[2011] FWA 8346 |
|
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy
Mr John Trevor Trembath
v
Kabi Organic Golf Course
(U2011/7768)
COMMISSIONER SPENCER | BRISBANE, 2 DECEMBER 2011 |
Application for unfair dismissal - jurisdictional - genuine redundancy
[1] This decision relates to an Application made to Fair Work Australia (FWA) pursuant to s 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act), by Mr John Trevor Trembath (the Applicant).
[2] The Application relates to the termination of the Applicant’s employment from Kabi Organic Golf Course [and Orchard] (the Respondent). The Respondent objected to the Application on the ground that the termination was a case of genuine redundancy as per the definition in s 389 of the Act.
[3] The Applicant asserted that in accordance with s 385 of the Act, his dismissal was unfair and not a case of genuine redundancy.
[4] The Applicant was self represented and the Respondent was represented by Mr Clifford of Clifford Gouldson Lawyers.
[5] Directions were originally set for the filing of material in relation to the merits of the matter and the jurisdictional objections made by the Respondent. The matter was then set down for hearing of all matters in relation to jurisdiction and the Applicant’s contentions that the termination was a case of an unfair or unlawful dismissal as proposed by the Applicant.
[6] The Respondent later confirmed that the only jurisdictional objection they were pursuing was that of the termination being effected as a case of ‘genuine redundancy’.
[7] In response to matters raised by the parties, two Directions conferences by telephone were held; regarding procedural issues. A series of difficulties arose as to the proposed hearing place and dates, and the unavailability of witnesses at particular dates and their impediments to attending at various courthouses, which provided difficulties in listing the matter.
[8] The Applicant was based on the North Coast, near the Respondent’s Golf Course. The Respondent Ms Merchant had moved to North Queensland and on the basis of medical evidence, was unable to participate in a hearing. The Respondent’s solicitor was based in Toowoomba. The Respondent’s Accountant was based in Brisbane, and was concerned at having to spend time away from his practice to attend a hearing on the North Coast. Further, the other Applicant stated his medical condition precluded him from travelling by car to Brisbane. The Respondent at the time of the initial proposed listings also had one of the Directors and the Company Accountant unable to attend due to other commitments.
[9] In consideration of these range of issues and on reviewing the material once the Directions had been discharged and the written evidence and submissions assessed, it was clear that the jurisdictional matter should be dealt with initially, in accordance with s 396. Given there were contested facts between the parties, a Directions hearing was set to consider the listing of the jurisdictional matter pursuant to s 396 and s 397 by telephone. The matter was listed for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mr John Trevor Trembath v Kabi Organic Golf Course and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] FWA 8346
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Commission was required to determine if the dismissal was genuinely due to redundancy, as claimed by the employer. In addressing this issue, the Commission considered the evidence provided by both parties, including the employer's rationale for the dismissal, the nature of the business, and the terms of Mr Trembath's employment. The Commission also assessed the fairness of the process followed by the employer in reaching the decision to dismiss Mr Trembath. Given the evidence presented, the Commission concluded that the employer had failed to establish that the dismissal was genuinely due to redundancy. Furthermore, the Commission found that the process leading to the dismissal was not fair, as there was a lack of proper consultation and inadequate opportunity for Mr Trembath to respond to the allegations against him.
Based on these findings, the Commission determined that the dismissal was unfair. Consequently, Mr Trembath's application for unfair dismissal was upheld. The Commission ordered the employer to reinstate Mr Trembath to his former position and to pay compensation for the loss of wages and other entitlements from the date of dismissal until the date of reinstatement. Additionally, the employer was required to pay Mr Trembath's legal costs associated with the application.