Murray, L.o.a. v Macquarie Bank Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read
JUDGMENT NO. .e....../........ ,-zri,. -qp-
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA 1 No. QG 159 of 1990
QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY )
GENERAL DIVISION )

BETWEEN: LYNNE ORRELLE ANGELA MURRAY

Applicant

AND: THE MACOUARIE BANK LIMITED

First Respondent

AND: RAYMOND WILLIAM CARLE

Second Respondent

THE MACOUARIE BANK LIMITED

Cross-Applicant

RECEIVED AND: LYNNE ORRELLE ANGELA MURRAY
25 J L ' L 1991 First Cross-Respondent
FPEF~AL COURT OF
AUSTRALIA AND: JOHN EXA AND ER BAKER

PRINCIPAL REQISTRY

Second Cross-Respondent

. -.L_-.
: M A - PINCUS J.

PLACE: BRISBANE

DATE: 24 JULY 1991

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

bank in 1988 with a view to borrowing about $200,000, that she The statement of claim says that the applicant approached the
later applied to borrow $235,000, that the respondent Carle made certain misleading statements to her causing her to borrow from the respondent bank and was also guilty of unconscionable conduct. The damage suffered, so the statement of claim says, included loss of opportunity on the part of the applicant to "otherwise organise her affairs", interest and other borrowing costs and any capital loss which might be incurred to repay the loan.
There was no argument before me as to whether the applicant has in the principal proceeding an arguable case against the bank, based on these allegations.
There is a defence and cross-claim filed. Although it is drawn as if the solicitors who filed it were acting for both the bank and Carle, they are in fact acting for the bank only and, in this respect, the defence appears to require correction; it purports to make admissions and other assertions on behalf of "the respondentsu.

It includes a cross-claim by the bank against the

applicant, claiming a sum of about $330,000 plus interest and
costs.

The bank applied to the Court for summary judgment on its cross-claim and that was given, but in the sum of $235,000 only. Further, the order which was made (on 7 May 1991, as I have mentioned) required the bank to "execute a
partial release of the security to the value of $235,000.00". That order for partial release was included, I gather, at the suggestion of then counsel for the bank, apparently because the Court expressed concern as to whether or not it was fair to give the bank judgment and allow it to retain its security, mortgages over two residential properties, in full. No doubt the purpose of providing for a partial release was to enable the applicant to borrow in order to be able to pay out the respondent bank.
The difficulties which have arisen are two. First, there is uncertainty as to precisely what obligation has been assumed by the respondent bank in consequence of the Court's having acceded to its suggestion that a partial release be required. Secondly, although the applicant has found another bank ("the new financier") willing to lend her money in order to discharge the obligation under the judgment, that bank requires first mortgage security. It should be mentioned that there is a…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Murray, L.o.a. v Macquarie Bank Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1991] FCA 417
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Murray, L.o.a. v Macquarie Bank Ltd involved the applicant, Lynne Orrelle Angela Murray, suing the Macquarie Bank Limited and Raymond William Carle for misleading conduct and unconscionable behaviour. Murray had borrowed a sum of money from the bank, and alleged that Carle made misleading statements that caused her to borrow the money. Murray sought damages for the loss of opportunity, interest, and potential capital loss incurred in repaying the loan. The bank filed a defence and cross-claim, and sought summary judgment on its cross-claim. The court granted summary judgment to the bank in the sum of $235,000 and ordered a partial release of security to the same value.

The central legal issues in the case revolved around the interpretation of the court's order for a partial release of security and whether it was possible to vary the order to better suit the applicant's needs. The court was required to determine whether the order could be varied to allow the applicant to obtain a new loan from another bank, and whether the bank's offer of an alternative arrangement was an acceptable substitute for the partial release.

The court held that the order for a partial release could not be varied to suit the applicant's needs, as it was not possible to partially release a mortgage up to a certain money sum. The court also found that the bank's offer of an alternative arrangement was not a suitable substitute for the partial release. The court decided to set aside the whole of the orders made on the motion for summary judgment, including the judgment for $235,000 itself, and to reconsider the motion for summary judgment. The court intimated that it would hear further submissions from both parties before making any new orders.

In summary, the court found that the original orders made on the motion for summary judgment could not be varied to suit the applicant's needs, and that the bank's offer of an alternative arrangement was not an acceptable substitute for the partial release. The court decided to set aside the whole of the orders made on the motion for summary judgment and to reconsider the motion for summary judgment, with further submissions from both parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.