Mueller and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

Mueller and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 23 (16 January 2024)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):2022/6840      

Re:Mueller  

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:The Hon Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

Date:16 January 2024

Place:Sydney

Pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c)(ii) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the Chief Executive Officer of the National Disability Insurance Agency in accordance with the following direction:

a) The decision under review is varied to provide 1:1 SIL funding for a period of seven months, during which time the Applicant’s capacity to live with a co-resident is to be reviewed.
b) The Applicant’s SIL provider be reimbursed for the difference between 1:1 SIL and 1: 2 SIL support provided between 8 September 2022 and 9 November 2023 at the standard intensity rate applying at the time.

....................[SGD]...............................................

The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME - reasonable and necessary supports - supports for participant rules - value for money - harm to the participant and risk to others - reimbursement - behaviours of concern - shared accommodation - independence - functional capacity - decision under review set aside and remitted with direction

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 43(1)(c)(ii)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) Act 2013 (Cth) ss 33, 34, 46, 53

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

CASES

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Mazy and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 3099

SECONDARY MATERIALS

National Disability Insurance Agency, Our Guidelines – Including Specific Types of Supports in Plans Operational Guidelines (Web Page) < align="left">NDIS Pricing Arrangements and Price Limits 2023-24 (previously published as the NDIS Price Guide)

NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission, NDIS Practice Standards: skills descriptors (Web Page) < FOR DECISION

The Honourable Pru Goward AO, Senior Member

16 January 2024

INTRODUCTION

  1. Ryan Muller (the Applicant) is a thirty-three-year-old man with a diagnosis of Cerebral Palsy, Intellectual Disability (Mild -Moderate), Epilepsy, as well as Generalised Anxiety Disorder, Major Depression Disorder and Dermatillomania.

  2. On 25 May 2022, the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Respondent) approved a statement of participant supports for the Applicant, the original decision, which reduced the total funded supports from $673,674.78 to $381,580.09 for the period 25 May 2022 to 25 May 2023. 

  3. After a request from the Applicant to review the original decision to include 24/7 1:1 Supported Independent Living (SIL) supports (made on 14 June 2022), the decision not to fund the requested support was confirmed on 16 August 2022.

  4. On 24 August 2022, the Applicant applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) for review of the internal review decision under s 103 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (the Act). Under S 42D of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act), the Tribunal remitted the decision to the Respondent for consideration on 22 May…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mueller and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a dispute between Mr Ralph Mueller, the applicant, and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) concerning the provision of Specialist Disability Accommodation (SDA) funding. The applicant, who has cerebral palsy and associated impairments including behaviours of concern, sought 24/7 one-to-one (1:1) Supported Independent Living (SIL) funding for a period of twelve months. The NDIA had proposed a reduction in this funding, suggesting 1:1 SIL for seven months, followed by a period of shared accommodation with a 1:2 support ratio for the remaining time.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine the appropriate duration for which 1:1 SIL funding constituted a "reasonable and necessary" support for the applicant, in accordance with the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) legislation. This involved assessing the applicant's functional capacity, the impact of his behaviours of concern, the effectiveness of past capacity-building supports, and the risks associated with shared accommodation, particularly in light of a failed trial. The Tribunal was required to balance the applicant's need for independence and safety against the NDIS's requirement for value for money and the potential for harm to the participant or others.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the applicant's significant and ongoing behaviours of concern, including faecal and urination practices, aggression, and self-harm threats, which had previously led to a failed trial of shared accommodation. Evidence indicated a decline in the applicant's functional capacity and a history of resistance to capacity-building supports. Considering these factors, the Tribunal concluded that 1:1 SIL support was reasonable and necessary for the full duration of the plan, with a review of his capacity to live with a co-resident to occur after seven months. The Tribunal also ordered reimbursement to the applicant's SIL provider for the difference between the 1:1 and 1:2 SIL funding provided during a specified period.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant relies upon section 39 of the Act to determine whether the disputed support be paid from the time of the original decision viz:The Agency must comply with the statement of participant supports in a participant’s plan.BACKGROUND The Applicant has a range of impairments arising from his primary disability of cerebral palsy, including intellectual impairment, anxiety and depressive disorders. However, it is his behaviours of concern, including faecal and urination practices and incontinence; dermatillomania; and others such as aggression, a compulsion to play X Box games, threats of self-harm and sexualised advances, which are central to the Applicant’s request for sole occupancy supported living. The Applicant is also morbidly obese and struggles with his mobility contribute to the general difficulties he has in his everyday life. Additionally, his support workers and therapists agreed that his oral communication is poor but occasionally misleads the listener into believing his comprehension is greater than it is in reality. The Applicant has lived alone with 1:1 SILS 24/7 since 2021 and requires significant assistance from support workers. His family consider his functionality has declined in the past few years and he is more dependent on others for everyday needs than he once was. His supervising Occupational Therapist (OT), Ruth Howell, also confirmed that his functionality had declined since 2018; his unwillingness to engage in community activities and his independence with self-care have both reduced, while his behaviours of concern appear to have increased in recent years. Although the Applicant has a Behaviour Support Plan to assist him in managing his behaviours of concern, the shortage of therapists in his hometown in regional New South Wales, the impact of Covid and his reluctance to engage with therapists have made it difficult to provide him with his recommended capacity building supports. His preference for playing on his Xbox, on one occasion for days without sleep, has also limited the time available to develop his capacities. The Applicant had not seen his psychiatrist in over two years and had also ceased receiving treatment from his psychologist two years ago. From August-December 2022, his SILS provider, Chrysalis, planned and then provided a program, a detox program, to reduce the Applicant’s reliance on anti-psychotic medication, Risperidone. The detox program ran from 12 September 2022 until 7 December 2022. The Tribunal notes anti-psychotic medication is a chemical restraint and accordingly, his support provider considered it desirable that the level be reduced, which was achieved. In January 2023, sometime after the Respondent had affirmed its decision to reduce the Applicant’s SILS funding from 1:1 support to 1:2 support, Chrysalis commenced a trial of shared accommodation in the Applicant’s home with another client of their service. Several witnesses confirmed that the trial of shared accommodation had been a failure and the trial was abandoned after 9 days following verbal and physical altercations with the other occupant and both residents threatening self-harm and harm to one another.CONTENTIONS

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal has had regard to various material before it, including:a)Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions filed 16 August 2023b)Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions filed 27 September 2023c)Respondent’s reply to Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions filed on 17 November 2023 d)Joint Hearing Tender Bundle filed by Respondent on 22 November 2023 (includes T-Documents filed on 29 August 2022ORAL EVIDENCE The Tribunal heard oral evidence from the following witnesses:a)Mr Ralph Mueller, Applicant’s fatherb)Ms Tanya Denny, Director of Chrysalis Accommodationc)Ms Katherine Savidis, Behaviour Support Practitionerd)Ms Ruth Howell, Occupational Therapiste)Ms Basia Kmita, Occupational Therapist CONSIDERATIONS1:1 SIL Support for which period The Tribunal was asked to decide whether the Applicant should be provided with 1:1 SIL support 24/7 for seven months, during which time a review of the Applicant’s progress is to be made (Respondent’s proposal), or whether the provision of 1:1 SIL support, 24/7, for twelve months (Applicant’s proposal), is the correct or preferable decision. That is, for which period is the SIL funding a reasonable and necessary support. For the remaining five months of the Applicant’s plan, the Respondent proposed the Applicant would continue to receive 1:1 SIL support for two hours daily but be expected to share SIL support at a ratio of 1:2 people for the remaining time each day, with inactive overnight support, 24/7. That is, the Applicant would be expected to share his accommodation with a co-resident. The Tribunal heard from several witnesses who confirmed that the Applicant had received only limited capacity building supports over the past two years and that it would take some time to re-engage with his psychologist and establish rapport with a new psychiatrist. Further, that the Applicant had resisted many capacity building supports in the past, such as physiotherapy and occupational therapy, and declined to answer calls from therapists attempting to see him. Walking the OT assistant’s dog was one of the few exceptions to this; being prepared to go to the toilet regularly, when instructed, was another. The Applicant’s behaviours of concern were another issue; he was known to defecate when asked to do something he did not want to do, his father describing this as:“sometimes he will do it deliberately in front of somebody just in spite”. The Applicant’s father also told the Tribunal this incontinence began in 2017/8, when he was about 27 years old. It appears, from the evidence, to be a combination of physical incontinence and a behaviour of concern. Witnesses described the Applicant as becoming angry and aggressive with staff if he was not able to play his X Box continuously. The Applicant’s skin picking, defecation and urination also consumed much of the support staff’s time, so that they were not always able to help with capacity building tasks set by therapists.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal concludes that the provision of 1:1 SIL 24/7 was a reasonable and necessary support for the duration of the plan commencing 25 May 2022 and accordingly that the Applicant’s provider is entitled to reimbursement of the difference between 1:1 SIL and the 1:2 SIL funding provided by the Respondent from the 12 September 2022, standard intensity, to 9 November 2023 at the prices applying at the time.DECISION Pursuant to subsection 43(1)(c)(ii) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the Chief Executive Officer of the National Disability Insurance Agency in accordance with the following direction: a)The decision under review is varied to provide 1:1 SIL funding for a period of seven months, during which time the Applicant’s capacity to live with a co-resident is to be reviewed. b)The Applicant’s SIL provider be reimbursed for the difference between 1:1 SIL and 1:2 SIL support provided between 8 September 2022 and 9 November 2023 at the standard intensity rate prices applying at the time.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal heard oral evidence from the following witnesses:a)Mr Ralph Mueller, Applicant’s fatherb)Ms Tanya Denny, Director of Chrysalis Accommodationc)Ms Katherine Savidis, Behaviour Support Practitionerd)Ms Ruth Howell, Occupational Therapiste)Ms Basia Kmita, Occupational Therapist CONSIDERATIONS1:1 SIL Support for which period The Tribunal was asked to decide whether the Applicant should be provided with 1:1 SIL support 24/7 for seven months, during which time a review of the Applicant’s progress is to be made (Respondent’s proposal), or whether the provision of 1:1 SIL support, 24/7, for twelve months (Applicant’s proposal), is the correct or preferable decision. That is, for which period is the SIL funding a reasonable and necessary support. For the remaining five months of the Applicant’s plan, the Respondent proposed the Applicant would continue to receive 1:1 SIL support for two hours daily but be expected to share SIL support at a ratio of 1:2 people for the remaining time each day, with inactive overnight support, 24/7. That is, the Applicant would be expected to share his accommodation with a co-resident. The Tribunal heard from several witnesses who confirmed that the Applicant had received only limited capacity building supports over the past two years and that it would take some time to re-engage with his psychologist and establish rapport with a new psychiatrist. Further, that the Applicant had resisted many capacity building supports in the past, such as physiotherapy and occupational therapy, and declined to answer calls from therapists attempting to see him. Walking the OT assistant’s dog was one of the few exceptions to this; being prepared to go to the toilet regularly, when instructed, was another. The Applicant’s behaviours of concern were another issue; he was known to defecate when asked to do something he did not want to do, his father describing this as:“sometimes he will do it deliberately in front of somebody just in spite”. The Applicant’s father also told the Tribunal this incontinence began in 2017/8, when he was about 27 years old. It appears, from the evidence, to be a combination of physical incontinence and a behaviour of concern. Witnesses described the Applicant as becoming angry and aggressive with staff if he was not able to play his X Box continuously. The Applicant’s skin picking, defecation and urination also consumed much of the support staff’s time, so that they were not always able to help with capacity building tasks set by therapists. Tanya Denny, the Director of Chrysalis Accommodation and Clinical Director for Chrysalis Therapeutic Support Services, which provides SIL support to the Applicant, considered his defecation and urination incontinence and behaviours of concern were an ongoing problem:Other participants in our SIL programs sometimes are affected by how [the Applicant] might smell or, you know, they notice. People notice. And because sometimes [the Applicant] doesn’t, and he gets quite angry if it’s pointed out to him that his soiling might be affecting other people.