[2013] FWC 6700 |
FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s 365 - Application to deal with contraventions involving dismissal
Mr Lee Price
v
John Holland Group Pty Limited
(C2013/3301)
DEPUTY PRESIDENT SAMS | SYDNEY, 6 SEPTEMBER 2013 |
Applications for costs under the Act’s general protection provisions - no reasonable prospects of success - whether reasonably apparent to the lawyers that there were no prospects of success - new and novel arguments as to the construction of the general protections provisions - competing authorities - both costs application dismissed.
[1] This decision concerns cross applications for costs arising from a jurisdictional decision of the Fair Work Commission (FWC or the ‘Commission’), Lee Price v John Holland Group Pty Limited and Others[2013] FWC 3329 (the ‘primary decision’), in respect to an application filed by Mr Lee Price (the ‘applicant’) against John Holland Group Pty Ltd and others (the respondents), pursuant to the general protections provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the ‘Act’).
[2] In the primary decision, the Commission dismissed the jurisdictional objections of the respondents, which had sought to have Mr Price’s s 365 application summarily dismissed. These objections were summarised at paras [6]-[7] of the Commission’s decision as follows:
‘[6] Mr Ludeke further submitted that the primary failures of the purported application are twofold. Firstly, there can be no application before the Commission because there could be no allegation that the applicant was dismissed in contravention of Part 3-1 of the Act. This is so because no workplace right/s were identified. Secondly, in the absence of any identified workplace right/s, there can be no dispute between the parties. The respondents do not know what workplace right the applicant had and what their contravention was. There cannot be a dispute if the respondent parties are unaware of how they are alleged to have contravened Part 3-1 of the Act; See: CEPU v Active Tree Services Pty Ltd [2011] FMCA 535 (‘CEPU v Active Tree Services).
[7] While Mr Ludeke noted that the Act does not define ‘dispute’ for the purposes of Part 3-1, Divison 8 requires a tangible dispute to exist between parties. In the absence of something real which is disputed between the parties, the jurisdiction of the Commission, and ultimately the Courts, is meaningless. It followed that relief cannot be provided in proceedings for a nonexistent dispute.’
[3] Unsurprisingly, the applicant has applied for costs pursuant to s 376 of the Act. It should be noted that the ‘fruits of his victory’ in the primary decision has resulted in little more than the gateway being opened to further proceedings before the Federal Circuit Court or the Federal Court as to the substantive merits of the applicant’s general protections case. Notwithstanding the reality that the respondent’s objections were dismissed and its arguments comprehensively rejected (from which I observe there has been no appeal), the respondents have also sought costs against the applicant’s lawyers, on the basis of s 376 of the Act. At this…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mr Lee Price v John Holland Group Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] FWC 6700
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the respondent’s opposition to the unfair dismissal application had no reasonable prospects of success and whether it was reasonably apparent to the respondent's lawyers that there were no prospects of success. Additionally, the court considered whether the applicant had raised new and novel arguments concerning the interpretation of the general protections provisions, which had not been previously considered by the Fair Work Commission. The court also needed to assess whether these arguments were supported by competing authorities, and if the respondent’s opposition was based on an arguable position.
The court found that the respondent’s opposition to Mr Price's unfair dismissal application had reasonable prospects of success. It was noted that the arguments raised by Mr Price were not new and novel but were instead well-established interpretations of the general protections provisions. Furthermore, the court found that it was not reasonably apparent to Mr Price's lawyers that there were no prospects of success. The respondent's opposition was based on an arguable position, and the competing authorities did not conclusively support Mr Price's arguments. As a result, both of Mr Price's applications for costs were dismissed.
The court did not make any final orders as both applications for costs were dismissed. The respondent was not required to pay any costs to Mr Price under the Fair Work Act.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi