Mouratidis v Brown

Link copied
Case Copied 83 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mouratidis v Brown [2002] FCAFC 330

NEGLIGENCE – Alleged negligence by medical practitioner in connection with investigation of possible breast cancer – Whether practitioner carried out a careful and adequate physical examination of the plaintiff’s breasts, including by palpation – Significance of findings of the trial judge on this issue – Whether palpation would probably have caused the practitioner to carry out further investigations by fine needle aspiration or biopsy – Whether such a procedure would probably have led to discovery of her cancer – No basis for disturbing findings of trial judge on these issues.

COSTS – Whether trial judge erred in making a “Bullock” order in relation to costs incurred in connection with discontinued action against other defendants.

BILL MOURATIDIS and THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY v DAVID ROSS BROWN AS APPOINTED REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF THE LATE AMANDA BROWN

A 64 of 2001

WILCOX, HIGGINS and GYLES JJ
7 NOVEMBER 2002
CANBERRA


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

DISTRICT REGISTRY

A 64 of 2001

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

BETWEEN:

BILL MOURATIDIS
FIRST APPELLANT

THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
SECOND APPELLANT

AND:

DAVID ROSS BROWN AS APPOINTED REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF THE LATE AMANDA BROWN
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

WILCOX, HIGGINS and GYLES JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

7 NOVEMBER 2002

WHERE MADE:

CANBERRA

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The appeal be dismissed.

2.        The appellants pay the costs incurred by the respondent in connection with the appeal.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

DISTRICT REGISTRY

A 64 of 2001

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE SUPREME COURT OF THE
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

BETWEEN:

BILL MOURATIDIS
FIRST APPELLANT

THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
SECOND APPELLANT

AND:

DAVID ROSS BROWN AS APPOINTED REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ESTATE OF THE LATE AMANDA BROWN
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

WILCOX, HIGGINS and GYLES JJ

DATE:

7 NOVEMBER 2002

PLACE:

CANBERRA

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

WILCOX and HIGGINS JJ:

  1. This is an appeal by Dr Bill Mouratidis and the Australian Capital Territory (“the ACT”) against a judgment entered in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory in a medical negligence action.  Crispin J held that Dr Mouratidis, the third defendant, failed to discharge his duty of care towards the plaintiff, Amanda Brown, in relation to a condition of lobular cancer of her left breast.  His Honour entered judgment for the plaintiff, in the sum of $223,143.60, against Dr Mouratidis and the ACT, his employer.  The ACT was the fourth defendant.  He rejected a claim made by Ms Brown against the fifth defendant, Dr Sanjiv Jain.  The action was discontinued against Dr Clare Willington, the first defendant, and her employer and second defendant, Family Planning Association ACT Incorporated (“FPA”).

  2. Ms Brown died within a few days of Crispin J’s decision.  Accordingly, the appellants named as respondent to their appeal her husband,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mouratidis v Brown and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCAFC 330
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Mouratidis v Brown was brought by the appellant, Ms Brown, against the respondent, Dr Mouratidis, a medical practitioner. The dispute concerned an alleged failure by Dr Mouratidis to adequately examine Ms Brown’s breasts for signs of cancer, which resulted in a delayed diagnosis and treatment of her breast cancer. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory.

The central legal issues in this case revolved around whether Dr Mouratidis had conducted a thorough and appropriate physical examination of Ms Brown’s breasts, including palpation, and if this examination was sufficient to prompt further investigations such as fine needle aspiration or biopsy. Additionally, the court had to determine whether such further investigations would have likely led to the discovery of Ms Brown’s cancer. The trial judge had found against Dr Mouratidis on these points, and the appeal questioned the correctness of these findings.

The court found that there was no basis to disturb the trial judge’s findings on the adequacy of Dr Mouratidis’ examination and the potential outcomes of further investigations. The trial judge had considered the evidence and concluded that palpation would likely have led to further investigations, which in turn might have resulted in an earlier discovery of Ms Brown’s cancer. The appeal court upheld the trial judge’s conclusions, finding no errors in his assessment of the evidence.

The court also addressed the issue of costs, specifically a "Bullock" order made by the trial judge regarding costs incurred in connection with a discontinued action against other defendants. The appeal court found no error in the trial judge’s handling of the costs issue.

The final orders of the court were to dismiss the appeal and to require the appellants to pay the costs incurred by the respondent in connection with the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellants pay the costs incurred by the respondent in connection with the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

There is nothing new or controversial about those statements. It is common ground that Dr Mouratidis should have conducted such an examination. A major issue is whether or not he did so.The facts The plaintiff was born on 7 January 1960. In late 1985 she had a cancerous thyroid removed. It was not suggested at the trial that this cancer had any relationship with the plaintiff’s subsequent breast cancer, but Crispin J accepted her evidence that the thyroid cancer left her particularly aware of, and anxious about, the possibility of other cancers. In 1990 the plaintiff married the respondent, David Ross Brown. In March 1991 she gave birth to a son, James. In November 1993 a second son, Hayden, was born. Ms Brown breast-fed Hayden until a few weeks before she attended a clinic in Canberra conducted by the FPA. Ms Brown attended the FPA clinic on 10 August 1995. She gave evidence that she was concerned about two lumps in her left breast. She said one lump was “on the nipple”; but Crispin J found it was more correctly described as being in the areola adjacent to the nipple. The plaintiff said the other lump was “on the left side of the breast”, apparently in the upper quadrant. Mr Brown also gave evidence about these lumps. He claimed to have seen and felt them. At the FPA clinic, Ms Brown was initially examined by Nurse Kippen. She was then seen by Dr Willington, a medical practitioner employed at the clinic. Dr Willington and Nurse Kippen collaborated in the preparation of a medical note that included a sketch of the two breasts. No abnormality was attributed to the right breast. However, two comments were made about the left breast. At the end of an arrow pointing to the centre of the left breast, it was noted “small round mobile pea size lump that appears to be a sebaceous cyst”. A second arrow, pointing to the upper outer quadrant of the breast, was labelled “Firmer lumpier tissue”. Nurse Kippen wrote the words “recently lactating” and “mammogram u/s review in 2 months”. “u/s” is an abbreviation for ultrasound scan, a technique that involves the transmission of sound waves through the body at very high frequencies. When the ultrasound wave hits tissue, it is bounced back to the machine and provides pictures. It was common ground at the trial that ultrasound is useful in searching for carcinomas. However, ultrasound frequently provides false negatives, especially in relation to lobular carcinomas. Ultrasound can reveal lumps and lumpiness. It may reveal a lesion. However the absence of a lesion does not mean there is no carcinoma. Dr Willington referred the plaintiff to Woden Valley Hospital for a mammogram, ultrasound scan and fine needle aspiration if indicated. Fine needle aspiration, or FNA, is a procedure by which a needle is injected into the body to collect cells. The cells are squirted onto a slide which is examined by a cytologist to determine whether they are cancerous. In his reasons for judgment, the trial judge set out the following account of the plaintiff’s consultation with Dr Mouratidis:“The plaintiff attended at the Woden Valley Hospital on 18 August 1995. She was advised by a woman at the hospital, who may have been a nurse, a radiographer or other medical practitioner, that they could not do a mammogram because her breasts were too dense following breast feeding. This statement seems to have been incorrect but a mammogram subsequently conducted in February 1996 proved negative and the error seems to have had no impact on the plaintiff’s condition. Ultrasound scans of her breasts were undertaken on 18 August 1995 and she had a conversation with the third defendant who was a physician in nuclear medicine and diagnostic ultrasound. She said he told her that since she was only thirty-five years old and there had been no history of breast cancer in the family there was no need to worry. She had previously had cancer of the thyroid but said that when she mentioned this to the third defendant he had reassured her that there was nothing to worry about as it had been so long ago and so remote from the lumps in her breast. He said that the lumps were most likely to have been fibrous and explained that they were in line with the ducts. More significantly, she said that whilst he read the ultrasound he did not feel or otherwise examine her breasts by palpation.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.