Ms Yik Tung (Christy) Tsui v Altara Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read
[2023] FWC 1443

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Ms Yik Tung (Christy) Tsui
v

Altara Group Pty Ltd

(U2023/2205)

COMMISSIONER JOHNS

MELBOURNE, 25 JULY 2023

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – whether dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy – application dismissed

Introduction

  1. On 16 March 2023, Ms Yik Tung (Christy) Tsui (Applicant), made an application to the Fair Work Commission (Commission) pursuant to s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) for an order granting a remedy, alleging that she has been unfairly dismissed from her employment with Altara Group Pty Ltd (Respondent).

  1. On 30 March 2023, the Respondent filed its response to the application. It raised a jurisdictional objection contenting that the dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy.

  1. Attempts to conciliate the matter were unsuccessful. Accordingly, on 28 April 2023 I issued Directions and scheduled the matter for a determinative conference.

The proceedings

  1. The determinative conference was conducted by Video using Microsoft Teams on 20 June 2023. 

  1. In advance of the determinative conference the parties filed materials which were compiled in a Digital Tribunal Book (DTB). For completeness I set out below the documents relied upon by the parties. I have had regard to all these materials in coming to this decision:

Exhibit Document title Document date
1 Form F2 16-03-2023
2 Form F3 30-03-2023
3 The Respondent's material 10-05-2023
3.1 Outline of arguments: objections 10-05-2023
3.1.1 •   Attachment 1- Position Description General Manager Finance Undated
3.1.2 •   Attachment 2 - Position Description Senior Management Accountant Undated
3.2 Statement of evidence 10-05-2023
3.3 Outline of arguments: Merits 10-05-2023
4 The Applicant's material 26-05-2023
4.1 Outline of arguments: objections 26-05-2023
4.2 Statement of evidence 26-05-2023
4.3 Outline of arguments: merits 26-05-2023
4.4 Letter of Redundancy 27-02-2023
4.5 Letter of Service 27-02-2023
4.6 Payslip 31-12-2022
4.7 Employment Contract 05-07-2022
5 The Respondent's reply material 05-06-2023
5.1 Reply submissions 05-06-2023
6 The Applicant’s CV Undated
7 The CV of the successful candidate Undated
  1. During the determinative conference, I requested that the Respondent produce the CVs of each of the Applicant and the person who was successful in attaining the new position of General Manager of Finance. Accordingly, these materials were added as exhibits 6 and 7 respectively.[1]

  1. During the determinative conference, additional oral evidence was provided by the Applicant and the Respondent’s Chief Executive Officer, Mr Clive Callaway. I have had regard to all of the evidence in coming to this decision.

Factual findings

  1. The following matters were either agreed between the parties or not substantially contested. Consequently, I make the following findings of fact based on the evidence:

a)Up until mid-2022 the Respondent employed as part of its senior management structure the position of General Manager of Finance (GM Finance).[2]

b)The GM Finance resigned in around May 2022.[3]

c)After the resignation the Respondent undertook a review of its operational requirements.  It decided to downgrade…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ms Yik Tung (Christy) Tsui v Altara Group Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FWC 1443
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ms Yik Tung (Christy) Tsui v Altara Group Pty Ltd, heard by Commissioner Johns of the Fair Work Commission, addresses an application for an unfair dismissal remedy under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009. Ms Tsui alleged unfair dismissal from her position as Senior Management Accountant with Altara Group Pty Ltd, which she held from July 2022 until her dismissal in February 2023. The Respondent contested the application on the basis that the dismissal was a genuine redundancy. The primary issue before the Commission was whether the dismissal of Ms Tsui was a case of genuine redundancy under s.389 of the Fair Work Act, which would exempt the dismissal from being considered unfair.

In determining whether the dismissal was a genuine redundancy, the Commission considered three essential elements: whether the Respondent no longer required the Applicant’s job to be performed by anyone due to operational changes, whether the Respondent complied with any consultation obligations, and whether it would have been reasonable in all circumstances to redeploy the Applicant. The Commission found that the role of Senior Management Accountant no longer existed due to operational changes resulting from the Respondent’s review of its business structure and the decision to re-introduce the position of General Manager of Finance. The Commission further found that the Respondent had not failed to consult as no such obligation applied, and that it was not reasonable to redeploy the Applicant given her visa restrictions and the nature of the new role.

The Commission concluded that the dismissal was a case of genuine redundancy, as the role of Senior Management Accountant ceased to exist due to operational changes, consultation obligations did not apply, and redeployment was not feasible. Accordingly, the application for an unfair dismissal remedy was dismissed. The Commission did not find the dismissal to be unfair as it met the criteria for genuine redundancy.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established