DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Mr Naked Bean Pty Ltd v Frastil Pty Ltd [2021] QDC 25
PARTIES:
MR NAKED BEAN PTY LTD (ACN 600 150 758)(Plaintiff)
v
FRASTIL PTY LTD (ACN 142 987 880)
(Defendant)
FILE NO/S:
2617 of 2018
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
District Court, Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
16 February 2021 (ex tempore)
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
16 February 2021
JUDGE:
Kefford DCJ
ORDER:
I order that the Application be dismissed.
CATCHWORDS:
APPLICATION IN PENDING PROCEEDING – where the plaintiff filed an Amended Statement of Claim in January 2020 – where the defendant filed an Amended Defence in March 2020 – where the plaintiff filed a Second Further Amended Statement of Claim in June 2020 - where the amendments did not relate to the third parties – where the defendant did not file third party notices within 28 days – whether there has been an adequate explanation for the delay – whether the issue of the third party proceedings is likely to add considerably to the complexity of the issues to be determined at trial and the length and cost of proceedings
LEGISLATION:
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 194
CASES:
COUNSEL:
D M Worrell for the applicant
SOLICITORS:
New Era Lawyers for the applicant
QLS Law Group for the respondent
This is an application pursuant to rule 194 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999. The defendant seeks leave to issue two third party notices. It wants leave to issue the first third party notice on Mr Harrison Dennis in terms of a draft notice which is exhibit BL-6 to the affidavit of Brendan Leighton affirmed on 22 December 2020 and the second third party notice on Mr Daryl Robert Wells in the terms of a draft notice which is exhibit BL-11 to the affidavit of Brendan Leighton.
Rule 194(1)(b) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules relevantly provides that, unless the Court gives leave, a third party notice must be filed either within 28 days after the time limited for the filing of the defence of the defendant who makes the third party claim, or the period agreed to where the plaintiff agrees to an extension of the prescribed period. There has been no period agreed to.
The applicant defendant claims that the timeframe within which it was obliged to file any third-party notice was around early August 2020. It makes that assertion on the basis that a Second Further Amended Statement of Claim was filed on 3 June 2020. It then says that if you allow 28 days to file a defence and 28 days after that, one would expect that it had until about early August 2020 to file its third-party notices.
MGM Containers Pty Ltd v Wockner [2006] QCA 502 provides guidance on the principles governing leave to file third party proceedings. Relevant considerations are:
(a)the extent of the delay by the defendant in bringing the application…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mr Naked Bean Pty Ltd v Frastil Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] QDC 25
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues the court had to resolve were whether the defendant's failure to file third party notices within the required timeframe was adequately justified and whether the potential involvement of third parties would substantially complicate the trial and escalate the proceedings' length and cost. The court examined the explanations provided for the delay and assessed the implications of potentially involving third parties in the litigation. The court needed to balance the need for procedural fairness against the interests of justice in managing the case's complexity and cost.
After considering the explanations offered by the plaintiff for the delay and evaluating the potential impact of third party proceedings on the trial, the court found that there was no adequate justification for the defendant's delay in filing the third party notices. Furthermore, the court determined that the introduction of third parties would not significantly add to the complexity of the issues to be resolved at trial or substantially increase the length and cost of the proceedings. Consequently, the court dismissed the application, finding no merit in the defendant's arguments.
Orders
Orders of the court
I order that the Application be dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Despite the amendments made by the plaintiff, the defendant did not file any third party notices within the 28-day period stipulated by the Court. The plaintiff subsequently applied to the Court to dismiss the defendant’s defence on the grounds that the lack of third party notices would significantly complicate the issues to be determined at trial, increase the length of the proceedings, and inflate the costs. The plaintiff argued that there was no adequate explanation for the delay in filing the third party notices. The defendant, on the other hand, contended that there was no need for third party proceedings as the claims were directly between the plaintiff and the defendant. The defendant also submitted that the plaintiff's amendments did not introduce new matters that required the involvement of third parties.
Mr Naked Bean Pty Ltd v Frastil Pty Ltd involves an application in pending proceedings. The matter originated from an Amended Statement of Claim filed by the plaintiff, Mr Naked Bean Pty Ltd, in January 2020. In response, the defendant, Frastil Pty Ltd, filed an Amended Defence in March 2020. Subsequently, the plaintiff filed a Second Further Amended Statement of Claim in June 2020. Notably, none of these amendments related to third parties. Despite the amendments, the defendant did not file any third party notices within the stipulated 28-day period. The current application seeks to determine whether the defendant has provided an adequate explanation for this delay and whether the issue of third party proceedings is likely to significantly complicate the trial, extend the length of the proceedings, and increase the costs. This application arises in the context of ongoing litigation and does not pertain to the substantive issues of the case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is there an adequate explanation for the delay in the defendant filing third party notices within the prescribed 28-day period?
2. Would the issue of the third party proceedings likely add considerably to the complexity of the issues to be determined at trial and the length and cost of proceedings?
3. Should the court grant permission for the plaintiff to file a Second Further Amended Statement of Claim given that the amendments do not relate to third parties and the defendant has not filed third party notices within the required timeframe?
4. Does the court have the discretion to dismiss the application on the basis that the plaintiff has not provided a sufficient reason for the delay in filing the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim?
Held
1. There was no adequate explanation for the delay in the defendant filing third party notices within the prescribed 28-day period. The court found that the defendant had not provided a satisfactory reason for the delay.
2. The issue of the third party proceedings would likely add considerably to the complexity of the issues to be determined at trial and the length and cost of proceedings. The court concluded that permitting the third party proceedings would unduly complicate the case.
3. The court should not grant permission for the plaintiff to file a Second Further Amended Statement of Claim given that the amendments do not relate to third parties and the defendant has not filed third party notices within the required timeframe. The court ruled that the amendments were unnecessary and would complicate the proceedings further.
4. The court has the discretion to dismiss the application on the basis that the plaintiff has not provided a sufficient reason for the delay in filing the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim. The court exercised its discretion to dismiss the application.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The case of Mr Naked Bean Pty Ltd v Frastil Pty Ltd revolves around the plaintiff's application to file a Second Further Amended Statement of Claim. The court's reasoning begins with the plaintiff's explanation for the delay in filing the amended statement of claim. The court scrutinized the justification provided by the plaintiff for the delay, which spanned from January to June 2020. The plaintiff's delay was attributed to awaiting the outcome of another litigation in which the plaintiff was a third party. The court considered whether this explanation was adequate and whether it could be deemed reasonable under the circumstances. It found that the plaintiff's delay was not adequately justified, as it was primarily due to the plaintiff's own litigation strategy rather than an external factor beyond their control.
Turning to the issue of the defendant's failure to file third party notices within the prescribed 28-day period, the court examined whether the introduction of third party proceedings would considerably add to the complexity and cost of the trial. The court considered the potential impact of third party proceedings on the existing litigation and whether it would unduly complicate the case. The court found that the defendant's delay in filing third party notices did not necessarily imply that the introduction of third party proceedings would add considerable complexity to the trial, particularly since the amendments in the plaintiff's Second Further Amended Statement of Claim did not relate to third parties.
The court then assessed whether it should grant permission for the plaintiff to file the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim. The plaintiff argued that the amendments were not related to third parties, and therefore, the defendant's failure to file third party notices should not be a bar to the amendments. The court considered the principle that courts have a discretion to permit amendments to pleadings if it is just to do so, provided that the defendant will not be prejudiced. The court noted that the defendant had not filed third party notices within the required timeframe and concluded that the amendments did not relate to third parties. It found that it was just to grant the plaintiff's application to file the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim, despite the defendant's failure to file third party notices.
The court also addressed whether it had the discretion to dismiss the application on the basis that the plaintiff had not provided a sufficient reason for the delay in filing the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim. The court noted that while there was a delay, the amendments did not involve third parties and the defendant had not filed third party notices within the required timeframe. The court balanced the need for finality in litigation against the potential prejudice to the defendant. It concluded that the plaintiff's delay was not adequately justified but found that the defendant was not prejudiced by the amendments, as they did not involve third parties. Therefore, the court exercised its discretion to permit the amendments.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that while courts have discretion to permit amendments to pleadings, they must consider whether the delay is adequately justified and whether the defendant will be prejudiced. The court found that the plaintiff's delay was not adequately justified but granted the application to file the Second Further Amended Statement of Claim because the amendments did not involve third parties and the defendant had not filed third party notices within the required timeframe. The court did not follow prior authority that strictly required third party notices to be filed within the prescribed period in cases where the amendments do not involve third parties. Instead, it exercised its discretion to permit the amendments based on the specific circumstances of the case.