Mr Nicholas Fletcher v Gordon House Management Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read
[2025] FWC 2572

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Mr Nicholas Fletcher
v

Gordon House Management Pty Ltd

(U2025/1780)

COMMISSIONER TRAN

MELBOURNE, 2 SEPTEMBER 2025

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – dismissed for reasons relating to performance and conduct – valid reasons – opportunity provided to respond to reasons – dismissal not unfair

  1. Mr Nicholas Fletcher (the applicant) was employed as a general manager by Gordon House Management Pty Ltd (the respondent / employer). He was initially employed by a related company in 2015 and held various roles in other associated entities of Gordon House. From 25 June 2024, Mr Fletcher was employed as General Manager with Gordon House. Gordon House manages accommodation and has an onsite café. Mr Fletcher was responsible for managing the onsite café.

  1. Gordon House dismissed Mr Fletcher for unsatisfactory performance. Mr Fletcher’s employment ended on 6 February 2025.

  1. Mr Fletcher applied for an unfair dismissal remedy under section 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). He did so within the required period of 21 days after the dismissal took effect.

  1. I held a determinative conference in this matter on Wednesday 28 May 2025. Mr Fletcher gave evidence on his own behalf. Mr Christopher Banson, Director, Gordon House (and its related entities), gave evidence on behalf of the employer. There were no other witnesses. Gordon House filed a witness statement on behalf of Ms Lisa James, strategy analyst at Saltwater Properties Pty Ltd. As Ms James did not attend the determinative conference to affirm her evidence, I have not taken it into account.

  1. Having considered the evidence and submissions of the parties, I am satisfied that the employer's dismissal of Mr Fletcher was for valid reasons, it followed a fair procedure, and the dismissal was not otherwise harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. I therefore dismiss the application. My reasons follow.

Mr Fletcher is protected from unfair dismissal

  1. I am satisfied that Mr Fletcher is a person who is protected from unfair dismissal.

  1. Mr Fletcher completed the minimum period of employment required by s 383(a). The employer is not a small business employer as defined in s 23. Gordon House employed 12 employees at the time of Mr Fletcher's dismissal. However, Mr Banson confirmed that Gordon House is an associated entity of 20 other corporate entities and together all those entities employed more than 15 employees at the time of Mr Fletcher's dismissal. Mr. Banson also confirmed that Mr Fletcher was not employed by the one entity throughout the period from 2015 until his employment ended, but his service among the related entities was recognised as one period of service with the employer.

  1. At the time of his dismissal, Mr Fletcher's annual earnings were less than the high-income threshold.

  1. There is no dispute that the employer dismissed Mr Fletcher within the meaning of s 386.

  1. Mr Fletcher's dismissal was not a case of genuine redundancy within the meaning of section 389.

Chronology

Mr Fletcher was initially…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mr Nicholas Fletcher v Gordon House Management Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FWC 2572
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr Nicholas Fletcher sought an unfair dismissal remedy against Gordon House Management Pty Ltd in the Fair Work Commission. Mr Fletcher, who had served as the General Manager of the onsite café at Gordon House, was dismissed for reasons of unsatisfactory performance and conduct. The Fair Work Commission considered the validity of the reasons for dismissal, the procedural fairness, and whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. The Commission found that the employer provided valid reasons for dismissal, which included issues with cash reconciliation and unauthorized access to a leased area. The employer also notified Mr Fletcher of these reasons and provided him with opportunities to respond. While the dismissal occurred during Mr Fletcher's sick leave, the Commission concluded that the reasons for dismissal were valid and the process was fair. Consequently, the application for an unfair dismissal remedy was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Nicholas Fletcher was employed by Gordon House Management Pty Ltd as General Manager, responsible for managing the onsite café. He was initially employed by a related company in 2015 and held various roles in other associated entities of Gordon House before starting his role with Gordon House on 25 June 2024. Gordon House dismissed Mr Fletcher for unsatisfactory performance on 6 February 2025. Mr Fletcher applied for an unfair dismissal remedy under section 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The employer's reasons for dismissal were related to incomplete cash reconciliations for two periods in 2024 and unauthorised access to and changing the locks on Lot 24, an area near the café. Mr Fletcher had been given multiple opportunities to respond to the employer's concerns about these issues, including a formal meeting on 7 January 2025 and a follow-up letter on 20 January 2025.

This matter was heard by Commissioner Tran of the Fair Work Commission in a determinative conference held on 28 May 2025. Mr Fletcher gave evidence on his own behalf, and Mr Christopher Banson, Director of Gordon House, gave evidence on behalf of the employer. There were no other witnesses. The Commission considered the evidence and submissions of the parties and dismissed Mr Fletcher's application for an unfair dismissal remedy.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was there a valid reason for Mr Fletcher's dismissal related to his capacity or conduct?
2. Was Mr Fletcher notified of the reasons for his dismissal and given an opportunity to respond to those reasons?
3. Did Gordon House unreasonably refuse to allow Mr Fletcher to have a support person present during discussions relating to his dismissal?
4. Did Gordon House warn Mr Fletcher about his unsatisfactory performance before dismissing him?
5. To what degree did the size of Gordon House and the absence of dedicated human resources management specialists impact the procedures followed in effecting the dismissal?
6. Are there any other matters that the FWC considers relevant to whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable?

Held
1. There was a valid reason for Mr Fletcher's dismissal related to his capacity or conduct.
2. Mr Fletcher was notified of the reasons for his dismissal and given an opportunity to respond to those reasons.
3. Gordon House did not unreasonably refuse to allow Mr Fletcher to have a support person present during discussions relating to his dismissal.
4. Gordon House warned Mr Fletcher about his unsatisfactory performance before dismissing him.
5. The size of Gordon House and the absence of dedicated human resources management specialists impacted the procedures followed in effecting the dismissal, but this did not weigh greatly in favour nor against a finding that the dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable.
6. There were no other matters that the FWC considered relevant to whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered various factors in determining whether Mr Fletcher's dismissal was unfair. The first factor was whether there was a valid reason for the dismissal. The employer, Gordon House, provided valid reasons for the dismissal, which related to Mr Fletcher's capacity to perform his job and his conduct. The employer's reasons were based on discrepancies in cash reconciliations and Mr Fletcher's unauthorized access to a leased property. The second factor considered was whether Mr Fletcher was notified of the reasons for his dismissal and given an opportunity to respond to those reasons. The employer informed Mr Fletcher of the reasons for his dismissal in a letter and during a meeting, and provided him with an opportunity to respond. The third factor was whether the employer unreasonably refused to allow Mr Fletcher to have a support person present during discussions relating to his dismissal. The employer informed Mr Fletcher that he could have a support person present, but Mr Fletcher chose to attend the meeting alone. The fourth factor was whether the employer warned Mr Fletcher about his unsatisfactory performance before dismissing him. The employer had previously warned Mr Fletcher about his unsatisfactory performance in relation to cash reconciliations. The fifth factor considered was the degree to which the size of Gordon House and the absence of dedicated human resources management specialists impacted the procedures that were followed in effecting the dismissal. The employer did not have dedicated human resources management specialists, but this did not weigh greatly in favour nor against a finding that the dismissal was harsh, unjust, or unreasonable. The final factor considered was any other matters that the FWC considered relevant. The court found that Mr Fletcher's claims of a hostile work environment and dismissal while on sick leave did not alter the valid reasons for his dismissal.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that an employer may dismiss an employee for valid reasons related to the employee's capacity or conduct, and provide the employee with an opportunity to respond to those reasons, even if the employer does not have dedicated human resources management specialists. The court also found that an employer may dismiss an employee while they are on sick leave, but not because they have taken the leave. In this case, the employer had valid reasons for dismissing Mr Fletcher and provided him with an opportunity to respond to those reasons, and therefore the dismissal was not harsh, unjust, or unreasonable.