Morton v Walker

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read
22 CLR 203

RESPONDENT. DEFENDANT, Building Regulations-Irregularity in building-Certificate of official referees-

Sufficiency-Melbourne Building Act 1849 (N.S.W.) (13 Vict. No. 39), sec. 13.

Sec. 13 of the Melbourne Building Act 1849 is, so far as is material, as follows :- Be it enacted with regard to any buildings

and every other part of every building be hereafter built rebuilt enlarged or altered within the said city " (of Mel- bourne) "contrary to the provisions hereof, SO far as relates to the removal thereof, That if the same be not built materials and in every other respect according to and in conformity with the several rules and directions which are in this Act particularly specified, and if any person build or begin to build

contrary thereunto, and if in either of such cases it so appear by the certificate of the official referees, then the said building

or such part thereof so irregularly built shall be deemed a nuisance; and that thereupon it shall be the duty of the surveyor, and he is hereby directed and required, to summon the builder before any two justices of the peace;

and that thereupon it shall be the duty of such builder, and he is hereby required, to enter into a recog- nizance in such sum as the said justices shall appoint for abating and taking down the same," &.

Held, that a certificate by the official referees, which, after setting out that they had had submitted to them copies of notices served on the defendant to amend irregularities existing in certain buildings " the said irregularities being that the walls are not built of brick laid in mortar to produce solid

22 CLR 204

work," stated that they decided and determined 'that the said buildings are nuisances requiring to be abated," was not a good certificate within the mean- ing of the section as it certified to a matter of law, and not of fact.

Special leave to appeal from the decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria (Hodges J.) Morton v. Walker, (1916) V.L.R., 647; 38 A.L.T., 93, refused.

APPLICATION for special leave to appeal.

At the Court of Petty Sessions at Melbourne an information was heard whereby Henry Edgar Morton, Surveyor of the City of Mel- bourne, charged that Augustine William Walker being the builder, within the meaning of Act 13 Vict. No. 39, did, at Little Queensberry Street, Melbourne, build portions of a certain building irregularly and in such a manner as to be deemed a nuisance, viz., walls not built of bricks laid in and with mortar, contrary to Schedule C, Part 2, of the said Act. A document was put in evidence purport- ing to be a "certificate and award of the official referees," which was in the following terms We, the official referees duly appointed under the provisions of the Melbourne Building Act, 13 Vict. No. 39, have had submitted to us copies of notices dated 25th November and 14th December 1915 served on the said A.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Morton v Walker and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1916] HCA 50
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Henry Edgar Morton, the Surveyor of the City of Melbourne, sought special leave to appeal to the High Court from a decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The dispute concerned alleged irregularities in the construction of certain buildings by the respondent, Augustine William Walker, a builder. The core of the matter was whether a document purporting to be a certificate from official referees was sufficient under section 13 of the Melbourne Building Act 1849 to deem the buildings a nuisance requiring abatement.

The legal issue before the High Court was whether the document presented as a certificate by the official referees met the requirements of section 13 of the Melbourne Building Act 1849. Specifically, the court had to determine if the certificate validly certified that the buildings were constructed contrary to the Act's provisions, thereby deeming them a nuisance, or if it improperly certified a matter of law rather than fact.

The High Court held that the certificate was "plainly bad" because it certified to a matter of law, not a matter of fact. Section 13 of the Act required the official referees to certify to the factual existence of irregularities in the building. The document in question, however, stated that the referees "decide and determine that the said buildings are nuisances requiring to be abated," which was an interpretation of the law rather than a finding of fact regarding the construction. Consequently, special leave to appeal was refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established