Mouflih v Minister for Home Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Mouflih v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCA 1744

File number: QUD 774 of 2018
Judge: RANGIAH J
Date of judgment: 25 October 2019
Catchwords:

MIGRATION – application for extension of time within which to seek judicial review – application filed 11 days outside time limit – extension granted

MIGRATION – decision not to revoke cancellation – whether Minister considered documents – whether documents material to Minister’s decision – decision quashed

Legislation:

Constitution s 75

Migration Act 1994 (Cth) ss 476A, 477A, 501 and 501CA

Cases cited:

Hay v Minister for Home Affairs [2018] FCAFC 149

Hossain v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 35 ALR 1; [2018] HCA 34

Martin v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCA 1

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v CPA16 [2019] FCAFC 40

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Guo (1997) 191 CLR 559

Navoto v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 135

Plaintiff S157/2002 v Commonwealth of Australia (2003) 211 CLR 476

Viane v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) FCAFC 116

Date of hearing: 11 July 2019
Registry: Queensland
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 56
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr SW Jones
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr J Byrnes
Solicitor for the Respondent: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

QUD 774 of 2018
BETWEEN:

YOUSSEF MOUFLIH

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS

Respondent

JUDGE:

RANGIAH J

DATE OF ORDER:

25 OCTOBER 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The time for the making of the applicant’s application for judicial review of the respondent’s decision of 14 August 2018 to not revoke the cancellation of the applicant’s visa (decision) be extended to 22 March 2019.

2.The respondent’s decision is quashed.

3.The respondent make the decision according to law.

4.The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the application.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

RANGIAH J:

  1. On 20 October 2017, the applicant’s visa was cancelled pursuant to s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1994 (Cth) (the Act), on the basis that he was serving a term of over twelve months imprisonment.

  2. On 14 August 2018, the respondent (the Minister) personally made a decision under s 501CA(4) of the Act to not revoke the cancellation.

  3. The applicant has applied for an extension of time to seek judicial review of the Minister’s decision. The application was filed on 22 October 2018, eleven days outside the time limit imposed by s 477A(1) of the Act. The delay is not substantial. The applicant’s explanation is that he was under the misapprehension that the solicitor representing him would take steps to protect his interests. The solicitor has accepted responsibility for the misunderstanding. I consider that the applicant has provided a reasonable explanation for the delay. 

  4. The Minister opposes an…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mouflih v Minister for Home Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1744
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Mouflih v Minister for Home Affairs, the Federal Court of Australia considered an application for judicial review of a decision by the Minister for Home Affairs not to revoke the cancellation of the applicant’s visa. The applicant, a citizen of Morocco, had been granted a Partner (Provisional) visa in 2014. However, in August 2017, he was convicted of assault occasioning bodily harm against his wife, who is an Australian citizen. Following this conviction, the Minister cancelled the applicant’s visa and invited him to make representations for revocation. The applicant’s wife submitted additional documents to the Department of Home Affairs in support of the revocation request, which were allegedly not considered by the Minister.

The court had to determine whether the Minister failed to consider several documents sent by the applicant’s wife, and if such failure constituted a jurisdictional error that would warrant quashing the decision. The applicant argued that the Minister’s oversight of these documents was material to the outcome of the decision. The Minister contended that the documents were never posted or received by the Department.

The court found that the documents in question were indeed part of the bundle sent by the applicant’s wife and were received by the Department. However, the Minister’s failure to consider these documents did not amount to jurisdictional error because they were not material to the decision. The court concluded that the Minister had sufficiently considered the relevant factors and that the documents, even if considered, would not have led to a different outcome.

Consequently, the court extended the time for the applicant to seek judicial review, quashed the Minister’s decision, and ordered the Minister to reconsider the application according to law. Additionally, the court ordered the Minister to pay the applicant’s costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The time for the making of the applicant’s application for judicial review of the respondent’s decision of 14 August 2018 to not revoke the cancellation of the applicant’s visa (decision) be extended to 22 March 2019.

2. The respondent’s decision is quashed.

3. The respondent make the decision according to law.

4. The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The focus of the appeal was upon the first ground. That ground is concerned with whether the Minister committed jurisdictional error by failing to consider several documents alleged to have been sent to the Department by Mrs Mouflih.The evidence Mrs Mouflih provided evidence on behalf of the applicant. She deposed as follows:3.On 16 November 2017 I sent a bundle of documents to the Department of Home Affairs by registered post…4. Included in the bundle of documents I sent to the Department of Home Affairs on 16 November 2017 was:(a)the Applicant’s signed requested for revocation form dated 14 November 2017…(b)a copy of an application I had made to vary or revoke an the apprehended violence order placed on the Applicant …(c)a copy of a Notice of Appeal to the District Court of New South Wales dated 31 August 2017 (annexed and marked SMM06 is a copy of the Notice of Appeal to the District Court dated 31 August 2017);(d)a copy of a letter I had given to the Magistrates Court at Armidale regarding the Applicant’s sentencing …(e)copies of letters from my general practitioner Dr Robert Cruickshanki.6 September 2017 …ii.13 September 2017 …iii.dated 20 September 2017 ……6.The Respondent’s Statement of Reasons contained a table of evidence or material considered by the Respondent in making his decision. The table does not refer to the documents listed above at subparagraphs 4(b) to 4(e).(Emphasis in the original.) Mrs Mouflih was cross-examined at the hearing. Under cross-examination, Mrs Mouflih said that on 14 November 2017, she made a copy of the bundle of documents she sent to the Department. She said that it consisted of 281 pages. She said she later cross-referenced the document list (attached to the Minister’s reasons) against the copy of the bundle she had kept. She identified documents that were in her copy but not in the list, and notified the applicant’s lawyer of those documents. Mrs Mouflih said she prepared a list of documents entitled “Supporting Documents” that was included in the bundle. Item 28 was, “Any other information”. Mrs Mouflih agreed that the list did not expressly refer to any of the documents in contention. She said she just put them all under the one subheading. Mrs Mouflih said she printed out two copies of each document. She placed one copy on one side and the other copy on the other side. When asked whether it was possible that in the course of collating the bundle, she missed out some documents from her copy, she responded, “No, absolutely not”. She maintained that the copy of the documents she kept was exactly the same as the documents she placed into the envelope. The Minister relied upon an affidavit of Ms Maria Rizza, an employee of the Department of Home Affairs. Ms Rizza is employed as the Assistant Team Manager in the Pipeline Management Team of the National Character Consideration Centre (NCCC). She has been in that role since January 2018. Ms Rizza deposed as follows:3.As part of my role, I oversee the receipt and processing of post to the NCCC, and its storage on a document management system. As a result of my employment with the Department, I am familiar with the usual process of the receipt and storage of post. The usual process involves the following:(a)hard copy post is opened by a team called the “Converga” (which was recently changed to the “Decipha”) team. This team is made up of people who are contracted with the Department;(b)the Converga team date-stamp the hard copy documents and provide the documents, including any envelopes, to staff within the Pipeline Management Team;(c)a member of staff in Pipeline Management Team takes a complete scan of the hard copy documents received from the Converga team and stores the PDF on an electronic document management system called “HPE Records” (which was previously called “TRIM”);(d)the original hard copy bundle is then sent to storage; and(e)the Revocation team has access to the PDF document on HPE Records, which forms the basis of briefing to the Respondent.4.I am not aware of any recent changes to the usual process and believe that it was the same process in place in November 2017.5.I am aware that an issue in this proceeding concerns whether or not the NCCC received the following documents:(a)letter to Armidale Magistrates Court from Mrs Mouflih;(b)Mrs Mouflih’s application to vary the apprehended violence order;(c)Notice of Appeal to the District Court of New South Wales; and(d)letters from Dr Cruickshank dated 6, 13 and 20 September 2017 (together, the Contentious Documents).6.On 14 January 2019, I arranged for the hard copy documents held in storage that the NCCC received in relation to the Applicant’s file to be recalled from storage. The first page of the hard copy bundle is date-stamped “20 November 2017”. I have been unable to determine who from the Converga team opened the documents received and I am not aware of any record of this. Given the size of the hard copy bundle, I have not attached a copy of it to this affidavit.7.On 15 January 2019, I checked the hard copy bundle of the documents to see if it contained any of the Contentious Documents (which I have seen for this purpose). Based on my review, the hard copy bundle does not contain the Contentious Documents.8.Based on my review of HPE Records, the PDF bundle of the hard copy documents was uploaded at 3.13 pm on 21 November 2017. The person recorded as having uploaded the PDF bundle no longer works in my team.9.Also on 23 January 2019, I checked the PDF on HPE Records in relation to the Applicant’s file. I checked the PDF against the hard copy bundle, and they were consistent. The only differences that I could make out were:(a)that the PDF bundle had intermittent white pages, which I take to have been introduced in the PDF as part of the scanning process; and(b)the hard copy document contains two further pages, exhibited here as “MR-1”. These documents are not contained in the PDF bundle. I do not know why these two pages were not in the PDF.10.Again, I have not attached the PDF bundle to this file given its size.11.Based on my review, the PDF file on HPE Records does not contain the Contentious Documents.12.I have no reason to think that the hard copy bundle or the PDF held on the Applicant’s file have been adjusted or amended.13.If the Contentious Documents had been received by the NCCC, I would expect to have found them in the course of taking the steps outlined above.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I will describe the Minister’s decision, before turning to consider the grounds of review.The decision under review The applicant is a citizen of Morocco. In 2006, he met an Australian citizen, Susan Mouflih. They married in 2009. The applicant was granted a Partner (Provisional) visa in 2014. On 31 August 2017, the applicant was convicted of assault occasioning bodily harm in the Magistrates Court of New South Wales. The victim was his wife. They were drinking and got into an argument. He lashed out at her while he had a glass of wine in his hand, cutting her face. The applicant was sentenced to 18 months imprisonment, with a non-parole period of three months. On 20 October 2017, the applicant was notified that his visa had been cancelled, and invited to make representations to the Minister about revoking the decision. The applicant completed a form entitled “Request for Revocation of a Mandatory Visa Cancellation under s 501(3A)”. In that form, the applicant set out his reasons for requesting revocation for the decision and provided details about his personal circumstances, the hardship that his removal would cause to him and his wife, and other matters. Mrs Mouflih posted the form, together with other material in support of the revocation of the cancellation decision, to the Department. The material was received by the Department on 20 November 2017. On 14 August 2018, the Minister made his decision to not revoke the cancellation decision. The Minister’s reasons noted that the applicant and Mrs Mouflih had made representations seeking revocation. The Minister stated that he had assessed all of the information that was set out in the attachments to his reasons. The Minister stated that he had considered the strength, nature and duration of the applicant’s ties with Australia, the extent of the impediments the applicant would face if removed to Morocco, the nature of the offending and risk to the Australian community. The Minister noted that Mrs Mouflih had said she would not remain in Australia if her husband were deported, but would return to Morocco with him. The Minister stated that he had considered the consequences of the decision for Mrs Mouflih. The Minister found that there was a risk, albeit a low one, that the applicant would reoffend. The Minister considered that, should the applicant reoffend in a similar manner, it could result in serious physical or psychological harm to members of the Australian community. The Minister concluded:73.I considered all relevant matters including (1) an assessment of whether the person has made representations in accordance with the invitation for the purposes of s501CA(4)(a); (2) an assessment of whether I am satisfied that the person passes the character test (as defined by s501) for the purposes of s501CA(4)(b)(i); (3) an assessment of whether I am satisfied that there is another reason why the original decision should be revoked for the purposes of s501CA(4)(b)(ii); and (4) all evidence available to me, including evidence provided by, or on behalf of, Mr MOUFLIH.74.I concluded Mr MOUFLIH has made representations in accordance with the invitation.75.I am not satisfied that Mr MOUFLIH passes the character test (as defined by s501).76.In addition, I have considered the length of time Mr MOUFLIH has made a positive contribution to the Australian community (four years) and the consequences of non­revocation of the original decision for his wife.77.On the other hand, in considering whether I was satisfied that there is another reason why the original decision should be revoked, I gave significant weight to the serious nature of the crime committed by Mr MOUFLIH, that is of a violent nature including of a domestic nature.78.Further, I find that the Australian community could be exposed to harm should Mr MOUFLIH reoffend in a similar fashion. I could not rule out the possibility of further offending by Mr MOUFLIH given the recent nature of his offending and that his conduct has not been tested in the community.79.In reaching my decision about whether I am satisfied that there is another reason why the original decision should be revoked, I concluded that Mr MOUFUH represents an unacceptable risk of harm to the Australian community and that the protection of the Australian community outweighed his claims that he will suffer hardship if returned to MOROCCO and the hardship Mr MOUFLIH, his wife and social networks will endure in the event the original decision is not revoked.80.Having given full consideration to all of these matters, I am not satisfied, for the purposes of s501CA(4)(b)(ii), that there is another reason why the original decision under s501(3A) to cancel Mr MOUFLIH’s visa should be revoked. Accordingly, as I am not satisfied that there is another reason why the original decision should be revoked, my power to revoke is not enlivened and Mr MOUFLIH’s Class UF Subclass 309 Partner (Provisional) visa remains cancelled.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Rizza was not required for cross-examination.ConsiderationConsideration of Ground 1 The applicant alleges that he was denied procedural fairness because the Minister failed to consider several documents sent by Mrs Mouflih to the Department, and that failure was material to the Minister’s decision. The Minister’s decision was made under s 501CA(4) of the Act. That section provides:(4) The Minister may revoke the original decision if:(a)the person makes representations in accordance with the invitation; and(b)the Minister is satisfied:…(ii)that there is another reason why the original decision should be revoked. The application for review has been made under s 476A(1)(c) of the Act, which confers original jurisdiction on the Federal Court of Australia in relation to a privative clause decision, or purported privative clause decision, made personally by the Minister under s 501CA. Pursuant to s 476A(2), that jurisdiction is the same as the jurisdiction of the High Court of Australia under s 75(v) of the Constitution. The remedies provided by s 75(v) of the Constitution are only available for jurisdictional error: Plaintiff S157/2002 v Commonwealth of Australia (2003) 211 CLR 476 at [83]; Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332 at [46]. In Viane v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) FCAFC 116, the Full Court held at [30], [41]–[42] that where the Minister overlooks sufficiently important material provided by, or on behalf of, the applicant which, if accepted, would or could be dispositive of the decision, there may be jurisdictional error: see also Navoto v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 135 at [86]; Hay v Minister for Home Affairs [2018] FCAFC 149 at [10]. The applicant contends that the Minister overlooked six documents that were sent by Mrs Mouflih to the Department, namely: a letter applying to revoke the Apprehended Violence Order (AVO) made against the applicant; the applicant’s notice of appeal to the District Court of NSW; a letter to the Armidale Magistrates Court; and reports from Dr Cruickshank dated 6, 13 and 20 September 2017 (collectively, the Contentious Documents). The Minister accepts Mrs Mouflih posted a bundle of documents to the Department and that the bundle was received by the Department on 20 November 2017. The Minister accepts that he is taken to have received the documents that were received by the Department. However, the Minister contends that the Contentious Documents were never posted to, and never received by, the Department. The onus of proving there was jurisdictional error is on the applicant. It is necessary for the applicant to demonstrate that:(1)The bundle of document sent by Mrs Mouflih and received by the Department included the Contentious Documents.(2)The Minister’s failure to consider one or more of the Contentious Documents was material to the outcome of the Minister’s decision. The Minister accepts that Mrs Mouflih believes she placed the Contentious Documents in the envelope together with the other documents she sent to the Department. However, the Minister argues Mrs Mouflih is mistaken in that belief. The Minister submits that Ms Rizza’s evidence demonstrates there is no reason to think the documents went missing within the Department.