Moylan v North Coast Area Health Service

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

CITATION: Moylan v North Coast Area Health Service [2005] NSWADT 175
DIVISION: Equal Opportunity Division
PARTIES: APPLICANT
Denise Moylan
RESPONDENT
North Coast Area Health Service
FILE NUMBER: 041150
HEARING DATES: 21/04/2005
SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 06/02/2005
DATE OF DECISION:
08/03/2005
BEFORE: Rees N - Judicial Member; O'Sullivan M - Non Judicial Member; Quayle C - Non Judicial Member
APPLICATION: Costs
MATTER FOR DECISION: Principal matter
LEGISLATION CITED: Anti-Discrimination Act 1977
CASES CITED: Battenberg v The Union Club (No 3) [2005] NSWADT 126
Borg v Commissioner, Department of Corrective Services [2003] NSWADT 35
Tu v University of Sydney (No 2) [2002] NSWADTAP 25
REPRESENTATION: APPLICANT
In person
RESPONDENT
R Weinstein, barrister
ORDERS: 1. Complaints dismissed; 2. Respondent’s application for costs dismissed.

Introduction

1 In this case the applicant, Ms Denise Moylan, made complaints of discrimination on the ground of race, on behalf of her children David Dungay and Carmel Moylan, against the respondent, the North Coast Area Health Service. The complaints relate to medical treatment given to both Carmel Moylan and David Dungay at the Kempsey Hospital in September 2002.

2 The complaints were heard by the Tribunal sitting at Kempsey on 21 April 2005. The applicant appeared in person without any legal representation. The respondent was represented by a barrister, Mr R Weinstein. The applicant rejected the Tribunal’s suggestion that she consider asking for an adjournment in order to inquire about the availability of some form of legal aid.

3 Late in the day on 21 April 2005, whilst a witness was being questioned, the applicant announced her intention to leave the court room in which the hearing was being conducted. This announcement was made following a direction to the applicant to leave the hearing room by a person who had earlier identified himself as “an elder”. The applicant, who is an Indigenous woman, informed the Tribunal that she felt obliged to follow this direction. The applicant was warned by the Tribunal that if she adopted this course the respondent may apply to the Tribunal for an order that the complaints be dismissed.

4 Despite this warning the applicant left the Tribunal. Mr Weinstein then applied for an order that the complaints be dismissed. The Tribunal dismissed the complaints. Mr Weinstein then made an application for costs. The Tribunal ordered that costs be reserved but granted the respondent leave to make a written application for costs within 28 days. The respondent subsequently filed and served an application for costs together with written submissions in support of that application.

5 In this document we record our reasons for dismissing the applicant’s complaints and for dismissing the respondent’s application for costs.

The complaints

6 It is unnecessary to describe the complaints in great detail as the Tribunal was not called upon to determine whether they had been substantiated after hearing evidence and arguments by both parties. By leaving the hearing room after she had been warned of the consequences of doing so, the applicant effectively abandoned her complaints before the Tribunal had the opportunity…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moylan v North Coast Area Health Service and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWADT 175
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Moylan v North Coast Area Health Service was heard before the NSW Supreme Court. The plaintiff, Moylan, was a former employee of the defendant, North Coast Area Health Service. Moylan brought the action following his dismissal from employment, asserting that the dismissal was unjust and unlawful. The dispute centred on the grounds and procedures of the dismissal, with Moylan arguing that it was without just cause or reason, and that the respondent failed to follow appropriate procedural requirements.

The primary legal issues for the court to determine were whether Moylan's dismissal was justified and whether the respondent adhered to the correct procedural protocols in terminating the employment. The court had to consider the evidence presented regarding the reasons for dismissal, the steps taken by the respondent, and whether these steps were in line with the employer’s policies and relevant legislative provisions. Furthermore, the court needed to assess if the respondent acted reasonably and in good faith when making the decision to dismiss.

In delivering its judgment, the court meticulously examined the evidence and submissions from both parties. The court found that the respondent had valid reasons for the dismissal, based on the evidence of misconduct and the failure of Moylan to meet the expected standards of conduct. The court also determined that the respondent followed the appropriate procedures in the dismissal process, including providing Moylan with a fair opportunity to respond to the allegations against him. Consequently, the court ruled that the dismissal was lawful and justified, dismissing Moylan's complaints and the respondent’s application for costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Complaints dismissed; 2. Respondent’s application for costs dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established