Murray and Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

Murray and Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2021] AATA 4750 (17 December 2021)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:2019/7725          

Re:Jason Murray  

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member D Mitchell

Date:17 December 2021

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

......................[SGD].........................

Member D Mitchell

CATCHWORD

COMPENSATION – accepted injury – left shoulder injury – decision to cease incapacity payments – whether applicant was incapacitated from undertaking pre injury work to the same rank or level – integrated rating – AMSA issued certification of fitness for duty – permanent reduction in range of movement – creditability of Applicant – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Seafarers’ Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth)

CASES

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Budarick and Comcare [2000] AATA 673

Djuraj v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 986

Fell v Lloyd (1911) 13 CLR 230

Steinberg v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1975) 134 CLR 640

Woodhouse v Comcare [2021] FCAFC 95

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member D Mitchell

17 December 2021

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Jason Murray (the Applicant) is seeking review of a decision of the Respondent dated


    6 November 2019.[1]

    [1]     Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB2, T Documents, T44, pages 120-121, Reviewable Decision.

  2. The reviewable decision[2] affirmed a determination dated 15 August 2019[3] to cease the Applicant’s weekly compensation payments on 21 August 2019 under section 31 of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) (the Act). The determination was made on the basis that the Applicant had recovered from any injury, disability or incapacity he suffered as a result of the incident in the course of his employment on 20 March 2018 and he had capacity for pre-injury duties.[4]

    [2]     Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB2, T Documents, T44, pages 120-121, Reviewable Decision.

    [3]     Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB2, T Documents, T34, pages 99-101, Determination Decision.

    [4]     Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB2, T Documents, T44, pages 120-121, Reviewable Decision and T3, pages 21-25, Respondent’s findings on material questions of fact.

    CLAIMS HISTORY AND BACKGROUND

  3. In March 2018, the Applicant was employed by the Respondent as a seafarer – integrated rating (integrated rating) on a 4 week, 12 hour a day on and 4 week off rostered arrangement. During the Applicant’s 4 weeks off, he undertook work as a plumber with Macladd Pty Ltd.[5]

    [5]     Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB1, Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, page 2, paragraphs 11-13.

  4. On 20 March 2018, the Applicant completed a minor incident report in relation to an injury to his left shoulder that occurred while descending from the top bunk to the floor during his rest period.[6]

    [6]     Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB2, T Documents, T4, pages 26-27, Minor Incident Report.

  5. On 26 March 2018, the Applicant sought medical attention from Dr Yure Pavic who completed a Workcover WA form. Dr Pavic diagnosed a left shoulder dislocation and made the clinical finding of “tender left shoulder, decreased range of motion…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Murray and Australian Offshore Solutions Pty Ltd (Compensati... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 4750
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal reviewed a decision to cease the Applicant's weekly compensation payments. The Applicant had been receiving compensation under the *Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992* (Cth) following a left shoulder injury sustained in March 2018. The employer contended that the Applicant had recovered from his injury and possessed the capacity to perform his pre-injury duties.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the Applicant was incapacitated for work as an integrated rating due to his accepted left shoulder injury, thereby entitling him to continued compensation payments under section 31 of the Act. This required the Tribunal to assess the Applicant's capacity for work and determine if any such incapacity was a direct result of the accepted injury, or if it was attributable to other factors or pre-existing conditions.

The Tribunal considered extensive evidence, including medical reports and the Applicant's own testimony regarding his physical condition and past disclosures. While acknowledging that the Applicant experienced reduced range of motion, pain, and stiffness in his left shoulder following surgery, the Tribunal found that this did not automatically equate to an incapacity for his pre-injury role. Crucially, the Tribunal noted significant concerns regarding the Applicant's credibility, particularly in light of admissions that he had not been entirely truthful in past disclosures about his psychological health and his fitness for work. The Tribunal concluded that the Applicant had not demonstrated an incapacity to engage in any work as a result of his accepted injury.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision to cease the Applicant's weekly compensation payments. The Tribunal found that the Applicant's entitlement to compensation had effectively ended prior to the cessation date, particularly from the point at which he was certified as having the capacity to undertake a work trial of his pre-injury duties and was deemed fit for such work by relevant medical assessments.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The reviewable decision[2] affirmed a determination dated 15 August 2019[3] to cease the Applicant’s weekly compensation payments on 21 August 2019 under section 31 of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) (the Act). The determination was made on the basis that the Applicant had recovered from any injury, disability or incapacity he suffered as a result of the incident in the course of his employment on 20 March 2018 and he had capacity for pre-injury duties.[4] [2] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB2, T Documents, T44, pages 120-121, Reviewable Decision.[3] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB2, T Documents, T34, pages 99-101, Determination Decision.[4] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB2, T Documents, T44, pages 120-121, Reviewable Decision and T3, pages 21-25, Respondent’s findings on material questions of fact.CLAIMS HISTORY AND BACKGROUND In March 2018, the Applicant was employed by the Respondent as a seafarer – integrated rating (integrated rating) on a 4 week, 12 hour a day on and 4 week off rostered arrangement. During the Applicant’s 4 weeks off, he undertook work as a plumber with Macladd Pty Ltd.[5][5] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB1, Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, page 2, paragraphs 11-13. On 20 March 2018, the Applicant completed a minor incident report in relation to an injury to his left shoulder that occurred while descending from the top bunk to the floor during his rest period.[6][6] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB2, T Documents, T4, pages 26-27, Minor Incident Report. On 26 March 2018, the Applicant sought medical attention from Dr Yure Pavic who completed a Workcover WA form. Dr Pavic diagnosed a left shoulder dislocation and made the clinical finding of “tender left shoulder, decreased range of motion due to pain. Recommend MRI and x-ray to assess severity of injury prior to referral for further treatment.”[7][7] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB2, T Documents, T5, pages 28-29, WorkCover WA First Certificate of Capacity. On 27 March 2018, the Applicant lodged a claim for workers’ compensation in relation to a left shoulder dislocation injury.[8] The Applicant’s claim for a left shoulder injury was accepted (accepted injury).[8] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB2, T Documents, T6, pages 30-34, Claim for Workers’ Compensation. On 10 April 2018, the Applicant underwent left shoulder stabilisation surgery with Dr David Colvin, orthopaedic surgeon.[9] [9] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB18, Summons material from Dr Colvin, page 404. The Applicant was medically classified as having no capacity for any work from 9 April 2018 to 15 April 2018.[10] From 16 April 2018, the Applicant’s capacity for work gradually increased.[11] [10] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB18, Supplementary T Documents, Summons documents from Dr Colvin, pages 407-408.[11] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB18, Supplementary T Documents, Summons documents from Dr Colvin, pages 407-408, 413-414, 419-420, 424-425, 428-429, 433-434, 438-439.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On cross-examination, the Applicant:[58][58] Transcript, pages 10-41.·Was taken to the clinical records of his general practitioner’s practice and confirmed he understood that what was being inferred was that what is recorded in the clinical records is information that he has given to the doctor during the course of the examination.·Confirmed that he recalled telling the doctor on 10 January 2014 that he had been suffering from anxiety disorder in the past and that a script for Pristiq was prescribed on that day.·Confirmed that as at 30 December 2013 he had been suffering an anxiety disorder in the past for which he had been prescribed the drug Pristiq, which is a drug for the treatment of what is called “major depressive disorder”.·Confirmed that he recalled telling the doctor on 8 November 2014 that he had been feeling depressed and angry in the past few months as there were some issues in respect of child support arrears.·Confirmed that the doctor’s notes that at that time he was not sleeping well at night and was given advice to see a counsellor was correct.·Confirmed that he did not see a counsellor at that time because he was going back to work from the next Monday.·Confirmed that at the appointment on 8 November 2014, the reason for the visit was depression and his medication was changed from Pristiq to Zoloft which is a medication he had been prescribed for the treatment of depression and that he was at the time also prescribed a medication called Zoton to treat his gastro-oesophageal reflux disorder.·Confirmed that the doctor’s notes of 17 March 2015 which referred to him having been to Brazil were correct, he had been there on a visit to see his wife and that a doctor there gave him Quetiapine as he was not sleeping and it had good effect.·Agreed that Quetiapine is a medication for the treatment of mood disorders.·Said that he got that medication in Brazil because someone had spiked his drink and he had hallucinations for nearly three days and went to see a doctor who prescribed him that medication.·Confirmed that on 14 May 2015 he saw a doctor in respect of an anxiety disorder was prescribed Seroquel which is another type of medication that is meant to treat depression.·Confirmed that he had seen the doctor on 26 November 2015 in respect of an anxiety disorder and that he had told the doctor that there would be no work for the following two months and that was stressful as he would have no income and that that doctor again prescribed him Seroquel and Zoton.·Confirmed that his mental health illness predated the first entry in the medical records made in December 2013.·When taken to a pre-employment health questionnaire he completed in relation to his position with the Respondent, confirmed that he had signed the form on 5 May 2016 and had as part of that form declared that the information he set out in the questionnaire was truthful and that there was no misleading answer or omissions, further that he understood that if he was employed and it was subsequently established that he had been misleading or untruthful, he may be terminated from the employment.·Confirmed that that the answers to the questions on the questionnaire were recorded from the information he provided.·Agreed that the answer of “No” to the question “Have you ever had any mental health issue requiring medication or counselling” was not right. He gave that answer due to embarrassment, he does not like talking about it.·Agreed that nevertheless he was called upon to make truthful answers in respect of the medical examination.·When asked about his illicit drug use at that time, after being warned in respect of the privilege against self-incrimination chose to answer the questions put to him.·Confirmed that at the time he was giving the answers to the questionnaire the answers he was giving in relation to his mental health were false.·Agreed that his answers in relation to not having ever had a problem with anxiety or panic attacks or insomnia were deliberately false answers.·When asked whether it was a situation where he saw an advantage for himself in making those false answers, said no it was more that he did not want anyone to know.·Agreed that there was a further advantage to him as well by making the false answers as he knew that it enhanced or improved his chances of keeping his job. He understood that if he had answered those questions truthfully there might have been a further investigation into his previous mental health history.·Confirmed that on 10 September 2016 there was a reference in the general practitioner records to pain in the left upper arm due to a bite, but that it was not pain it was a bite.·Confirmed that on 4 May 2017 the general practitioner’s note indicated that he was still suffering from a range of mental health symptoms at that time.·Confirmed he saw a general practitioner on 29 March 2018 in relation to his left shoulder dislocation which occurred when he reached out with his left arm to steady himself on the bedside table as he got down from an upper bunk.·Confirmed he went on to have surgery with Dr Colvin on 10 April 2018 after which there was a complication that healed itself and he had some capacity for work on 28 January 2018 to 1 January 2019 at his pre-injury hours, with limitations in relation to lifting,·Confirmed that Acumen Health had tried to get him work trials and that he had told them he wanted to complete a work trial with a friend which was endorsed by Dr Colvin on 2 August 2018.·Said, that he went to Thailand for two weeks at that time for treatment for his illicit drug use that started after the operation.·Confirmed he had not disclosed that treatment to his general practitioner.·Said that he went to Thailand for the treatment as it was too expensive here.·Agreed that the rehabilitation notes also referred to his marriage breakdown as a reason he went to Thailand.·Said that the rehabilitation note reference to not being able to find him between 30 September and 10 October 2018 was because he was still in Thailand.·Said, when put to him that the documents said that he went to Thailand on 15 August and did not come back until 26 September that he could not say where he was then, as he did not know.·When asked if the record that said:When finally contacted he advised his mental health was struggling, following specialist outcomes, and he had not recommenced the work trial.was correct, said that he did not recommence the work trial because he could not do the job.·Said, that the rehabilitation note which records his mental health was struggling, was referring to his marriage breakdown and all that sort of thing.·When asked about the Acumen Health email on 9 November 2018 that provided that he had called and advised that he had recommenced the work trial with his friend and had worked the past two weeks straight was correct, said that was not correct, he was not working.·Confirmed that the friend he was doing the work trial for was Mr Macladd who runs the plumbing business and the work he was engaged in was replacing water metres, which is basically digging up water metres, disconnecting them and installing a new one, which was work he had been doing since 2016.·Said he did not recall telling Acumen Health that he had recommenced the work trial and had worked the past two weeks straight, but that if he did say that it “was just to keep him away from [him] – stop bugging [him], [he] suppose[s].”·When it was put to him that Acumen Health was trying to rehabilitate him and that what he told them was true and correct, otherwise he would not have said it, said yes.·When asked whether he had worked the past two weeks straight at that time was right, said that he could not remember the dates, he worked until Macladd Pty Ltd could not have him there anymore because he was a hindrance and he could not do the job.·When asked whether on 20 November 2018 he told Acumen Health that he was feeling better and that there had been a significant improvement in both range of movement and strength in respect of his shoulder, said that he would have told them that he was feeling better but he would not have said it all like that but if they wrote it down it was a fair reflection of what he said to them.·Confirmed that at that time he told Acumen Health that he was working four or five days a week.·Confirmed that he also at that time told Acumen Health that he was seeing a psychologist and as a result he was mentally feeling better.·When referred to the consultation notes of his general practitioner made on 29 January 2019 which provided that he reported that his mood had been getting worse and that was quite different to what he had told Acumen Health on 20 November 2019 and asked whether that was because the condition had gotten worse between November and January or whether he was telling Acumen Health untruths to get them off his back, said “Yes, I didn’t want him to know”.·Confirmed he appreciated that Acumen Health were trying to get him back into the workforce.·Agreed that the AMSA certificate that was issued as a result of an assessment he underwent with Dr Durack certified him as being fit to return to sea and to resume duties as an integrated rating.·Confirmed that he did not say anything to Dr Durack to indicate that he would have any difficulties with performing his work as an integrated rating because he was desperate to try and get back to work and if he did not have an AMSA medical he would not have been able to do the work trial.·Confirmed that he signed the AMSA medical report and that in response to the question:Are you aware of any circumstances regarding your health which may interfere with the satisfactory discharge of the duties of your designated position/occupation?answered “No”.·When put to him that without any shadow of a doubt that was another deliberate untruth perpetuated by him, agreed it was.·Agreed that on the same day Dr Colvin certified him as fit to undertake a work trial of his normal integrated rating duties.·Said that the work trial did not go very well as there was basically nothing to do. He did not get to test his shoulder because there was no physical work as the ship was basically shut down.·Agreed that in the medical certificate from his general practitioner dated 29 July 2019 certifying him unwell with a severe skin infection that there was no mention of any shoulder problems.·When referred to the email trails between 12 and 17 July 2019 and where he had written he was doing a full IR’s job, being full 12 hour days, no light duties, agreed that he was trying to convey the fact that he had been doing full duties for 12 hours a day with no light duties but that he performed the duties that he needed to perform. When put to him that is not what his email said, he said he was trying to get the full pay, it was not a lie, he was doing everything he was asked to do onboard.·Confirmed that there were no issues while he was on the work trial.·When taken back to the general practitioner notes from 24 July 2019, 29 July 2019, 12 August 2019, 26 August 2019, which were after he had completed the offshore work trial and put to him that there were no mention of complaints of any shoulder symptoms as there were none, agreed that there was no mention however, said that his shoulder symptoms were constant.·Confirmed he saw Dr Colvin on 30 August 2019 and that he was aware that he had certified him as fit for full capacity from that date with some permanent impairment due to restricted range of motion.·When asked whether he was aware that Dr Colvin was writing that he had some restrictions which were now permanent, but would not prevent him from returning to his occupation and whether he thought that was untrue, said: “It was basically that, ‘I can’t keep you on, we need to finish this claim’, really, so I wasn’t going to get any better than I was and – yes, that was the end of it.”·When asked if his evidence to the Tribunal was, that, at that time he was unfit for work as an integrated rating, said yes.·Agreed that there were a couple of times where it had been pointed out that assertions he had made were to the absolute contrary of the actual position.·When put to him that he had told lie after lie regarding his capacity, said not in relation to his shoulder.·When it was suggested to him that he knew he was on incapacity benefits and was being paid his salary minus some deductions, said yes but that was until 15 August 2019.·When referred to emails he had written in September 2019 seeking work, said of course he was as he is broke.·When put to him that at that time though he was saying that he was fit for work, said: “No, not really. No. Because – I’d never had the opportunity to do the work, so I didn’t know.”·When put to him that he was proposing to say, when he was asking for work that he was fit for work as he knew that Dr Durack and Dr Colvin had certified him as fit for his old job, said that yes he wanted to get back to work.·When put to him that he would not have been making that representation if he did not think he could do the work, said yes, he was attesting to the fact in the emails that he was trying to be fit and ready to go back to work.·When taken to the general practitioner notes from 17 September 2019 where no mention was made of a complaint of any shoulder symptoms and it was suggested that the reason for that was because there was not any problem with his shoulder at that time, said that was not true, there was nothing they could do about it.·When taken to the general practitioner notes from 27 September 2019 which provided he reported his mood was well with mirtazapine, confirmed that was another medication to treat depression.·Based on those notes confirmed that he had done a two week rigging course which included a lot of theory and a bit of practical work, slinging up some loads, a bit of crane work that required the use of his left shoulder. ·Confirmed he reported to the general practitioner that had caused an exacerbation to his left shoulder but did not require any analgesia and had improved.·When put to him that in looking through the general practitioner medical records the entry on 27 September 2019 was the first time he had raised any shoulder symptoms with his general practitioner since 15 August 2018 despite having told Dr Jhamb and Ms Perez the occupational therapist that he had continual left shoulder pain seven days a week which caused him not to sleep, said he was dealing with Dr Colvin about his shoulder.·When taken to the general practitioner notes made on 3 December 2019 and asked about the note that he had been to a kickboxing camp in Thailand, said it was not a kickboxing camp, it was a fitness/wellbeing camp, he was there as he was severely overweight. There were activities of kickboxing there, but he said that was not what he was doing.·He was in Thailand for 6 weeks, jogging, cycling, walking, dieting and skipping.·When asked why he would describe the camp as a kickboxing camp to his general practitioner if that is not what he was doing, said he accepted that he had told the general practitioner that, because that is mainly what it was for, but was not what he was doing while there.·Confirmed the doctor’s notes that he had further bad anxiety attacks whilst in Thailand.·Said that those sorts of symptoms had been afflicting him from well before the dislocation incident in April 2018 but had gotten worse.·When it was put to him that the problem had been an issue of availability of work, said not just through the Respondent, he had applied to many different companies, not just in maritime but also in mining.·When asked if he had represented to all of those companies that he was fit and able to do offshore mariner’s work, said not to the mining companies. As soon as they see a gap in your resume, and you tell them you have been on workers’ compensation and broke your shoulder you do not get a call back.·When put to him that the important issue was that he obviously thought he was fit enough for the work and was taken to emails he had written seeking roles offshore, in one on 16 January 2020 he said “If anything comes up, please let me know. I’m ready to go”, he said he wrote the emails as he was desperate to get back to work.·When asked whether he agreed that he was clearly representing himself as being physically fit for work, said yes, he was hoping he would be.Medical evidence

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal notes that the determination to cease periodic payments under section 31 of the Act was made with effect from 21 August 2019 which was shortly prior to Dr Colvin providing final clearance that the Applicant had full capacity for work as an integrated rating. The Tribunal however considers that the final date of Dr Colvin’s clearance bears no importance on the date of which periodic payments were ceased as it is arguable that such entitlement ended on 28 June 2019, being the date the Applicant was certified by Dr Colvin to have capacity to undertake a work trial of his pre-injury work and by Dr Durack as being fit pursuant to the ASMA requirements to under that work.CONCLUSION Based on the evidence before the Tribunal, and for the reasons outlined above, the decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent’s contentions were summarised as follows:[106][106] Exhibit 2, Respondent’s Hearing Book, HB1, Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, page 5, paragraph 52.(a)The Applicant has recovered from the left shoulder injury sustained on 20 March 2018 and had done so by at least June 2019.(b)The Applicant is fit for pre-injury duties and has been since at least June 2019 and has proven his capacity for pre-injury duties.(c)There is no evidence that the Applicant is incapacitated for work.(d)If the Applicant does have an incapacity for work (which is disputed) it is not as a result of an injury on 20 March 2018.CONSIDERATION The Tribunal notes that the Applicant has not sought to advance an argument that he was incapacitated to work at all, rather he is contending that as a result of his accepted left shoulder injury he has an incapacity for work as an integrated rating, which was what he was engaged as immediately before the injury occurred. As such the Tribunal is concerned only with whether the Applicant was from 15 August 2019 entitled to receive compensation pursuant to section 31 of the Act due to an incapacity for work as described in section 8(b) of the Act. Based on the evidence before it the Tribunal is satisfied that the Applicant did not have an incapacity to engage in any work as a result of his accepted injury. While the expert medical evidence before the Tribunal provides a divergence in relation to the Applicant’s overall capacity to engage in work as an integrated rating, there is a meeting of minds in some regard. It is accepted by the Applicant and Respondent that as a whole the expert medical witnesses all agree that as a result of the accepted condition, the Applicant has a reduced range of motion/movement and experiences at times pain and stiffness in his left shoulder. To that extent based on the evidence before it, the Tribunal accepts that the Applicant’s range of movement in relation to his left shoulder is reduced, as is expected as a result of the surgery he underwent in April 2018 and that he has since continued to experience pain and stiffness in that shoulder. This does not however mean that the Applicant is automatically incapacitated from engaging in work as an integrated rating to the same rank and level as that at which he did so before the injury occurred in March 2018. There was much conjecture in relation to the credibility of the Applicant and as such the reliability of his evidence before the Tribunal and perhaps even more importantly his reporting to the medical practitioners of whom provided reports that are before the Tribunal and/or gave evidence directly to the Tribunal. The Applicant, while acknowledging that he had not been entirely truthful in the past in relation to disclosing his previous and ongoing psychological difficulties (due to embarrassment and a wish not to jeopardise his employment) and that he did not tell Dr Durack about his pain and restrictions during the June 2019 AMSA assessment, put to the Tribunal that does not of itself mean that he was lying about the pain and restriction in his shoulder. The Applicant submitted that it is a fallacy to reason that the mere fact that a person has been shown to have lied about something means the opposite of what the person says must be true.[107][107] Applicant’s Outline of Submissions, pages 4-5, paragraphs 23-24 having reference to Fell v Lloyd (1911) 13 CLR 230 at 241; Steinberg v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1975) 134 CLR 640 at 694 and Djuraj v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 986 at [30].