MRLH and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

MRLH and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2020] AATA 4727 (26 November 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/6908

Re:MRLH

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndYTSS

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Ms A E Burke AO, Member

Date:26 November 2020

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

…………….[sgd]………………

Ms A E Burke AO, Member

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – whether interim care period applies – where family court order regarding care of child in force – child refusing to participate in contact – whether reasonable action to ensure compliance with care arrangement was taken – whether special circumstances existed – commencement of an interim care period – decision under review affirmed

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth)

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth)

Cases

Confidential and Social Security Appeals Tribunal and Anor [2010] AATA 1.

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No. 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Secondary Materials

Australian Government, Family Assistance Guide, Version 1.202 (20 March 2018)
Australian Government, Child Support Guide, Version 4.31 (3 April 2018)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms A E Burke AO, Member

INTRODUCTION

  1. MRLH is seeking a second-tier review of the care determination of the Child Support Registrar (the Registrar) that from 30 December 2018 he had 0% care of his child.

  2. The application was heard on 29 September 2020 by telephone. MRLH and the other party, YTSS were respectively self-represented. Ms Maleah Underhill, a seconded lawyer in the Freedom of Information and Litigation Team, Department of Human Services appeared for the respondent, the Registrar.

    BACKGROUND

  3. MRLH and YTSS are parents of a child now aged 17. On 13 June 2013 Court Orders were made which provided that the child have regular contact with both parents. The parties have always accepted the Registrar’s assessment of the percentage of care as being 33% to MRLH and 67% to YTSS.

  4. On 10 January 2019 an Interim Intervention Order was made in the Warrnambool Magistrates’ Court against MRLH.  The Order prohibited him from committing family violence, contacting or communicating, approaching or remaining within 5 meters; and/or to go within or remain within 50 meters of the home of his child. The order provided MRLH may:

    (a)do anything that is permitted by a Family Law Act order, a child protection order or a written agreement about child arrangements; or

    (b)communicate with a protected person through a lawyer or mediator; or

    (c)arrange and/or participate in counselling or mediation: BUT ONLY IF the respondent does not commit family violence while doing so.

  5. On 20 March 2019 MRLH was advised by the Registrar that his child support percentage had been updated to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MRLH and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 4727
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a review of a Child Support Registrar's decision regarding the care percentage of a child between the parents, MRLH and YTSS. The dispute arose after YTSS reported a change in care arrangements, claiming 100% care of their now 17-year-old child from 30 December 2018, leading the Registrar to update MRLH's care percentage to 0%. MRLH objected, asserting that YTSS was withholding care and that prior care arrangements were in accordance with court orders from 13 June 2013. The Registrar initially disallowed MRLH's objection, finding that while MRLH had taken reasonable steps to ensure compliance with the court-ordered care, special circumstances existed that warranted an immediate assessment based on actual care, without an interim period.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether an interim care period should apply, whether MRLH had taken reasonable action to ensure compliance with the care arrangements, and whether special circumstances existed that justified departing from the court-ordered care percentage. The Tribunal was required to consider the evidence presented, including an interim intervention order against MRLH, a police statement from the child, and a victim impact statement, to determine if there was a substantial risk to the child's well-being if the previous care arrangement continued. The Tribunal also had to consider whether the cessation of the intervention order and the non-pursuit of charges by the police altered the assessment of special circumstances.

The Tribunal reasoned that the Assessment Act does not permit the determination of an interim period after the event. It found that on 30 December 2018, when the care arrangements ceased, there was sufficient evidence, including the child's police statement and an intervention order, to suggest MRLH posed a risk to his child, thus warranting the refusal of an interim care determination. Although the Tribunal noted that the child was 15 at the time of the statement and that the intervention order had concluded and charges were not pursued, it still considered that the risk was present for the maximum period of 26 weeks. The Tribunal concluded that MRLH had taken reasonable steps to ensure compliance with the court orders, but the existence of special circumstances at the time of the care change meant no interim period should apply.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, finding no basis to determine a later interim care period.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The application was heard on 29 September 2020 by telephone. MRLH and the other party, YTSS were respectively self-represented. Ms Maleah Underhill, a seconded lawyer in the Freedom of Information and Litigation Team, Department of Human Services appeared for the respondent, the Registrar. BACKGROUND MRLH and YTSS are parents of a child now aged 17. On 13 June 2013 Court Orders were made which provided that the child have regular contact with both parents. The parties have always accepted the Registrar’s assessment of the percentage of care as being 33% to MRLH and 67% to YTSS. On 10 January 2019 an Interim Intervention Order was made in the Warrnambool Magistrates’ Court against MRLH. The Order prohibited him from committing family violence, contacting or communicating, approaching or remaining within 5 meters; and/or to go within or remain within 50 meters of the home of his child. The order provided MRLH may:(a)do anything that is permitted by a Family Law Act order, a child protection order or a written agreement about child arrangements; or(b)communicate with a protected person through a lawyer or mediator; or(c)arrange and/or participate in counselling or mediation: BUT ONLY IF the respondent does not commit family violence while doing so. On 20 March 2019 MRLH was advised by the Registrar that his child support percentage had been updated to 0% based on advice received from YTSS on 21 January 2019 that their child had been in her care 100% of the time since 30 December 2018. On 20 March 2019 MRLH lodged an objection, with the Registrar, to the decision to change his care percentage to 0%. On 9 May 2019 an Intervention Order against MRLH, which he agreed without admission in the same terms as the Interim order, was made at the Warrnambool Magistrates’ Court which expired on 9 November 2019. On 6 June 2019 the Registrar advised MRLH they had disallowed his recent objection to the decision made on 20 March 2019 to reflect YTSS had 100% and he had 0%. The reason for the decision was as follows:REASONS FOR THE DECISIONYTSS reported a new care change in the care arrangements for the child on 21 January 2019 effective 30 December 2018.During our discussions with MRLH and YTSS, they have confirmed YTSS has full care of the child, however MRLH is stating YTSS is withholding care, and prior to this care was in accordance with court orders dated 13 June 2013.The child support assessment may continue to be based on the court ordered care dated 13 June 2013, during an interim period due to the care of the child being withheld from MRLH.In order for us to continue to reflect the parenting plan dated 13 June 2013, for an interim period, we must be satisfied that MRLH has taken reasonable steps to ensure that the court ordered care is complied with.In accordance with the correspondence provided by MRLH that consisted of an application and summons for an intervention order, the interim intervention order and the letter from his lawyers to initiate court proceedings, we are satisfied that he has taken reasonable steps to ensure the court ordered care dated 13 June 2013 is complied with.However, we have discretion to decide that in special circumstances, the percentage of care be immediately based on the actual care and no interim period will apply. Special circumstances may include circumstances that relate to the child directly as well as circumstances that relate to another individual, such as the person with increased care, to the extent that those circumstances also relate to the child. This discretion is only to be exercised in unusual cases, for example, where there is evidence of violence or other inappropriate behaviour by the person who has reduced care which led to the change in care. This recognises that if a person's own unreasonable or inappropriate actions are a significant cause for the care arrangement not being complied with, the person should not benefit from an interim period, even if they are seeking the return of the child.We will consider the individual circumstances that led to the change in care to determine whether the circumstances are a significant cause of the change in care, and whether there was a substantial risk to the physical, emotional or psychological well-being of the child if the care arrangement had continued to be followed.·A police report detailing violent behaviour towards a child or the person with increased care,·An intervention order preventing contact with the child or person with increased care, or·Statements from a medical or other relevant professional regarding assault or abuse of the child or person with increased care.With the evidence that has been supplied being the intervention order made by Victoria Police and the Victim Impact statement from the child, we are satisfied special circumstances exist and we have therefore determined not to apply an interim care decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The term “special circumstances” used in section 51(5) is not defined in the Act. The Guide, at 2.2.4, sets out special circumstances where an interim period does not apply and states: The Registrar has discretion to decide that in special circumstances, the percentage of care be immediately based on the actual care and no interim period will apply. Special circumstances may include circumstances that relate to the child directly as well as circumstances that relate to another individual, such as the person with increased care, to the extent that those circumstances also relate to the child. This discretion is only to be exercised in unusual cases, for example, where there is evidence of violence or other inappropriate behaviour by the person who has reduced care which led to the change in care. This recognises that if a person’s own unreasonable or inappropriate actions are a significant cause for the care arrangement not being complied with, the person should not benefit from an interim period, even if they are seeking the return of the child.The Registrar will consider the individual circumstances that led to the change in care to determine whether the circumstances are a significant cause of the change in care, and whether there was a substantial risk to the physical, emotional or psychological well-being of the child if the care arrangement had continued to be followed. Examples of unreasonable or inappropriate behaviour of the parent include:·violence towards the child,·exposing the child to family violence (within the meaning of section 4AB of the FL Act),·violence towards the person with increased care,·directly involving the child in a criminal act,·exposing the child to alcohol, drugs or substance abuse,·substantially failing to comply with legal schooling requirements, and/or·neglecting the child’s basic needs, such as withholding essential medical care from the child or disregarding their daily needs for food, shelter, hygiene etc.EVIDENCE The child’s statement to the Police at Stawell Police station on 31 December 2018 at 2:45am, which states (errors in the original):2.I am making this statement at Stawell Police station in the presence of my mother…..3.Both my parents have been separated for the last 16 years and i live with my mother while my dad lives at another address.4.On Friday the 28th of December 2018, my dad drove … and me from …. to halls gap to spend some time together over the school holidays.5. … and I go to the same school and we've been friends for over 10 years.6.We got there, dad had started to drink beer at around 6pm and everything was fine.7.On Saturday the 29th December 2018, at approximately 8pm at night, dad came into the bedroom yelling at me to clean up my bathroom because I left 2 towels on the bathroom floor. He was also upset that … and I had used up all the hot water. … was sitting on the bed at the time and she saw what happened.8.At the time, I was standing in the door way and dad grabbed me on the shoulder by the jumper and dragged me out of the bedroom and into the bath room. I told him at least twice to let me go but he wouldn't so I used my left hand and punched him in the middle of his chest. He did not feel a thing and didn't react to my punch, instead pulled me closer to him then raised his right fist over me as if to hit me. He paused for a moment, but he didn't hit me. I was wondering he was going to hit me or not but I didn't feel scared at the time but I was scared afterwards.9.Dad did not hit me at all. I do not have any bruises on me. He then told me to suck a cock and I went into my bedroom where ….was10.Tonight at around 8:45pm, dad got angry at …. and I because we did not cook the pizza correctly. Dad had been drinking again and called us cunts, dumb and told us to pull our heads in.11.I don't know the address of the place in Halls Gap where we had been staying because Dad never told us.12.Dad told us to get out of the house, to fuck off and we took out personal belongings and walked down the street and waited outside the police station.13.At around I0pm, 2 police officers came to the police station, picked us up and dropped us at the Stawell Police Station.14.I waited with … at the police station for my mum and … (step dad) to come,

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal finds the Assessment Act does not provide scope for a determination of an interim period to be made after the event. The Tribunal finds the care arrangements ceased on the 30 December 2018 and at the time there was sufficient evidence to consider MRLH posed a risk to his child to warrant not granting him an interim care determination regardless of the fact he was seeking to provide care to his child. The Tribunal determines, on the facts before it, that this risk was present for the maximum period of 26 weeks; and as such found there was no basis on which to determine a later interim care period.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

YTSS submitted during the hearing that MRLH should not be rewarded with the provision of an interim care order as he had caused great harm and stress to their child who had been struggling for some time but was now in a good space. YTSS contented that regardless of the fact the police had dropped their proceedings and the IVO was no longer in place, the child was still scared of MRLH and did not want to have anything to do with him. CONSIDERATION The Tribunal, based on all the evidence before it, considers that MRLH had been actively engaged in trying to recommence his pattern of care through numerous avenues including obtaining legal advice and seeking to undertake family mediation. The Tribunal also relied upon MRLH’s lawyers’ letter to the Registrar of 11 April 2019 which outlined avenues taken to facilitate recommencement of care:Our client has been seeking time with the child since time was unilaterally suspended by the mother. In the course of facilitating access he has consented to the child remaining in the mother's care for the duration of the summer holiday period from the 29th of December and for the suspension of the Family Law orders under s.68R of the Family law Act from the 21st of February to the 11th of April 2019. Our client has at all other times sought to have the child in his care pursuant to the orders and the mother has unilaterally withheld the child. The Tribunal finds that MRLH, in accordance with Section 51(1)(d) of the Assessment Act, had taken all reasonable action to ensure the care arrangement pursuant to the court orders were being complied with. The Tribunal finds YTSS, as the parent who has increased care of the child, had agreed to participate in family mediation in accordance with the policy guidelines. The Tribunal, based on the evidence before it, considers that at 30 December 2018 there were special circumstances which warranted the refusal of an interim care order. The Registrar based their determination not to grant an interim care order on the evidence as presented at the time of their decision, which comprised the child’s Police Statement, Victim Impact Statement and the IVO. Subsequently, the AAT1 relied upon this evidence and MRLH’s advice that he had recently been charged in respect of the incident at Halls Gap. The Tribunal considers that this evidence was sufficient for the Registrar and AAT1 to determine that there was a substantial risk to the physical, emotional and psychological well-being of the child if the care arrangement had continued to be followed. As the Tribunal is hearing the matter de novo, that is afresh, it must consider the factual evidence before it, which now includes evidence the Police did not pursue assault charges against MRLH, and the IVO has concluded. Given the child in question was 15 at the time she made the Police and Victim Impact statement, the Tribunal does not place significant weight on these documents. However, the Tribunal noted that the child consistently refers to being scared of MRLH whilst acknowledging he did not hit her.