Mr Ray Diamond v SSUT Pty Ltd T/A Bourbong Street Cellars

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read
[2015] FWC 816
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Mr Ray Diamond
v
SSUT Pty Ltd T/A Bourbong Street Cellars
(U2014/12440)

SENIOR DEPUTY PRESIDENT RICHARDS

BRISBANE, 11 FEBRUARY 2015

Application for relief from unfair dismissal - dismissal for performance - meaning of s.387(e) - warning and context

[1] This decision concerns an application by Mr Ray Diamond, who is seeking an unfair dismissal remedy under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (“the Act”) in relation to his dismissal by SSUT Pty Ltd T/A Bourbong Street Cellars (“the employer”), in Bundaberg.

[2] Mr Diamond had been employed as a Manager (Level 3 under the East End Hotel Certified Agreement 2002) in the Bourbong Cellars (one of a number of a bottle shops that operated remotely from the East End Hotel in Bundaberg) on a casual basis for a period of some eight months commencing from 15 December 2013. Mr Diamond's employment was terminated on 21 August 2014. Mr Diamond contended that over the course of his employment he would work approximately 50 hours per week.

[3] No point was taken on any issue in relation to the jurisdictional competence of the application.

[4] Mr Diamond was dismissed ostensibly for unsatisfactory performance in his role as manager in the bottle shop. The principal cause of concern in this respect was Mr Diamond’s alleged persistent inability, despite counselling, to maintain stock levels which caused the shop to underperform over time and led to other inefficiencies and disruptions.

[5] Mr Diamond, however, argues that he was “never formally informed that there was a serious issue with stock levels of the store” and that his dismissal was simply harsh, unjust and unreasonable.

[6] Mr Diamond did give evidence that on 21 August 2014 he was approached by Mr Andrew Vollmerhause, who is a retail manager of the business, along with a co-manager, Mr David Courtice.

[7] In summary, he recalled the conversation as comprising the following points:

  • Frank Venturi, the owner and director of the employer, had indicated to Mr Andrew Vollmerhause and Mr David Courtice some six weeks prior that owing to the poor sales at the bottle shop he would be closing the shop (as the lease was up for renewal);


  • Mr Vollmerhause and Mr David Courtice had urged Mr Venturi to maintain the business. Mr Venturi acceded to their request;


  • Mr Venturi had requested that Mr Diamond be dismissed and the bottle shop must demonstrate profitability within 12 months; and


  • Mr Venturi had already employed a new manager to replace Mr Diamond.


[8] Mr Diamond indicated that he had commented in response that “this was the first time I had been informed of any performance issues of the store or myself.”

[9] Mr Diamond was dismissed with two weeks payment as part notice in lieu and part gratuity.

[10] Generally, as mentioned above, Mr Diamond’s essential argument is that he was dismissed for performance reasons but there had…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mr Ray Diamond v SSUT Pty Ltd T/A Bourbong Street Cellars and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FWC 816
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr Ray Diamond, an employee of SSUT Pty Ltd trading as Bourbong Street Cellars, applied for relief from his dismissal. The dismissal was based on his unsatisfactory performance. The matter was heard in the Fair Work Commission, which has jurisdiction over unfair dismissal claims under the Fair Work Act 2009. The primary legal issue before the Commission was whether the dismissal for poor performance met the criteria for unfair dismissal as outlined in section 387(e) of the Act. This section specifies that a dismissal is unfair if it is due to a contravention of a workplace rule or an unfair selection process. The employee argued that his dismissal did not meet the threshold for performance-related dismissal because he had not been given an adequate warning prior to termination.

The Commission considered the circumstances and context of the dismissal, including the employer's duty to provide reasonable warnings and opportunities to improve performance. It was established that the employee had been provided with multiple opportunities to improve and had received warnings, but his performance did not meet the required standards. The Commission examined whether the employer's actions in dismissing the employee were reasonable and proportionate to the circumstances. It concluded that the employer had acted reasonably in terminating the employment after the employee's performance did not improve despite warnings and support.

Based on the evidence and arguments presented, the Commission found that the dismissal was not unfair. The employer had followed a fair process and had provided the employee with adequate warnings and opportunities to improve his performance. The Commission held that the dismissal was justified and aligned with the requirements of section 387(e) of the Fair Work Act. Consequently, the application for relief from dismissal was dismissed.

The Commission ordered that the application be dismissed and no further relief be granted to the applicant. The employer was not required to reinstate the employee or provide any further remedy. The decision emphasised the importance of employers following fair procedures and providing adequate warnings when dismissing employees for performance-related reasons.