Municipality of South Perth v Hackett

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read
8 CLR 44

MUNICIPALITY OF SOUTH PERTH

JOHN WINTHROP HACKETT AND

RESPONDENTS. OTHERS DEFENDANTS,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Rating - Municipal Institutions Act 1900 (W.A.) (64 Vact. No. 8), sec. 324-Land

belonging to public body- - Exemption-Zoologica Gardens Act 1898 (W.A.) (62 Vict. No. 32). PERTH,

Land vested in trustees under the Zoological Gardens Act 1898 (W.A.) (62 Vict. No. 32) is not rateable, the trustees being a public body created by Statute within the meaning of sec. 324 of the Municipal Institutions Act 1900 (W.A.) (64 Vict. No. 8); and the failure of the trustees to appeal in accord- ance with sec. 342, does not prevent them from setting up the exemption as a defence in an action for the recovery of rates.

The fact that such a body allowed the land vested in them to be used in a way not within the limits of the trust is not material to the question whether it is rateable or not, nor is the fact that the grant may be invalid any reason for interference by the municipality.

Decision of Supreme Court of Western Australia affirmed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

Certain lands situated within the municipality of South Perth were vested in the defendants in accordance with the provisions of the Zoological Gardens Act 1898. The plaintiffs sued rates and claimed that certain breaches of trust had been made,

8 CLR 45

viz., the setting aside of a certain portion of the land for the use of members of a tennis club to the exclusion of non-members. When the defendants received notice of the rate having been levied, they failed to appeal in accordance with the provisions of sec. 342 of the Municipal Institutions Act 1900.

Villeneuve Smith and Henning, for the appellants. The defendant trustees are not really a public body created by Statute within the meaning of sec. 324 of 64 Vict. No. 8. This section refers to boards such as road boards with power to levy rates, cf. a definition in an Imperial Statute, The Public Bodies Corrupt Practices Act, 52 &53 Vict. c. 69, sec. 7; and even if they were they cannot now set up the exemption as they failed to comply with the provisions of sec. 342 of the Municipal Insti- tutions Act 1900. The evidence shows that they allowed the lands to be used in breach of their trust, allowing the members of a tennis club the use of a certain portion to the exclusion of the general public. Counsel referred to the following Statutes and cases :-64 Vict. No. 8, secs. 324, 342, 345; 62 Vict. No. 32 56 Vict. No. 14, sec. 19 6 &7 Vict. c. 36, sec. 1; 42 Eliz. C. 2, sec. 6 Mayor of Essendon v. Blackwood 1; Municipal Council of Sydney v. Royal Agricultural Society of New South Wales 2; Churchwardens of Birmingham v. Shaw 3; Borough of Glebe V. Lukey 4; Perth City Council…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Municipality of South Perth v Hackett and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1908] HCA 73
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Municipality of South Perth (appellant) appealed from a decision of the Supreme Court of Western Australia concerning the rateability of land vested in trustees under the Zoological Gardens Act 1898. The municipality had sued for unpaid rates, alleging that the trustees, as a public body, had breached their trust by allowing a portion of the land to be used exclusively by a tennis club. The trustees had failed to appeal the rate assessment within the time prescribed by the Municipal Institutions Act 1900.

The central legal issues before the Full High Court were whether the land vested in the trustees was exempt from municipal rates under section 324 of the Municipal Institutions Act 1900, and if so, whether the trustees' failure to appeal the rate assessment precluded them from raising this exemption as a defence in an action for recovery of the rates. The municipality argued that the trustees were not a "public body created by Statute" and that, in any event, their failure to appeal meant they could not now claim exemption.

The High Court dismissed the appeal, affirming the decision of the Supreme Court. The Court held that the trustees constituted a public body created by statute within the meaning of section 324 of the Municipal Institutions Act 1900, and therefore the land vested in them was exempt from rating, irrespective of its use. The Court reasoned that the exemption under section 324 for land belonging to a public body created by statute was based on ownership, not use. Furthermore, the Court found that the appeal provisions in the Municipal Institutions Act 1900, which were limited to questions of valuation, did not grant the council or the Local Court jurisdiction to determine the fundamental question of rateability or exemption. Consequently, the trustees were not prevented from raising the exemption as a defence in the action for rates. The Court also noted that any alleged breaches of trust were matters for the Attorney-General, not the municipality, and did not affect the land's exemption from rates.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.