FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| MULLEN & ACKEN (NO. 3) (Interim property settlement; Directions for trial) | [2011] FamCA 880 |
| FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Hearing – Where the wife did not attend Court or file any documents in relation to the husband's application – Where the Court proceeded to hear the application on an undefended basis. FAMILY LAW – CHILDREN – Where the husband sought that passports be issued for the children, in circumstances where the wife would not sign the passport application form. FAMILY LAW – INTERIM PROPERTY SETTLEMENT – Where the husband sought that the former matrimonial home be sold and each of the parties receive $100,000 by way of interim property settlement. |
| Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) |
| Strahan & Strahan (Interim Property Orders) [2009] FamCAFC 166 Hickey and Hickey and A-G for the Commonwealth of Australia (Intervener) (2003) FLC 93-143 |
| APPLICANT: | Ms Mullen |
| RESPONDENT: | Mr Acken |
| INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: | Mr D Piekarski |
| FILE NUMBER: | MLC | 10068 | of | 2010 |
| DATE DELIVERED: | 21 October 2011 |
| PLACE DELIVERED: | Melbourne |
| PLACE HEARD: | Melbourne |
| JUDGMENT OF: | Bennett J |
| HEARING DATE: | 17 October 2011 |
REPRESENTATION
| COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: | No Appearance |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: |
| COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: | Mr Mulvany |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: | TJ Mulvany & Co |
| COUNSEL FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: | Ms Boymal |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: | Victoria Legal Aid |
ORDERS:
IT BE DECLARED that Pursuant to section 7 and 11 of the Passports Act 1938 (Cth) and the Court being satisfied that it is not practicable to obtain the consent of the respondent wife, Ms Mullen, to enable the children of the relationship S born … September 1998, E born … March 2000 and T born … December 2001 to obtain an Australian Passport to travel out of Australia.
IT IS ORDERED BY THE COURT:
That the husband, Mr Acken, the father of the children S- born … September 1998, E born … March 2000 and T born … December 2001 be and is hereby permitted to apply for Australian Passports to enable the children to leave Australia notwithstanding that the respondent wife, Ms Mullen, the mother of the said children has not signed the passport application form and furthermore the said children be permitted to leave Australia without the permission of the respondent wife.
IT IS REQUESTED, pursuant to Section 8(1)(b) of the Australian Passports Act the Department of Immigration and Citizenship forthwith do all acts and things to issue an Australian Passport in the name of each of the children.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED:
That the husband be and is hereby at liberty to take the children (or any of them) out of Australia for the purpose of a holiday not exceeding eight (8) weeks’ duration.
That not less than 14 days prior to removing the children (or any of them) from Australia pursuant to the preceding paragraph of this Order, the husband:-
(a)deliver to his solicitor and the independent children’s lawyer, a colour copy of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mullen & Acken (No 3) (Interim property settlement; Directio... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] FamCA 880
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether to grant the husband's application for interim property settlement, including the sale of the former matrimonial home and the distribution of proceeds, and whether to issue orders permitting the children to obtain Australian passports and to travel internationally without the wife's consent. Additionally, the court needed to establish directions for the final hearing, given the wife's non-participation in the current proceedings.
Applying the provisions of the *Passports Act 1938* (Cth), the court was satisfied that it was not practicable to obtain the wife's consent for the children's passports and therefore permitted the husband to apply for them, allowing the children to leave Australia notwithstanding the wife's lack of signature. The court also ordered the sale of the former matrimonial home by public auction or private sale, setting a reserve price and outlining the process for engaging real estate agents and conveyancers. The proceeds were to be applied towards sale costs, a refund to the husband for preparation expenses, and then equally between the parties, with each to receive $100,000 as an interim distribution. The court also made extensive directions for the final hearing, including the filing of financial statements, evidence, case outlines, and the provision of information by the independent children's lawyer, noting that failure to participate could result in the court proceeding without further input from the non-participating party.
Orders
Orders of the court
IT BE DECLARED that Pursuant to section 7 and 11 of the Passports Act 1938 (Cth) and the Court being satisfied that it is not practicable to obtain the consent of the respondent wife, Ms Mullen, to enable the children of the relationship S born … September 1998, E born … March 2000 and T born … December 2001 to obtain an Australian Passport to travel out of Australia.
IT IS ORDERED BY THE COURT:
1.
That the husband, Mr Acken, the father of the children S- born … September 1998, E born … March 2000 and T born … December 2001 be and is hereby permitted to apply for Australian Passports to enable the children to leave Australia notwithstanding that the respondent wife, Ms Mullen, the mother of the said children has not signed the passport application form and furthermore the said children be permitted to leave Australia without the permission of the respondent wife.
2.
IT IS REQUESTED, pursuant to Section 8(1)(b) of the Australian Passports Act the Department of Immigration and Citizenship forthwith do all acts and things to issue an Australian Passport in the name of each of the children.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED:
3.
That the husband be and is hereby at liberty to take the children (or any of them) out of Australia for the purpose of a holiday not exceeding eight (8) weeks’ duration.
4.
That not less than 14 days prior to removing the children (or any of them) from Australia pursuant to the preceding paragraph of this Order, the husband:-
(a) deliver to his solicitor and the independent children’s lawyer, a colour copy of the identification page of each child’s passport and a detailed itinerary showing flight and other transport arrangements, the address of all accommodation and telephone and email details of how he and the children may be contacted for the period during which the children (or any of them) will be absent from Australia; and
(b) provide to the wife by prepaid post a general description of locations (by city or province or town or region) of where the children will be located between specified dates –
and I reserve liberty to the wife to make application to the court that the husband’s solicitor and/or the independent children’s lawyer disclose specific details from the children’s itinerary to her in the event that an emergency arises whilst the children are absent from Australia which, in the opinion of the Court, requires the wife to be able to contact the husband and or any of the children.
5.
That the husband do all acts and things necessary to irrevocably instruct his solicitor to advise my Associate – email … of the date and time of the proposed departure of the children from Australia in order that she may advise the Afterhours Service of the Court to have the matter listed before me immediately in the event that there is any difficulty with the husband’s ability to remove the children (or any of them) from Australia.
6.
That the husband and the wife take all requisite and necessary steps to effect a sale of the former matrimonial home situated and known as B property, (“the former matrimonial home”) by public auction and, if such auction is unsuccessful, thereafter by private sale and by way of implementation of this Order:-
(a) the husband and the wife do all acts and things necessary to retain the services of LJ Hooker Real Estate, …, Director at a commission fee calculated on two per centum of the sale price payable together with an advertising budget;
(b) the wife and the husband do all things necessary to instruct the real estate agent that the reserve price for the sale of the former matrimonial home is $525,000.00, with a settlement date of not less than sixty (60) and not more that one hundred and twenty days (120) following the sale;
(c) the husband and the wife do all acts and things to sign all documents necessary to effect the retention of the said agent, the engagement of an appropriate conveyancer including but not limited to a lawyer and, in the event that the husband and the wife are unable to agree in writing upon a lawyer within 14 days of this Order, the firm of TJ Mulvany & Co, lawyers (the husband’s lawyers) undertake the conveyancing of the former matrimonial home, the completion of all documents necessary to obtain a Discharge of Mortgage and all necessary documents to complete the sale;
(d) in the event or the refusal or failure by the wife to complete any documents which are necessary to effect and complete a sale of the former matrimonial home then, pursuant to Section 106A (2) of the Family law Act 1975, a Registrar of this Registry of the Court be appointed to execute on behalf of the wife or on any documents which are necessary to effect a sale of the former matrimonial home and completion of the sale including but not limited to:
(i) The forms for engagement of the real estate agent;
(ii) The Vendor’s statement required pursuant to Section 32 of the Sale of Land Act 1962;
(iii) The Section 27 Statement;
(iv) The Contract of Sale;
(v) The Transfer of Land;
(vi) Application to the mortgagee to prepare discharge of Mortgage;
(vii) All other documents reasonably required to effect and complete a sale of the former matrimonial home;
And it is sufficient proof of the fact that the wife has failed or neglected to execute a document or do something required of her if a solicitor makes and files an affidavit attesting to that fact which is served on the wife prior to the request being made.
7.
That the wife and husband do all acts and things necessary to cause the proceeds of sale of the former matrimonial home be applied as follows:
(a) Upon release of the deposit monies, all of the fees and outlays of the said agent hereinbefore appointed be paid, the husband be refunded to a maximum five thousand dollars ($5,000.00) for expenses incurred in preparing the former matrimonial home for sale and thereafter the balance be paid equally between the wife and the husband.
(b) On completion of the sale and payment the balance of the proceeds of sale, interest and fees due to the mortgage on the property:-
(i) Unless such expenses have already been paid, the account sales and repair costs referred to in sub-paragraph (a) of this Order;
(ii) The relevant conveyancing fees incurred in the sale of the matrimonial property be paid;
(iii) One hundred thousand dollars ($100,000.00) be paid to each of the husband and the wife and be categorized as an interim property distribution and be paid as follows:-
A. As to the wife, $100,000 into whatever account the wife nominates in writing and if no account is nominated, then the monies remain held on trust on her behalf;
B. As to the husband (for the avoidance of doubt, the $100,000 does not include the $5,000 provided for in paragraph 7(a)):-
1. $70,000 to the husband’s solicitors to be held in trust and applied in payment of legal costs and disbursements as authorised by the husband; and
2. $30,000 to, or at the direction of, the husband;
C. The balance to be held until agreement in writing between the husband and the wife, or an Order of this Court in the joint names of the husband and the wife in the trust account of the husband’s lawyers, TJ Mulvany & Co, in interest bearing deposit at call, and it is requested that by the 14th day of each month, the husband’s lawyers provide copy of same to the wife.
8.
That the distribution of the proceeds of sale pursuant to subparagraph 7(b)(iii) is conditional upon the husband’s superannuation trustee having advised the husband’s solicitors that he/she does not seek to be heard on the issue of splitting the husband’s superannuation interest.
9.
That until further order the wife be restrained from causing permitting or suffering any request to be made of any third person, including but not limited to, any members of her family and Ms P from engaging and/or requesting any third person to be the wife’s agent for the purpose of delivering any letters and/or gifts and/or cards and/or any other form of communication, including telephone communication, to any one or more of the children on behalf of the wife.
10.
That the husband’s costs of and incidental to his application in a case filed 13 September 2011 be reserved.
11.
IT IS DIRECTED that a Registrar of this Registry of the Court send a copy of these reasons to:-
(a) the wife’s parents;
(b) the wife’s friend, Ms P;
(c) the proper officers of the schools at which any of the children attend –
for their own reference and that the husband’s solicitors forthwith provide to my Associate – email …. - the postal addresses to which that correspondence should be sent.
12.
IT IS DIRECTED that these reasons be provided to the family consultant who is preparing the s 62G family report and that she consider inviting the wife’s sister, C Mullen of … (telephone: 03 …) to be interviewed by her for the purpose of her family report assessment.
13.
That otherwise, the matter remains listed for final hearing on 21 November 2011 at 10.00 am.
14.
That the father file and serve an amended response by 4.00 pm on 18 October 2011 in which he seeks a splitting order in relation to his superannuation interest.
15.
That by not later than 12 noon on 28 October, the husband and the wife each file and serve an up to date financial statement.
16.
That the mother file and serve any evidence upon which she seeks to rely at the final hearing by 28 October 2011 NOTING THAT the wife is not at liberty to rely on documents already filed without leave of the Court.
17.
That the husband file and serve any evidence upon which he proposes to rely at the final hearing by 12 noon on 7 November 2011.
18.
That the affidavits to be sworn or affirmed by the husband and wife personally must be not more than 70 pages in length (including annexures) on A4 single sided pages size, in font not smaller than 12 point with lines no more closely spaced than 1.5 space and may not incorporate by reference any earlier or other documents filed in this proceeding.
19.
That the independent children’s lawyer file any updated report by Dr N by 11 November 2011.
20.
That by 15 November 2011 each party be at liberty to deliver to the Court, to my Court Officer, up to 100 A4 pages to be incorporated into a Court Book, noting that the documents will not automatically be admissible.
21.
That any party who seeks to tender or to refer a witness (including himself or herself) to a document at the final hearing must have five (5) clean copies of that document to hand out in Court prior to, or contemporaneously with, the proposed tender or request that the witness have reference to it.
22.
That each party file and serve:-
a) a case outline document about parenting matters, and
b) a case outline about financial matters; and
c) a list of documents to relied upon by that party
as follows:-
i) the mother by 12.00 noon on 14 November 2011;
ii) the father by 12.00 noon on 15 November 2011;
and provide same to the email address ….
23.
That the case outline document about parenting orders summarise the arguments in support of each party’s case including, but not necessarily limited to, the following issues:-
a) Whether the presumption in relation to equal shared parental responsibility is rebutted and, if so, on what basis; and
b) Whether it is the best interests of S born … September 1998, E born … March 2000 and T born … December 2001 to spend equal time with each parent and, if not, why not; and
d) Whether it is the best interests of the children for the parent with whom the children are not primarily resident to be entitled to spend substantial or significant time to spend equal time with the children and, if not, why not; and
e) What parenting orders are sought by that party;
f) Why the parenting orders sought by that party are in the best interests of the children having regard to the primary and additional considerations set out in s60CC(2) and s60CC(3) of the Act.
24.
That the case outline document pertaining to financial matters include the following:-
a) a list of assets divisible between the parties (including any add-backs);
b) a summary of argument including but not limited to the following matters relating to a final alteration of property interests:-
i. the contribution based entitlement claimed, expressed as a percentage of the net value of assets -
1. as at final separation;
2. at the time of trial;
ii. in dot point form the different types of contribution being financial contributions (s79(4)(a)), non-financial contributions (s79(4)(b)) and contributions to the welfare of the family (s79(4)(c)) upon which that party relies to support the contribution based entitlement for which they contend:-
1. during cohabitation;
2. since separation
iii. any other matters relevant to a division of property including any adjustment to the contribution-based claim (if any) expressed as a percentage of the net value of the assets divisible between the parties having regard to the factors in s79(4)(d), (e), (f) and (g);
iv. in dot point form what relevant s75(2) or other factors relied upon by that party for any adjustment;
c) a summary of any matters upon which evidence is adduced from experts and is not agreed, including but not limited to:-
i. the date and outcome of the last conference between experts;
ii. the particular matters upon which there is no agreement between experts;
iii. what the difference there would be to the final outcome in the event that one expert’s view of any particular matter is accepted over the other experts view;
d) a summary of argument in relation to any other financial relief which is sought including child support or spousal maintenance;
e) a minute of the Orders which he / she seeks be made at the final hearing if that is different from the response or application last filed by that party.
25.
That by 12.00 noon on Wednesday 16 November 2011 the independent children’s lawyer provide to each other party to the proceedings and to the email address …:-
a) a chronology of relevant events;
b) a minute of the orders which in the preliminary view of the independent children’s lawyer ought to be made at the final hearing;
c) a list of documents upon which the independent children’s lawyer intends to rely -
and the parents, through their legal practitioners or by themselves, cooperate with the independent children’s lawyer to ensure, to the extent that it is practicable to do so, that the information contained in the chronology is agreed to be accurate.
AND THE COURT NOTES that in the event a party fails or neglects to participate in the proceedings or to file any documents which he/she is required to file, the Court may proceed to determine finally the proceedings or any urgent applications arising therein (including any appropriate ex-parte applications) without further input by the non-participating party and without further notice to them.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.