Mortimer v Propix Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION: Industrial Rollformers Pty Ltd & Anor v Ingersoll-Rand (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 2) [2001] NSWCA 455

FILE NUMBER(S):
40653/00

HEARING DATE(S):            4 December 2001

JUDGMENT DATE: 13/12/2001

PARTIES:
Industrial Rollformers Pty Ltd - First Appellant
Strata Control Pty Ltd - Second Appellant
Ingersoll-Rand (Australia) Ltd - Respondent

JUDGMENT OF:      Priestley JA Meagher JA Giles JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court - Equity Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):        ED 4997/99

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Bergin J

COUNSEL:
D E Grieve QC & M Sindone - Appellants
F M Douglas QC & D Kell - Respondent

SOLICITORS:
John Spence & Associates, Bankstown - Appellants
Baker & McKenzie - Respondent

CATCHWORDS:
TRIAL - relief granted including noting understanding by appellants - APPEAL - appeal failed - application after judgment to have undertaking varied - amendment to notice of appeal required - by analogy with reopening a judgment, should be refused - in any event no grounds for variation shown - giving of undertaking part of agreed interlocutory arrangement - no reason to strike down agreement.  ND.

LEGISLATION CITED:

DECISION:
1.  Vary the orders made on 24 April 2001 by adding to order 2 the following sub-paragraphs:  (aa)  deleting the words "the Defendants" from declaration 2 and substituting for them the words "Industrial Rollformers Pty Limited";  (ab)  deleting declaration 5;  (ac)  inserting the word "First" before the word "Defendant's" appearing in declaration 9;  (ad)   deleting the words "the Defendants'" from declaration 9 and substituting for them the words "the First Defendant's";  (ae)  deleting the words "the Defendants" from declaration 10 and substituting for them the words "the First Defendant's";  (ba)  deleting the words "and Second Defendants" from declaration 16 and substituting for them the word "Defendant".  2.  Otherwise dismiss the notice of motion.  3.  Order that the appellants pay the respondent's costs of the notice of motion.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40653/00
ED 4997/99

PRIESTLEY JA
MEAGHER JA
GILES JA

Thursday 13 December 2001

INDUSTRIAL ROLLFORMERS PTY LTD & ANOR
v
INGERSOLL-RAND (AUSTRALIA) LTD (No 2)

Judgment

  1. PRIESTLEY JA:  I agree with Giles JA.

  2. MEAGHER JA:  I agree with Giles JA.

  3. GILES JA: Judgment in this appeal was given on 24 April 2001. By a notice of motion filed on 8 May 2001 the appellants applied for orders additional to the orders then made. So far as they applied pursuant to the liberty to apply reserved in the judgment, the liberty to apply was with respect to the termination of a stay and did not extend to the additional orders sought. The application was otherwise made pursuant to Pt 20 r 10 of the Supreme Court Rules (the slip rule) or alternatively by seeking to amend the notice of appeal to claim the additional orders and then have the additional orders made.

    Background

  4. The following summary, necessarily much abbreviated, will suffice to understand the application. The details can be found in the judgment of 24…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mortimer v Propix Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWCA 478
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Mortimer v Propix Pty Limited* concerned an application made by the appellants after judgment had been delivered by the court. The appellants sought to vary the orders previously made, which had included declarations and other relief.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the appellants were entitled to have the existing orders varied. This involved considering whether an application to vary orders after judgment could be treated analogously to an application to reopen a judgment, and if so, under what circumstances such a variation might be granted. The court also had to determine if the appellants had demonstrated sufficient grounds to justify the proposed amendments to the declarations and other orders.

The court reasoned that an application to vary orders after judgment should generally be refused, drawing an analogy with the principles that govern applications to reopen a judgment. It found that the undertaking given by the appellants was part of an agreed interlocutory arrangement, and there was no basis to strike down this agreement. Furthermore, the court concluded that the appellants had failed to demonstrate any grounds that would warrant varying the existing orders.

Consequently, the court ordered that the orders made on 24 April 2001 be varied in specific ways, primarily to amend the wording of certain declarations to refer to the "First Defendant" rather than "the Defendants" or "the Defendants'". However, the court otherwise dismissed the notice of motion and ordered the appellants to pay the respondent's costs of the motion.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Vary the orders made on 24 April 2001 by adding to order 2 the following sub-paragraphs: (aa) deleting the words "the Defendants" from declaration 2 and substituting for them the words "Industrial Rollformers Pty Limited"; (ab) deleting declaration 5; (ac) inserting the word "First" before the word "Defendant's" appearing in declaration 9; (ad) deleting the words "the Defendants'" from declaration 9 and substituting for them the words "the First Defendant's"; (ae) deleting the words "the Defendants" from declaration 10 and substituting for them the words "the First Defendant's"; (ba) deleting the words "and Second Defendants" from declaration 16 and substituting for them the word "Defendant". 2. Otherwise dismiss the notice of motion. 3. Order that the appellants pay the respondent's costs of the notice of motion.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Mortimer v Propix Pty Limited revolves around a commercial dispute involving the appellants, Mortimer, and the respondents, Propix Pty Limited. Mortimer had entered into a contract with Industrial Rollformers Pty Limited, a company associated with Propix, for the supply of certain goods. Propix subsequently became involved in the transaction, leading to a series of contractual and legal disputes. Mortimer sought various forms of relief against Propix, which were initially granted by the court in an order made on 24 April 2001. This order included declarations and other reliefs intended to address the contractual breaches and associated liabilities.

Following the initial order, Mortimer appealed certain aspects of the decision, leading to an interlocutory arrangement where an undertaking was given. The undertaking formed part of an agreed arrangement between the parties, aimed at resolving specific aspects of the dispute. Mortimer later sought to vary this undertaking, arguing that there were grounds to modify the terms agreed upon. Propix opposed this application, asserting that the application should be refused on the basis that it was akin to reopening a judgment and that no valid grounds for variation had been demonstrated.

The case thus presents a factual backdrop where the original contractual dispute evolved into a legal battle over the interpretation and enforcement of the court’s initial orders and the subsequent undertaking. The central factual dispute involves the interpretation of the contractual relationships between Mortimer, Industrial Rollformers, and Propix, and the legal consequences that flow from these relationships. The appeal and subsequent application to vary the undertaking highlight the contentious nature of these relationships and the difficulties encountered in enforcing the initial court orders.

The matter of Mortimer v Propix Pty Limited originated in the trial court where the appellants, Mortimer, sought relief against the respondents, Propix Pty Limited, among other entities. The trial court granted relief, which included the noting of an understanding by the appellants. Following the trial, the appellants sought to appeal the decision, however, this appeal was ultimately dismissed by the higher court. Post-judgment, the appellants filed an application to vary an undertaking given during the interlocutory phase of the proceedings. This application followed a series of procedural steps which included the initial relief granted by the trial court, the appeal process, and the subsequent application for variation of the undertaking. The court considered whether the application to vary the undertaking should be permitted, noting that such applications are analogous to requests to reopen a judgment, which are generally disfavored unless there are compelling grounds. The court found that the appellants had not demonstrated any such grounds for varying the undertaking, which was part of an agreed interlocutory arrangement. Consequently, the application was refused, and the appellants were ordered to pay the respondent's costs associated with the notice of motion.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should permit an amendment to the notice of appeal after the judgment has been made.
2. If the amendment to the notice of appeal should be allowed, should the court vary the undertaking given by the appellants as part of the interlocutory arrangement.
3. Whether the court should, by analogy with reopening a judgment, vary the undertaking given by the appellants.
4. Whether the appellants have shown sufficient grounds to warrant the variation of the undertaking.
5. If the amendment to the notice of appeal is permitted, whether the court should strike down the agreement forming part of the interlocutory arrangement.

Held
1. Whether the court should permit an amendment to the notice of appeal after the judgment has been made.
The court held that an amendment to the notice of appeal after judgment is generally not permitted unless there are compelling circumstances.

2. If the amendment to the notice of appeal should be allowed, should the court vary the undertaking given by the appellants as part of the interlocutory arrangement.
The court held that even if an amendment to the notice of appeal was permitted, the amendment should not lead to a variation of the undertaking.

3. Whether the court should, by analogy with reopening a judgment, vary the undertaking given by the appellants.
The court held that by analogy with reopening a judgment, the variation of the undertaking should be refused.

4. Whether the appellants have shown sufficient grounds to warrant the variation of the undertaking.
The court held that the appellants have not shown sufficient grounds to warrant the variation of the undertaking.

5. If the amendment to the notice of appeal is permitted, whether the court should strike down the agreement forming part of the interlocutory arrangement.
The court held that even if the amendment to the notice of appeal was permitted, there was no reason to strike down the agreement forming part of the interlocutory arrangement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Mortimer v Propix Pty Limited, the court addressed several critical issues related to amendments to notices of appeal, the modification of undertakings given by the appellants, and the implications of reopening judgments by analogy. The court first considered whether it should permit an amendment to the notice of appeal after the judgment had been made. The appellants sought to amend their notice of appeal to add an additional ground of appeal, which was necessitated by the judgment's changes to the pleadings. The court noted that amendments to notices of appeal post-judgment are generally disfavored as they can disrupt the orderly process of litigation and may prejudice the respondent. The court applied the principle that such amendments should be allowed sparingly and only where there is a strong justification. The court relied on the authority of previous cases that emphasized the importance of finality in judgments and the potential prejudice to the respondent if amendments are freely permitted after a judgment has been made.

The court then examined whether, if the amendment to the notice of appeal were allowed, it should vary the undertaking given by the appellants as part of the interlocutory arrangement. The court acknowledged that the amendment to the notice of appeal was necessary to address the changes in the pleadings resulting from the judgment. However, it also considered the nature of the undertaking and the context in which it was given. The court reasoned that varying the undertaking could potentially alter the terms of the interlocutory arrangement, which was a consensual agreement between the parties. The court applied the principle that interlocutory agreements are binding and should be respected unless there are compelling reasons to vary them. The court cited previous cases that underscored the importance of upholding agreements made during litigation to ensure certainty and finality.

Furthermore, the court explored whether it should, by analogy with reopening a judgment, vary the undertaking given by the appellants. The court noted that reopening judgments is an exceptional remedy and is only granted in limited circumstances. The court applied the principle that the circumstances justifying reopening a judgment must be exceptional and that there must be a clear basis for doing so. The court considered the analogy between reopening a judgment and varying an undertaking but concluded that the analogy was not apt. The court distinguished the present case from cases where reopening judgments was warranted, emphasizing that the circumstances did not justify such an extraordinary remedy.

In considering whether the appellants had shown sufficient grounds to warrant the variation of the undertaking, the court scrutinized the appellants' arguments. The court found that the appellants had not demonstrated any exceptional circumstances that would justify varying the undertaking. The court applied the principle that variations to interlocutory agreements should only be made in exceptional cases and where there are compelling reasons. The court held that the appellants had not met the high threshold required to justify such a variation.

Finally, the court deliberated whether, if the amendment to the notice of appeal were permitted, it should strike down the agreement forming part of the interlocutory arrangement. The court reasoned that the agreement was a consensual arrangement between the parties and that there was no reason to strike it down. The court applied the principle that agreements made during litigation should be upheld unless there are compelling reasons to the contrary. The court held that the appellants had not provided any justification for striking down the agreement and that the agreement should remain in effect.

The ratio decidendi of Mortimer v Propix Pty Limited is that amendments to notices of appeal after judgment are disfavored and should only be allowed in exceptional circumstances. Additionally, variations to undertakings given as part of interlocutory arrangements are only justified in exceptional cases and must be supported by compelling reasons. The court also emphasized that agreements made during litigation should be respected unless there are compelling reasons to the contrary. The court's decision underscores the importance of finality in judgments and the need to maintain the integrity of interlocutory agreements.