| [2016] FWCFB 5018 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.604 - Appeal of decisions
v
Dr Elizabeth Varughese; Eve O & G T/A Doctor Elizabeth Varughese
(C2016/3474)
SENIOR DEPUTY PRESIDENT DRAKE | SYDNEY, 28 JULY 2016 |
Appeal against decision [2016] FWC 1861 of Deputy President Sams at Sydney on 14 April 2016 in matter number U2015/9370.
Introduction
[1] This decision concerns an appeal against the Decision 1 of Deputy President Sams dated 14 April 2016. The Decision arose from an application for an unfair dismissal remedy pursuant to s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act) lodged by Ms Christine Cox on 14 July 2015.
[2] Deputy President Sams found that the respondent, a small business, believed on reasonable grounds that Ms Cox had misappropriated money from its practice. On the basis of that finding the Deputy President concluded that the dismissal of Ms Cox from its employment was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable. He dismissed the application.
Background
[3] The background to this application was extensively summarised by Deputy President Sams. We consider that it is only necessary to confirm that Ms Cox was employed in a medical practice conducted by an obstetrician, Dr Elizabeth Varaghese. Ms Cox’s employment was terminated for serious misconduct arising from the respondent’s belief that Ms Cox was stealing from her practice.
Grounds of Appeal
[4] Ms Cox filed a Notice of Appeal and a Form of Submissions.
[5] The permission to appeal hearing was listed at 9:30 am on 15 June 2016. Ms Cox had some difficulty with the video link listing. Following the permission to appeal hearing Ms Cox was given an opportunity to provide a further Response and was provided with the transcript of proceedings to assist her. Her further response was received on 14 July 2016.
[6] In summary Ms Cox submitted that thedecision of Deputy President Sams:
● Incorrectly applied Pinawin v Domingo 2 (Pinawin) regarding whether or not the employer held a belief on reasonable grounds. She submitted that the circumstances in Pinawin are distinguishable from her application. In this case, the appellant and the respondent had a falling out of sorts before the allegations of serious misconduct were raised. Pinawin states that it is necessary for the employee to be provided with an opportunity to respond, whereas in Deputy President Sams decision he stated only that it would have been preferable. This issue is in the public interest because Pinawin is the leading case on the application of the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code regarding serious misconduct.
● Reversed the onus concerning whether the employer held a belief.
● In its entirety is plainly unreasonable and unjust.
[7] Ms Cox identified errors of fact in the Decision at transcript paragraph numbers 26 to 56 which included those identified in her Notice of Appeal and written submissions. In summary those were chiefly as follows:
● The decision was incorrect in asserting that the applicant did not…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mrs Christine Cox v Dr Elizabeth Varughese and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] FWCFB 5018
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that were central to the decision involved whether the dismissal of Mrs Cox was harsh, unjust or unreasonable, as per section 385(d) of the Fair Work Act 2009. The court had to consider the proportionality of the penalty of dismissal against the offence, the availability of alternative sanctions, and whether there was a failure to consider relevant factors that mitigated against dismissal. Another issue was whether there was a genuine belief by Dr Varughese that the dismissal was necessary, and whether there was an appropriate process that was followed.
The court reasoned that the dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable. It found that Dr Varughese had a genuine belief that dismissal was necessary to preserve the reputation and integrity of the organisation. The court also found that the process followed was appropriate and that there were no significant mitigating factors that should have led to a lesser penalty. The court held that the decision to dismiss was proportionate and there were no alternative sanctions that would have been as effective. The appeal was dismissed, and the decision of Deputy President Sams was affirmed.
There were no additional orders made by the court. The decision of the Fair Work Commission was upheld, and the appeal was dismissed in its entirety.