Mudiy v Minister for Home Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Mudiy v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] FedCFamC2G 346

File number(s): MLG 389 of 2018
Judgment of: DEPUTY CHIEF JUDGE MERCURI
Date of judgment: 13 May 2022 
Catchwords: MIGRATION – application for judicial review – decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal – Partner (Residence) Visa – allegations of family violence committed by sponsoring partner – consideration of whether the Tribunal failed to provide the applicant with a meaningful opportunity to obtain and produce evidence, and in failing to do so, acted unreasonably – circumstances distinguished from Minister for Immigration v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332 – no jurisdictional error established – application dismissed with costs.
Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 360

Migration Regulations 1994, regs 1.22, 1.23, 1.24, 1.25, div 1.5, sch 2, cl 801.221

Cases cited: Minister for Immigration v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332
Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 90
Date of last submission/s: 4 November 2021
Date of hearing: 4 November 2021
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Dr McBeth
Solicitors for the Applicant: Clothier Anderson & Associates
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr Tran
Solicitors for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

MLG 389 of 2018

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

NISHANTHA MAHAKUMBURA HERATH MUDIY
Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS
First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

DEPUTY CHIEF JUDGE MERCURI

DATE OF ORDER:

13 MAY 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant’s application be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the first respondent’s costs in a sum to be fixed if not agreed.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

DEPUTY CHIEF JUDGE MERCURI:

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application for judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) dated 10 January 2018 to affirm the decision of a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs (‘the Minister’) to refuse to grant the applicant a Partner (Residence) Visa (‘permanent partner visa’).

  2. The applicant’s application was filed outside the statutory timeframe and, consequently, the applicant sought an extension of time.[1]  The first respondent ultimately conceded that the extension of time ought to be granted, therefore that issue was no longer live before this court.[2]

    [1] Applicant’s Amended Application filed 7 October 2021.

    [2] First Respondent’s written submissions filed 21 October 2021 at paragraph [2].

  3. By his amended application filed on 7 October 2021, the applicant raises one ground of review:

    The failure of the Tribunal to adjourn the proceeding to provide a meaningful opportunity for the applicant to obtain…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mudiy v Minister for Home Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FedCFamC2G 346
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Mudiy v Minister for Home Affairs, the applicant, Mudiy, challenged the refusal of his application for a permanent partner visa, asserting that the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) unreasonably failed to adjourn the proceeding to provide him with an opportunity to obtain and present necessary evidence of family violence. Mudiy argued that the AAT's refusal to adjourn the proceeding prevented him from providing adequate evidence, thereby affecting the decision's fairness and reasonableness.

The central legal issue in this case was whether the AAT's refusal to adjourn the proceeding to allow Mudiy additional time to obtain and present the required evidence of family violence was unreasonable. Specifically, the court had to determine if this refusal constituted a jurisdictional error that affected the AAT's decision. The court also considered whether the evidence provided by Mudiy was sufficient to establish a non-judicially determined family violence claim under the relevant regulations.

The court found that the AAT's refusal to adjourn the proceeding was not unreasonable. The court reasoned that Mudiy had not provided evidence in the appropriate form as required by regulation 1.24. Moreover, Mudiy's representative conceded that the psychologist's report did not state that Mudiy had suffered family violence and had not been particularly helpful in providing the necessary information. The court concluded that the AAT had correctly found that no valid non-judicially determined family violence claim had been made by Mudiy, and therefore, the AAT had no valid claim to consider.

As a result, the court dismissed Mudiy's application, holding that the AAT's decision was not affected by jurisdictional error. The court also awarded costs to the Minister for Home Affairs as Mudiy made no submissions opposing the costs order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

By his amended application filed on 7 October 2021, the applicant raises one ground of review:The failure of the Tribunal to adjourn the proceeding to provide a meaningful opportunity for the applicant to obtain and provide the necessary evidence was unreasonable in the circumstances.BACKGROUND Before addressing the applicant’s submissions and the Minster’s response to this ground, I will set out the factual and procedural background which is not largely in dispute. On 5 June 2013, the applicant applied for a permanent partner visa.[3] He and his then sponsor were married on 23 March 2013. It is common ground that the applicant’s relationship with his then sponsor broke down in or about September 2015. The applicant was then advised on 5 October 2015 that the sponsorship for his visa application had been withdrawn. The applicant was provided with a further opportunity to provide additional information. [4][3] Court book at page 15.[4] Court book at pages 92 to 94. By letter from his migration agent dated 23 October 2015, the applicant confirmed that the relationship had broken down and further stated that he had suffered family violence perpetrated by his former sponsor.[5] Relevantly, correspondence from his then representative, dated 23 October 2015, contained the following statement:Mr Mudiy has been subjected to domestic family violence as his wife had abused him throughout the relationship with the support of his mother in law who has also encouraged his wife. … Additionally due to the abuse he has suffered, he has suffered severe anxiety and depression as outlined by Dr Mendis in the attached report.[5] Court book at pages 92 and 101. Attached to this letter is a letter from Dr Mendis, which relevantly provides that the applicant has been his patient since February 2013.[6] In his letter, Dr Mendis refers to the applicant’s marriage and goes on to say ‘… his partner has requested him to leave the house and does not wish to continue with the marriage. He has been having severe anxiety and depression due to separation, which has come as a surprise for him. …’[6] Court book at page 104. On 11 November 2015, the applicant’s representative provided further information to the delegate, including a report from the applicant’s psychologist dated 9 November 2015 and a statutory declaration from the applicant regarding his family violence allegations.[7][7] Court book at pages 105 to 106.Requests for further information on 8 January 2016 and 9 May 2016 By letter dated 8 January 2016, the delegate requested further information from the applicant. Relevantly, in this correspondence, the delegate stated:The items submitted to advance your family violence claims do not meet the minimum evidentiary requirements for a family violence claim. The applicant was requested to provide this information in the appropriate form. A further request was made for this information by letter dated 9 May 2016.[8] It appears that no response was provided to these requests. I note that in the course of the hearing, the applicant complained that his previous solicitor had not appropriately represented his interest. I take it from this that this might explain the lack of response to the specific requests for further information about the applicant’s claims relating to family violence in the period between January and May 2016.[8] Court book at page 276.Refusal of partner visa application on 23 June 2016

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Regulation 1.23 also provides for certain circumstances in which family violence is said to have occurred where there has been no judicial determination of such violence. Relevantly, for the present purposes, at regulation 1.23(9), the regulations provide:(9)For these Regulations, an application for a visa is taken to include a non-judicially determined claim of family violence if:(a)the applicant seeks to satisfy a prescribed criterion that the applicant, or another person mentioned in the criterion, has suffered family violence; and(b) the alleged victim is:(i) the spouse or de facto partner of the alleged perpetrator: …(ii) …(iii) … and(c)the alleged victim or another person on the alleged victim’s behalf has presented evidence in accordance with regulation 1.24 that:(i) the alleged victim has suffered family violence; and(ii)the alleged perpetrator committed that relevant family violence. (emphasis added) The remainder of regulation 1.23 goes on to specify how the Minister is to consider evidence of non-judicially determined family violence. Those provisions are not relevant for the purposes of this application. Regulation 1.24, however, goes on to relevantly state:The evidence mentioned in paragraph 1.23(9)(c) is:(a)a statutory declaration under regulation 1.25 (which deals with statutory declarations by or on behalf of alleged victims); and(b)the type and number of items of evidence specified by the Minister by instrument in writing for this paragraph. The relevant instrument was IMMI 12/116.[20] That instrument specifies that two pieces of evidence were required of a type set out in the left hand column of the table in schedule 1 and containing details set out in the right hand column of that table.[20] Court book at pages 296 to 297. The evidence that the applicant relied upon in support of his application was:·a statutory declaration of the applicant;[21]·a letter from his psychologist;[22] and·a report from the applicant’s medical practitioner (at page 104 of the Court Book and updated at page 457 of the Court Book).[21] Court book at pages 111 to 116.[22] Court book at pages 109 to 110. It is common ground and not in dispute that the applicant provided a statutory declaration that complied with regulation 1.25, and by implication, regulation 1.24(a). It is also not in dispute that the applicant has not provided evidence in a form which would satisfy regulation 1.24(b). The issue for determination in this proceeding is whether, by not agreeing to an extended adjournment, the Tribunal failed to provide the applicant with a meaningful opportunity to obtain and produce evidence of the type and in a form to satisfy regulation 1.24, and therefore, acted unreasonably such that its decision was affected by jurisdictional error.APPLICANT’S CLAIMS OF FAMILY VIOLENCEEvidence of the applicant In his statutory declaration, the applicant refers to his former wife making offensive, belittling and derogatory statements to and about him, in particular, denigrating him because of his lack of income earning capacity. The applicant also refers to his former wife engaging in conduct which could be described as financially abusive and asserts that his former mother in law also engaged in belittling comments about and towards him, as well as encouraging the wife’s abusive conduct towards him.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For each of these reasons, the applicant’s sole ground of review is not made out.CONCLUSION The first respondent sought costs. No submissions were made by the applicant that costs should not follow if the application were dismissed. I therefore dismiss the applicant’s application with costs to be fixed if not agreed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ultimately, Gageler J also concluded that the Tribunal acted in a legally unreasonable manner, and consequently, its decision was affected by jurisdictional error.CONSIDERATION I have extracted various aspects of the judgment from Li in some detail given the reliance placed on it by the applicant in this case. Unlike Li, in this case, no coherent reason was given for the adjournment request. Rather, and leaving aside the form of the letter not being contained in a statutory declaration, the applicant’s representative herself conceded on a number of occasions that the report prepared by the applicant’s psychologist did not itself refer to the applicant having suffered domestic violence. At its highest, the applicant’s representative indicated that if more time was provided, she might be able to arrange an alternative psychologist who might be able to provide the necessary information. It is clear from the submissions made by the applicant’s representative that:(a)the information contained in the report from the applicant’s psychologist, Ms Bartlett, was not only not in a compliant form (i.e. a statutory declaration) but it did not itself state that the applicant had suffered family violence;(b)attempts had been made to get more information from Ms Bartlett, but ‘she had not been particularly helpful’; and(c)insofar as a request was made to have more time to seek an opinion from another expert psychologist or psychiatrist, there was no evidence given about steps taken to secure any such second opinion. In considering whether the refusal by the member to allow additional time for the applicant to either obtain a second opinion or to seek further information in the requisite form from Ms Bartlett was unreasonable, regard must be had to the statutory task before the Tribunal member. At this stage of the proceeding, the Tribunal member had to consider whether the applicant had produced evidence in the requisite form that might establish that he had been subjected to family violence at the hands of his former wife. In circumstances where the applicant, through his representative, conceded that he had not provided the necessary documents which might give rise to a finding of family violence, the issue is whether the Tribunal acted unreasonably in refusing additional time to allow the applicant to obtain such evidence in the appropriate form. Ultimately, the Tribunal in its decision record found that in circumstances where neither the letter from the applicant’s treating doctor nor the letter from the applicant’s treating psychologist met the evidentiary requirements of the regulation, ‘a valid non-judicially determined family violence claim has not been made by the applicant’.[36] The Tribunal went on to therefore find that as there was no evidence of family violence in accordance with regulation 1.23, the ‘Tribunal has no valid claim to consider’.[37][36] AAT decision record dated 10 January 2018 at paragraph [15].[37] AAT decision record dated 10 January 2018 at paragraph [16].