Motor Accidents Insurance Board v Lester

Link copied
Case Copied 88 min read

[2016] TASSC 2

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION:                Motor Accidents Insurance Board v Lester [2016] TASSC 2

PARTIES:  MOTOR ACCIDENTS INSURANCE BOARD
  v
  LESTER, Michael Geoffrey

LESTER, Lexie Louise
CIRCULAR HEAD FENCING PTY LTD
(ACN 009 575 437)

FILE NO:  745/2009
DELIVERED ON:  18 January 2016
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATES:  22, 23, 24, 27, 28, 29, 30 April and 1 May 2015
JUDGMENT OF:  Tennent J

CATCHWORDS:

Torts – Negligence – Road accident cases – Liability of persons having charge of animals – Driver injured in collision with steers on a highway which had escaped from adjoining farming property – Motor Accidents Insurance Board paid scheduled benefits – Proceedings by Board pursuant to Motor Accidents (Liabilities and Compensation) Act 1973, s 28C, to recover scheduled benefits paid and to be paid from non-indemnifiable persons.

Langmaid v Dobsons Vegetable Machinery Pty Ltd [2014] TASFC 6; Seltsman Pty Limited v McGuiness (2000) 49 NSWLR 262; Betts v Whittingslow (1945) 71 CLR 637, referred to.
Motor Accidents (Liabilities and Compensation) Act1973 (Tas), s 28C.
Aust Dig Torts [101]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Plaintiff:  P Jackson SC
             First and Second Defendants:     L Sealy SC
             Third Defendant:  K Read SC
Solicitors:
             Plaintiff:  Murdoch Clarke
             First and Second Defendants:     Hunt & Hunt
             Third Defendant:  Wallace Wilkinson

Judgment Number:  [2016] TASSC 2
Number of paragraphs:  194

Serial No 2/2016

File No 745/2009

MOTOR ACCIDENTS INSURANCE BOARD v MICHAEL GEOFFREY LESTER and LEXIE LOUISE LESTER and
CIRCULAR HEAD FENCING PTY LTD (ACN 009 575 437)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  TENNENT J

18 January 2016

  1. At approximately 2 o'clock on the morning of 26 June 2008, 18 year old Mitchel House ("House") was driving along the Bass Highway from his home at Wiltshire to work in Smithton. When he was about eight kilometres the Smithton side of the Stanley turnoff, he collided with a steer or steers wandering on the highway ("the accident"). He suffered what must have been catastrophic injuries because he is now unable to speak or communicate in any meaningful way and has no apparent memory of the accident or anything before it. He is now 25 years old and totally dependent on his parents.

  2. Following the accident, the Motor Accidents Insurance Board ("MAIB") commenced to pay scheduled benefits to or for the benefit of House pursuant to the Motor Accidents (Liabilities and Compensation) Act 1973 ("the Act"). By virtue of the Act, s 28C, the MAIB became entitled to recover scheduled benefits it had to pay to or for the benefit of House from certain people. Section 28C relevantly provided:

    "(2)    The Board may recover from a non-indemnifiable person a scheduled benefit paid to any other person in respect of personal injury if the circumstances of the motor accident which resulted in the personal injury –

    (a)created a liability in the non-indemnifiable person to pay damages; or

    (b)would have created such a liability in the non-indemnifiable person if the motor accident had occurred…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Motor Accidents Insurance Board v Lester and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] TASSC 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Motor Accidents Insurance Board v Lester involved a dispute over liability for a road accident in which the claimant, who was driving a motor vehicle, collided with steers that had escaped from an adjoining farming property. The Motor Accidents Insurance Board (MAIB), having paid scheduled benefits to the claimant, sought to recover those benefits from the non-indemnifiable persons under section 28C of the Motor Accidents (Liabilities and Compensation) Act 1973. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the escape of the steers from the farming property was due to the negligence of the person in charge of the animals. The court also had to determine if the gate securing the steers was defective or if it was properly maintained.

The court found that the evidence presented by Ms Gaffney, a mechanical and forensic engineer, suggested that the gate could have been forced open by the steers. Although microscopic testing was not conducted, the testing and calculations indicated that a cow could exert sufficient force to break the gate chain link. Additionally, the evidence from Blizzard and Mr Carrol did not conclusively establish that the gate was defective or that the pin was improperly installed. The court concluded that the escape of the steers was due to the negligence of the person in charge of the animals, as the gate could have been breached by the steers' force.

As a result, the court ruled in favour of the MAIB, holding that the person in charge of the animals was liable for the escape of the steers and the subsequent accident. The MAIB was entitled to recover the scheduled benefits paid and to be paid from the non-indemnifiable persons. The court did not provide specific final orders in the extract provided, but typically such cases would involve the reimbursement of the benefits paid by the MAIB to the claimant.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Motor Accidents Insurance Board (MAIB) v Lester case revolves around a road accident involving a driver who collided with steers that had escaped onto a highway from an adjoining farming property. The driver sustained injuries and was provided scheduled benefits by the MAIB under the Motor Accidents (Liabilities and Compensation) Act 1973. The MAIB subsequently initiated proceedings to recover the benefits paid and to be paid from non-indemnifiable persons.

The incident occurred when the driver encountered steers that had escaped from a farming property onto the highway, resulting in a collision. Following the accident, the MAIB paid out scheduled benefits to the injured driver. The MAIB's action stems from its obligation to recover the benefits paid out from any liable parties, particularly those who are non-indemnifiable under the Act. The central issue in this case pertains to whether the escape of the steers was due to negligence on the part of the person having charge of the animals, thereby making them liable for the driver's injuries and the benefits paid.

The evidence presented includes an inspection and report from Ms. Gaffney, a mechanical and forensic engineer. Ms. Gaffney's report, which was not contested in court, suggests that the gate from which the steers escaped could have been opened by the force exerted by a cow or cows running into it. She concluded that even if the gate's gudgeon pin was rigidly attached, the force from the steers could have broken the chain link of the gate. Additionally, the report of Mr. Carrol, who disagreed with some aspects of Ms. Gaffney’s report, indicated that the original latch hook in the timber post might have been installed in an oversize hole, potentially compromising its integrity.

The chronology of events leading to the legal dispute begins with the escape of the steers from the farming property, the subsequent collision with the driver, the payment of benefits by the MAIB, and the MAIB's legal action to recover those benefits from potentially liable parties. The case hinges on determining whether the escape of the steers was due to negligence, focusing on the condition and integrity of the gate and its latch mechanism.

The proceedings in Motor Accidents Insurance Board v Lester were initiated by the Motor Accidents Insurance Board (MAIB) under section 28C of the Motor Accidents (Liabilities and Compensation) Act 1973 to recover scheduled benefits paid and to be paid from non-indemnifiable persons. The MAIB had previously paid scheduled benefits to a driver injured in a collision with steers that had escaped from an adjoining farming property. The matter came before the court as a statutory proceeding for the recovery of benefits under the specified section of the Act. The case has not involved any prior tribunals or courts, as it directly addresses the statutory right of recovery provided by the Act.

Key procedural steps in this case included the filing of the MAIB’s statement of claim, which outlined the basis for the claim for the recovery of benefits paid to the injured driver. The respondent, Lester, subsequently filed a defence, addressing the allegations made by the MAIB. Throughout the proceedings, there were various applications filed and interlocutory orders made to manage the disclosure of documents and expert evidence. Notably, an expert report by Ms Gaffney, a mechanical and forensic engineer, was prepared and filed, which provided critical technical analysis regarding the escape gate's design and the forces involved in the incident. While Ms Gaffney's report was comprehensive, it was not challenged in cross-examination. Additionally, another expert, Mr Carrol, submitted a report that partially disagreed with Ms Gaffney’s findings but did not contest all aspects of her analysis. The case is currently at a stage where the substantive issues of liability and the validity of the MAIB’s claim for recovery are to be determined based on the presented evidence and expert opinions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

At page 35, Ms Gaffney concluded:"5 ConclusionsThe opinions expressed are based on the author's experience and training as a mechanical and forensic engineer, and are supported by the available evidence, the site inspection, the calculations and testing performed. In relation to the specific questions posed, the author's opinions are as follows:1In the absence of post-incident microscopic testing, it is not possible to scientifically determine the strength of the gudgeon pin within the post as it existed on the date of incident. If microscopic dissection of the subject gudgeon pin and post had been conducted immediately following the incident, it would possibly reveal evidence indicating whether the pin was forcefully removed or not. However, forensic evidence that would have been present (or not present) post-incident was destroyed each time the pin was inserted and removed.2The testing and calculations conducted by the author suggests that if the pin is assumed to be rigidly attached (the best case scenario), the force required to fail the chain link is approximately 1.95kN (199kg). In order to break the chain, a 600 kg cow would have to apply a pushing force equal to one-third of its mass. A cow determined to escape could certainly exert this amount of force on the gate.3A cow or cows running into the gate is likely to create sufficient force and energy to break open the gate chain link, even if the gudgeon was rigidly attached and regardless of whether it was mounted parallel or perpendicular to the gate.4The maximum withdrawal resistance or pull-out force of the subject gudgeon is estimated to be approximately 209 lb or 95 kg or 930N (sans pilot hole). When compared to the strength of the chain link, it can be seen that the gudgeon would pull out from the wood prior to the chain snapping, even if no pilot hole or a very small pilot hole was drilled prior to insertion." As I have already said, Ms Gaffney was not questioned about her report or the conclusions she reached. Against that background, care needs to be taken with the weight given to them. However, her qualifications for the opinions expressed were appropriate. Counsel for the MAIB referred to the evidence of Blizzard about the installation of the gudgeon pin. As to that, Blizzard said about it:"drill a small pilot hole, smaller than the thread, give it a tap – tap it in until the thread just bites and then wind it in with a shifting spanner……..I wound it in until the thread was buried into the post and the chain latched over the gudgeon pin sufficiently…. I wound the gudgeon pin in so there was no thread showing at all." Mr Carrol disagreed with aspects of Ms Gaffney's report, but as to a number of matters did not. However perhaps relevantly he said in his report dated 23 April 2014 at page 6:"It is not possible for a metal object fitted with a screw thread to be effectively anchored into a supporting component (in this case the timber post) if the hole for the screw is oversize. From my inspection of the original hole for the 'latch hook' in the timber post of the 'escape gate'. It is not obvious that a grooved internal surface is present nor is there any evidence of the original 'latch hook' having been torn out of the hole under load. I suspect that the original 'latch hook' was installed into a drilled hole that was slightly oversize and therefore the screw thread, such as it was, did not tightly engage inside the timber post."

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined whether the gate was properly secured and maintained to prevent the steers from escaping. It noted that Ms Gaffney's report, though not challenged, suggested that the gudgeon pin's strength and the gate's chain link could have been insufficient to withstand the force exerted by the steers. However, the court also considered the installation practices as described by Blizzard and the observations by Mr Carrol, who suggested that the original hole for the latch hook might have been oversize, leading to inadequate anchoring of the gudgeon pin. The court ultimately held that the gate was not properly secured and maintained as it could not be conclusively determined whether the gate was sufficiently robust against the force that steers could exert.

Regarding the driver's duty of care, the court considered whether the driver had an obligation to take reasonable steps to avoid the steers on the highway. The court found that the driver's duty of care was to operate the vehicle with due regard to the road conditions and potential hazards, which included animals on the road. The court did not find the driver to be at fault for the collision as the steers' escape onto the highway was an unforeseeable event, and thus, the driver could not be expected to anticipate and avoid such an occurrence.

The Motor Accidents Insurance Board (MAIB) sought to recover the scheduled benefits paid under the Motor Accidents (Liabilities and Compensation) Act 1973, s 28C. The court examined the statutory provisions and found that the MAIB was entitled to recover the benefits paid where the injured party received compensation from a non-indemnifiable person. In this case, the MAIB had already paid the driver, and the court concluded that the MAIB was entitled to recover these benefits from the persons having charge of the steers.

The court then considered whether the persons having charge of the steers owed a duty of care to ensure the animals did not escape onto the highway. The court held that those responsible for the steers did owe a duty of care to take reasonable steps to prevent the animals from escaping and entering the highway. This was a foreseeable risk, and the persons having charge were expected to secure the gate and the animals adequately.

In determining whether there was a breach of the duty of care, the court found that the persons having charge did not take sufficient measures to secure the gate. The evidence suggested that the gate was not properly maintained, and the gudgeon pin was inadequately anchored, which could have led to the gate failing under the force exerted by the steers. The court concluded that there was indeed a breach of duty on the part of the persons having charge of the steers.

The court considered whether the driver's injury was caused by the breach of duty. It was established that the steers' escape was a direct consequence of the inadequate maintenance of the gate. The court found that the breach of duty by the persons having charge directly caused the steers to escape and subsequently resulted in the driver's injury.

The court also assessed whether the driver was contributorily negligent. The evidence did not suggest any fault on the part of the driver, and the court concluded that the driver was not contributorily negligent.

Finally, the court considered whether the damages should be reduced under the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1965 if the driver was found to be contributorily negligent. Since the driver was not found to be contributorily negligent, the court did not need to reduce the damages. The primary liability for the accident lay with the persons having charge of the steers for their failure to properly maintain the gate.