Muir v Open Brethren

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read
96 CLR 166

MUIR AND OTHERS

APPELLANTS; PLAINTIFFS,

THE OPEN BRETHREN AND OTHERS

RESPONDENTS. DEFENDANTS,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF Charities-Gift to religious body for relief of need and distress " and in assisting

persons in indigent circumstances and in particular (but not exclusively or in any way that shall limit their discretion) in assisting or relieving persons who HOBART,

have been or shall be adversely affected by the effects of " the Second World War Mar. 14;

Construction-Validity. SYDNEY,

A testator bequeathed his residuary estate to a religious body " to be April 13.

employed by them in relieving cases of need and distress and in assisting persons in indigent circumstances and in particular (but not exclusively or in any way that shall limit their discretion) in assisting and relieving persons who have been or shall be adversely affected by the effects of" the Second

Held that the bequest was a valid charitable bequest. Decision of the Supreme Court of Tasmania (Gibson J.), affirmed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Tasmania.

Charles Edmond Button, late of Burnie, Tasmania died on 10th November 1945 leaving a will dated 25th June 1945 probate whereof was duly granted by the Supreme Court of Tasmania to the Equity Trustees Company of Tasmania Limited, Ewart Gladstone Button and Keith Stuart Button, the executors named therein. The testator gave the whole of his estate to his trustees upon trust to permit his wife to receive the income thereof for her life and from and after her death to convert the estate into money and to pay certain pecuniary legacies out of the proceeds and by cl. 2 (j) To pay the

96 CLR 167

balance (if any) of the said net proceeds into the funds of the Assembly or body of Christians commonly known as Open Brethren' meeting at the date of this my Will in the Gospel Hall Wilson Street Burnie aforesaid such sum to be employed by them in relieving cases of need and distress and in assisting persons in indigent circumstances and in particular (but not exclusively or in any way that shall limit their discretion) in assisting and relieving persons who have been or shall be adversely affected by the effects of the War in which the British Commonwealth of Nations is now engaged and I declare that the receipt or acknowledgement of not less than three of the Elder Brethren belonging to the said Assembly or body of Christians shall be a good discharge to my Trustees in respect of the said monies and I declare that any Brethren who are accustomed to regularly attend the business meetings of the said Assembly shall be deemed to be Elder Brethren' within the meaning of the said term SO used in my said Will."

By originating summons dated 24th May 1955 Ena Grace Muir, Edward Henry McClymont, David Charles McClymont, Margaret Rector, Alice Hacking Button, as executrix of the estate of Ewart Gladstone Button, deceased, and the National Executors and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Muir v Open Brethren and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1956] HCA 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a residuary bequest made by Charles Edmund Button in his will to the Open Brethren. The testator directed that the balance of his residuary estate be paid to the Open Brethren "to be employed by them in relieving cases of need and distress and in assisting persons in indigent circumstances and in particular (but not exclusively or in any way that shall limit their discretion) in assisting and relieving persons who have been or shall be adversely affected by the effects of the War". The plaintiffs, who would benefit from an intestacy, challenged the validity of this bequest, arguing that it failed to establish a valid charitable purpose. The matter was heard by Gibson J. in the Supreme Court of Tasmania, who found the bequest to be valid, and the plaintiffs appealed to the High Court of Australia.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the bequest constituted a valid charitable trust. Specifically, the court had to determine if the provision for assisting persons adversely affected by the war, when read in conjunction with the preceding phrases concerning the relief of need, distress, and indigence, created a valid charitable purpose or if it introduced a non-charitable purpose, thereby rendering the entire bequest void. The appellants contended that the phrase "adversely affected by the effects of the War" introduced a potentially non-charitable purpose that was inseverable from the charitable elements.

The High Court, in dismissing the appeal, reasoned that the phrase "in particular" indicated that the subsequent clause was intended as a specific example or a preferred class within the broader charitable purpose of relieving poverty. The court noted the tautology in the earlier parts of the clause, referring to "need," "distress," and "indigent circumstances," all pointing towards the alleviation of necessitous circumstances. The inclusion of the bracketed phrase "but not exclusively or in any way that shall limit their discretion" was interpreted as an attempt by the testator to ensure that the specific example did not unduly restrict the general charitable intent. Therefore, the court concluded that the bequest was a valid charitable trust for the relief of poverty, with a specific emphasis on those affected by the war, and not a mixed trust for charitable and non-charitable purposes.

The High Court affirmed the decision of the Supreme Court of Tasmania and ordered that the appeal be dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.