Moss and Phillips v Donohoe

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read
20 CLR 580

MOSS AND PHILLIPS

DEFENDANTS, DONOHOE Trading with the Enemy--Attempt to obtain goods from an enemy country-Goods of

neutral in enemy country-Contract with neutral to purchase goods-Goods to be brought to Australia-Evidence-Summary conviction-Trading with the Enemy SYDNEY,

Acts 1914 (No. 9 of 1914-No. 17 of 1914), secs. 2, 3-Imperial Proclamation of May 4, 5. 6,

9th September 1914, clause 5 (7)-Acts Interpretation Act 1904 (No. I of 1904), sec. 8--Crimes Act 1914 (No. 12 of 1914), sec. 7. MEIBOURNE,

A company incorporated in the United States of America, and having its Sept. 17.

head office at New York, had branch houses at Rotterdam in Holland and at Hamburg in Germany. The company's business was the sale and export of gin, which was manufactured for it in Holland by independent distillers. Before the outbreak of the war it was the company's practice to send the gin in bulk to its warehouse at Hamburg, where it was bottled and packed, and whence it was exported, M. and P., residents of Australia, who had dealt with the company for many years, having been convicted before a Stipendiary Magistrate of an attempt, by means of a cablegram sent to the company in New York on 7th December 1914, to trade with the enemy, on appeal to the High Court,

Held, by Isaacs, Gavan Duffy, Powers and Rich JJ. (Griffith C.J. dissenting), that on the evidence the Magistrate might properly find that the telegram was an acceptance of an offer by the company to sell to M. and P. goods of the company which were then in fact, and as M. and P. believed, at Hamburg and which were expected by M. and P. to be brought thence to Australia: that on such a state of facts the sending of the telegram was an attempt by M. and P.

20 CLR 581

to obtain the goods from an enemy country within the meaning of the Imperial Proclamation of 9th September 1914; and that such an attempt was an attempt to trade with the enemy within the meaning of sec. 3 of the Trading with the Enemy Acts 1914, and was punishable summarily under that section by virtue of sec. 8 of the Acts Interpretation Act 1904 and sec. 7 of the Crimes

Principles applicable to such cases discussed.

APPEAL from a Stipendiary Magistrate of New South Wales.

At the Central Police Court, Sydney, before a Stipendiary Magis- trate, an information was heard whereby John Thomas Tamplin Donohoe charged that on or about 7th December 1914 Laurence Edward Moss and Lawrance David Phillips, by means of a cable addressed and transmitted to "Wolsey, New York," did attempt to trade with the enemy. Both defendants having been convicted, they appealed to the High Court by way of statutory prohibition.

The material facts are stated in the judgments hereunder. Knox K.C. (with him Campbell K.C. and C. E. Weigall), for the appellants. The Proclamations and the Trading with the Enemy Acts 1914 must be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moss and Phillips v Donohoe and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1915] HCA 62
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Moss and Phillips appealed to the High Court against their summary conviction for attempting to trade with the enemy. The appellants had been charged with attempting to trade with the enemy by sending a cablegram to the Udolpho Wolfe Company in New York on 7th December 1914. The Udolpho Wolfe Company, a US-incorporated entity, had branch houses in Rotterdam and Hamburg, and its business involved the export of gin manufactured in Holland. Prior to the war, the company's practice was to send gin in bulk to its Hamburg warehouse for bottling and export. The appellants, who were long-standing agents for the company in Australasia, believed that the cablegram was an acceptance of an offer to purchase 20,000 cases of gin from the company's Hamburg warehouse, which they expected to be shipped to Australia.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether the sending of the cablegram constituted an attempt to trade with the enemy, and if so, whether this attempt was punishable summarily. Specifically, the court had to determine if the appellants' actions fell within the scope of the Imperial Proclamation of 9th September 1914, which prohibited obtaining goods from an enemy country, and the Trading with the Enemy Acts 1914. The interpretation of "obtaining" in the context of goods located in an enemy country, and the extent to which a transaction with a neutral entity could constitute trading with the enemy, were key considerations.

A majority of the High Court (Isaacs, Gavan Duffy, Powers, and Rich JJ.) held that the magistrate could reasonably infer from the evidence that the cablegram was an acceptance of an offer to purchase goods from the Udolpho Wolfe Company, which were then located in Hamburg, and which the appellants expected to be brought to Australia. The Court reasoned that on these facts, the sending of the cablegram constituted an attempt by the appellants to obtain goods from an enemy country, as defined by the Imperial Proclamation. This attempt was deemed to be an attempt to trade with the enemy under section 3 of the Trading with the Enemy Acts 1914, and was punishable summarily by virtue of section 8 of the Acts Interpretation Act 1904 and section 7 of the Crimes Act 1914. Griffith C.J. dissented, finding that the evidence did not establish that the appellants intended to obtain goods from the enemy country, but rather from a neutral entity.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established