Mr Brett Dalton-Downward v The Trustee for Newform Precast Unit Trust

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read
[2025] FWC 1440

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.394 - Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Mr Brett Dalton-Downward
v

The Trustee for Newform Precast Unit Trust

(U2025/2582)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT MILLHOUSE

MELBOURNE, 26 MAY 2025

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – application under s 399A – failure to comply with directions of the Commission – s 399A application granted – application dismissed.

  1. This decision concerns an application made under s 399A of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Act) by the Trustee for Newform Precast Unit Trust, to dismiss an unfair dismissal application brought against it by Mr Brett Dalton-Downward.

  1. For the reasons that follow, the respondent’s application under s 399 is granted. Mr Dalton-Downward’s application for an unfair dismissal remedy is dismissed.

Procedural context

  1. On 5 March 2025, Mr Dalton-Downward through his paid agent, Unfair Dismissals Australia, made an application for an unfair dismissal remedy pursuant to s 394 of the Act. On 29 April 2025, Mr Dalton-Downward’s paid agent attended a conciliation conference convened by the Commission in relation to the application, but Mr Dalton-Downward did not attend and was not contactable by either the Commission or his representative.

  1. Upon allocation of the application to my Chambers on 9 May 2025, the matter was listed for a Case Management Conference, to proceed at 10:00am (AEST) on 14 May 2025 via Microsoft Teams. The parties were provided with a copy of the Notice of Listing and directed to provide their appearances by 4:00pm on 12 May 2025. The respondent provided its appearances on 12 May 2025 pursuant to the direction. Appearances were not provided by Mr Dalton-Downward or his representative.

  1. On 14 May 2025 at 9:18am, shortly prior to the commencement of the Case Management Conference, my Chambers emailed the parties noting that Mr Dalton-Downward had not provided his appearance as directed. My Chambers directed Mr Dalton-Downward or his representative to file an appearance for the conference as soon as possible.

  1. Approximately 1 minute later, at 9:19am, the applicant’s representative emailed my Chambers stating that it would not be participating in the conference. Later correspondence confirmed the representative’s position that Mr Dalton-Downward has been, and remains, unresponsive to its attempts to contact him.

  1. At approximately 9:20am, my Chambers made two unsuccessful attempts to call Mr Dalton-Downward. At approximately 9:30am, Mr Dalton-Downward telephoned my Chambers and was advised that the Case Management Conference would commence at 10:00am that day and he had not provided his appearance, as directed. Mr Dalton-Downward requested an email with the Microsoft Teams link for the conference and asked that Chambers treat his telephone call as confirmation of his intention to appear on his own behalf.

  1. At 9:33am, my Chambers emailed the parties attaching the Notice of Listing, inclusive of the Microsoft Teams link, and explained that Chambers had spoken with Mr Dalton-Downward regarding his intention to appear.

  1. At 10:00am when the Case Management Conference was due to commence, there was no appearance for the applicant despite Mr Dalton-Downward’s request for the Microsoft…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mr Brett Dalton-Downward v The Trustee for Newform Precast U... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FWC 1440
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Mr Brett Dalton-Downward versus The Trustee for Newform Precast Unit Trust, the Fair Work Commission was called upon to determine an application under section 399A of the Fair Work Act 2009 to dismiss an unfair dismissal application brought by Mr Dalton-Downward against his former employer, the respondent. The application for dismissal arose from Mr Dalton-Downward's failure to attend conciliation and case management conferences, and his overall lack of engagement with the Commission regarding his unfair dismissal claim. The Deputy President of the Commission, Millhouse, was tasked with deciding whether the respondent's application to dismiss Mr Dalton-Downward's unfair dismissal application should be granted.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Mr Dalton-Downward's failure to attend the required conferences and his general non-compliance with the Commission's directions constituted unreasonable conduct warranting the dismissal of his unfair dismissal application under section 399A of the Act. This involved a two-step discretionary decision: first, whether Mr Dalton-Downward had unreasonably failed to attend the conferences, and second, whether, upon finding such unreasonable failure, the dismissal of his application was warranted.

The Deputy President found that Mr Dalton-Downward had indeed unreasonably failed to attend the conferences, noting his absence at both the conciliation conference on 29 April 2025 and the Case Management Conference on 14 May 2025, despite clear directions from the Commission. Additionally, Mr Dalton-Downward did not respond to the Commission's directives or provide any explanation for his non-attendance. The Deputy President was satisfied that all reasonable steps had been taken by the Commission to ensure Mr Dalton-Downward was aware of the necessity to comply with the directions and the potential consequences of his non-compliance. The Deputy President concluded that there were no circumstances that would weigh against the exercise of the discretion to dismiss the application, leading to the decision that the respondent's application under section 399A should be granted.

In light of the findings, the Deputy President dismissed Mr Dalton-Downward's application for an unfair dismissal remedy. The decision was made on the papers, given Mr Dalton-Downward's lack of engagement with the Commission and failure to provide any justification for his non-compliance. The dismissal effectively terminates Mr Dalton-Downward's claim for an unfair dismissal remedy.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Brett Dalton-Downward made an application for an unfair dismissal remedy against The Trustee for Newform Precast Unit Trust pursuant to section 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009. Mr Dalton-Downward did not attend a conciliation conference convened by the Commission on 29 April 2025 and failed to attend a Case Management Conference scheduled for 14 May 2025, despite being directed to do so by the Commission. The respondent, The Trustee for Newform Precast Unit Trust, applied under section 399A of the Act to dismiss Mr Dalton-Downward's unfair dismissal application due to his non-attendance and failure to engage with the proceedings.

On 5 March 2025, Mr Dalton-Downward filed an application for an unfair dismissal remedy. His representative attended a conciliation conference on 29 April 2025 but Mr Dalton-Downward did not attend. On 9 May 2025, the matter was allocated to Deputy President Millhouse's Chambers and listed for a Case Management Conference on 14 May 2025. The parties were directed to provide their appearances by 4:00pm on 12 May 2025. The respondent provided its appearance on time, but Mr Dalton-Downward or his representative did not. Despite efforts by the Commission to contact Mr Dalton-Downward, he did not attend the conference. The respondent subsequently made an application under section 399A of the Act to dismiss Mr Dalton-Downward's unfair dismissal application for his failure to comply with the Commission's directions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Mr Dalton-Downward unreasonably failed to attend the conciliation conference and the Case Management Conference in relation to his application for an unfair dismissal remedy.
2. Whether the Commission should exercise its discretion under section 399A of the Act to dismiss Mr Dalton-Downward's unfair dismissal application due to his non-compliance.

Held
1. The court concluded that Mr Dalton-Downward unreasonably failed to attend the conciliation conference and the Case Management Conference in relation to his application for an unfair dismissal remedy.
2. The court determined that the Commission should exercise its discretion under section 399A of the Act to dismiss Mr Dalton-Downward's unfair dismissal application due to his non-compliance.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering the application under section 399A of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by the Trustee for Newform Precast Unit Trust to dismiss Mr Brett Dalton-Downward's unfair dismissal application, the Deputy President of the Fair Work Commission, Millhouse, examined the procedural context and legislative framework. The court noted that Mr Dalton-Downward did not attend the conciliation conference on 29 April 2025 and failed to appear for the Case Management Conference on 14 May 2025 despite being contacted by the Commission. Additionally, Mr Dalton-Downward did not provide any response to the Commission's directions regarding the s 399A Application.

The court applied the provisions of section 399A of the Act, which allows the Commission to dismiss an application if the applicant has unreasonably failed to attend a conference conducted by the Commission or failed to comply with a direction of the Commission. The court referenced the Full Bench decision in Lockyear v Cox, which outlined the process to be observed before dismissing an application under section 399A. The court noted that the Commission had followed the necessary procedural steps, including providing Mr Dalton-Downward with an opportunity to respond and warning him of the potential consequences of non-compliance.

Given that Mr Dalton-Downward had failed to attend the required conferences and did not provide any explanation or material in response to the s 399A Application, the court concluded that his failure to comply was unreasonable. The court exercised its discretion under section 399A to dismiss Mr Dalton-Downward's unfair dismissal application, considering the respondent's need to prosecute its case and Mr Dalton-Downward's lack of engagement with the application process. The court determined that there were no mitigating factors that would weigh against dismissing the application. Consequently, the court granted the respondent's application and dismissed Mr Dalton-Downward's unfair dismissal application.