Mr Bankrupt Secondhand Goods Pty Ltd v Richards No. Scgrg-99-1020

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

MR BANKRUPT SECONDHAND GOODS PTY LTD v RICHARDS
[2000] SASC 189

Full Court: Olsson, Wicks and Gray JJ

  1. OLSSON J       I have had the benefit of reading, in draft, the reasons published by Wicks J.  I agree with the conclusion to which he has come.

  2. WICKS J          This is an appeal from a judgment of a judge of this Court obtained on 14 December 1999 on appeal from a judgment of a magistrate obtained on 12 August 1999.

  3. The plaintiff was the proprietor of the business name C D Richards Transport and was engaged in the business of road transportation of goods.  The defendant, Mr Bankrupt Secondhand Goods Pty Ltd, was a company incorporated on 8 December 1997.

  4. In or about early May 1998, the plaintiff was contacted by an associate in the transport industry and advised of a customer who needed the services of a carrier to transport office furniture from Sydney to Adelaide.  The plaintiff was given the telephone number for the customer concerned.

  5. The plaintiff telephoned the number supplied and spoke to Mr Dean Scadding, who said that he was the manager for what he described as “Mr Bankrupt”.  The plaintiff wondered about the reliability of the customer and queried the name.  In response, Mr Scadding said that money for the project was guaranteed.  He said that he wanted about ten semi-trailer loads of furniture loaded at Villawood in New South Wales to be delivered to Mr Bankrupt at Shop 1, 69 Port Road, Thebarton, being a warehouse used by Mr Bankrupt for sales.

  6. Mr Scadding agreed to a delivery price of $2000 for each full load of furniture carried from Sydney to the warehouse at Thebarton. He also gave an address in Victoria to which invoices should be sent.

  7. The plaintiff delivered all ten full loads of furniture to the Adelaide address and concluded with the tenth delivery on 16 June 1998.

  8. On 25 June 1998, the plaintiff received part-payment in the sum of $2000, leaving a further $18000 to pay.

  9. After the full ten loads had been delivered, the plaintiff telephoned Mr Scadding in Victoria to ascertain when the balance outstanding would be paid.  The plaintiff said that initially Mr Scadding sought to reassure him that the invoices were being fixed up or that some money would be sent as soon as the sale of furniture had occurred.  When no payment had eventuated after these promises from Mr Scadding, the plaintiff said that he was thereafter unable to contact Mr Scadding, who did not return his telephone calls.

  10. The plaintiff said that he received a telephone call on 27 August 1998 from Mr Doug Clark who identified himself as a representative of Mr Bankrupt, requesting a full load of furniture to be collected from a Sydney location and delivered to Mr Bankrupt’s premises in Adelaide.  In the course of the conversation, Mr Clark stated that the load of furniture in question was for “Mr Bankrupt”.  The plaintiff subsequently received a facsimile transmission from Mr Clark…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mr Bankrupt Secondhand Goods Pty Ltd v Richards No. Scgrg-99... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] SASC 189
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Mr Bankrupt Secondhand Goods Pty Ltd v Richards involved an appeal by the defendant, a company, against a judgment obtained by the plaintiff in the Magistrates Court. The plaintiff, who operated under the business name C D Richards Transport, sought to recover $19,000 for the transportation of office furniture from Sydney to Adelaide. The defendant, Mr Bankrupt Secondhand Goods Pty Ltd, denied liability, asserting that it had no involvement in the business conducted by the plaintiff's counterpart, Mr Dean Scadding, prior to its incorporation and activation in late 1998.

The legal issues before the court were whether the defendant could be held liable for the contractual obligations of Mr Scadding, who operated under the business name Mr Bankrupt, and whether the defendant was bound by the contract despite its dormant status during the period in question. The central issue was whether Mr Scadding, when referring to himself as the manager of Mr Bankrupt, was acting on behalf of the defendant company or in his personal capacity as trustee of the N C Trust.

The court found that the defendant was not liable for the contractual obligations of Mr Scadding. The reasoning was that at the time of the contract, the defendant company was dormant and had not yet commenced trading. Mr Scadding was operating the business of buying and selling secondhand furniture in his personal capacity as trustee of the N C Trust, not as an agent or manager of the defendant company. The term "manager" used by Mr Scadding could be interpreted as a reference to himself, not the defendant company. Therefore, the court concluded that there was an alternative version of the facts that, if proven at trial, would result in the dismissal of the plaintiff's claim against the defendant. The appeal was allowed, and the case was ordered to be retried before another magistrate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

OLSSON J WICKS J GRAY J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: OLSSON J, WICKS J, GRAY J