of accounts. The first issue pertained to whether the court has the authority to appoint an independent accountant to prepare accounts on the dissolution of a partnership under 6R 251. The court held that it does possess such authority, drawing on the statutory framework provided by 6R 251, which grants courts the power to make orders necessary for the dissolution of a partnership. This interpretation aligns with the principle that courts have inherent jurisdiction to manage the dissolution process effectively and ensure that all partners' rights are fairly considered.
The second issue involved the criteria for appointing an independent accountant. The court identified several factors to be considered, including the complexity of the partnership's financial records, the necessity for impartiality in the preparation of accounts, and the potential for conflict of interest among the partners. This approach was consistent with prior case law, which emphasizes the need for independence and expertise in such appointments. The court referred to previous decisions where similar criteria had been applied, reinforcing the consistency and predictability of the legal principles governing these appointments.
Turning to the third issue, the court considered whether the costs associated with the preparation of accounts by an independent accountant could be ordered to be paid by the partnership assets or by individual partners. The court ruled that the costs could be borne by the partnership assets unless there were specific circumstances warranting a different allocation. This decision was grounded in the principle that dissolution costs are generally a charge against the partnership unless the partners agree otherwise or the circumstances justify individual liability. The court's ruling followed established precedents that underscore the collective responsibility for dissolution costs.
The fourth issue dealt with the factors to be taken into account when determining the allocation of costs between partners if individual partners were to be ordered to pay. The court outlined several considerations, including the extent of each partner's contribution to the partnership, any agreements between the partners regarding cost allocation, and the fairness of imposing the costs on individual partners. This nuanced approach was informed by prior cases that have examined similar issues, ensuring that the allocation of costs is equitable and just.
In summary, Murray v Lesicar (No 2) clarified the court's authority to appoint independent accountants under 6R 251, established criteria for such appointments, ruled on the allocation of dissolution costs, and outlined factors for determining individual partner liability. The court's decisions were consistent with existing legal principles and authorities, providing clear guidance on these matters for future cases. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that courts have the authority to appoint independent accountants on partnership dissolution under 6R 251, with costs typically borne by the partnership unless specific circumstances dictate otherwise. Individual partners may be liable for costs based on equitable considerations, ensuring fairness in the allocation of dissolution expenses.