[2013] FWC 3167 |
FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy
Mr Paul Bidinost
v
Orica Australia Pty Ltd
(U2012/14640)
SENIOR DEPUTY PRESIDENT RICHARDS | BRISBANE, 7 JUNE 2013 |
Termination of employment - arbitration - tampering with blast recording equipment - admissions - deception - employer leniency - contrition - treatment of other employees in comparative circumstances.
[1] On 30 October 2012 Mr Paul Bidinost (“the Applicant”) made application under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (“the Act”) for an unfair dismissal remedy in relation to the decision by his employer, Orica Australia Pty Ltd (“the Respondent”), to dismiss him from its employment.
[2] The Applicant had been a shotfirer with the Respondent but was dismissed for reasons of misconduct in so far as it is alleged that he wilfully tampered with audio monitoring of air noise during site (quarry) blasts. Audio monitoring is required by the Environmental Protection Authority (“EPA”).
The Claims
[3] The Respondent contracts with its clients on the basis that it will regulate blasting to meet EPA standards in relation to noise levels from blasting. The conditions of a licence being granted to a quarry to operate include that its blasting activities meet EPA standards. This obligation passes from the quarry to the contracted blasting operator - the Respondent. Tampering with the audio monitors therefore, it is claimed by the Respondent, flouted the regulatory environmental conditions and jeopardised the contractual relationship with the client and the conditions of the quarry licence.
[4] The Respondent also contends that tampering with the monitors demonstrated that the Applicant had also failed to comply with:
- Orica Quarry Services Shotfirers Work Instruction (SWI), clause 16, “Blast Monitoring and Airblast”;
- Mining and Quarrying Safety and Health Regulation 2001, Chapter 2, Ways of achieving and acceptable level of risk, Part 7, Hazardous substances and dangerous goods”; and
- Orica Safety, Health and Environmental Policy.
[5] The Applicant commenced employment with the Respondent in May 2008 and was dismissed on 2 October 2012. His application was subject to a determination in respect of s.394(2)(b) of the Act. That determination was the subject of my decision in [2013] FWC 2089.
[6] The Applicant claims never to have been counselled or reprimanded over the course of his employment until such time as the current circumstances (as set out below) arose.
[7] The Respondent’s dismissal letter stated that following an investigation into abnormal blast records in mid August 2012 it was revealed that:
- Blast records confirmed that the Applicant was the shotfirer at the Dundowran site on 4 September 2012 when duct tape was found by a Supervisor to have been placed over three audio monitors prior to the blast proceeding;
- The Applicant admitted tampering with the monitors by placing duct tape over the microphones of each monitor on that day;
- Blast monitoring records show that the three monitors first commenced recording results below the normal range on 22 June 2012, and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mr Paul Bidinost v Orica Australia Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] FWC 3167
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the tribunal included whether Mr Bidinost’s actions constituted a valid reason for termination, whether his admissions and the surrounding circumstances demonstrated deception, and how the employer's leniency and the treatment of other employees in similar circumstances should be factored into the decision. It was also necessary to consider whether the employer acted fairly and reasonably in terminating the employment.
The tribunal found that Mr Bidinost had indeed tampered with the equipment, which constituted a serious breach of safety protocols. Despite the employer's leniency in the form of a warning prior to this incident, the seriousness of the current offence warranted a more severe response. The tribunal considered the employer's approach to similar incidents involving other employees and concluded that the termination was not unfair or unreasonable given the circumstances. The employer's treatment of other employees, who faced different consequences for their actions, was also taken into account, leading to the conclusion that the decision was proportionate and justifiable.
The tribunal ultimately upheld the employer's decision to terminate Mr Bidinost’s employment, finding it to be within the bounds of fairness and reasonableness. The tribunal did not order reinstatement or compensation, as it found that the employer's actions were justified under the circumstances.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi