Mullins v Jacjas Real Estate Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Mullins v Jacjas Real Estate Pty Ltd & Ors [2024] QIRC 142

PARTIES:

Mullins, Katie
Applicant

v

Jacjas Real Estate Pty Ltd
First Respondent

&

Jacqui Read
Second Respondent

&

Jason Read
Third Respondent

CASE NO:

AD/2023/115

PROCEEDING:

Application to be represented by an unpaid agent

DELIVERED ON:

4 June 2024

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

Pratt IC

On the papers

ORDER:

1.      The Application is granted.

2.      The Applicant may be represented by Mr Heffernan in these proceedings on a pro bono basis.

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – APPLICATION FOR LEAVE FOR RESPONDENT TO BE REPRESENTED BY AN UNPAID AGENT – where applicant previously granted leave to be represented by a lawyer – where lawyer formerly representing applicant no longer able to represent applicant – where applicant cannot afford replacement legal representation – where applicant made an application to be represented by an unpaid agent – consideration of section 529 of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) and relevant legal principles – where applicant submits that no issue created by unpaid agent's lack of legal qualifications – where applicant submits that it would be unfair to represent herself against respondent who has legal representation – where applicant submits that matter is complex – where applicant submits they have no other reasonably available options for representation – where applicant and unpaid agent both say the unpaid agent not directly or indirectly receiving or demanding fee – where respondent submits that unpaid agent has indirectly received a fee – where respondent submits the proceedings would not be dealt with more efficiently by the presence of the unpaid agent – whether there was payment of fees between the applicant and the unpaid agent – held that the applicant is not seeking leave to be represented by a person who directly or indirectly demands or receives a fee for representing the applicant in the proceedings – whether matters would proceed more efficiently with unpaid agent – held matter would proceed more efficiently with unpaid agent – whether fairness dictates that applicant should be represented by an unpaid agent – held that fairness dictates that applicant should be represented by an unpaid agent – application granted.

LEGISLATION & OTHER MATERIALS:

CASES:

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) s 529, 530.

Industrial Relations and Other Legislation Amendment Bill 2022

SZTAL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] HCA 34.

Reasons for Decision

  1. Ms Katie Mullins ('the Applicant') seeks leave to be represented by an unpaid agent pursuant to s 529(3) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) ('IR Act') ('the Application'). This representation would be for proceedings for a claim of unlawful discrimination made pursuant to the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 ('AD Act').

  2. The Applicant was previously granted leave to be represented by a lawyer in these proceedings, as was the Respondent. However, the Applicant's lawyer, Mr Dryley-Collins, suffered a debilitating health condition that meant he could no longer continue to represent the Applicant. Consequently, the Applicant is left in the troubled position…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mullins v Jacjas Real Estate Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QIRC 142
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mullins v Jacjas Real Estate Pty Ltd involved an application for leave to be represented by an unpaid agent in industrial law proceedings. The applicant, Mullins, sought to be represented by Mr Heffernan on a pro bono basis after her former lawyer was unable to continue representing her due to financial constraints. The respondent, Jacjas Real Estate Pty Ltd, opposed the application on the grounds that Mr Heffernan had indirectly received a fee for his services. The legal issues centered around the interpretation of section 529 of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld), which governs the discretion to allow representation by an unpaid agent. The court had to determine if the applicant was seeking to be represented by someone who directly or indirectly demanded or received a fee, whether the proceedings would be more efficiently dealt with by the presence of the unpaid agent, and whether fairness dictated that the applicant should be represented by an unpaid agent.

The court considered the evidence and submissions from both parties. It found that Mr Heffernan was not receiving or demanding any fee for representing Mullins, either directly or indirectly. The court was satisfied that any past payments made by Mullins were not for Mr Heffernan's representation in the proceedings. The court also found that while there were reservations about the efficiency of the proceedings with Mr Heffernan, the complexity of the matter and the applicant's lack of legal representation made it fair for Mullins to be represented by an experienced industrial relations practitioner. Given the respondent's legal representation and the absence of any unfair payment arrangement, the court concluded that the discretion within section 529(3) was enlivened and granted the application.

In conclusion, the court granted Mullins' application to be represented by Mr Heffernan on a pro bono basis. The court found that the applicant was not seeking to be represented by someone who directly or indirectly demanded or received a fee, and that fairness dictated that Mullins should be represented by an unpaid agent. The court ordered that Mullins may be represented by Mr Heffernan in the proceedings on a pro bono basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Application is granted.

2. The Applicant may be represented by Mr Heffernan in these proceedings on a pro bono basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The second fairness consideration within s 529(3)(c) goes to fairness as between the parties. In this case, as I have mentioned above, the Respondent employer is represented by solicitors who have briefed counsel. The Applicant's unchallenged evidence is that she has no way of engaging another lawyer, which I accept. The Commission has already granted the Applicant leave to be represented by a lawyer in these proceedings. Granting the leave that is now sought would avail the Applicant of free representation by an experienced industrial relations practitioner. Having regard to the Respondent's position, which I must when weighing up the consideration of fairness as between the parties, I find that it would be unfair to the Applicant to refuse her application for representation. On that basis I conclude that the consideration at s 529(3)(c) is also made out.Conclusion I conclude that the Applicant is not applying to be represented by a person who directly or indirectly demands or receives a fee for representing her in these proceedings. I have some reservations that greater efficiency in dealing with this matter will result from granting this application, although I expect there to be such efficiency as has been promised. Even so, I find it a compelling conclusion that it would be unfair to the Applicant not to grant her application to be represented by Mr Heffernan on a pro bono basis. On that basis, I conclude that the discretion within s 529(3) is enlivened. Having regard to the facts of this case, I am of the view that it is appropriate in this instance to exercise the discretion in favour of granting the application. I order accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant complied with those orders. The answer to each of those questions was 'no' in the Applicant's affidavit. Mr Heffernan to also put on affidavit evidence responding to the same questions, although pertaining to him personally. Mr Heffernan, in his affidavit, also answered 'no' to all of the questions.Consideration I have considered all materials from both the Applicant and the Respondent. In delivering my reasons below, I have only referred to the relevant materials. The Respondent contends that I must refuse leave as Mr Heffernan has likely already indirectly been paid a fee for his services in representing the Applicant in these proceedings. This indirect fee, the Respondent submits, comes from Mr Heffernan's association with the entity that previously had financial ties with the lawyer acting for the Applicant. I am sympathetic to the Respondent's submission that the Applicant's and Mr Heffernan's affidavit and submissions about the fee arrangement is not as clear as one might hope. The Applicant's carefully worded affidavits and submissions has placed the arrangement between the Applicant, Mr Heffernan and the two industrial advocacy firms behind frosted glass. Nonetheless, the affidavit evidence filed by both the Applicant and Mr Heffernan allows me to see that arrangement clearly enough to be satisfied from the evidence that Mr Heffernan is not, either directly or indirectly, receiving or demanding any fee for representing the Applicant in these proceedings. I am also satisfied that the Applicant is not paying any fee to any person or entity for representation in these proceedings. But what of any fee that the Applicant previously paid to an entity, of which Mr Heffernan was a shareholder at the relevant time? The Respondent's argument is that such a payment in the past still counts and therefore Mr Heffernan cannot appear. For the following reasons, I do not accept that submission. On my assessment, any past payment the Applicant made to the solicitor and his firm was not a payment for Mr Heffernan to represent the Applicant in the proceedings. At all times prior to this application, a lawyer was engaged by the Applicant as her representative in the proceedings. That lawyer acted as such, having been granted leave to do so. I do not accept that at the time the Applicant entered into any such arrangement, she was paying a fee, even indirectly, to Mr Heffernan for Mr Heffernan to represent her in the proceedings. I am therefore satisfied that the Applicant is not seeking to be represented by a person who directly or indirectly demands or receives a fee for representing the Applicant in the proceedings. It falls to the Commission to then deal with the three abovementioned considerations within s 529(3) to see if the discretion is enlivened. Efficiency Ms Mullins argues that Mr Heffernan is an experienced industrial relations advocate who has expertise in the process of the Commission that she does not possess. The Applicant's submission is that, having regard to the complexity of the matter, the matter would be more efficiently dealt with if Mr Heffernan were to represent the Applicant than if she ran the matter by herself.