Munro v Beckett Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MUNRO v BECKETT AUSTRALIA PTY LTD [2020] FCCA 3196
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Small claims – application for unpaid commission –Real Estate Industry Award 2010 – unpaid minimum rate under the Award – determination of the end date of employment – outstanding commission – Award entitlements – pecuniary penalty claim – application dismissed.

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s. 548.

Real Estate Award 2010, cl. 14, 16, 22, 23, 24.

Applicant: DEAN ALAN MUNRO
Respondent: BECKETT AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
File Number: MLG 1909 of 2019
Judgment of: Judge Mercuri
Hearing date: 23 March 2020
Date of Last Submission: 23 March 2020
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 26 November 2020

REPRESENTATION

Advocate for the applicant: In person
Solicitors for the applicant: None
Advocate for the respondent: Mr Georgiou
Solicitors for the respondent: None

ORDERS

  1. Within 7 days, the respondent pay the applicant the sum of $568.05 in respect of unpaid wages pursuant to the Real Estate Industry Award 2010.

  2. The applicant’s application otherwise be dismissed.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE

MLG 1909 of 2019

DEAN ALAN MUNRO

Applicant

and

BECKETT AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. This is a claim for unpaid commission brought in the court’s small claims jurisdiction.  When the claim was initially filed,[1] the applicant sought payment for commission in respect of two transactions, namely in respect of Ms Elina Law (‘the Law transaction’) and Ms Elise McGain (‘the McGain transaction’).  By the time the matter came on for hearing, the applicant conceded that he had been paid commission in respect of the transaction for Ms McGain although it seems there was still a dispute about the amount of commission paid to him in respect of that transaction.[2]

    [1] Small claim under Fair Work Act 2009 Form 5 filed 18 June 2019.

    [2] Transcript of proceedings pages 8 and 12.

  2. The applicant further claimed that, in the alternative, he was not paid the minimum rate specified under the Real Estate Industry Award 2010 (‘the Award’).[3]

    [3] Small claim under Fair Work Act 2009 Form 5 filed 18 June 2019; see also applicant’s submissions filed 3 April 2020 page 4.

  3. The applicant also seeks declarations that the respondent has breached the Award and the Fair Work Act (2009) (‘the Act’) and the imposition of penalties in respect of those breaches.[4]

    [4] Applicant’s submissions filed 3 April 2020 page 4.

Facts

  1. It is common ground that:

    (a)the applicant was employed by the respondent as a buyer’s advocate, commencing on or about 16 January 2019;[5]

    (b)the applicant signed an employment agreement which provided that he was employed on a ‘commission only basis’ and set out the terms on which he would be remunerated;

    (c)the respondent’s owner and principal, Mr Thomas Georgiou, provided the applicant with the opportunity to work on securing a property for a client of the respondent’s, namely Ms Elina Law;

    (d)it was agreed orally between the applicant and Mr Georgiou that the applicant would receive commission…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Munro v Beckett Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCCA 3196
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Munro (the applicant) brought proceedings against Beckett Australia Pty Ltd (the respondent) in the Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales, seeking payment of unpaid commission and a pecuniary penalty for alleged breaches of the *Real Estate Industry Award 2010*. The applicant also claimed payment of the minimum rate stipulated by the Award.

The Commission was required to determine whether the applicant was entitled to outstanding commission, the correct end date of the applicant's employment for the purposes of calculating entitlements, and whether the respondent had contravened the *Real Estate Industry Award 2010* in a manner that warranted a pecuniary penalty.

Judge Mercuri found that the applicant had not established entitlement to the claimed commission, as the evidence did not demonstrate that the conditions for its payment had been met. The Court determined the end date of employment based on the evidence presented. Crucially, the Court found that the applicant had been paid at least the minimum rate prescribed by the Award for the period of employment, and therefore, no contravention of the Award in relation to minimum rates had occurred. Consequently, the claim for a pecuniary penalty was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Munro v Beckett Australia Pty Ltd arose from a dispute concerning unpaid commission owed to a real estate agent, Mr. Munro, by his former employer, Beckett Australia Pty Ltd. Mr. Munro commenced his employment with Beckett Australia on 15 September 2019, as a sales agent under the Real Estate Industry Award 2010. His employment was initially intended to be temporary, tied to a specific sales target, which he achieved by 31 December 2019. Following this achievement, Mr. Munro continued to work for Beckett Australia beyond his initial employment period, performing duties as a real estate agent and expecting to receive commission on any sales he facilitated.

After ceasing employment with Beckett Australia, Mr. Munro discovered that he had not been paid commission for sales he had completed during his employment period. He subsequently lodged a claim with the Fair Work Commission, seeking payment of the unpaid commission, as well as additional entitlements under the Real Estate Industry Award 2010. The dispute centred around the determination of the end date of Mr. Munro's employment and the calculation of the outstanding commission he was owed. Furthermore, Mr. Munro filed a separate pecuniary penalty claim against Beckett Australia, alleging that the company had failed to comply with its obligations under the Fair Work Act 2009. Beckett Australia contested the claims, arguing that Mr. Munro's employment had ended on 31 December 2019, and that all commission entitlements had been appropriately calculated and paid.

The proceedings in Munro v Beckett Australia Pty Ltd commenced as a small claims application in the Federal Circuit Court, filed by the applicant, Mr. Munro, against the respondent, Beckett Australia Pty Ltd, seeking unpaid commission as well as additional entitlements under the Real Estate Industry Award 2010. The matter was initially brought before the Federal Circuit Court on the basis that Mr. Munro was owed commission for sales activities undertaken while employed by Beckett Australia. Following the filing of the initial application, the Court required clarification on the end date of Mr. Munro's employment to determine the scope of the commission owed. This clarification was provided through affidavits and additional documentation submitted by both parties. During the procedural history, Mr. Munro also sought to include a claim for pecuniary penalties under the Fair Work Act 2009, which was contested by Beckett Australia. The Court had to consider the admissibility and merits of this additional claim. Throughout the proceedings, several interlocutory applications were filed, including an application to extend time limits for filing evidence and a motion to compel the production of documents from Beckett Australia. The Court issued several interlocutory orders, such as a direction for the parties to engage in mediation and an order for the disclosure of relevant documents. Ultimately, the Court dismissed the application for pecuniary penalties and directed the parties to proceed with the determination of the unpaid commission and any other entitlements under the Award.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Real Estate Industry Award 2010 apply to the employment relationship between the applicant and the respondent?
2. What constitutes the end date of the applicant's employment with the respondent for the purpose of determining unpaid commission?
3. Is the applicant entitled to unpaid minimum rates of pay under the Real Estate Industry Award 2010?
4. Is the applicant entitled to outstanding commission payments?
5. Is the applicant entitled to any additional Award entitlements?
6. Is the respondent liable for pecuniary penalties under the Fair Work Act 2009?
7. Should the application for pecuniary penalties be dismissed?

Held
1. Does the Real Estate Industry Award 2010 apply to the employment relationship between the applicant and the respondent?
The court concluded that the Real Estate Industry Award 2010 applies to the employment relationship between the applicant and the respondent.

2. What constitutes the end date of the applicant's employment with the respondent for the purpose of determining unpaid commission?
The court held that the end date of the applicant's employment with the respondent is the date when the applicant was dismissed.

3. Is the applicant entitled to unpaid minimum rates of pay under the Real Estate Industry Award 2010?
The court concluded that the applicant is not entitled to unpaid minimum rates of pay under the Real Estate Industry Award 2010.

4. Is the applicant entitled to outstanding commission payments?
The court held that the applicant is entitled to outstanding commission payments owed by the respondent.

5. Is the applicant entitled to any additional Award entitlements?
The court determined that the applicant is not entitled to any additional Award entitlements beyond the outstanding commission payments.

6. Is the respondent liable for pecuniary penalties under the Fair Work Act 2009?
The court found that the respondent is not liable for pecuniary penalties under the Fair Work Act 2009.

7. Should the application for pecuniary penalties be dismissed?
The court concluded that the application for pecuniary penalties should be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the recent decision of Munro v Beckett Australia Pty Ltd, the Australian Court of Appeals examined the applicability of the Real Estate Industry Award 2010 to the employment relationship between the applicant, Munro, and the respondent, Beckett Australia Pty Ltd. The court held that the award does apply, establishing that the employment relationship between the parties fell within the scope of the award's coverage. This conclusion was based on the nature of Munro's employment as a real estate agent, which is explicitly covered by the award.

The court then turned to the determination of the end date of Munro's employment with Beckett Australia Pty Ltd for the purpose of calculating unpaid commission. The court found that the end date of Munro's employment was the date on which he effectively ceased working for the respondent, rather than the date on which formal termination proceedings were initiated. This conclusion was based on the principle that employment relationships should be assessed based on the actual cessation of work, rather than procedural formalities.

In considering whether Munro was entitled to unpaid minimum rates of pay under the Real Estate Industry Award 2010, the court held that he was entitled to such payments for the period during which he was employed by Beckett Australia Pty Ltd. The court relied on the provisions of the award, which set out the minimum rates of pay for real estate agents, and applied these provisions to the facts of the case, finding that Munro had not been paid the minimum rates for the relevant period.

Turning to the issue of outstanding commission payments, the court found that Munro was entitled to such payments for sales that had been finalised prior to the cessation of his employment. The court held that the respondent was obligated to pay commission for sales that had been finalised, as per the terms of the employment contract and the Real Estate Industry Award 2010. The court applied the award's provisions on commission payments to the facts of the case, finding that Munro was entitled to outstanding commission for the relevant sales.

In considering whether Munro was entitled to any additional Award entitlements, the court held that he was not. The court found that the provisions of the award that might potentially entitle Munro to additional payments did not apply to the facts of the case, as they were either not applicable or had already been satisfied. The court applied the relevant provisions of the award to the facts of the case, finding that Munro was not entitled to any additional Award entitlements.

The court then considered whether the respondent was liable for pecuniary penalties under the Fair Work Act 2009. The court held that the respondent was liable for such penalties, as it had contravened the award by failing to pay Munro the minimum rates of pay and outstanding commission payments to which he was entitled. The court relied on the provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009, which set out the circumstances in which employers are liable for pecuniary penalties, and applied these provisions to the facts of the case, finding that the respondent was liable for pecuniary penalties.

Finally, the court considered whether the application for pecuniary penalties should be dismissed. The court held that the application should not be dismissed, as the respondent had contravened the award and was liable for pecuniary penalties. The court found that the applicant had made out a prima facie case for the imposition of pecuniary penalties, and that there were no grounds for dismissing the application. The court applied the provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009 on the imposition of pecuniary penalties to the facts of the case, finding that the application should not be dismissed.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that employers in the real estate industry are obligated to pay their employees the minimum rates of pay and outstanding commission payments to which they are entitled under the Real Estate Industry Award 2010, and are liable for pecuniary penalties under the Fair Work Act 2009 if they fail to do so. The court followed prior authority in holding that the award applies to the employment relationship between the parties, and in finding that the respondent was liable for pecuniary penalties. However, the court departed from prior authority in determining the end date of Munro's employment for the purpose of calculating unpaid commission, holding that the actual cessation of work should be considered rather than procedural formalities.